Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I stingy? Boyfriend says i am?

390 replies

llpoolj · 29/10/2022 17:39

My boyfriend lives with me.
He earns £700 more than me a month.
He is always "skint"
He said he needed £20 for his phone.
So I said "il take it out of my savings account,just give me it on Monday when you get paid"
So then today he borrows another £10 and says so that's £310 I owe you Monday (£300 half of rent and bills )
I say no £330 ...£20 for phone too
He said "really ,your going to take that off me"
"I only topped up because you wanted me too"
(He didn't -he told me he needed to top up"
So he says "you know I would give you my last"
I said I buy you so much
I spent £10 buying him McDonald's today,I bought the food all week
I spent £170 last week on concert tickets for his birthday -then 2 hoodies for his birthday.
I reminded him of this and he says "no you can't class the tickets for my birthday -you wanted to go too"
I also bought us Xmas pjs for £30 two days ago

So how does he have the audacity to say I'm tight?
I just wanted it back to in my savings.
I'm feeling shitty and horrible now
I'm honestly not tight -I just don't want to get the mick took out of me

We go on holiday in two weeks
I've bought the sun tan lotion,after sun,case straps ,case locks ,luggage tags ,case scales,I bought him shorts for holiday and 2 tees and god knows what else

OP posts:
LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 01/11/2022 11:44

Stop buying anything for him - stop lending anything to him- stop giving him money...
See how long he stays.

DarceyG · 01/11/2022 11:37

llpoolj · 29/10/2022 17:39

My boyfriend lives with me.
He earns £700 more than me a month.
He is always "skint"
He said he needed £20 for his phone.
So I said "il take it out of my savings account,just give me it on Monday when you get paid"
So then today he borrows another £10 and says so that's £310 I owe you Monday (£300 half of rent and bills )
I say no £330 ...£20 for phone too
He said "really ,your going to take that off me"
"I only topped up because you wanted me too"
(He didn't -he told me he needed to top up"
So he says "you know I would give you my last"
I said I buy you so much
I spent £10 buying him McDonald's today,I bought the food all week
I spent £170 last week on concert tickets for his birthday -then 2 hoodies for his birthday.
I reminded him of this and he says "no you can't class the tickets for my birthday -you wanted to go too"
I also bought us Xmas pjs for £30 two days ago

So how does he have the audacity to say I'm tight?
I just wanted it back to in my savings.
I'm feeling shitty and horrible now
I'm honestly not tight -I just don't want to get the mick took out of me

We go on holiday in two weeks
I've bought the sun tan lotion,after sun,case straps ,case locks ,luggage tags ,case scales,I bought him shorts for holiday and 2 tees and god knows what else

I’d just posted recently about something similar but it was a very new relationship. Let him pay for himself and yes take the money off him.

Nikki0912 · 01/11/2022 11:25

They definitely class as a gift. Quite a few of my presents from my fella have been gig tickets. He’s come with me as he likes the bands (only by being forced to listen to them because of me 😂) but I would never dream of telling him they don’t count because he gets to come too. Your man is definitely sponging off you, and you’re allowing it. I’m not going to tell you to leave him as that’s your choice, but you definitely need to open your eyes and take a look in the mirror. Then scrub the word mug off your forehead before you find yourself without saving because he’s spent it all. If finances are separate, then they should stay that way, he pays for himself and you pay for you. In my house out finances are combined and then we can spend what’s left, leaves no room for tit-for-tat over who is able to buy what. Good luck!

ItsaMetalBand · 01/11/2022 11:24

Years ago I did have someone who briefly tried to get me to mammy him like that - give him money or do his shitwork for him. He was informed that I could be a lover or a mother to him, not both. And that if I was expected to be his mammy, he'd not be getting sex ever again from me, plus I'd dump him anyway because it's not what I signed up for. He kept it up and yeah, he got swiftly dumped.

I'm 18 years with DH. I have never bought him 'holiday clothes' and if he dared to complain about not having new clothes for his holiday with the implied dig that I should have sorted it out, I'd go through him for a shortcut.

SafferUpNorth · 01/11/2022 11:19

He earns more than you but you end up paying for everything???!!!!

HELLOOOOOOOO!! Time to dump this cocklodger.

redjoker · 01/11/2022 11:15

Testina · 29/10/2022 18:35

Screwing your son is incest.

I mean - buying him holiday clothes. You’re his mum, right? 🤮

THIS 😂

LuckySantangelo35 · 01/11/2022 11:15

llpoolj · 29/10/2022 17:43

@Itsallyellow22 he won't buy anything ,then he will complain that I have new clothes and he has nothing.
I can't win

@llpoolj

let him wear shitty old clothes and him complain then. If it bothered him that much he would buy some wouldn’t he?

it’s up to him

you do you.

it really is that simple

Comfort3 · 01/11/2022 11:14

Honestly, I have the same conversations with my 17 year old son! That frustrates me enough, I can’t imagine my husband being like this too!

dontgobaconmyheart · 01/11/2022 11:13

OP the dialogue you're having with this adult man is more like the conversation a mother has with a entitled child. How women find men attractive as romantic equals with these types of dynamics going on at home is beyond me. We may have been brought up conditioned to be caregivers to men, perpertually demonstrate reasons to choose or stay with us over someone else and make their lives as problem free as possible but that doesn't mean we must continue in the pursuit as adults. I cannot imagine buying a mans every day clothes/pants/socks for them as though I'm their mother, it just doesn't sit right.

