Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why some men have children at all?

244 replies

TheRossatron · 29/10/2022 13:56

When they have absolutely zero interest in family life? I see it on here constantly. I don't mean men who accidentally get someone pregnant and shirk responsibility... I mean men who enter into a relationship with a woman, propose, get married and try for babies... then end up with two toddlers and a presumption that they can dump everything onto the wife and fuck off out all weekend every weekend to play golf? Or get smashed in the pub? Or sit playing video games all day? I myself loathe the thought of family life - I just wouldn't want to be tied to anyone and would feel suffocated and resentful. So why on earth don't they just stay single and childless?! Baffles me.

(Disclaimer - I know there are loads of really good men out there!)

OP posts:
Cuppasoupmonster · 29/10/2022 23:19

Yes I am Zelda. Do you have children?

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/10/2022 23:11

b) then I hope you don’t expect there to be anyone to cut your hair, take your bins out or nurse you when you’re elderly 🤷🏼‍♀️

Small price to pay for saving the planet for other species. Are you aware of the insect-die off, what is happening to marine life and other depradations caused by human overpopulation? The elephants and rhinos? The bees?

Scottishskifun · 29/10/2022 22:29

I have a friend who's husband is a chocolate teapot of a dad, she makes excuses for him, he promised to change for their second it lasted all of 3 weeks til he went back to being lazy doing what he wanted at weekends without a second thought for his wife now with 2 kids.
She still makes excuses for him.

I don't think hobbies before children is a give away my DH is a amazing dad and does outdoor sports. But we communicate and share it equally so we both get time and it's gone from every weekend to once a month/a fortnight depending on conditions.

RandomMusings7 · 29/10/2022 22:22

Are you trying to argue that it's ok for kids to grow up in broken homes, in poverty, with shit fathers etc just because we need to keep feeding the capitalist machine with cheap labour?

Do you hear yourself @Cuppasoupmonster ??

RandomMusings7 · 29/10/2022 22:19

b) then I hope you don’t expect there to be anyone to cut your hair, take your bins out or nurse you when you’re elderly 🤷🏼‍♀️

@Cuppasoupmonster are you for real? 😂😂🤡

Cuppasoupmonster · 29/10/2022 22:17

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/10/2022 22:10

If only people in perfect circumstances had kids; hardly anybody would.

a) if only people would spend their teens and 20s becoming educated, self-aware and financially solvent, THEN have kids, the circumstances of most births would be orders of magnitude better

b) hardly anyone producing children would be a massive boon to this poor planet and all of the other species we're killing off each and every day.

The idea that it's better to produce offspring in sub-par situations than to do without is just ... words fail me.

a) why do you get to dictate what ‘educated’ and ‘self aware’ is? You sound incredibly patronising.

b) then I hope you don’t expect there to be anyone to cut your hair, take your bins out or nurse you when you’re elderly 🤷🏼‍♀️

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/10/2022 22:10

If only people in perfect circumstances had kids; hardly anybody would.

a) if only people would spend their teens and 20s becoming educated, self-aware and financially solvent, THEN have kids, the circumstances of most births would be orders of magnitude better

b) hardly anyone producing children would be a massive boon to this poor planet and all of the other species we're killing off each and every day.

The idea that it's better to produce offspring in sub-par situations than to do without is just ... words fail me.

DonnaBanana · 29/10/2022 22:05

To be fair, if young men and women were properly educated on what it takes to raise a child we’d die out as a species. It is not an alluring prospect at all but you just close your eyes and cross your fingers. You don’t want to know too much, much like not looking inside a supermarket sandwich or knowing what’s in your burger.

RandomMusings7 · 29/10/2022 22:02

Cuppasoupmonster · 29/10/2022 21:31

If only people in perfect circumstances had kids; hardly anybody would.

@Cuppasoupmonster there's a great wide spectrum between shit circumstances and perfect circumstances and you are being purposefully obtuse.

TedMullins · 29/10/2022 21:59

SandyY2K · 29/10/2022 21:08

@ZeldaWillTellYourFortune

each and every month I was totally in charge of my own fertility, in charge of who I slept with, in charge of what contraception I/we used, in charge of whether or not to abstain during fertile periods, in charge of what happened should an unwanted pregnancy happen.

No one else controlled these circumstances for me and in no way, shape or form would I have proceeded with a pregnancy with some loser, user, abuser, addict, unemployable, spendthrift, man-child, disinterested or fickle man, no matter how attractive, how good in bed or how much "in love" I was.

Frankly, it IS that black and white for me, and if we counseled/educated young women as we should, about the huge toll to them, to their offspring and to society of reproducing with shit men, maybe more of them would take charge and be discriminating about their sperm donors.

