Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think not everything is ‘misogyny’

905 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 29/10/2022 16:11

… and that the word is massively overused on here?

I’m getting quite tired of it if I’m honest, it feels like every other conversation the ‘misogyny’ card is whipped out and anyone who disagrees has ‘internalised misogyny’ (um no I just have a different opinion).

It’s becoming the ‘BeKind’ of feminism. Overused to the point it’s getting meaningless and irritating, and just used to ‘win’ any kind of nuanced topic without any proper discussion.

AIBU? 🤷🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
Topgub · 03/11/2022 10:47

No.

And neither will @Cuppasoupmonster

Because they'd have to admit it's not about the supposed precious life.

It's about judging and punishing women.

AKA mysoginy

Lookingforbargains · 03/11/2022 10:40

Clearly @niceduvet is not going to answer the question about why foetuses conceived in rape are not covered by the ‘all life is precious’ rule.

Topgub · 03/11/2022 10:20

niceduvet · 03/11/2022 09:49

I agree with Cuppa here. The argument that men are free from the consequences of getting a woman pregnant is just not true.

They dont face anything like the same consequences though, do they?

They aren't judged as being at fault in the sale way women are

I bet when you're judging women for having an abortion it never crosses your mind to judge the man.

Are you going to answer why you font care about the poor babies who were conceived through rape? Explain why you think they have no rights and their life is worthless?

LolaSmiles · 03/11/2022 10:08

I agree with Cuppa here. The argument that men are free from the consequences of getting a woman pregnant is just not true
So it's men who have to deal with the physical reality of pregnancy, the sick leave, the nature of birth, potential surgery

It's men who have to deal with postnatal complications

It's men who have to take time out of work because a baby has arrived and needs caring for 24/7

It's men who end up sacrificing their standard pay for a lower level allowance (and don't try to go on a tangent about shared parental leave because everyone I know, me and DH included, found quite quickly that SPL is not the norm, in fact it's unusual)

In the event an unplanned pregnancy is forced to continue and the relationship has ended/was never a relationship, it's the men who end up being the primary parent and the one the child lives

It's male non-resident parents who end up paying the majority of the costs that come with raising a child

It's men who end up having to sacrifice earning potential because they need a part time job in order to fit around school and childcare

It's men who take a hit on their pensions from large amounts of time out the workplace looking after small children

It's men who lose their long term earning potential and prospects because men are discriminated against for having children and the flexibility that requires

How long before we get the NAMALT argument/but women are mean to poor men/but society isn't actually systemically oppressive to women, it's just women don't like the consequences of their choices argument?

InsertPunHere · 03/11/2022 10:07

@Cuppasoupmonster but it clearly isn't as effective as you make out. The number of unplanned children born is huge - and that's the ones who were "surprised but OK with it" as opposed to "oh dear god no!"

According to one NHS trust, while "perfect use" of most forms of contraception are 99% effective, "typical use" are effective as little as 82% (condom) or 91% (pill). In a population that's a lot of unanticipated pregnancies.

monsteramunch · 03/11/2022 09:52

@niceduvet

Yes I do absolutely believe that life begins at conception. A life is forming right from the start obviously - what value you place on that clearly differs from person to person. For me, it is precious and has inherent value and worth just by existing.

So why do you make an exception for babies conceived through rape?

How come their lives aren't precious with inherent value?

niceduvet · 03/11/2022 09:49

Cuppasoupmonster · 03/11/2022 09:23

Meanwhile men are free to have as much sex as they like with whoever they like.

But they’re not are they? If they get someone pregnant they have zero say in whether she goes ahead it with it, and quite rightly. He is then legally bound to pay maintenance for 18 years. Which is as it should be.

I agree with Cuppa here. The argument that men are free from the consequences of getting a woman pregnant is just not true.

lifeturnsonadime · 03/11/2022 09:42

For me, it is precious and has inherent value and worth just by existing.

Unless it is a baby that derives from rape. Then it has less value and can be aborted.

@niceduvet why are babies of raped mothers less worthy.

You have been consistently asked this and have not answered.

pointythings · 03/11/2022 09:40

@LolaSmiles yes, that's the thing. Either life begins at conception, in which case alul life is precious and all abortions should be banned, or.... not. You can't say that women who are careless with contraception shouldn't get abortion, but those who have been careful, or who have been raped are allowed an abortion. That's completely inconsistent. Nail your colours to the mast - you're either a forced birther or not.

LolaSmiles · 03/11/2022 09:36

I dontwanna - Yes I do absolutely believe that life begins at conception. A life is forming right from the start obviously - what value you place on that clearly differs from person to person. For me, it is precious and has inherent value and worth just by existing

But your view is illogical because you're saying that some babies are more precious than others and it's fine to kill some babies but not others.

