Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why some men have children at all?

244 replies

TheRossatron · 29/10/2022 13:56

When they have absolutely zero interest in family life? I see it on here constantly. I don't mean men who accidentally get someone pregnant and shirk responsibility... I mean men who enter into a relationship with a woman, propose, get married and try for babies... then end up with two toddlers and a presumption that they can dump everything onto the wife and fuck off out all weekend every weekend to play golf? Or get smashed in the pub? Or sit playing video games all day? I myself loathe the thought of family life - I just wouldn't want to be tied to anyone and would feel suffocated and resentful. So why on earth don't they just stay single and childless?! Baffles me.

(Disclaimer - I know there are loads of really good men out there!)

OP posts:
Vallmo47 · 29/10/2022 19:15

I just cannot believe how insensitive some people are being - is life REALLY that black and white that you can solely blame the woman for an unwanted pregnancy now? And if the woman cannot face terminating the baby, for whatever reason, again it’s ENTIRELY her fault and she should have known better, because she already knew the man was shit? Fantastic- I’m out.

Endlesssummer2022 · 29/10/2022 19:12

Because there are people who just drift into things thinking they want it because everyone else including their partner wants it. They are man babies.

For example, I know a guy who was all for having kids and a SAHW. His DW was the main driver but he went with it because he loved her but now he resents being the main breadwinner. He hasn’t said anything to her as far as I know but bitches about it to DH. It’s really childish behaviour.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/10/2022 19:12

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 29/10/2022 19:09

There was a very similar thread to this not long ago and it really annoyed me how those of us who genuinely were left in the lurch by men who had been good, reliable, sensible partners, planned children etc and were fully involved until they suddenly weren't are told that we are either lying or deluded and that there MUST have been warning signs. There really aren't sometimes.

But rarely. Very rarely do adults do 180-degree personality / character changes.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/10/2022 19:11

I’m pretty sure all human beings get things wrong at times.

Yes, well, choosing a shit man for another human being's father isn't exactly a minor life error like running up credit-card debt or crashing your car into the garden wall.

It's a monumental fuck-up that is going to have ramifications for the offspring and those around him/her for the next 70-100 years. Saying "oh well, never mind, you couldn't help it" to people who choose to procreate (often repeatedly) with horrible or even lackluster partners is letting them off far too easily and just perpetuates the social ills that result from poor reproductive choices.

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 29/10/2022 19:09

There was a very similar thread to this not long ago and it really annoyed me how those of us who genuinely were left in the lurch by men who had been good, reliable, sensible partners, planned children etc and were fully involved until they suddenly weren't are told that we are either lying or deluded and that there MUST have been warning signs. There really aren't sometimes.

SandyY2K · 29/10/2022 19:09

@TeapotTitties · Today 15:01

When a woman has a baby with a man who turns out to be a shit dad, she knows he's a shit dad and complains that he's a shit dad.

Would you blame her for deciding to have more children with him, or is there a way to contort yourself and really really stretch to that being 100% his fault?

I know a couple of people who have gone on to have more kids with a shit dad, because they didn't want multiple fathers for their kids.... in this case they are actively chosing a shit dad for child number 2. That is on her.

That is100% her fault. It's not her fault that he's shit, but it is absolutely HER fault, for choosing him to father yet another child with.

Vallmo47 · 29/10/2022 19:04

@CheezePleeze No not at all, but Op doesn’t have children and is judging away anyway. I just don’t think it’s helpful to parents to get further judgment - dealing with a shit father/husband isn’t bad enough? I just think it’s in bad taste that’s all- I wouldn’t go up to Op and judge her for her life choices, I’m pretty sure all human beings get things wrong at times. I’m not saying the child itself is a mistake obviously, but how do we know for a fact who is going to be a perfect parent? I didn’t even know what I’d be like as a parent, every day is trial and error and we all learn as we go along. Is it so hard to be nice and understanding to women who are struggling? The many replies saying about women pushing men into it is in bad taste, I’m pretty sure most men are educated enough to know what to do to avoid accidental pregnancies. In life there are no guarantees and there are many parents who come across bad at times - because parenting 24/7 isn’t easy. What is easy is tut and wag your finger and say “I knew this man was no good” with evidence in hand. Even with evidence of the above, I still don’t think it’s helpful to a struggling parent. But Op did well getting a rise out of so many, job well done.

