Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(electric cars) aibu to think that this won't work?

206 replies

greenacrylicpaint · 29/10/2022 11:21

currently stuck at a motorways service station.
there is a long queue for the chargers of which a few are not working.

imagine summer holidays. how is that going to work? train long distance and then cars/bikes locally?

OP posts:
F4chrissakes · 30/12/2022 12:31

Electric cars and their batteries are very heavy. I read somewhere the other day that when electric vehicles are the norm, that multi storey car parks will need rebuilding in order to be able to cope with the extra weight.

bellac11 · 30/12/2022 11:57

For me its the combination of lack of range (in what would be my price range) and the time spent charging up. We do a lot of long journeys and theres no way I want to be spending 40 mins (and thats assuming you get a charger right away and no waiting) extra on journeys that take long enough as it is. I resent stopping for petrol and that takes about 5 mins!!

My price range for a car is about 5k, once my current car bites the dust, I would be looking to spend that, perhaps my car will last another 5 years, perhaps more if Im lucky, its only done around 120k and I could get that again out of it I reckon.

For that money, I wont get an e car that has the range I currently have although presumably servicing, tax, mot etc would be much cheaper, as well as the electric.

Sidking · 30/12/2022 11:47

I would love an EV, but we do 200 miles motorway driving to get to my parents, usually with no breaks (definitely not if I'm alone) and the ones that would possibly be in my budget second hand simply don't have the range, we also have to use the local pub car parks for parking at home and have no way to plug it in so we would HAVE to charge on the go

I'm also wary of how potentially difficult it is to repair, my mechanic's shop is a 2 minute walk away, I've never seen an EV in there but I assume they can do standard stuff like mot/tyres etc but what about the other stuff? Do they have to go specialists/manufacturers? (I know telsa want you to only have work done via them), how much more expensive is that compared to the standard cost of maintenance on a petrol/diesel car? I don't know if it is, I've not looked into it for the reasons i gave to start with, but I expect it must be----

bellac11 · 30/12/2022 11:01

SamanthaCaine · 30/12/2022 10:45

The annoying thing with the EV infrastructure is that the government has purposely left it to commercial businesses to sort out. Some councils have invested but mostly I think it's down to businesses to spot the areas where they can maximize profits.

This is problematic because it ends up being a bit chicken/egg. Consumers won't buy cars if the infrastructure isn't there and business won't invest if they don't get a return. Also most EV owners (like me) have drives so mostly don't need the network, except on occasion. It's a stupid scenario which needed huge government input to get things going. Especially when they want to ban ICE sales from 2030.

Tory governments are 'small goverrnments', they believe in the market sorting things out, look at housing, utilities, transport etc etc

(unless of course its their cronies getting contracts to supply PPE etc)

And this is what people voted for so there isnt really any surprise at this

SamanthaCaine · 30/12/2022 10:45

SleeplessInEngland · 30/12/2022 10:27

The UK is weirdly shit at big infrastructure projects. We talk the talk but rarely walk the walk.

The annoying thing with the EV infrastructure is that the government has purposely left it to commercial businesses to sort out. Some councils have invested but mostly I think it's down to businesses to spot the areas where they can maximize profits.

This is problematic because it ends up being a bit chicken/egg. Consumers won't buy cars if the infrastructure isn't there and business won't invest if they don't get a return. Also most EV owners (like me) have drives so mostly don't need the network, except on occasion. It's a stupid scenario which needed huge government input to get things going. Especially when they want to ban ICE sales from 2030.

SamanthaCaine · 30/12/2022 10:38

WatchoRulo · 30/12/2022 10:26

I think your idea of exponential is a little different from the accepted definition.

I'd say it was more exponential than linear.

www.gov.uk/government/statistics/electric-vehicle-charging-device-statistics-january-2022/electric-vehicle-charging-device-statistics-january-2022

SleeplessInEngland · 30/12/2022 10:27

The UK is weirdly shit at big infrastructure projects. We talk the talk but rarely walk the walk.

WatchoRulo · 30/12/2022 10:26

Xiaoxiong · 29/10/2022 12:02

The numbers of chargers are increasing exponentially though - I remember at one of the services on the M4 when they got their first 7kW charger a few years ago, when we stopped there again earlier this week they had about 20 150+kW chargers and there were still people waiting. We need to get to the point (and we will, eventually) where every space in the carpark has a charger.

