Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(electric cars) aibu to think that this won't work?

206 replies

greenacrylicpaint · 29/10/2022 11:21

currently stuck at a motorways service station.
there is a long queue for the chargers of which a few are not working.

imagine summer holidays. how is that going to work? train long distance and then cars/bikes locally?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 01/01/2023 09:55

I live rurally and work in community nursing covering a large rural area, I do not have a drive. Electric car is currently not going to work for us or anytime soon but I am considering a hybrid next as it would be useful when doing visits in villages etc

SamanthaCaine · 01/01/2023 09:35

Like all new tech it take a few 'generations' for it to become mainstream and everyday usable. But that takes time. Sometimes a long time.

Indeed an inordinate amount of time given the archaic, doom mongers and negative people on here. Although to be fair there are literally millions of people who are incapable of change and unable to see past their noses until it's forced upon them. Always able to find reasons why they can't, instead of solutions and alternatives.

Caspianberg · 01/01/2023 07:08

@user1471447863 - our id4 does 550km (340miles) on one charge in good conditions. It drops slightly in winter, but we live where it’s -minus several months of the year and snowy and it hasn’t been a problem at all so far.

user1471447863 · 01/01/2023 00:01

Like all new tech it take a few 'generations' for it to become mainstream and everyday usable. But that takes time. Sometimes a long time.
I doubt there is time before 2030 for the tech and infrastructure to mature to the extent that it is a suitable replacement for everyones needs.
I see recharging service stations popping up - like motorway service stations did back in the 60's and various petrol stations refurbing themselves to have a few fast chargers. but hanging around a service station for an hour or so every week is going to get pretty old pretty quickly compared to 5 mins tops in a petrol station.

For those that don't have private parking (and the type of private parking that can allow them to have a private charger) this is going to be a pain in the arse. Yes you can recharge in 30mins or so at a very fast charger, but the kwh unit rate is (much) more expensive the faster the charge (another poor tax) & fast charging is more detrimental to battery life.
The worse economy/tank size car i've owned got 300 miles to a tank (summer, winter, rain or shine it was the same) but i could refuel it in a few minutes - even faster now with pay at pump or apps to pay, whereas 300 miles range is still wishful thinking for current EV's (i'm sure there will be the odd model that will do that range on paper) and then they have a much longer recharge time and inconvenience if they don't have home overnight charging.

It's also not just a case of plonking a handful of chargers in parking bays at a services or supermarket, you also need the electricity network upgrades to support it. The demand from 150kw+ fast chargers soon adds up to very big demands on the supply infrastructure - you are very soon in the your own small power station territory of electrical power requirements. These upgrades are not going to happen overnight.

Parsley1234 · 31/12/2022 20:31

@LadyVictoriaSponge yes I can see this happening it’s so fucking tedious ! I don’t know what the answer is but EV certainly aren’t and Greta Thunburgh on being interviewed has said she doesn’t want to think about these as there has to be another way as in not travelling just being in your area fuck this shit I’m glad I’m older and won’t be around to see the cluster fuck of life

TonTonMacoute · 31/12/2022 20:01

araiwa · 29/10/2022 11:55

At some.point in the future I'd imagine every parking space at a motorway service station will have a charger

Yes, this is the problem.

Lots of people like you just blithely assume that this will happen. I certainly wouldn't bet on it!

bellac11 · 31/12/2022 19:54

lieselotte · 31/12/2022 19:51

Exactly, this is the main issue. Anyone can cycle, you don't have to be "poor", you just need a bike! Or a trike, if you have no balance.

We have bikes and I have very bad balance, hence why i wont go on roads

I dont have the space for a trike, I wouldnt be able to get it in the house neither would we be able to get it on the bike rack

lieselotte · 31/12/2022 19:51

bellac11 · 31/12/2022 19:37

I would only cycle anywhere if it was on traffic free lanes. Proper traffic free lanes, not just lines drawn on the road with cars parked in them and traffic rushing past

Exactly, this is the main issue. Anyone can cycle, you don't have to be "poor", you just need a bike! Or a trike, if you have no balance.

lieselotte · 31/12/2022 19:50

Yes, so all the poor people can get on their bikes or walk

Not poor people, people with a social conscience. Lots of people with decent incomes cycle and walk when they can. The main stumbling block is infrastructure and the arrogant attitudes of many drivers, who think they own the road because they pay "road tax".

User963 · 31/12/2022 19:41

greenacrylicpaint · 31/12/2022 15:20

yep. move to ev will only work if personal car ownership and use is vastly reduced.

anything up to 5 miles is/can be cycled. 10 miles e-bike. cycling infrastructure dependent of course.

But surely all those journeys can easily be done by an electric car? If you can charge at home those are exactly the kind of journeys people use electric cars for. It’s the long distance journeys which are much more problematic.
Of course I see the reasons why it would still be better to cycle but I don’t think the impracticalities of an electric car would
necessarily make people swap to a bike for short distances. Maybe people who can’t access a charger easily.

bellac11 · 31/12/2022 19:37

I would only cycle anywhere if it was on traffic free lanes. Proper traffic free lanes, not just lines drawn on the road with cars parked in them and traffic rushing past

Abraxan · 31/12/2022 19:27

greenacrylicpaint · 31/12/2022 15:20

yep. move to ev will only work if personal car ownership and use is vastly reduced.

anything up to 5 miles is/can be cycled. 10 miles e-bike. cycling infrastructure dependent of course.

