Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(electric cars) aibu to think that this won't work?

206 replies

greenacrylicpaint · 29/10/2022 11:21

currently stuck at a motorways service station.
there is a long queue for the chargers of which a few are not working.

imagine summer holidays. how is that going to work? train long distance and then cars/bikes locally?

OP posts:
Frazzled2207 · 30/12/2022 15:55

@Cherrysoup
Yes- your battery will last longer and your range will be better if you moderate your speed. 65ish on the motorway is very efficient. Faster is fine but you will need to stop earlier to recharge.
it’s just one of those things EV drivers have to get used to. That and plugging your car in at home to charge overnight. Which is infinitely easier and less faff than going to petrol stations.

best bit more me personally is when stuck in urban traffic I can be smug about the fact that I’m shedding zero dodgy chemicals that harm the kids walking up the side of the road.

Cherrysoup · 30/12/2022 15:49

Frazzled2207 · 30/12/2022 15:43

@Cherrysoup
i think I have found the edf energy article you refer to
the actual words are
“However, the current prediction is that an electric car battery will last from 10 – 20 years before they need to be replaced.”
20 years is a lot longer than 10 and there is every indication that this will become a viable solution in a few years time when/if today’s EVs meet that threshold.

however I can honestly tell you that our car in its 5 years (we have had it for four) has lost a negligible amount, if any, of its battery power. We have looked after it though (don’t power down the motorway at 75+)

I do go at a decent speed on the motorway, it’s about 5 hours to my mum’s, up the M1. If I get an ev (which we’ll all have to do eventually) should I moderate to below 70? (Yes, I know it’s the limit!) It would take forever to get home!

Frazzled2207 · 30/12/2022 15:43

@Cherrysoup
i think I have found the edf energy article you refer to
the actual words are
“However, the current prediction is that an electric car battery will last from 10 – 20 years before they need to be replaced.”
20 years is a lot longer than 10 and there is every indication that this will become a viable solution in a few years time when/if today’s EVs meet that threshold.

however I can honestly tell you that our car in its 5 years (we have had it for four) has lost a negligible amount, if any, of its battery power. We have looked after it though (don’t power down the motorway at 75+)

SamanthaCaine · 30/12/2022 15:43

EDF are talking rubbish. Not sure why they're wading into EV advice but it's more nonsense.

Besides, EV batteries that have been upgraded on early Nissan Leafs are doing very well in domestic settings where any reduced capacity is not an issue.

Second life usage for EV batteries is set to be the next big industry as we move to solar.

Cherrysoup · 30/12/2022 15:38

Frazzled2207 · 30/12/2022 15:34

Sorry that was to @Cherrysoup
and no it’s not really a thing to swap out batteries every few years in a modern EV.
sort of a thing for the early models.

As I posted, EDF Energy say every 10 years. This does not negate the fact that there are very few places that can store worn out batteries and that they can’t yet be recycled.

Frazzled2207 · 30/12/2022 15:34

Sorry that was to @Cherrysoup
and no it’s not really a thing to swap out batteries every few years in a modern EV.
sort of a thing for the early models.

Frazzled2207 · 30/12/2022 15:33

Eh? My uncle lives in the very north of Norway where temperatures like that are very much the norm and now the majority of cars are EVs.

it’s true it can take a bit longer to charge in the cold. But there was no difference in ours in the recent cold snap which got to at least minus 9. And it wasn’t kept warm in a garage.

SamanthaCaine · 30/12/2022 15:12

Cherrysoup · 30/12/2022 14:54

I can’t imagine a garage being of much use unless it’s heated? I noticed cars plugged in whilst in Finland (before electric cars were a thing) apparently to ensure the engine isn’t too cold before turning it over as the cold starts do serious damage to ICE.

I think we need major changes before everyone takes on board the ev thing: batteries degrade over time and should last 10 years, according to EDF Energy. There are what, 4 places in Europe where they can currently be stored once removed and can’t be recycled (at the minute).

My car is an 06 plate, there’s no way I’m replacing it til it literally falls apart. I’m a bit concerned that we (as a country and the world in general) are just not set up to succeed with evs just yet. You need a drive to charge, in an ideal world. Not sure what people in flats are meant to do. I know I sound very doom and gloom, but I just think we don’t yet have the set up, but I understand the urgency with which the industry has moved, it is essential.