I remember when the first public 150kW charger was installed in London - in 2019!! So this stuff is all still very new. Big infrastructure projects take time to roll out but charging will catch up.

At the same time, the capacity of car batteries is also increasing exponentially so you won't have to charge so often with newer models, making an EV more feasible for those with no offstreet parking.

I think your idea of exponential is a little different from the accepted definition.

Frazzled2207 · 30/12/2022 10:24

What about the press coverage of the petrol shortages at pumps a few months ago? There will be far more of these in the future.

hattie43 · 30/12/2022 10:22

I think the press coverage of the problems with electric cars / charging is the death knell of all electric cars . My car is due for renewal and I won't be getting an electric one . Quite happy with my reliable diesel SUV .

Frazzled2207 · 30/12/2022 10:16

We’ve been electric for 4 years. The amount of chargers out there has risen considerably but not nearly as much as the amount of EVs out there. When we got ours we’d see one or two a week. Now they’re all over the place.

funny how social media has really gone mad with this- I seem to recall long queues at petrol stations not that long ago. I suppose at Christmas time (and summer) long journeys are more common.

they won’t work (yet) for all families, especially those with high mileages. However for families like us who use cars for local journeys plus a handful of longer journeys, and do 99% or our charging at home, we love our EV. I have never waited more than 10 minutes for a charge. I know lots of converts and not one that regrets it.
not yet anyway.

bellac11 · 30/12/2022 10:10

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 30/12/2022 10:05

We first travelled from Matlock (pre cmas weekend break) to home, charged 30 mins at Woodall Services. Put it on the home charger for 3h while we repacked then drove to Hull dock. Next morning charged 45 mins in Antwerp, 45 mins in Metz, 20 mins in Basel then done.

Thank you, so how many miles in between each charge is that and how many miles do each of those charging times get you?

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 30/12/2022 10:05

bellac11 · 30/12/2022 09:52

Can you set out your itinery of stops, what charges took place and how long they took along the way?

So from when you set off from home, where and when was your first stop and hhow long?

We first travelled from Matlock (pre cmas weekend break) to home, charged 30 mins at Woodall Services. Put it on the home charger for 3h while we repacked then drove to Hull dock. Next morning charged 45 mins in Antwerp, 45 mins in Metz, 20 mins in Basel then done.

ThreeblackCats · 30/12/2022 10:02

I don’t have to “imagine”

summer 2022 and we took out electric car from the West Midlands to Dover, taking our grandchildren on holiday. Journey to Dover was fabulous. We stopped once for breakfast and fully recharged our electric car. (A2021 Nissan Leaf)

coming home from our 7 days in Europe courtesy of the ship Disney Magic. We stopped for our recharge, of the 9 or so charging units 2 or 3 were not working. A few were being used by people who appear to have left the country or died. The remaining 5 were causing fights, we moved on.

Next services there were at least half of them out of service.

Final stop and not enough power to move to any other power points, at least an hours wait. 2 young children who wanted to see their parents, a 4+ hour journey ended up being about 9 hours. Very off putting.

Im due to go to Heathrow next August. DH driving me. We will use our petrol car.

Seriously live our electric car and shes do economic, but there really needs to be more, faster and better charging points. Especially on motorways.

bellac11 · 30/12/2022 09:52

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 30/12/2022 09:00

Just driven our EV from northern England to the alps. Easy all the way !

Can you set out your itinery of stops, what charges took place and how long they took along the way?

So from when you set off from home, where and when was your first stop and hhow long?

TimeForMeToF1y · 30/12/2022 09:11

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 30/12/2022 09:00

Just driven our EV from northern England to the alps. Easy all the way !

Which is great for you but doesn't mean that the problems currently being reported in England aren't happening.

I don't think that there's any question that the infrastructure needs to catch up with the numbers on evs on the road now

They aren't quite the pancea to fossil fuels yet

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 30/12/2022 09:00

Just driven our EV from northern England to the alps. Easy all the way !

user2754977 · 30/12/2022 08:51

Lots in the news recently about queues for chargers over the Christmas period and distances reduced because of the cold and having to have heaters on. We just have a small one for local journeys, only charging at home and use our diesel to go any distance, the EV is OK for second car but we will be replacing our diesel soon with another diesel, I wouldn't want to use public chargers.