BreadInCaptivity · 29/10/2022 18:58

My friend was married to a man who was very clear he didn't want children.

She begged and begged until he gave in, but said in no uncertain terms that she shouldn't expect him to be a hands on father.

Thing is, as soon as their DD was born he simply feel in love and turned out to about as hands on as it gets. She's absolutely the apple of his eye (and about to turn 18 now so not a flash in the pan).

He still says how grateful he is that his wife "made" him agree to have a child and how much he loves her for not giving up on him.

So, it can work the other way around, though IME this is a less common scenario.

Part of it I think is just that people think it's just what you do. Get married, buy a home, have children and just live life on autopilot without really thinking about it.

The other thing I've noticed is the issue of maturity. I've known couples where the woman is ready to have children and the husband is still acting like he's in his twenties when pushing 40. Unfortunately time is in mens side when it comes to fertility and that frankly been an issue in having children at their wife's pace and not their own. Quite a few have become good fathers to a second family, whilst being shocking to their first simply imho because they finally grew the fuck up.

All that said, unless a man is pressured into having children then I think it's really hard to guess what sort of parent he will be. Men I thought would be great fathers turn out to enjoy anything and everything above being an active parent and the same in reverse.

I know blended families have their own challenges but one thing I was 100% sure of was that DH would be a good father to our children because he was such a good father to his existing child (and an effective co-parent with his ex and didn't low ball her on maintenance because he wanted his child and her mum to have a good standard of living).

mydogisthebest · 29/10/2022 18:55

Vallmo47 · 29/10/2022 16:03

Wow, I find this thread utterly, utterly depressing. How helpful to point out that others make life choices you’d never in a billion years do themselves. I’d never in a billion years choose to not have kids because the “sperm donor” MIGHT turn out to be useless. I’m with the most wonderful man who didn’t initially want children in fear he wasn’t responsible enough, but as time went on his opinions changed and he stepped up and is a fantastic dad. This also happens. We are a team and it works very well. But I don’t judge anyone for where life takes them, full stop. Maybe if you’re on Mumsnet to criticise parents you should think twice before posting- you have no idea who you offend. 🤨

So many women are just so desperate to have children they would have them with almost any man.

If a woman is stupid and desperate enough to have a child or even more than 1 with an utterly useless man then she deserve to be criticised and tough if she is offended.

I also agree with other posters that the number of "accidental" pregnancies is ridiculous

SudocremOnEverything · 29/10/2022 18:48

I think it’s that some men genuinely do think that that’s all that’s required to be considered a ‘family man’. The family is there to meet his needs if he chooses. But mostly he’d rather bugger off to play golf and leave his wife with the kids and the household labour.

That’s what wanting kids and a family means to them.

The bar is very low for men, so it’s easy for them to find themselves surrounded by people who think the same way and reinforce what a brilliant father he is. To the extent that it’s the disgruntled wife who gets painted as a controlling shrew if she isn’t delighted with this set up.

cavily1806 · 29/10/2022 18:46

I don't think anyone, including women, know how hard it'll be until the kids are here. It's just more socially acceptable for men to be rubbish or walk away than women

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/10/2022 18:46

Penguinsaregreat · 29/10/2022 18:42

I can say with authority that around 30% of people should not breed. They are unfit parents.
Society pushes people into having children selling them a lie.
Not only do these people have a child they then go on to have yet more children, often with other people.
Quite often it’s intelligent, kind, compassionate women who do not have children.
As for unsuitable men, well the fact is women have sex with men they find attractive. These men are not necessarily great father and husband material. The same applies to men. They do not think “hey let me marry and have sex with a woman who will be a committed mother.” No they just have sex with who turns them on. I also agree that a good percentage of men just go along with what these women they want to shag want. They don’t have the guts to say “No, I do not want children.”