Yes, you do sound doom and gloom. Disproportionately so.

People that live in flat will do something similar to what people do with ICE now. Do you have a petrol pump at home? No. The difference is that you can charge a car literally anywhere, instead of just a petrol station. This makes EV's infinitely more flexible.

Sure, charging times are currently not on par with petrol/diesel but this will change. Also it only really matters if you're looking to charge in a hurry. Most other times you can happily wait a few hours if you're out to dinner/cinema/shopping/walking the dog etc. etc.

I've owned an EV for about 4 years and the battery is still tip top. I don't expect this to change. The beauty of an EV in cold weather is that you can precondition the battery and cabin. This warms up the battery ready for use and also defrosts the car so it's nice and toasty warm with no scraping to do. Unless you live in places where they have blankets on engines then the cold is very damaging to the myriad parts. You shouldn't thrash a cold engine either. No such issues with an EV so they're also perfect for short journeys.

You say that your car is 2006. Fine. By the time you change it (maybe 5-10 years) you can buy another ICE. By the time that one dies, EV's will be significantly better than they are now and they pretty good already. The infrastructure should be well evolved by then too.

Cherrysoup · 30/12/2022 14:54

Frabbits · 30/12/2022 14:37

No, it's not true. It's just slower to charge in lower temperatures.

And garages are a thing.

I can’t imagine a garage being of much use unless it’s heated? I noticed cars plugged in whilst in Finland (before electric cars were a thing) apparently to ensure the engine isn’t too cold before turning it over as the cold starts do serious damage to ICE.

I think we need major changes before everyone takes on board the ev thing: batteries degrade over time and should last 10 years, according to EDF Energy. There are what, 4 places in Europe where they can currently be stored once removed and can’t be recycled (at the minute).

My car is an 06 plate, there’s no way I’m replacing it til it literally falls apart. I’m a bit concerned that we (as a country and the world in general) are just not set up to succeed with evs just yet. You need a drive to charge, in an ideal world. Not sure what people in flats are meant to do. I know I sound very doom and gloom, but I just think we don’t yet have the set up, but I understand the urgency with which the industry has moved, it is essential.

Chersfrozenface · 30/12/2022 14:53

The range on a diesel VW Passat with a full tank is around 650 miles.

bellac11 · 30/12/2022 14:49

Nw22 · 30/12/2022 14:15

Wee currently have an ev with a 180 mile range and have ordered one with 280 miles range. Last month we drove from the nw to Cornwall and had no problems charging. The place we stayed at had a charger for each guest. We would never go back to petrol.

What is the one with 280 mile range (still quite low)

Chersfrozenface · 30/12/2022 14:47

Frabbits · 30/12/2022 14:37

No, it's not true. It's just slower to charge in lower temperatures.

And garages are a thing.

Only a smidge over 50% of UK homes have garages.

Frabbits · 30/12/2022 14:37

Cherrysoup · 30/12/2022 14:09

Is it correct that the electric batteries won’t charge under -15? So pretty useless in many Eastern European/half of America in winter? And do the batteries need swapping out every few years? Aren’t they extremely expensive still?

No, it's not true. It's just slower to charge in lower temperatures.

And garages are a thing.

SamanthaCaine · 30/12/2022 14:34

Cherrysoup · 30/12/2022 14:09

Is it correct that the electric batteries won’t charge under -15? So pretty useless in many Eastern European/half of America in winter? And do the batteries need swapping out every few years? Aren’t they extremely expensive still?

I don't think that's true. People drive EV's in Finland and they have -20 degree winters. People also drive in Canada and many parts of America with no need to swap out batteries.

More scaremongering I suspect.

NotMeNoNo · 30/12/2022 14:29

Yes I meant it to the person you were quoting!

SamanthaCaine · 30/12/2022 14:25

NotMeNoNo · 30/12/2022 13:54

I'll just reassure you that roads and bridges are designed to take the weight of fully loaded lorries and a small increase in car weight is no issue. The load allowances for car parks are pretty generous but any one thought to be a risk would be repainted to fewer spaces.

Thanks. I honestly thought as much but was just indulging the OP.