Your decision on which babies are precious and not seems to come down to your beliefs about a woman's behaviour.

LolaSmiles · 03/11/2022 09:34

He is then legally bound to pay maintenance for 18 years. Which is as it should be
Meanwhile in reality:

It's very easy for men to walk away in a way that mother's can't

If the father feels like playing ball they can pay very little maintenance that in no way compares to half the financial cost of a child, and can easily find ways to avoid paying maintenance. Some men will do the right thing obviously, but the ones who don't want to don't have to do much because our bar for them is so low.

They don't have the impact of taking leave from their job because there's a baby

They don't have the financial hit of being on maternity pay for a period of time.

They don't have to give or adjust their careers to reflect the fact they're a parent as it's the mothers who usually end up being the resident parent

They don't have to be the one taking unpaid leave when the child is poorly
They get to continue building their career,

They get to build their pension contributions and their earning potential because someone else is the primary parent.

Aside from the fact it's immoral to force a woman to give birth, the impact of forcing a woman to give birth is not equal between the mother and the father.

niceduvet · 03/11/2022 09:32

I dontwanna - Yes I do absolutely believe that life begins at conception. A life is forming right from the start obviously - what value you place on that clearly differs from person to person. For me, it is precious and has inherent value and worth just by existing.

lifeturnsonadime · 03/11/2022 09:25

it's a separate life in it's own right, so the women's right to autonomy over her own body argument (regarding abortion) falls down for me right there.

But that's not your argument. You think that some babies can be aborted. What about those babies lives. Because you argument that it is for the right of the unborn child fails the second you make the choice about the behaviour of the woman.

Cuppasoupmonster · 03/11/2022 09:23

Meanwhile men are free to have as much sex as they like with whoever they like.

But they’re not are they? If they get someone pregnant they have zero say in whether she goes ahead it with it, and quite rightly. He is then legally bound to pay maintenance for 18 years. Which is as it should be.

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 03/11/2022 09:21

Anyone would think that the pro life position was more about policing women's bodies for the crime of being sexual beings.

On the one hand we've got the argument of the deserving women who should have abortions and those pesky immoral women who have abortions for the 'wrong' reasons, and on the other we have the line that sex is fine for fun but unless they're consenting to motherhood women shouldn't be having sex.
Meanwhile men are free to have as much sex as they like with whoever they like.

Topgub · 03/11/2022 09:14

No

Some of them will be down to rape and assault and incest.

Some of them will be down to medical reasons

Some of them will be down to sheer carelessness

Some of them will be down to finances and a whole host of reasons.

What difference does it make?

The ending of a life is either OK or its not

If its not then it doesn't matter why you need to end it.

Lookingforbargains · 03/11/2022 09:13

Cuppasoupmonster · 03/11/2022 09:11

No, I think it’s 99% effective. And I don’t believe hundreds of thousands of abortions a year are down to true contraceptive failures.

What do you think they are down to then?

Topgub · 03/11/2022 09:11

@Cuppasoupmonster and if it fails?

OK to take a life then?

Why is that?

Cuppasoupmonster · 03/11/2022 09:11

No, I think it’s 99% effective. And I don’t believe hundreds of thousands of abortions a year are down to true contraceptive failures.

OP posts:
Topgub · 03/11/2022 09:11

@niceduvet

Ah.

So we don't have an answer as to why the lives of rapists babies are worthless. Why they deserve to die.

Poor things

Lookingforbargains · 03/11/2022 09:10

Cuppasoupmonster · 03/11/2022 09:09

@InsertPunHere well no because contraception? It’s free, it’s highly effective, use it?!

Do you think all contraception is 100% effective @Cuppasoupmonster ?

Cuppasoupmonster · 03/11/2022 09:09

@InsertPunHere well no because contraception? It’s free, it’s highly effective, use it?!

OP posts:
InsertPunHere · 03/11/2022 09:07

Pro-life is intrinsically a misogynistic position because it penalises women for having sex unless every single time they do so, they are consenting to motherhood.

That is clearly ridiculous.

ldontWanna · 03/11/2022 06:53

niceduvet · 02/11/2022 23:06

... why should the life you've created through an act of choice to have sex (assuming consensual) then have to pay the ultimate price.

Do you believe life starts at conception?

LolaSmiles · 03/11/2022 06:47

and no Lola, I certainly don't think sex is just for creating babies - fun sex is great!
Except you think women should have a consequence for engaging in fun sex because even if they use contraception you think they should be forced into giving birth.
It's a pretty quick way to shut down women's sex lives and remove the fun because your position becomes: men have as much sex as you like, but women better accept being forced into having a baby