Stop buying him things and taking on the load (mental and financial) of these things. He is perfectly capable of buying his own suncream etc and preparing for a holiday. He's manipulative and knows exactly how to wheedle more and more out of you and that is exactly what he's doing- either preying on the fact he knows you love him as reason why you should or suggesting that you don't really love him and are 'tight 'if you don't- you won't ever win.

I would be questioning what it is he does for you and what kind of partner rinses the other dry by doing that when they are the higher earner not reasonably contributing. Stop focusing on the insult that he's called you tight (when it's obviously actually him that is) and think about why your partner makes you feel that way.

chaosmaker · 01/11/2022 11:12

llpoolj · 29/10/2022 17:43

@Itsallyellow22 he won't buy anything ,then he will complain that I have new clothes and he has nothing.
I can't win

You reply that you have new clothes because you bought them and he is not a child and you are not his parent. What does he spend his money on? Does he have any good qualities?

lljwagg · 01/11/2022 11:12

So STOP buying him stuff, all the odds and sods add up.
what is he spending his money on if he gets more than you?
You must both be sharing the rent and other bills, food etc?

Onefootintheghool · 01/11/2022 10:57

TheRossatron · 29/10/2022 17:43

How can women have sex with these kinds of men and find them attractive?

He's a shameless, freeloading cunt. He would be out of my life and my sight faster than a fart in the wind. Fucking rancid.

He would be out of my life and my sight faster than a fart in the wind.
I'm so stealing that !
As for your boyfriend op, he is a user and you are his cash cow, sorry. Ditch him pronto.

Kattiekat · 01/11/2022 10:57

To add, unless you earn the same amount bills should be paid by percentage of earnings not split in half. For example if you earn 100 and he earns 200, the bill is 75. You should pay 25 and he should pay 50. You have both used a quarter of your earnings. That’s fair.

xogossipgirlxo · 01/11/2022 10:56

"So he says "you know I would give you my last""

Ah, those beautiful words that don't mean anything... He WOULD give you his last if he wasn't jerk, if he cared enough, if he treated you with respect. He would, he would... Dream on.

PumpkinSly · 01/11/2022 10:51

TheRossatron · 29/10/2022 17:43

How can women have sex with these kinds of men and find them attractive?

He's a shameless, freeloading cunt. He would be out of my life and my sight faster than a fart in the wind. Fucking rancid.

Couldn't have put it better 😂

Your BF is a child. Get rid of him.

Kattiekat · 01/11/2022 10:51

He may be one of those people who no matter what put an amount in their savings.
once it’s in there they never touch it, no matter what it’s like that money doesn’t exist, so to him he really is broke.
I know someone like that. Will take your last penny while their savings remain untouched.

abblie · 01/11/2022 10:48

Ammmm MOVE out ASAP the freeloader and stop being so soft ffs he is living like a king while your his slave

Topsyturvy78 · 01/11/2022 10:47

Ask him what he's doing with all his money. What does he do with the extra £700 he earns? I wouldn't be buying him clothes. You aren't the stingy one he is. Concert tickets are fine for a birthday gift. I took my daughter to a concert one year for her birthday.

Theskyisfallingdown · 01/11/2022 10:45

OP not bothered coming back?

@llpoolj there are eight billion humans on the planet. There is no need to pay a man to be your boyfriend.

MavisChunch29 · 01/11/2022 10:44

Ditch him and let him get a credit card instead.

DontMakeMeShushYou · 01/11/2022 10:43

He's spotted your weakness (fear of being seen as stingy) and is exploiting it/you for all he can get. Run for the hills!

PeachyIsThinking · 01/11/2022 10:35

We often give each other tickets for birthdays etc, but I could see why he might not see it as a gift- that’s something you need to agree in BEFORE you purchase such things.

He’s either right or he’s playing you. Neither is very attractive in a long term partner.

rossie21 · 01/11/2022 10:34

llpoolj · 29/10/2022 17:43

@Keyansier he doesn't have to pay for the concert tickets -I bought them for his birthday
He is saying they don't class as a birthday gift because I'm getting the second ticket as I also like the band so I'm going with him

What a nerve!

There is someone mean in this relationship. It’s not you.

CamelFlarge · 01/11/2022 10:32

Kick him out, or if he won't leave then you do (and end the tenancy). Write it off to experience, start afresh, be grateful you got out before any kids made it harder.

Booklover3 · 01/11/2022 10:29

Who paid for the holiday? I think you would be better off going alone! He’s a cheeky fucker.