I've had sex and relationships with a number of attractive men whom I knew would be shit fathers, so I took rigorous steps to make damn sure I didn't become pregnant by them.

It really galls me to hear women (or read them on fora such as this) complaining about the difficulties of life with some longtime waster and then add ".... and I can't work because we have 2/3/4 DC and I am trapped as a SAHM...and we're not married..." I mean, just why? do they never think of the lives their poor offspring are destined to lead?

Have all the recreational bad-boy sex you want, just for god's sake use multiple forms of birth control.

VladmirsPoutine · 29/10/2022 18:45

I've said it before and I'll say it again, there's very good reason why the happiest demographics are single childfree women, and married men.

CheezePleeze · 29/10/2022 18:44

Vallmo47 · 29/10/2022 16:03

Wow, I find this thread utterly, utterly depressing. How helpful to point out that others make life choices you’d never in a billion years do themselves. I’d never in a billion years choose to not have kids because the “sperm donor” MIGHT turn out to be useless. I’m with the most wonderful man who didn’t initially want children in fear he wasn’t responsible enough, but as time went on his opinions changed and he stepped up and is a fantastic dad. This also happens. We are a team and it works very well. But I don’t judge anyone for where life takes them, full stop. Maybe if you’re on Mumsnet to criticise parents you should think twice before posting- you have no idea who you offend. 🤨

Maybe if you’re on Mumsnet to criticise parents you should think twice before posting- you have no idea who you offend. 🤨

No-one is above criticism just because they've managed to procreate.

So if your bloke turned out to be a shit dad, you'd be fine with that and never criticise him for it?

Penguinsaregreat · 29/10/2022 18:42

I can say with authority that around 30% of people should not breed. They are unfit parents.
Society pushes people into having children selling them a lie.
Not only do these people have a child they then go on to have yet more children, often with other people.
Quite often it’s intelligent, kind, compassionate women who do not have children.
As for unsuitable men, well the fact is women have sex with men they find attractive. These men are not necessarily great father and husband material. The same applies to men. They do not think “hey let me marry and have sex with a woman who will be a committed mother.” No they just have sex with who turns them on. I also agree that a good percentage of men just go along with what these women they want to shag want. They don’t have the guts to say “No, I do not want children.”

Getoff · 29/10/2022 18:41

Just as many men want children as women.

I would have agreed with the person you are disagreeing with, but then I saw a survey that supported your position. Actually, about 10% few men say they want children, but I think it was something like 70% vs 80% for women, so that's not a significant difference.

My fall-back position is, OK, maybe nearly as many men say they want children, but when you compare men who say they do with women who say they do, do both want them equally strongly, on average? Ignoring that men can't give birth, if they could do anything women do, would they be equally willing to make the same level of sacrifice? Perhaps a lot of those men are only saying they want children based on the assumption that a woman is going to be doing all the work.

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 29/10/2022 18:38

It's the men who cant seem to fathom that life has to change with an extra little human in the mix. They dont seem to realise sleepless nights will be ongoing for months and yes, even though they're working they will still be expected to do their fair share!

No, you cant just plan meals out or nights on the town at the drop of a hat, who did you think would have the baby?

I feel that's part of the issues, men just cant seem to figure out how much life will change. Whereas a woman knows she'll spend 9 months pregnant, not drinking, not partying etc. She has already made that peace.

My BIL refused to give up his friday night pub crawls, my sister had 2 kids with him yet still moaned that he went out. He ended up meeting another woman, with no kids, and having an affair. Eventually moving in with her.

We're 13 years into parenting, it's been bloody hard! But DH has been a hands on Dad all the way through thank goodness. He's probably better at it than I am as he seems to have more patience.

I see so many women who dont protect themselves from having children with drug taking, heavy drinking losers. How many threads do we read where OP says they're DH has taken cocaine, or cannabis and they know he used to take it and seem surprised that they're sitting at home with the baby and DH is off doing it again. Colour me shocked.

