Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Woman shouting at security in ASDA?

113 replies

Driedpotatochip · 29/10/2022 22:40

Just did a quick late night shop, only one door open and as I was walking in this woman with maybe her son were walking out when their trolley locked.

As they’d blocked one side of the door I had to wait whilst she was screaming at security at how dangerous this was and security were like - there was signs. But she just kept shouting saying she was going to do more than go to customer service.

Was she unreasonable or is locking trolleys ok? I’ve actually never seen it happen before.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ImustLearn2Cook · 31/10/2022 01:22

youkiddingme · 30/10/2022 05:48

Just a small thought - if the trolley locks in such a way that someone pushing it briskly could be hurt then I doubt any amount of signage makes that acceptable. Surely they could be designed to brake gradually rather than abruptly. Not everyone can read. Not everyone can see well enough to read signs that are at a distance.

I was thinking the same.

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 30/10/2022 23:39

This happened to me when sainsburys didn't have the thing I wanted, so I didn't go thru checkout. Scared the absolute bejesus out of me it happens very quickly.

Pixiedust1234 · 30/10/2022 23:14

oohhhhh this explains something that happened to me. During summer I went in with a trolley for something heavy but there wasn't any out (it wasn't compost but that size and heaviness) so I turned round and went out the double doors and the darn thing froze. I thought it was faulty so I picked it up like a wheelbarrow and pushed it out to the trolley bay. Nobody stopped me. Security must have thought I was a right nutter 😂

youkiddingme · 30/10/2022 23:00

melj1213 · 30/10/2022 11:27

How would that work considering the system is designed to stop people who are shoplifting, without warning? The way the system works is that as soon as you go through the security gate at the door the wheels lock if the system hasn't been deactivated. There is technically a small "warning" from the sound of the wheel locking but, obviously, if you're not listening or know to listen for it then it doesn't help.

Also, we have massive, bright yellow signs with huge writing on both doors, next to the doors and on our security podium, with pictures to warn of the trolley locking system ... People will still claim that the signs aren't obvious enough, but since working in retail I have encountered far too many people who seem to become unable to read when they walk into a shop.

I literally once had a man complaining that he'd waited at the kiosk when he wanted customer services and then had to wait again and said "There should be a sign to make it clearer which is which" ... I literally turned to the wall behind my desk with the 5ft illuminated green and white sign saying "CUSTOMER SERVICE" and the 5ft illuminated green and white one at the desk next to me saying "CIGARETTES AND LOTTERY KIOSK" and said "You mean like these signs?". His response? "Well I didn't read that!" 🙄

It can't be that difficult to design a break that works over a space of a few feet rather than inches. The idea is to stop shoplifting. It's irrelevant if there's a warming of a few seconds. You can't just have equipment that could injure someone as a security measure. Several people have said it happened to them on this thread and they weren't shoplifting.
Perhaps one reason people don't read every sign is that they are bombarded with advertising so become accustomed to tuning them out. Approx 10% of people have a degree of dyslexia. 9 million people in the UK are functionally illiterate.

AutumnsCrow · 30/10/2022 22:45

I mean, I've got degenerative disc disease in my spine. I've posted on MN threads elsewhere about the awful levels of pain I'm in.

Something like a sudden and unexpected jarring stop and a stumble up against trolley could be a pretty significant medical incident for me. If I stumbled and fell, I'd not be getting up on my own. I'd be in a lot of pain. It's really made me think.

Is that why so many people are now exiting supermarkets at mega-slow tortoise pace? I'll be joining them.

Ineedsleepandcoffee · 30/10/2022 22:24

melj1213 · 30/10/2022 17:56

How do you want stores to inform customers? Stop everyone before they enter and personally warn them? Have them sign a waiver before they use a trolley?

We inform every customer the second they walk into the building with two massive yellow posters on the doors with words and pictures explaining the anti theft system we have in place.

We also have two more signs on the walls inside the store, next to the doors before you leave and another on the security podium which is located between the doors. You literally can't miss them as they're A1 size, bright yellow and big bold writing. If customers don't see them or don't read them then that is not the store's fault.

