Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(electric cars) aibu to think that this won't work?

206 replies

greenacrylicpaint · 29/10/2022 11:21

currently stuck at a motorways service station.
there is a long queue for the chargers of which a few are not working.

imagine summer holidays. how is that going to work? train long distance and then cars/bikes locally?

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/11/2022 08:05

The technology is still evolving at a very high rate. The range only keeps getting better and better.

One concern I have is that the makers obviously focus all their R&D and marketing on when the cars are new, but that doesn't really help people at my end of the market who buy cars when they're 8-10 years old.

Petrol and diesel cars don't lose that much in efficiency when they're older - and even if they do, it might be 600 miles to a tank becoming, say, 450 miles, which is still a massive range. What's the point for those of us with a much more modest budget if a car can do 200 miles on a charge if it ends up at half that by the time the car reaches us? And even for people who can afford new, if they keep the car for a reasonable amount of time, they will find the same thing before long; and if they sell it on soonish, I'd expect depreciation to be harsh, with that in mind.

I think we'll have to have some kind of system whereby the cars themselves and the batteries are considered separately, with the latter maybe rented and/or expected to be changed much more regularly than the rest of the vehicle. Otherwise, it's not very eco-friendly if perfectly good cars end up being scrapped far before they're worn out, just because of that one limiting part.

Frazzled2207 · 03/11/2022 07:56

toomuchlaundry · 03/11/2022 07:36

How are we going to provide all the extra electricity needed?

We don’t have high mileage but we are intending to almost fully charge ours on our rooftop solar (which will be stored in a battery if our car is “out” that day).

Frazzled2207 · 03/11/2022 07:55

We have an electric. Our only car.
in 2 years we’ve only charged publicly about 10 times, always been fine, we just charge at home.
Tbf we have our own driveway and don’t do much long distance which makes the difference

FWIW there are a LOT more chargers than there were 2 years ago. They literally are springing up everywhere. But the amount of EVs on the road is currently rising faster. It is an issue, but improving

plinkypots · 03/11/2022 07:46

The technology is still evolving at a very high rate. The range only keeps getting better and better.

toomuchlaundry · 03/11/2022 07:36

How are we going to provide all the extra electricity needed?

Dexionmagic · 03/11/2022 07:36

This is why I’m wary of driving from the NW to London in our electric car. Its range of around 100 miles means a stop or two is inevitable.

Driving around the NW - not a problem. Most of my journeys I can get there and back in one go.

A question for those that queue for chargers at motorways……..
Most services only allow a 2 hour visit, after which parking charges come in, enforced by ANPR.

When waiting for a charger do you suck it up and pay for charging, take a chance or speak to someone inside?

Thanks

And for anyone on the M6 near Preston Charnock Richard services just a couple of (non-Tesla) chargers on each side. Drive a few more miles to the Standish turn off. Just by the roundabout an 8 bay charging station at a petrol station and Costa.

Abraxan · 03/11/2022 07:27

The more cars bought the better the network will be. It's already improved vastly over the past few years.

When planning a longer journey we know we will need to stop once in the way. But we always used to anyway for a comfort break. The fast chargers only take around 20-30 minutes or so max ime.

We tend to look out for the places we know have a large number of chargers, rather than just one or two. There are more of these around now.

We have apps we can use to tell us if the chargers are being used, etc too. Again I suspect these will improve the more electric cars are bought and used.

We've had electric cars for a few years now and have traveled long journeys throughout and never really had any issues.

greenacrylicpaint · 03/11/2022 07:24

I'm not a petrol chill.
we as family have decided to get rid of the family car and to rent one if we need one.

and I think that's the way we need to go as the infrastructure to charge cars the same way as we fill up petrol/diesel is very complicated to implement and prone to errors.

OP posts:
sunshineandsuddenshowers · 03/11/2022 07:24

Folk who say ‘oh but I drive so much I’m sticking to fossil fuel’ - I bet that in 10
years you won’t be driving the way you are now. It won’t be economical to drive 400 miles in a day either for work or leisure. So
OP I think you are right, charging DOES need to change, but as part of a wider transformation in travel and transport.

SellFridges · 03/11/2022 07:23

We have not had a single issue finding somewhere to charge in about 15 months. We do have a Tesla which means we aren’t usually fighting for the normal chargers, although we use those when necessary.

We have to break up long journeys (eg. Cornwall) so just plug in for 20m to top up while we have a wee. That said, the car insists we can make it without stopping, we just wouldn’t have much left on arrival so prefer to top up.

rookiemere · 03/11/2022 07:15

We have a hybrid and that feels like the best of both worlds to me.

So when we have been holidaying in UK we've checked out the charging facilities, but inevitably at motorway services there are generally 3-4 and they are full. Can't charge at hotels or holiday homes unless we have agreement to do so and ability to plug into a socket within reach.

Phrenologistsfinger · 03/11/2022 07:13

I am always wary of the petrol industry shills on threads like this - or maybe it’s just people who fear change - as the shared experiences are always so negative and so far from our own and our friends’ experiences driving EVs! They are easier and more convenient.

Phrenologistsfinger · 03/11/2022 07:10

We regularly travel a 400 mile return journey and have never had any issues in last 3-4 years. Waited for 2 mins once in the summer. We chose our (second hand) EV based on its charger network. Chargers are increasing all the time! You can also use a granny charger (normal plug socket), which we do when visiting in laws overnight etc.