Oh the privilege of not being older or having mobility or other health issues. Or living in a relatively flat area with safe roads. Or not needing to take passengers, or carry heavy loads to and from work/destinations.

Abraxan · 31/12/2022 19:25

Newwardrobe · 30/12/2022 17:30

@Caspianberg thank you, just wondering how I could work it , my drive is lower than my house and looks like a parking bay not a private driveway, so would be worried that some idiot would unplug my car in the middle of the night.

You can't.
To remove the charger you need to unlock your car, so they'd need to take your keys or somehow bypass them. And tbh it they were doing that I doubt they'd hang around to charge their own car - you'd know as your car's app would alert you.

Roselilly36 · 31/12/2022 19:10

We won’t be buying an ev anytime soon having researched it. The projected range of the ev seems very optimistic. Less range in cold weather when using heater etc. lack of charging stations when on a journey, the time it takes. Now multi storey car parks are reporting that they need to check the structure as ev are much heavier than usual cars. We will look at it again in a few years, but our next car will be petrol.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 31/12/2022 18:53

anything up to 5 miles is/can be cycled. 10 miles e-bike. cycling infrastructure dependent of course.

Lucky that there aren't any elderly or disabled folk in society, isn't it....

LadyVictoriaSponge · 31/12/2022 18:38

RedRiverShore2 · 31/12/2022 15:34

Yes, so all the poor people can get on their bikes or walk

Yes this, if you think there is wealth inequality now just wait to see what it’s like in 10/15/20 years. Young people think they have it bad now not being able to afford to buy a house, but soon they will never be able to afford a car either, driving and travel will be for the relatively wealthy only, no one will want terraced houses and will loose value as everyone will want a house with a private drive for car changing, society is going backwards at a rapid pace. I imagine in the not too distant future unless you are born into a relatively comfortable family that future generations won’t own houses, won’t drive or own cars, won’t be able to afford travel and will have stay in their designated climate zones working to keep the rich in the style to which they have become accustomed, sounds dystopian but it’s happening already.

RedRiverShore2 · 31/12/2022 15:34

greenacrylicpaint · 31/12/2022 15:20

yep. move to ev will only work if personal car ownership and use is vastly reduced.

anything up to 5 miles is/can be cycled. 10 miles e-bike. cycling infrastructure dependent of course.

Yes, so all the poor people can get on their bikes or walk

Yarrawonga · 31/12/2022 15:28

In 2021 there were 12 cars to every 10 households in the UK.

But how many of those cars will need charging every day, or even every week?

There are five cars registered at our address. There are only two of us and we rarely use more than one at at time. We haven’t driven anywhere for the last three days and have no plans to until at least Tuesday.

greenacrylicpaint · 31/12/2022 15:20

yep. move to ev will only work if personal car ownership and use is vastly reduced.

anything up to 5 miles is/can be cycled. 10 miles e-bike. cycling infrastructure dependent of course.

OP posts:
Chersfrozenface · 31/12/2022 15:15

In 2021 there were 12 cars to every 10 households in the UK. Over 30% of UK homes have no off-street parking. That will leave an awful lot of cars needing to use public chargers 100% of the time.

Caspianberg · 31/12/2022 14:36

We have on site holiday let. No problem with guests charging their car if they want to.

We charge our car at home 99% of the time. So working out how many cars can fill at petrol v public charger is pointless as majority of electric car chargers are only using public chargers on long distance routes.

Oakbeam · 31/12/2022 14:30

Is there not a way to take a giant battery pack into the car boot for charge.

In order to fully charge an empty battery, the battery pack would have to be more or less the same same size as the car’s internal battery.

A Tesla Model 3 battery weighs nearly half a ton. Getting one in the boot might be a bit of a struggle. Even one half the size would need a crane.

SecretVictoria · 31/12/2022 13:03

NotMeNoNo · 29/10/2022 12:30

I expect there will just be less personal car ownership/ use, less convenience. Holidays and journeys will have to be set up differently. If there is more rental/carpooling there will be fewer cars manufactured but they will be used more of the time. There needs to be time for a shift in behaviour as well as charging technology and other transport options to catch up.

This is because the climate is in an emergency situation you know, not just to inconvenience your preferred loo stop regime on a long journey.

How though? I live in a town with very high unemployment so I had to get a job doing shifts 25 miles away. There is no direct public transport and nothing that would get me there for the start of an early shift or home after a late shift.

My MIL lives about 150 miles away and when we go and see her we usually take her out for lunch/dinner so we need to drive and take the car. We like to go for days out and lots of places (e.g. Lake District) aren’t accessible by bus/train.

Shesasuperfreak · 31/12/2022 12:54

Is there not a way to take a giant battery pack into the car boot for charge.

essaytwenty · 31/12/2022 12:50

an ICE would be much less and you wouldn’t be helping the planet much either

As long as ICE is still a viable option. We may eventually have to look at getting connected to the grid just to stay mobile. That’s at least 15k at today’s prices that I’d rather spend on something else.