I have never seen signs about locking trolleys in my local Asda. Next time I go I will check. I would suggest that the warning signs should be in the trolleys themselves. Alternatively or in addition, a red line across the exit at the point where they lock.

AutumnsCrow · 30/10/2022 21:02

How do you want stores to inform customers?

Well they could put the warnings on the trolleys for a start.

VanillaImpulse · 30/10/2022 20:54

Years ago I used to work for Asda and there were so many people who used to think they could come in for a free trolley dash! They would leave with flatscreen tv's and bottles of alcohol to a car waiting outside. I'm not surprised Asda have had to do something about to prevent it.

melj1213 · 30/10/2022 18:45

Madwife123 · 30/10/2022 18:01

No I want supermarkets to not use devices that can injure their customers, end of sentence. A warning does not absolve them legally of any injuries caused and like I said not all people can see clearly, read well or understand English. I’m sure once they’ve been sued enough they will rethink.

If we have nothing that can injure a customer (or staff member) in stores then they would be empty buildings.

Customers have to take responsibility for themselves - if you read the signs (and as I have repeatedly said they are both written clearly and provide clear pictures for those who can't/don't understand the writing) then you are aware of the trolleys potentially locking at the doors. If customers don't read those signs then that is on them, not the store. If you dislike the policies and procedures in a store you're free to shop elsewhere.

Madwife123 · 30/10/2022 18:01

melj1213 · 30/10/2022 17:56

How do you want stores to inform customers? Stop everyone before they enter and personally warn them? Have them sign a waiver before they use a trolley?

We inform every customer the second they walk into the building with two massive yellow posters on the doors with words and pictures explaining the anti theft system we have in place.

We also have two more signs on the walls inside the store, next to the doors before you leave and another on the security podium which is located between the doors. You literally can't miss them as they're A1 size, bright yellow and big bold writing. If customers don't see them or don't read them then that is not the store's fault.

No I want supermarkets to not use devices that can injure their customers, end of sentence. A warning does not absolve them legally of any injuries caused and like I said not all people can see clearly, read well or understand English. I’m sure once they’ve been sued enough they will rethink.

melj1213 · 30/10/2022 17:56

Madwife123 · 30/10/2022 17:47

But it’s no good informing them customers AFTER they’ve been injured by this. I’m honestly shocked that Asda thinks this is ok.

How do you want stores to inform customers? Stop everyone before they enter and personally warn them? Have them sign a waiver before they use a trolley?

We inform every customer the second they walk into the building with two massive yellow posters on the doors with words and pictures explaining the anti theft system we have in place.

We also have two more signs on the walls inside the store, next to the doors before you leave and another on the security podium which is located between the doors. You literally can't miss them as they're A1 size, bright yellow and big bold writing. If customers don't see them or don't read them then that is not the store's fault.

Madwife123 · 30/10/2022 17:52

melj1213 · 30/10/2022 11:27

How would that work considering the system is designed to stop people who are shoplifting, without warning? The way the system works is that as soon as you go through the security gate at the door the wheels lock if the system hasn't been deactivated. There is technically a small "warning" from the sound of the wheel locking but, obviously, if you're not listening or know to listen for it then it doesn't help.

Also, we have massive, bright yellow signs with huge writing on both doors, next to the doors and on our security podium, with pictures to warn of the trolley locking system ... People will still claim that the signs aren't obvious enough, but since working in retail I have encountered far too many people who seem to become unable to read when they walk into a shop.

I literally once had a man complaining that he'd waited at the kiosk when he wanted customer services and then had to wait again and said "There should be a sign to make it clearer which is which" ... I literally turned to the wall behind my desk with the 5ft illuminated green and white sign saying "CUSTOMER SERVICE" and the 5ft illuminated green and white one at the desk next to me saying "CIGARETTES AND LOTTERY KIOSK" and said "You mean like these signs?". His response? "Well I didn't read that!" 🙄

And what about those with vision problems, who don’t speak English, who can’t read? Are they ok to injure? I’ve never noticed signs about trolley locks because believe it or not I’m there to do my shopping and go home and don’t tend to look around. I think it’s reasonable to expect supermarkets not to risk injuring their customers. Google shows law suits of people having sustained broken bones as a result!