TheGuv1982 · 03/11/2022 07:01

I’ve got one, but was under no illusions when I bought it that it didn’t come without downsides.

Range. They just don’t compete with ICE cars, though it’s improving. Mine has a range of 186 miles which by the time I hand it back would expect the norm to be 400 miles, which would be a game changer. Also, motorway driving sees a massive reduction in range.

Charging. The infrastructure is woeful, and can’t be trusted. People without driveways can’t have chargers, which is a huge problem. Where I am, Council have put in 8 fast chargers, which have been pretty much taken over by DPD vans.

Lunar270 · 03/11/2022 06:44

Chersfrozenface · 02/11/2022 11:34

This is the situation in Scotland, often lauded as an exemplar of best practice.

The BBC found that a quarter of public chargers faulty.
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-63371759

We don't have off-road parking. We won't be buying an electric car.

I think you'll find that Milton Keynes is the benchmark that the rest of the UK needs to follow.

I've driven to Scotland and it's not extraordinary. Zapmap would tend to agree.

Chersfrozenface · 02/11/2022 11:34

This is the situation in Scotland, often lauded as an exemplar of best practice.

The BBC found that a quarter of public chargers faulty.
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-63371759

We don't have off-road parking. We won't be buying an electric car.

greenacrylicpaint · 31/10/2022 15:00

You sure it was definitely public? My husband's work have a couple of chargers and they were, incorrectly, listed as public ones, so in car computers were directing people to them as the nearest charge point - they had to put a lock on them to stop random people turning up and using them!

definitely public. with key fob of big electric supplier thingy.
the car salespeople confirmed as well that this was the village's public charger.

OP posts:
ErrolTheDragon · 31/10/2022 14:22

IntentionalError · 29/10/2022 12:40

Another issue : One of my friends is a surveyor, she works for a house builder. Building regulations now stipulate that all new-build houses should be fitted with electric car charging points. Good idea. The only problem is that National Grid’s existing infrastructure can’t provide enough power to feed them all…

Which is why, currently, a car with its own generator ie a hybrid is the best bet for many.
We've got one, and another to replace our second car on order.

ContadoraExplorer · 31/10/2022 13:45

greenacrylicpaint · 30/10/2022 12:33

some public chargers are at such obscure locations.
we found one at a private air strip. lots of gliders starting and landing whilst we charged.
one was at a luxury car dealership. the teens loved sitting in a 100k sports car...

You sure it was definitely public? My husband's work have a couple of chargers and they were, incorrectly, listed as public ones, so in car computers were directing people to them as the nearest charge point - they had to put a lock on them to stop random people turning up and using them!

greenacrylicpaint · 30/10/2022 12:33

some public chargers are at such obscure locations.
we found one at a private air strip. lots of gliders starting and landing whilst we charged.
one was at a luxury car dealership. the teens loved sitting in a 100k sports car...

OP posts:
saltinesandcoffeecups · 29/10/2022 19:24

midgetastic · 29/10/2022 12:34

440 miles without a half hour break ?!

Why is that hard to believe? It’s about 5 hours, I routinely do this one-way with only a fill up and quick pee, 10 min or so.

Getoff · 29/10/2022 19:24

Electric cars are not suitable for people who do very high or very low milages. If you do high mileages, you will have the inconvenience and risk that comes with charging somewhere other than at home. If you do very low mileages, your emissions and fuel cost are negligible anyway, so the extra cost of an electric car isn't worth it.

The ideal scenario for an electric car is maybe someone who does a daily 100 mile round-trip commute, five days a week, and charges overnight at home.

ContadoraExplorer · 29/10/2022 19:22

ApolloandDaphne · 29/10/2022 12:22

We have a hybrid which is the best of both worlds. If we can't find a charger we can just use petrol.

Same, we felt the infrastructure wasn't there yet so decided hybrid was best for us, as our main car, for now. We have a charger on the drive and we do probably 90% of our driving on pure electric but longer distance we don't need to worry about charging up. Record is a couple of months from a full tank of petrol to having to fill up again.

When we eventually need to replace our second car, it's likely to be fully electric.

JenniferAllisonPhillipaSue · 29/10/2022 19:21

I won't be convinced that EV is a viable option until I see shopping centres where 50% of the parking bays have chargers, holiday camps where every static caravan has a charger, and every fuel station converted so that half of its footage is converted to chargers. That's the level of availtability that is needed to sustain a wholesale switch of propulsion system.

Yes I can understand that EV is good for short, local journeys - if you have a driveway with charger (it's all on-street parking here). Even on-street chargers are no good if there aren't enough to ensure you can get one without having to ask the neighbour from three doors down, who's probably had a drink, to move his car rather than leaving it hooked up overnight.

But I also want to be able to do a 6-8hr journey to take the family on holiday. Without having to extend that journey by 2 hours to allow for charging breaks (no, we don't take long meal breaks at services either). And I want to know that if I have to make a mad dash across the country to visit a dying relative, I don't have to wait hours before setting off because my car isn't charged for a long run; and I don't want to be worrying whether there are chargers available in the hospital car park at their end.

MooseBeTimeForSnow · 29/10/2022 19:15

@Xiaoxiong I live in Northern Alberta, so pretty close!