Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are you 'fatphobic'

167 replies

lawofmotion · 29/10/2022 09:40

According to this definition it seems I am.

Aibu to think that actually that's completely reasonable?

Teen Vogue writer Catherine Mhloyi said: "In having the word 'fat' appear on the scale, she made a choice to explicitly name her demon, the fear of being called fat, which is fatphobia in its most literal sense."

news.sky.com/story/taylor-swift-video-for-anti-hero-edited-to-remove-the-word-fat-12731618

OP posts:
Applesandcarrots · 29/10/2022 15:14

It also make sme wonder about situations such as group therapy actually/talks

Applesandcarrots · 29/10/2022 15:12

Butchyrestingface · 29/10/2022 14:36

Teen Vogue writer Catherine Mhloyi said: "In having the word 'fat' appear on the scale, she made a choice to explicitly name her demon, the fear of being called fat, which is fatphobia in its most literal sense."

I googled the name Catherine Mhloyi and first hit was for someone whose Insta handle is fatangryblackgirl. Second hit on Google suggests this is the same person. Maybe she should take her own advice?

The thing which would worry me is she wrotes for teens, eill be read mainly by girls I assume, and she is essentially saying that if your mh or situation gives you certain thoughts, you shouldn't discuss them.
It's kind of be kind on steroids here.
Iyswim

Dalekjastninerels · 29/10/2022 14:51

I am fat (Size 16) but more annoyed by my shape (Apple)

I would love to be Hourglass; keep my boobs, round out the sides of my bum so it looks good from the back not all boxy like now and flatten my belly into dipped in smallness.

Losing weight won't give me the body I want Sad

Butchyrestingface · 29/10/2022 14:36

Teen Vogue writer Catherine Mhloyi said: "In having the word 'fat' appear on the scale, she made a choice to explicitly name her demon, the fear of being called fat, which is fatphobia in its most literal sense."

I googled the name Catherine Mhloyi and first hit was for someone whose Insta handle is fatangryblackgirl. Second hit on Google suggests this is the same person. Maybe she should take her own advice?

MichelleScarn · 29/10/2022 14:36

*With that said though, the discussion now did slip away from the original topic of "is it ok to silence people talking about their experiences and issues because you take it too personally and think your issues are bigger than theirs" exactly @Applesandcarrots on on earth are we living in a time that's overrun by the "how dare you have feelings/opinions about yourself, you must centre me at all times and think about me!

Maverickess · 29/10/2022 14:36

CheezePleeze · 29/10/2022 14:11

I think in the end of the day it’s still down to personal responsibility to try and integrate at least some form of exercise and reasonably healthy food in one’s everyday life.

It absolutely is, otherwise nothing will ever change.

Besides, office jobs and shift work have always existed, since long before UK obesity hit 63.9%.

And manual jobs are in decline, because of automation, I'm not saying it's all because of the lifestyle choices that feel less like choices and more like necessity, but that it does have a bearing on how much more you can move and how easy accessing the healthier food is. And how much more important other things in your life are above focussing on maintaining a healthy weight.
For example I worked permanent nights, as a single parent on a low income - staying awake and alert to be able to do my job and keeping all the plates spinning and the bills paid took priority over everything else, my diet was appalling, I ate easy, cheap and unhealthy foods and I was frankly too exhausted to pay more attention to it than the fact I had to eat something, and night work messes with every system in your body which doesn't help. Now I work days and DD is older I've lost weight because I am less exhausted, have more time to put into some thought around my health and weight, I'm still overweight, but I'm healthier and happier for losing some and it wasn't a concerted effort, it was because the pressures in life got easier with time.

And if obesity is at 63.9% it's quite clear that deriding and shaming people and just telling them to move more and eat less really doesn't work because that's been going on for years and years, yet obesity has and continues to rise.

lawofmotion · 29/10/2022 14:32

CheezePleeze · 29/10/2022 14:11

I think in the end of the day it’s still down to personal responsibility to try and integrate at least some form of exercise and reasonably healthy food in one’s everyday life.

It absolutely is, otherwise nothing will ever change.

Besides, office jobs and shift work have always existed, since long before UK obesity hit 63.9%.

Wow... 63%

I don't agree with making normalising obesity. It's just not healthy.

OP posts:
Applesandcarrots · 29/10/2022 14:24

No pun intended

Applesandcarrots · 29/10/2022 14:24

I think in the end of the day it’s still down to personal responsibility to try and integrate at least some form of exercise and reasonably healthy food in one’s everyday life.

I agree. Took a while for me to go through 7 tages of "I am sure, it's not me it must be..." until it clicked that it was indeed me and I started doing what needed to be done😂 Dummy.

With that said though, the discussion now did slip away from the original topic of "is it ok to silence people talking about their experiences and issues because you take it too personally and think your issues are bigger than theirs"

CheezePleeze · 29/10/2022 14:11

I think in the end of the day it’s still down to personal responsibility to try and integrate at least some form of exercise and reasonably healthy food in one’s everyday life.

It absolutely is, otherwise nothing will ever change.

Besides, office jobs and shift work have always existed, since long before UK obesity hit 63.9%.

Mascia · 29/10/2022 14:02

Maverickess · 29/10/2022 13:36

Two things stand out here to me.

  1. Obesity is socially unacceptable, yet still on the rise, clearly shaming people isn't working, is it? You've only got to read comments on threads like this to realise it's socially unacceptable, the fact that people actively avoid gaining weight in order to avoid the stigma involved with being overweight.

