Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think not everything is ‘misogyny’

905 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 29/10/2022 16:11

… and that the word is massively overused on here?

I’m getting quite tired of it if I’m honest, it feels like every other conversation the ‘misogyny’ card is whipped out and anyone who disagrees has ‘internalised misogyny’ (um no I just have a different opinion).

It’s becoming the ‘BeKind’ of feminism. Overused to the point it’s getting meaningless and irritating, and just used to ‘win’ any kind of nuanced topic without any proper discussion.

AIBU? 🤷🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 02/11/2022 17:40

SlickShady · 02/11/2022 17:38

But ‘gender’ (biological sex) does matter when we look at violence and spot that violent crimes are overwhelmingly carried out by men. So we either ignore that massive common factor or we don’t, and if we ignore it then how do we combat violence?

I'm not in any way denying this, nor am I saying you should ignore it. What I am saying is that it's not rooted in misogyny (ie a social system) but in biology (ie physical reality).

If you try to combat it by educating men not to commit crimes, not only are you bound to fail because 'men' already know that, you also alienate the men who would have been willing to help as they patronised and unfairly maligned.

So you think men are biologically more violent? Why?

Pumperthepumper · 02/11/2022 17:39

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 17:38

Your assertion that women are fundamentally at risk is a misogynistic one because it relies on the belief that we are feeble.

That’s not what I said though. I said men are more likely to be a victim of stranger violence.

magma32 · 02/11/2022 17:39

Not all men in positions of power are rich.
Self appointed community leaders in socially deprived communities who think they have a god given right to be in charge for instance.
My experience of misogyny has certainly not been at the hands of rich men but that doesn’t mean rich men in power aren’t a problem for me, just for me my direct experiences have not been at the hands of rich men.

I had an issue this morning with a man from my community try to intimidate me and when he saw I wasn’t going to take any shit he cowered back. This was not a rich man, just a random man who thought he could scare me because he thought I was another woman from the community who would take the shit.

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 17:38

SlickShady · 02/11/2022 17:38

But ‘gender’ (biological sex) does matter when we look at violence and spot that violent crimes are overwhelmingly carried out by men. So we either ignore that massive common factor or we don’t, and if we ignore it then how do we combat violence?

I'm not in any way denying this, nor am I saying you should ignore it. What I am saying is that it's not rooted in misogyny (ie a social system) but in biology (ie physical reality).

If you try to combat it by educating men not to commit crimes, not only are you bound to fail because 'men' already know that, you also alienate the men who would have been willing to help as they patronised and unfairly maligned.

Same energy as "making murder illegal will ensure no one ever gets murdered"

monsteramunch · 02/11/2022 17:38

@AMorningstar

The men in positions of power are RICH men and a minority of men. They're about as unrelatable to the average man as a Martian is.

It's not men v women, it's the super wealthy vs everyone else.

Overwhelmingly those super wealthy people are male, on a global scale.

Yes, a tiny minority of people make decisions that affect people on an international or even national level.

But the higher up the ladder, the more statistically likely someone is to be male.

Therefore the majority of global power and influence is held by men.

Any disparity that great is reflected in policy making, allocation of funds, the legal system, healthcare, growth of industries...

It's not a difficult thing to understand, because it's just a statistical fact.

SlickShady · 02/11/2022 17:38

But ‘gender’ (biological sex) does matter when we look at violence and spot that violent crimes are overwhelmingly carried out by men. So we either ignore that massive common factor or we don’t, and if we ignore it then how do we combat violence?

I'm not in any way denying this, nor am I saying you should ignore it. What I am saying is that it's not rooted in misogyny (ie a social system) but in biology (ie physical reality).

If you try to combat it by educating men not to commit crimes, not only are you bound to fail because 'men' already know that, you also alienate the men who would have been willing to help as they patronised and unfairly maligned.

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 17:38

Pumperthepumper · 02/11/2022 17:37

I don’t know what this means. That doesn't relate in any way to my post.

Your assertion that women are fundamentally at risk is a misogynistic one because it relies on the belief that we are feeble.

Pumperthepumper · 02/11/2022 17:37

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 17:36

I actually resent the assumption that I'm perfectly safe to walk past yet a man is some sort of potential horror. Are women so weak and feeble to you?

I don’t know what this means. That doesn't relate in any way to my post.