It's a non issue ultimately and just adds to the list of ridiculous anti EV articles. I'm quite amazed that people just suck it up without really thinking.

Nw22 · 30/12/2022 14:15

Wee currently have an ev with a 180 mile range and have ordered one with 280 miles range. Last month we drove from the nw to Cornwall and had no problems charging. The place we stayed at had a charger for each guest. We would never go back to petrol.

xogossipgirlxo · 30/12/2022 14:11

You’re right, it won’t work. I don’t understand EV hype. I’d rather keep my petrol car, thank you. Then switch to hybrid.

Cherrysoup · 30/12/2022 14:09

Is it correct that the electric batteries won’t charge under -15? So pretty useless in many Eastern European/half of America in winter? And do the batteries need swapping out every few years? Aren’t they extremely expensive still?

NotMeNoNo · 30/12/2022 13:54

SamanthaCaine · 30/12/2022 13:05

More anti EV scaremongering unfortunately.

There has been a massive boom in huge SUV's over the last 10-20 years. Most of which, are heavier or as heavy as EV's. Mine weighs just 1300kg. A range rover weighs over 2000kg but no-one has been making a fuss about the rise of SUV purchases.

Thinking logically about it, what do you think a business will do? Spend millions on knocking down a huge multistorey car park and building a new one, or mitigate the extra weight by reducing the number of spaces and charging more?

The same applies to bridges. They're not going to rebuild them all but most likely regulate the number of cars allowed at any one time.

I'll just reassure you that roads and bridges are designed to take the weight of fully loaded lorries and a small increase in car weight is no issue. The load allowances for car parks are pretty generous but any one thought to be a risk would be repainted to fewer spaces.

bellac11 · 30/12/2022 13:50

lieselotte · 30/12/2022 13:40

Electric cars and their batteries are very heavy. I read somewhere the other day that when electric vehicles are the norm, that multi storey car parks will need rebuilding in order to be able to cope with the extra weight

Do away with SUVs and make cars smaller to compensate (if this is true, which I very much doubt)

Theres lots of articles about it if you google, but it does puzzle me because surely vans and lorries use those car parks too and they are very heavy?

lieselotte · 30/12/2022 13:40

Electric cars and their batteries are very heavy. I read somewhere the other day that when electric vehicles are the norm, that multi storey car parks will need rebuilding in order to be able to cope with the extra weight

Do away with SUVs and make cars smaller to compensate (if this is true, which I very much doubt)

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 30/12/2022 13:38

bellac11 · 30/12/2022 10:10

Thank you, so how many miles in between each charge is that and how many miles do each of those charging times get you?

The car will do around 3h between charges at motorway speeds, 5 people on board & holiday luggage. When fully charged it shows about 520km range on the screen but we get a bit less than that in practice with gradients and a heavy load.

Here on holiday we have been charging while supermarket shopping, getting full in 50 minutes while we shop on a CCS charger in the car park.

SamanthaCaine · 30/12/2022 13:05

F4chrissakes · 30/12/2022 12:31

Electric cars and their batteries are very heavy. I read somewhere the other day that when electric vehicles are the norm, that multi storey car parks will need rebuilding in order to be able to cope with the extra weight.

More anti EV scaremongering unfortunately.

There has been a massive boom in huge SUV's over the last 10-20 years. Most of which, are heavier or as heavy as EV's. Mine weighs just 1300kg. A range rover weighs over 2000kg but no-one has been making a fuss about the rise of SUV purchases.

Thinking logically about it, what do you think a business will do? Spend millions on knocking down a huge multistorey car park and building a new one, or mitigate the extra weight by reducing the number of spaces and charging more?

The same applies to bridges. They're not going to rebuild them all but most likely regulate the number of cars allowed at any one time.

lieselotte · 30/12/2022 12:44

I think hybrids are the current solution. I have a self-charge hybrid which I like, but I would happily replace our petrol car with a plug in hybrid when it needs replacing. It's easy to charge at home and then use petrol for longer journeys.

I don't want fully electric until there are fast chargers everywhere though. It takes less than 5 minutes to fill up with petrol and as bellac says, that is annoying in itself. 45 minutes simply isn't feasible.

There seem to be loads of chargers around where I live but a taxi driver was telling me that most of them don't work :(