I think women need to take responsibility for bringing a life into the word with a waste of space, as much as men need to take responsibility for the child they created. It's not an either or scenario here.

mydogisthebest · 29/10/2022 18:37

I think a lot of men really could not care less whether they have children or not but because most women want them they go along with it.

Also an awful lot of women regret having them when they realise the reality of life with children. Women can't usually easily walk away and most just would not. Men don't have any such problem with it.

I do also have to agree that so many women have children with men who they know, or have a damn good idea, will be shit fathers.

So many threads when women are moaning they have 2 or more children and have to do everything while their husband do nothing. Bad enough having 1 child with them but for goodness sake why have more?

Florenz · 29/10/2022 18:33

I honestly think that a male contraceptive pill would be the end of humanity. Well it wouldn't as governments would take measures to encourage people to have children.

BeyondsEnergyObsession · 29/10/2022 18:29

FrenchOnionShoeBox · 29/10/2022 17:42

I agree with the view that most men, given a free choice would remain childfree. My DH freely admitted that he was completely ambivalent about having children. Now DD is here he’s besotted with her and spends loads of time with her, but still freely admits that given the straight choice he wouldn’t have had kids.

OT, but I think it's important to note that a lot of women are ambivalent about having children too. But they have societal pressure towards it in a way that men don't.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/10/2022 18:24

EnterFunnyNameHere · 29/10/2022 17:01

DH and I are child free by choice. I get a LOT of stick for it - the typical "you'll change your mind when your older (I'm 38!) / meet the right man (I'm married!)" bullshit. I hate it.

But even worse, my DH gets a lot of "wow how did you swing that?!" in tones of wonder - these are married men with kids already! Luckily I'm not there when this is said or I'd struggle to restrain myself from pointing out it was entirely their decision to have children, I'm pretty sure none were raped by their wives! But imagine feeling confident enough that obviously no men actually want children to say that when you have them yourself, in a group who also mostly have them. And they're right in that there seems to be no backlash from the other dads.

A year or so I was out in a pub with an old college friend; a reasonably attractive man about my age (50s) was nearby and we were chatting. He asked a few questions and then marveled "You've never been married and you don't have kids???" like he had found the Holy Grail. He asked it again and again I confirmed. His eyes lit up and he asked for my contact information. I've had similar reactions over the years. (Didn't go out with him btw).

Based on remarks from co-worker men over the past couple of decades, and encounters like that, I do conclude that only a small sub-set of men actually want day-to-day parenting. Some want to prove their manhood, some go along to get along, some cave to family expectations, but very, very few really want to be interacting with infants, toddlers and school-age children.

It's a standing joke in my neighborhood that on weekends every man with kids takes 3x longer than those without to mow and tend their gardens, as an excuse to be out of the house with ear protectors on.

I just wish they'd have the balls to own up to their lack of interest and take steps to prevent conception. But many women know this about their men and proceed anyway; that's reprehensible too.

crazeecatladee · 29/10/2022 18:19

When I met DH I knew I loved him, but due to his fragile MH I also knew I'd never have children with him. I knew he wouldn't be able to cope. Fifty yrs later and I know it was the right decision. He's come to realise he's too selfish. Having children is an act of faith in the future......( and don't tell me he should have had a choice. He was quite happy for me to have a coil fitted for years so we wouldn't have to bother with condoms)

Rinatinabina · 29/10/2022 18:07

VladmirsPoutine · 29/10/2022 16:27

I think a lot of men, women included, underestimate the huge impact a baby/child will have on their lives and subsequently get resentful or just check out altogether. The issue is that unlike a new golf kit, you can't store kids in the cupboard when you're bored of them. That said, even men who go in all guns blazing can fall to this, and deep down a lot of women probably wish they'd never had kids but it's not very acceptable by societies standards for women to leave their babies.

Yup

SandyY2K · 29/10/2022 18:02

They like the image of being a family man, without the hard work that comes with it.

Kabbalah · 29/10/2022 18:01

PurpleButterflyWings Fuck me there are some shitty comments on this thread

Yep, mainly from you. 🥱

Swipe left for the next trending thread