Pumperthepumper · 02/11/2022 17:36

niceduvet · 02/11/2022 17:30

I'm pro-life, am a women, think women are great and believe abortion is a moral issue, not just simply "health care". Does that make me a misogynist?

It might, why do you think it’s a moral issue?

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 17:36

Pumperthepumper · 02/11/2022 17:35

Well, you don’t know that - you don’t know the average man on the street isn’t violent. And remember, men are more likely to be a victim of violence by a stranger….but the culprit is massively more likely to be another man.

Literally nobody loses if we address male violence. Nobody.

I actually resent the assumption that I'm perfectly safe to walk past yet a man is some sort of potential horror. Are women so weak and feeble to you?

Pumperthepumper · 02/11/2022 17:35

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 17:29

That has literally nothing to do with a man and woman you walk past on the street though. I mean take your example - I'm a weightlifter and know several fighting styles. Are you saying I'm vulnerable if a skinny guy who's never set foot in a gym walks past? That would clearly be ridiculous.

Look at the people in front of you and judge appropriately.

Well, you don’t know that - you don’t know the average man on the street isn’t violent. And remember, men are more likely to be a victim of violence by a stranger….but the culprit is massively more likely to be another man.

Literally nobody loses if we address male violence. Nobody.

ldontWanna · 02/11/2022 17:35

@AMorningstar have you ever been attacked/mugged ?

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 17:34

monsteramunch · 02/11/2022 17:33

@AMorningstar

That has literally nothing to do with a man and woman you walk past on the street though.

Who has said it does?

We've been discussing global level positions of power and influence for pages and pages.

You're responding as if someone has said "I walked past a man and a woman today and assume the man's a wanker and the woman's lovely. All men are like that" when nobody has said anything of the sort.

Sharing statistics that show disproportionate representation of a sex class is not the same as saying everyone belonging to that sex class is 'bad'.

Then its pointless saying men, isn't it? Given that's 50% of the population.

monsteramunch · 02/11/2022 17:33

@AMorningstar

That has literally nothing to do with a man and woman you walk past on the street though.

Who has said it does?

We've been discussing global level positions of power and influence for pages and pages.

You're responding as if someone has said "I walked past a man and a woman today and assume the man's a wanker and the woman's lovely. All men are like that" when nobody has said anything of the sort.

Sharing statistics that show disproportionate representation of a sex class is not the same as saying everyone belonging to that sex class is 'bad'.

SlickShady · 02/11/2022 17:33

@Lookingforbargains

You can call it something else if the word misogyny troubles you so much - how about oppression of the physically weaker people? Does it make it better if we describe it differently? It’s still the same old bullshit as far as women are concerned.

That's the argument I made right in the beginning. Violent crime is neither systemic nor motivated by misogyny. It's individual criminals going for the easiest targets.

Not something society condones or accepts, nor is it systemic. Hence the solution isn't education or changing the 'system', as the problems don't originate from there.

Topgub · 02/11/2022 17:32

monsteramunch · 02/11/2022 17:29

To say that men have a hugely disproportionate amount of power and influence on a global scale (which is statistically a fact) isn't the same as saying all men are arseholes.

It's reductive and simplistic (and disingenuous if you do have a grip on statistics) to suggest that someone saying the former also believes the latter.

You can still think it's right to treat everyone as an individual and not assume all men are arseholes (they aren't) while also acknowledging the disproportionate power and influence held by men as a sex class on a global scale.

They aren't mutually exclusive beliefs.

👏👏

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 17:32

monsteramunch · 02/11/2022 17:29

To say that men have a hugely disproportionate amount of power and influence on a global scale (which is statistically a fact) isn't the same as saying all men are arseholes.

It's reductive and simplistic (and disingenuous if you do have a grip on statistics) to suggest that someone saying the former also believes the latter.

You can still think it's right to treat everyone as an individual and not assume all men are arseholes (they aren't) while also acknowledging the disproportionate power and influence held by men as a sex class on a global scale.

They aren't mutually exclusive beliefs.

The men in positions of power are RICH men and a minority of men. They're about as unrelatable to the average man as a Martian is.

It's not men v women, it's the super wealthy vs everyone else.

niceduvet · 02/11/2022 17:30

I'm pro-life, am a women, think women are great and believe abortion is a moral issue, not just simply "health care". Does that make me a misogynist?