Madwife123 · 30/10/2022 17:47

melj1213 · 30/10/2022 11:06

If you don't have a reciept we just find out which checkout/self scan you used and either reprint the receipt or a member of staff verifies that they served you/witnessed you paying at a self scan and the security can unlock the trolley.

The security guard will usually ask a couple of questions to see why the trolley locked, and invariably it's because of the customer's actions and very very rarely is it due to malfunction - either they've switched their smaller trolley for a bigger one at the checkouts (we keep a few big trolleys at the back of the checkouts, usually for people using our mobility scooters who need help to take their stuff out to the car) so it has a "reset" trolley lock that will activate the door lock; or gone back through the self scan entrance because they used the first machine and it is quicker than going through the whole s/scan area; or bought a large item eg a TV at the cigarette kiosk (which doesn't have a deactivation point as it is right next to the exit) etc - so they can advise the customer how to avoid the situation in future.

But it’s no good informing them customers AFTER they’ve been injured by this. I’m honestly shocked that Asda thinks this is ok.

Ineedsleepandcoffee · 30/10/2022 16:27

Coincidentally I've just been to Asda and saw someone have an empty trolley lock on them as they tried to leave. They were unsurprisingly very confused looking.
I could see it happening to people with young kids/ babies as I've put them in the trolley before if I've gone in just to look for something rather than getting a buggy/ wheelchair out of the car.

melj1213 · 30/10/2022 14:34

Nocutenamesleft · 30/10/2022 13:34

I paid for all my stuff?!? Yet it still locked. Ours only goes if you try to go out the wrong entrance. Otherwise it works fine if you grabbed tons of food and rushed for the door! Ours doesn’t stop you

I know this because just two days ago someone did that exact thing at Asda!

Not every system is identical, every system will be set up differently depending on the store layout/requirements eg I know some systems don't activate their trolley locks immediately when you enter the store - it gives you a couple of minutes to go back out, without it locking, in case you realise you've forgotten your purse in the car or are just bringing a trolley in for a heavy item that has already been paid for etc

I'm just giving my experience and explanation of how the system works in general, and then specific examples of how it works in the store I'm employed in, to help people understand how it works.

Nocutenamesleft · 30/10/2022 13:34

melj1213 · 29/10/2022 23:32

The trolley locking system is basically that when you come in through the main doors with the trolley it "activates" the trolley lock which is only "deactivated" when you go through the checkout/exit the self scan area, allowing you to exit the store unimpeded. If you don't go through a checkout then when you go through the main doors the trolley will lock as it hasn't gone through the area needed to deactivate it.

It is a loss prevention system as basically it should only lock the trolley if you're trying to leave the store without going through a payment point. If someone fills up a trolley with items then tries to dash out of the store without paying then the trolley will lock at the door and stop them ... They might grab a few items from the trolley as they make a run for it but the store doesn't lose all of the stock.

Obviously there will be innocent people who are affected occasionally - if an individual trolley lock has malfunctioned and not deactivated; if you go to the cafe after shopping then the trolley lock will reset after a certain amount of time; if you just come in for a browse and you don't buy anything etc - but when those trolleys lock then a simple check that you have a receipt/trolley is empty and the security colleague can unlock it manually with a handheld device.

I paid for all my stuff?!? Yet it still locked. Ours only goes if you try to go out the wrong entrance. Otherwise it works fine if you grabbed tons of food and rushed for the door! Ours doesn’t stop you

I know this because just two days ago someone did that exact thing at Asda!

Nocutenamesleft · 30/10/2022 13:32

I had the trolley lock with me once. I swore you could drop the trolley off the other side of the store so that’s where I went

turns out you couldnt and it locked and they’ve got a special key that’s needed to unlock it again. Bloody nightmare!