I agree with you 100%

It was black and white for me.

Another problem is staying in a relationship with a shitty partner then accidentally getting pregnant, so you're then tied to the idiot for life.

If you split up, you then have to coparent and face the possibility that he'll end up with another woman, who becomes stepmum to your kids and resents their very existence.

It often amazes me that people can put more thought into where they go on holiday, than they do creating a new life.

I think they should educate young people as part of the national curriculum .... so that from a young age, some of this sticks.

I know someone who told me, her daughter's school had a session on abuse and abusive relationships, then she came home and told her mum what she learned in school and that she (mum) was being abused by her dad.

That was finally what made her leave (even though she already knew it was an abusive relationship) but she had 5 kids at this point.

Yes, another here who it literally is that black and white for. It seems like some people want to absolve women of any personal responsibility at all. Don’t get me wrong, society absolutely enables and even encourages shit, misogynist attitudes in men and it certainly isn’t women’s fault they’re shit, but women have a choice about the men they choose to associate with.

I’ve been in toxic relationships and hung onto abusive men, and I knew something was wrong that I seemed to keep being attracted to types like that, so I got therapy and worked on myself. Guess what, the root was having a shit father! But I made an active choice not to end up in the same position as my mum.

Ive always instinctively known I don’t want kids and I know several other women who feel the same, a couple of whom dumped their male partners because the men did want kids. We’re not that rare. Going on mumsnet only strengthened my feelings about not having them because you can come on here and read all day about the horrible realities of parenting (and the good parts wouldn’t make the bad worth it for me). As for doing it because you’re supposed to… I actually met a man recently who said this, and admitted he hates being a father. I have absolutely no respect or sympathy for anyone, man or woman, who had kids simply because that’s what “you’re meant to do”. I feel for the poor kids in that situation.

elprup · 29/10/2022 21:51

For me it’s been the opposite experience - DH really wanted kids, I wasn’t that fussed. We went on to have DC after he persuaded me and I’m so very glad we did - it’s been the best thing I’ve ever done. And DH is a great, very involved dad.

I’m just one example but knowing all my friends as I do, all their DHs are very hands on, loving dads too.

Kolarbri · 29/10/2022 21:50

@ZeldaWillTellYourFortune Couldn’t agree more. Someone on another thread said that around 30% of people just shouldn’t breed!
She’s not wrong!

Cuppasoupmonster · 29/10/2022 21:31

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/10/2022 21:24

Better to regret missing the chance to have kids than to perpetuate social ills by rearing hapless children in toxic, dysfunctional and abusive environments. SO incredibly selfish to produce offspring in these horrible circumstances.

And the kids will go on to create the same messes, odds are.

If only people in perfect circumstances had kids; hardly anybody would.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/10/2022 21:24

Better to regret missing the chance to have kids than to perpetuate social ills by rearing hapless children in toxic, dysfunctional and abusive environments. SO incredibly selfish to produce offspring in these horrible circumstances.

And the kids will go on to create the same messes, odds are.

BeyondsEnergyObsession · 29/10/2022 21:22

Look I never got accidentally pregnant, despite at times not being "in charge of my own fertility, in charge of who I slept with, etc etc". But is it really that hard to have a bit of empathy for women who do end up in shit situations? They end up there - precisely as you say - because of what they have learned about relationships from when they are younger/and even those they see at present.

And yes, it should be better, and women should be counselled/educated on what is a decent expectation for life - I agree with you 100% on that. But at present, they are not, and that is exactly what leads to suddenly realising (despite it being painfully obvious in hindsight; "well I always knew he was shit at xyz and I wasn't particularly happy, but thought that was normal/would improve/whatever") that you have fucked up the last ten years. projecting much, Beyond?

Another yes from me btw that it is black/white that women (and men, it applies to both) should be and are not taught - from life, or education - the realities of childbearing/rearing. People of both sexes should clearly understand that not having children is an option and they are not just "what comes next". And for my personal bugbear, risks should be highlighted more. OT but the minimisation of the risks of pregnancy imo contributes hugely towards the current normalisation of surrogacy (underlining unintentional here, I just can't get rid of it!)

KimberleyClark · 29/10/2022 21:18

Cuppasoupmonster · 29/10/2022 20:10

Well because they might be willing to put up with the deadbeat husband to have the kids they really want? They don’t want perfection to be the enemy of the good?

Or to put it another way they’ll have kids with any old piece of shit rather than risk not having kids at all?