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 17:29

Pumperthepumper · 02/11/2022 17:26

But ‘gender’ (biological sex) does matter when we look at violence and spot that violent crimes are overwhelmingly carried out by men. So we either ignore that massive common factor or we don’t, and if we ignore it then how do we combat violence?

That has literally nothing to do with a man and woman you walk past on the street though. I mean take your example - I'm a weightlifter and know several fighting styles. Are you saying I'm vulnerable if a skinny guy who's never set foot in a gym walks past? That would clearly be ridiculous.

Look at the people in front of you and judge appropriately.

monsteramunch · 02/11/2022 17:29

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 17:24

No wind up. I think highly of some women and very little of others - I judge them on their character and their gender is irrelevant.

Yeah me too. I hate this thing of judging people on what group they belong to. I don't care...I care whether you're an arsehole or not.

To say that men have a hugely disproportionate amount of power and influence on a global scale (which is statistically a fact) isn't the same as saying all men are arseholes.

It's reductive and simplistic (and disingenuous if you do have a grip on statistics) to suggest that someone saying the former also believes the latter.

You can still think it's right to treat everyone as an individual and not assume all men are arseholes (they aren't) while also acknowledging the disproportionate power and influence held by men as a sex class on a global scale.

They aren't mutually exclusive beliefs.

magma32 · 02/11/2022 17:29

Lookingforbargains · 31/10/2022 14:59

No, the biggest detractors of the feminine and attackers of women are other women.
You may laugh @ bargains but it's not as amusing as your ridiculous example of child care and misogyny, some rather spectacular fallacious reasoning

You are, quite simply, wrong. The idea that women are largely responsible for undermining women (assuming that’s what you mean by ‘detractors of the feminine’) is a lie sold to you by the patriarchy. Sure, there are women who criticise and undermine women, but the problem doesn’t originate there.

Ironically, of woman-against-woman criticism, it’s your brand of ‘pick me’ behaviour that undermines women the most. You’re part of the problem, I’m afraid, but you didn’t start it. You see, this ‘Women aren’t oppressed, look at me enjoying all this freedom’ is man-pleasing rhetoric even if you don’t realise it. And in settling for this, and getting a Pat on the head from Men, you throw less privileged women under the bus.

Haven’t read all the thread but this comment stands out to me and I completely agree.

Topgub · 02/11/2022 17:28

No

But the patriarchy exists because most positions of power are held by men, does make sense.

Your argument doesn't. It's not even comparable for a start

Pumperthepumper · 02/11/2022 17:27

SlickShady · 02/11/2022 17:26

You just happen to pick a marginalised ethnic and religious group who have had appalling atrocities committed against them to try and argue that women discussing patriarchy are unreasonable, whilst trying to place the dominant group (men) in the place of an oppressed group who are still enduring oppression?

For the final time (seriously).

The argument made is:
[ZZZZZ] run the world because the world's top [ZZZZZ] are [ZZZZZ].

Phrase it 'Jews run the world because the world's top bankers are Jews', and you're an anti-semitic nutter.

But 'Men run the world because the world's top CEOs are men' is a coherent argument?

But men in charge aren’t just bankers or CEOs.

Pumperthepumper · 02/11/2022 17:26

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 17:24

No wind up. I think highly of some women and very little of others - I judge them on their character and their gender is irrelevant.

Yeah me too. I hate this thing of judging people on what group they belong to. I don't care...I care whether you're an arsehole or not.

But ‘gender’ (biological sex) does matter when we look at violence and spot that violent crimes are overwhelmingly carried out by men. So we either ignore that massive common factor or we don’t, and if we ignore it then how do we combat violence?

SlickShady · 02/11/2022 17:26

You just happen to pick a marginalised ethnic and religious group who have had appalling atrocities committed against them to try and argue that women discussing patriarchy are unreasonable, whilst trying to place the dominant group (men) in the place of an oppressed group who are still enduring oppression?

For the final time (seriously).

The argument made is:
[ZZZZZ] run the world because the world's top [ZZZZZ] are [ZZZZZ].

Phrase it 'Jews run the world because the world's top bankers are Jews', and you're an anti-semitic nutter.

But 'Men run the world because the world's top CEOs are men' is a coherent argument?

Swipe left for the next trending thread