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 30/10/2022 13:27

Dragonskin · 30/10/2022 11:22

However her experience sounds unpleasant and if she was frazzled at the end of a long day at work, having just picked up a tired child from chilcare and done a big shop - spending a lot of money in the store - being upset is reasonable!

I love how people create a whole backstory for the woman based on the OP simply saying this woman with maybe her son were walking out when their trolley locked.

Even if she was frazzled, shouting at the staff is unreasonable

Grin I personally deduced that she was Welsh, big fan of Strictly, works in a bank. Only went into that Asda because she heard they had her toddler's favourite yoghourts. Her partner's name is Jim.

MrsSkylerWhite · 30/10/2022 11:32

HiveBee · Today 11:24
MrsSkylerWhite · Today 11:17
It’s never acceptable to shout at (poorly paid) shop staff.

I don’t know there are some scenarios where the shop staff shout before the customers do. Just like nurses they aren’t all bloody Saints.”

I’m 58. Never been shouted at by shop staff or seen them shout at anyone else 🤷‍♀️

melj1213 · 30/10/2022 11:27

youkiddingme · 30/10/2022 05:48

Just a small thought - if the trolley locks in such a way that someone pushing it briskly could be hurt then I doubt any amount of signage makes that acceptable. Surely they could be designed to brake gradually rather than abruptly. Not everyone can read. Not everyone can see well enough to read signs that are at a distance.

How would that work considering the system is designed to stop people who are shoplifting, without warning? The way the system works is that as soon as you go through the security gate at the door the wheels lock if the system hasn't been deactivated. There is technically a small "warning" from the sound of the wheel locking but, obviously, if you're not listening or know to listen for it then it doesn't help.

Also, we have massive, bright yellow signs with huge writing on both doors, next to the doors and on our security podium, with pictures to warn of the trolley locking system ... People will still claim that the signs aren't obvious enough, but since working in retail I have encountered far too many people who seem to become unable to read when they walk into a shop.

I literally once had a man complaining that he'd waited at the kiosk when he wanted customer services and then had to wait again and said "There should be a sign to make it clearer which is which" ... I literally turned to the wall behind my desk with the 5ft illuminated green and white sign saying "CUSTOMER SERVICE" and the 5ft illuminated green and white one at the desk next to me saying "CIGARETTES AND LOTTERY KIOSK" and said "You mean like these signs?". His response? "Well I didn't read that!" 🙄

HiveBee · 30/10/2022 11:24

MrsSkylerWhite · 30/10/2022 11:17

It’s never acceptable to shout at (poorly paid) shop staff.

I don’t know there are some scenarios where the shop staff shout before the customers do. Just like nurses they aren’t all bloody Saints.

Dragonskin · 30/10/2022 11:22

However her experience sounds unpleasant and if she was frazzled at the end of a long day at work, having just picked up a tired child from chilcare and done a big shop - spending a lot of money in the store - being upset is reasonable!

I love how people create a whole backstory for the woman based on the OP simply saying this woman with maybe her son were walking out when their trolley locked.

Even if she was frazzled, shouting at the staff is unreasonable

MrsSkylerWhite · 30/10/2022 11:17

It’s never acceptable to shout at (poorly paid) shop staff.

melj1213 · 30/10/2022 11:13

TheOrigRights · 30/10/2022 10:18

@Discovereads
I'm not suggesting people should be allowed to leave with a trolley in a fire, it was a response to the poster who was concerned a trolley would block a fire escape. If they become unlocked you could unblock the escape

Our fire exits are located at various points around the store and none of them have the trolley lock. The only doors with the trolley lock are the main entrance doors.

If there was a fire alarm, which are very rare, then security will be at the door anyway with the deactivation device. Anyone approaching the doors with a trolley will be asked to leave it to the side anyway (as you don't get to take it out with you) because anyone with paid for shopping will have been directed to use the fire exit at the checkouts (to get to the main entrance from the checkouts you have to pass two other fire exits) so no issue with trolleys locking.

PinkButtercups · 30/10/2022 11:12

Our local Asda the trollies only lock if you go over a yellow line where the boundary ends of Asda. Probably because it's right next to a creek and trollies always end up in there.