OhJimmyJimmy · 29/10/2022 21:14

A conversation with my DP earlier this week summed it up. We are childfree by choice, though time is not on my side (I'm 36). However he said to me "if you change your mind and say you want a child, I would do it for you". This is despite the fact he knows full well what it's like to grow up with an absent, uncommitted father. While he is a wonderful man and partner, I know that neither of us is cut out to be parents, but he has shown he will waver on this if I'm the one pushing for us to change our situation. I am sure many men are the same.

SandyY2K · 29/10/2022 21:08

@ZeldaWillTellYourFortune

each and every month I was totally in charge of my own fertility, in charge of who I slept with, in charge of what contraception I/we used, in charge of whether or not to abstain during fertile periods, in charge of what happened should an unwanted pregnancy happen.

No one else controlled these circumstances for me and in no way, shape or form would I have proceeded with a pregnancy with some loser, user, abuser, addict, unemployable, spendthrift, man-child, disinterested or fickle man, no matter how attractive, how good in bed or how much "in love" I was.

Frankly, it IS that black and white for me, and if we counseled/educated young women as we should, about the huge toll to them, to their offspring and to society of reproducing with shit men, maybe more of them would take charge and be discriminating about their sperm donors.

I agree with you 100%

It was black and white for me.

Another problem is staying in a relationship with a shitty partner then accidentally getting pregnant, so you're then tied to the idiot for life.

If you split up, you then have to coparent and face the possibility that he'll end up with another woman, who becomes stepmum to your kids and resents their very existence.

It often amazes me that people can put more thought into where they go on holiday, than they do creating a new life.

I think they should educate young people as part of the national curriculum .... so that from a young age, some of this sticks.

I know someone who told me, her daughter's school had a session on abuse and abusive relationships, then she came home and told her mum what she learned in school and that she (mum) was being abused by her dad.

That was finally what made her leave (even though she already knew it was an abusive relationship) but she had 5 kids at this point.

oldbrownjug · 29/10/2022 21:05

I suppose we don't understand because we always think we can do it differently. Human beings are very bad at learning from others' experience. We always think "It won't happen to me".
I wouldn't have had kids with a useless man though. Mine wasn't a great partner - and I knew I'd have to do most of it - but I've managed that relationship. The kids have had a good father. He was a good man and the kids were happy.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/10/2022 20:49

The way we know anything -- by learning it from our elders and extended family, by being taught in school, by observing. Come on.

Don't you think it's reprehensible to forge on with reproduction before informing oneself about all of the pros, cons, opportunity costs, financial costs, relationship costs, etc.?

If people were more honest about the downsides, perhaps, rather than being stigmatized for talking about the difficulties of parenting, and if we didn't coddle people who make these monumental misjudgments, perhaps so many people still wouldn't be making poor decisions in 2022.

Skinnermarink · 29/10/2022 20:48

Also some of them think they’re great. DH does a night of wake ups after I’ve done 7 in a row and honestly thinks he’s stepped up to the plate big time. We both work full time but he’s the one that gets the praise for nursery pick ups or remembering to put DS’s coat on. I don’t really know what to do with that. Except not have another, because fuck this for a game of soldiers quite frankly. I do nearly all of it, the difference is I don’t whinge.

thelobsterquadrille · 29/10/2022 20:44

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/10/2022 20:41

But why don't they understand it? It's hardly a secret.

Because how can anyone know what having kids is like until they've got them?

Skinnermarink · 29/10/2022 20:42

alwayslearning789 · 29/10/2022 20:41

Kinda misses point of thread but heck I'm going to say it anyway:

OP - Good guy or bad guy - Bottom line is Mums always seem to do MORE in 99% of cases...

Make of that what you will but them the facts since year dot.

And yes of course... there is the wonderful 1% who buck the trend...much love to them.

True, so true.

alwayslearning789 · 29/10/2022 20:41

Kinda misses point of thread but heck I'm going to say it anyway:

OP - Good guy or bad guy - Bottom line is Mums always seem to do MORE in 99% of cases...

Make of that what you will but them the facts since year dot.

And yes of course... there is the wonderful 1% who buck the trend...much love to them.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/10/2022 20:41

oldbrownjug · 29/10/2022 20:37

Women leave men who say no to kids. ("I wasted / don't want to waste my best years"). Men love their women and want to make them happy. Wome will push men to have kids (I did, I really wanted them and I was nearly 40 - knew it was my last shot).

Neither men nor women fully understand the changes that having children will cause in their relationship. Frequently neither is happy. The women blame the men because they don't do XYZ and the men leave the women because they do do ABC.

But why don't they understand it? It's hardly a secret.

Swipe left for the next trending thread