MissFranKubelik · 30/12/2022 07:54

I’ve had my EV for 6 weeks and it’s been brilliant locally with excellent public charging stations.

I just did 2 very long trips in the last week and am feeling very dispirited. Yesterday there was an enormous queue for 1 CCS charger just off the M74. I only needed a bit of charge to get me home comfortably so used my own AC cable - but the behaviour of some of the other queuers was awful. One lady had been waiting with a baby and toddler for 3 hours - and was next - a man pulled into the space and jumped the queue. I had to confront him - he was initially “snooze you loose” - but eventually relented and “let” her have 20 minutes on the CCS. It was horrible and stressful.

It was clearly a busy driving day with lots of families moving about the country so probably not typical. But whilst - planning works - and you need a Plan B (both bits of excellent advice) - it’s hard and the infrastructure needs improving quickly.

deplorabelle · 03/11/2022 14:26

We found it quite a challenge to identify which hotels had chargers. Eventually we found one that had a BP pulse in its grounds but when I contacted the hotel to double check it was available to me they said it had been broken for months and there was no way to get it fixed as not their equipment.

FastNed charging stations are brilliant. We used the Sunderland and Newcastle ones when staying in the region and they completely compensated for the lack of charging at our holiday accommodation. (For long distance we definitely prefer the train though).

Lunar270 · 03/11/2022 14:03

greenacrylicpaint · 03/11/2022 13:42

But that's not what you posted is it? Your OP said you were waiting in a line of cars for a charger. My response was that a look on zapmap would've told you the charger was busy, which it does.

Zapmap receives live data directly from the charger whether it's in use or not.

yes, apps can tell you a charger is free or not. but by the time you arrive it might be busy or broken/inactive.

going off motorway is also not always wise as at least motorway services usually have more chargers than just the one behind the bakery 10 miles away which only has a slow charge (compared to big brand chargers).

Thing is, there's always a scenario isn't there? That's why most people who are seasoned EV owners look for destination charging. It's what I do.

So if I'm going to another town/city I'll look for a car park etc where I can charge whilst I'm doing whatever I'm doing. Or I'll visit a charger before I get on the motorway.

Did you know that hotels are obliged to let you use a charger even if you're not a customer?

Sure I get there are some limited situations where people experience difficulties but I'd imagine that these can often be mitigated with some planning.

But it's early days and currently noone is under any obligation to purchase an EV. Therefore if people don't think one can work for them, what's the issue? You just wait until the infrastructure is good enough for you

Lunar270 · 03/11/2022 13:55

@MillyMollyMonday

From Zapmap:

Live data is information that is obtained directly from the charge point data. Updated every five minutes, users can see if a charge point is available, in use or unavailable.

You're right that there may well be a scenario whereby a car that's finished charging shows as being available but I'm not 100%. I can't say it's something I've experienced though as the majority of CCS chargers penalise people if they stay longer than a set time period. I think there's a £40 charge or something if you exceed 40 minutes on most.

fiftiesmum · 03/11/2022 13:53

We have found that if you report a fault it can sometimes be fixed on the spot - the computer just needs rebooting - doesn't always work though

greenacrylicpaint · 03/11/2022 13:42

But that's not what you posted is it? Your OP said you were waiting in a line of cars for a charger. My response was that a look on zapmap would've told you the charger was busy, which it does.

Zapmap receives live data directly from the charger whether it's in use or not.

yes, apps can tell you a charger is free or not. but by the time you arrive it might be busy or broken/inactive.

going off motorway is also not always wise as at least motorway services usually have more chargers than just the one behind the bakery 10 miles away which only has a slow charge (compared to big brand chargers).

OP posts:
MillyMollyMonday · 03/11/2022 13:40

@Lunar270 apology accepted 😬
One other thing about zap maps, though… I don’t think it tells you if there’s a car still plugged in ( and space hogging) long after they have finished charging. This was the case with two cars on my route, at my third (contingency) charging point!