Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are you 'fatphobic'

167 replies

lawofmotion · 29/10/2022 09:40

According to this definition it seems I am.

Aibu to think that actually that's completely reasonable?

Teen Vogue writer Catherine Mhloyi said: "In having the word 'fat' appear on the scale, she made a choice to explicitly name her demon, the fear of being called fat, which is fatphobia in its most literal sense."

news.sky.com/story/taylor-swift-video-for-anti-hero-edited-to-remove-the-word-fat-12731618

OP posts:
Maverickess · 29/10/2022 10:49

crumpetswithjam · 29/10/2022 10:41

The idea that I could make somebody feel physically unwell just by existing, and them not knowing or caring anything about my many other good qualities. It makes me depressed. What's the point?

The point is that it's a stick to beat someone with, an obvious and visible apparent failing in someone that is socially sanctioned to use to humiliate someone else to make themselves feel good.

That's the only point to a comment like this, and unfortunately that's how some people work, instead of just being a decent person and seeking validation that way, they seek perceived failures in others, that they don't feel they have, to boost their own ego. The worst ones then dress it up as 'concern' for the NHS or even the person.

I'm fat, overweight, bigger, curvy - whatever you want to call it, but I'm also a decent person, I don't rate the opinion of someone who gets their validation from attempting devalue someone else.

TheGoogleMum · 29/10/2022 10:49

I don't much like being called fat but I am. Perhaps I am fat phobic too! I have some fatter friends and think they wear their weight well though and am in no way afraid or ashamed of them for their bodies?

AdamRyan · 29/10/2022 10:47

Should also have said the inner critic is rarely right. So people can "feel" fat while not actually being fat.

AdamRyan · 29/10/2022 10:46

Oh this is ridiculous
Lots of people have an inner critic that uses the worst insults to them "you bitch, you're disgusting, you are ugly, you are fat" etc and it exacerbates their mental health problems.
She's trying to personify that inner critic in the video. Of course the inner critic is fat phobic. Inner critics are by their nature horrible and "phobic" or racist, misogynist in all sorts of ways
It would be more useful to many people to discuss that openly than simplify it to "the video is fat phobic"

I love Taylor Swift and think she's really brave about how she talks about being female these days in her music.

Topgub · 29/10/2022 10:42

@RealBecca

You can talk about your body but why lie?

If you're not fat (and you must know you're not) why pretend you are?

crumpetswithjam · 29/10/2022 10:41

Applesandcarrots · 29/10/2022 10:38

Why is everyone taking Sword's comment seriously? Let alone personally?

The idea that I could make somebody feel physically unwell just by existing, and them not knowing or caring anything about my many other good qualities. It makes me depressed. What's the point?

xPeaceX · 29/10/2022 10:39

Taylor Swift was labelled fat by the media though. She has the right to make the point that even a tall healthy weight woman is still put under pressure to be thinn-er. It's her story, her feelings, she was labelled fat.
I'm surprised she backed down and changed it. It really resonated with me.

Applesandcarrots · 29/10/2022 10:38

Why is everyone taking Sword's comment seriously? Let alone personally?

crumpetswithjam · 29/10/2022 10:36

I'm fat. I wouldn't have minded the word on the scales in the video staying in. Taylor was making a point about how the industry makes you feel, and not making a point anywhere near saying that fat people are bad.

crumpetswithjam · 29/10/2022 10:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

To somebody fat like me it's just absolutely heartbreaking to have to read this. I'm in tears now.

Applesandcarrots · 29/10/2022 10:30

@Smilelesstalkmore I blocked quote a few. Thanks to me searching once for something and looking at 1, I was suddenly drowning in them.
Half of it is made up like other things on influencers' insta are.
Chin lipo, face lipo, smart video editing. The thing is that they make themselves look like they can run miles and do very harsh HIIT at size 30+ without breaking a sweat. That has two results. Half a people idolises them and second half feels bad that they look like them but can't make it up the stairs without huffing like a broken steam engine.

And yup. They are trapped and will be until end of their sadly shorter end of life

Imho it is exactly like unhealthily skinny influencers.

Ponoka7 · 29/10/2022 10:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You need to discuss that in therapy. I just hope that you haven't verbalised that to your DD.

Spencerfloral · 29/10/2022 10:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

That's fine, your nasty attitude probably makes quite a few people feel sick as well.

Smilelesstalkmore · 29/10/2022 10:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Why? Why the fuck would you even care? Why are you spending your time in a restaurant watching other people eat? So you go out for a nice meal and you are put off your food from watching another person eat?

That's just weird, get a grip.

Smilelesstalkmore · 29/10/2022 10:23

BewareTheBeardedDragon · 29/10/2022 10:11

My teen has been telling me about 'body positive' tiktokkers who apparently say it is fatphobic, and therefore bigoted and bad, to diet, eat healthily in order to reach or maintain a healthy weight - even if you are not prejudiced against fat people and never talk about your own diet just doing it for yourself is 'phobic' Confused
Luckily - he thinks that is a ridiculous attitude.

This is absolutely a thing. Just look at the shit Adele got when she lost weight.

I know there are some 'body positive' influencers on Insta who have made their weight their USP, and for some of them it is clear that they were happier when they were smaller and want to try and lose a bit of weight. But they are trapped because they don't want to 'let their followers down' by losing any weight. They won't even say the word excercise because it's 'too triggering', it's 'movement'. And if you look in the comments of these accounts, none of the young women who follow them seem happy, everything is triggering, everything is about them and how they feel and how what that influencer says makes them feel, everything is fatphobic.

It's so fucked up and is probably messing with young people's body image just as much as before tbh.

lunar1 · 29/10/2022 10:23

Words change their meaning over time depending upon how they are being used.

There is absolutely nothing wrong on the surface with the word fat. However certainly through my 40 years on this earth, it hasn't been used simply as a descriptor.

It's used to bully, shame and intimidate. It's used to reduce a person's value and decimate their self esteem.

So fat would be an accurate description for many of us, it's been used and is still being used as a slur.

Some may describe themselves that way, and it may be used by healthcare professionals when talking with patients as a necessity, but many of us don't want to hear the word used to torment us used by slim people.

WrongWayApricot · 29/10/2022 10:22

It sounds to me like the change made the video more interesting anyway. Instead of her fear being on the scale it shows her fear is her own disappointment. I think that's a more accurate representation of an ED.

Chattycathydoll · 29/10/2022 10:20

Regardless of the debate, you know that image of the scale with the word ‘fat’ on it is going to be used over and over on pro-ana websites now. That’s more likely why it had to be removed, albeit too late.

RealBecca · 29/10/2022 10:18

MyLovelyPen · 29/10/2022 10:04

I think the criticism is aimed at those slim women (and we all know at least one) who constantly wangs on about how fat they are in front of their fat friends (I’m the fat friend). Does my fucking head in. Choose your audience (you have plenty of slim friends) and don’t be an insensitive prick.

Why cant I talk about wanting to lose a few pounds at size 12 without it upsetting you? Me losing or gaining weight makes no difference to you. Why does how I feel about my body need to be censored? Is there anything else I shouldn't talk about? Food generally?

NeverTalksToStrangers · 29/10/2022 10:16

Taylor has admitted having an eating disorder (she didn't use the word anorexia but basically said she starved herself (she was very very thin circa 2015)), that's what the video is about, how she negatively views herself.

VERY few of us feel good about putting on weight, we feel good if we lose it though. If she's fat phobic, then 95% of the population are.

RealBecca · 29/10/2022 10:16

So she isnt allowed to feel fat and noone is allowed to say fat without being phobic. So we are supposed to live in a world where we dont notice obesity and instead just celebrate curves? Whilst propping up the diet industry. Right.

SwordToFlamethrower · 29/10/2022 10:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Applesandcarrots · 29/10/2022 10:15

BewareTheBeardedDragon · 29/10/2022 10:11

My teen has been telling me about 'body positive' tiktokkers who apparently say it is fatphobic, and therefore bigoted and bad, to diet, eat healthily in order to reach or maintain a healthy weight - even if you are not prejudiced against fat people and never talk about your own diet just doing it for yourself is 'phobic' Confused
Luckily - he thinks that is a ridiculous attitude.

Yeah.

Remember Adele and others getting some blast back for betrayel and making it look like being fat isn't ok.
Totally ignoring the fact it may have been for helath reasons.

Swift talked about her ED. She got in hot water because her ED is not acceptable now...

RealBecca · 29/10/2022 10:13

I hate that she removed the word "fat".

That everyone is supposed to just pretend to be body positive. Its toxic positivity.

We are all supposed to pretend noone cares what they weigh when every product is marketed at body image, whether that's weight loss, slimming, celebrating your curves...its exhausting.

She cant even talk about her own body or self because others are taking offence.

Nothing she put on that scale would have been acceptable. Theres an entire industry and society built around body image and it offends people to acknowledge that it exists.

We arent allowed to talk about our own bodies anymore.

BewareTheBeardedDragon · 29/10/2022 10:11

My teen has been telling me about 'body positive' tiktokkers who apparently say it is fatphobic, and therefore bigoted and bad, to diet, eat healthily in order to reach or maintain a healthy weight - even if you are not prejudiced against fat people and never talk about your own diet just doing it for yourself is 'phobic' Confused
Luckily - he thinks that is a ridiculous attitude.