  2. I agree that 'moving more and eating less' is the basis of a weight that is optimal for good health, however we never seem to look at the other - societal - pressures that make that harder than the simple solution it needs to be. So many people with jobs that require you to sit at a desk for 8 hours, that drain you mentally but not physically, shift work that means people eat at times that aren't the best, reaching for what fills them quickly in the 20 minutes they get to eat, and after work before they move on to the next set of stuff that needs doing, demands of modern life that mean weight is a lower priority than keeping the bills paid and life running. During lockdown when I had relatively little to do except look after myself, I lost weight and got much fitter, life going back to 'normal' and I've put weight on again - and yes, that's my 'choice' but one driven through needing to prioritise and my weight being lower down the list than for some people.

I totally get your point about how certain jobs might make it more difficult to maintain a relatively healthy and active lifestyle. But what can we do as a society? We can’t just get rid of shift work or desk jobs.
I think in the end of the day it’s still down to personal responsibility to try and integrate at least some form of exercise and reasonably healthy food in one’s everyday life.

CheezePleeze · 29/10/2022 13:45

I agree that 'moving more and eating less' is the basis of a weight that is optimal for good health, however we never seem to look at the other - societal - pressures that make that harder than the simple solution it needs to be. So many people with jobs that require you to sit at a desk for 8 hours, that drain you mentally but not physically, shift work that means people eat at times that aren't the best, reaching for what fills them quickly in the 20 minutes they get to eat, and after work before they move on to the next set of stuff that needs doing, demands of modern life that mean weight is a lower priority than keeping the bills paid and life running. During lockdown when I had relatively little to do except look after myself, I lost weight and got much fitter, life going back to 'normal' and I've put weight on again - and yes, that's my 'choice' but one driven through needing to prioritise and my weight being lower down the list than for some people.

@Maverickess those things are always looked at it would seem.

But many people are still eating more calories than they're burning off. So looking at it is all well and good but obviously people need to take action for themselves if they want to lose weight.

But the fact is many of us eat too much food, regardless of lots of other factors and until we stop, we'll remain overweight.

hilariousnamehere · 29/10/2022 13:43

@CheezePleeze that's actually given me food for thought. In your example of the food stain yes, I'd change if I could, but if I couldn't (already on train or something) I'd style it out quite happily.

So for a base level of clean and tidy, sure - but beyond that I couldn't give a monkeys if people think I'm fat / loud / dress like a toddler / don't have any fashion sense / don't hide my squidgy bits like I "should" / plus all the other things I know people say. I don't exist to look nice for other people, and the pressure to look a certain way (whether weight related or not) feels like a way to keep women worrying about their own appearance and not using that headspace on other things.

KimberleyClark · 29/10/2022 13:42

A phobia is an irrational fear. I am not scared of fat people. But I don't think it's irrational to dislike rolls of flesh.

A phobia can also include feelings of revulsion and disgust. That is what, for example, emetophobia is.

VyeBrator · 29/10/2022 13:38

RealBecca · 29/10/2022 13:34

Perfect! Thank you, I missed your 'dickish behaviour/silencing" post so that makes total sense! Still a bit sleepy today!

I confused myself in the end 😂

CheezePleeze · 29/10/2022 13:36

Who cares what someone else thinks when they look at you?

Most people do.

This is the reason why we might comb our hair in the morning and put clean clothes on when leaving the house etc.

If you had a huge ketchup stain on your blouse, would you still go to work in it or quickly change before leaving the house?

Maverickess · 29/10/2022 13:36

reigatecastle · 29/10/2022 12:44

A phobia is an irrational fear. I am not scared of fat people. But I don't think it's irrational to dislike rolls of flesh. Interestingly there is an article in the Times today saying that we could do a lot to "protect" the NHS if we made obesity as socially unacceptable as smoking or drink driving. Maybe a bit extreme, but I see the author's point.

In most cases it is a choice (not all, the late Hilary Mantel being a case in point, she was a size 8 before she had to take medication for her endometriosis, I can't even begin to imagine what she went through).

Also I dislike the diet industry - mainly just snake oil. If people moved more and ate less, they would have far fewer customers and would have to find a more ethical way to make a living.

Two things stand out here to me.

  1. Obesity is socially unacceptable, yet still on the rise, clearly shaming people isn't working, is it? You've only got to read comments on threads like this to realise it's socially unacceptable, the fact that people actively avoid gaining weight in order to avoid the stigma involved with being overweight.

  2. I agree that 'moving more and eating less' is the basis of a weight that is optimal for good health, however we never seem to look at the other - societal - pressures that make that harder than the simple solution it needs to be. So many people with jobs that require you to sit at a desk for 8 hours, that drain you mentally but not physically, shift work that means people eat at times that aren't the best, reaching for what fills them quickly in the 20 minutes they get to eat, and after work before they move on to the next set of stuff that needs doing, demands of modern life that mean weight is a lower priority than keeping the bills paid and life running. During lockdown when I had relatively little to do except look after myself, I lost weight and got much fitter, life going back to 'normal' and I've put weight on again - and yes, that's my 'choice' but one driven through needing to prioritise and my weight being lower down the list than for some people.

Nightynightnight · 29/10/2022 13:36

Smilelesstalkmore · 29/10/2022 10:26

Why? Why the fuck would you even care? Why are you spending your time in a restaurant watching other people eat? So you go out for a nice meal and you are put off your food from watching another person eat?

That's just weird, get a grip.

But this is actual fat phobia. And like any other phobia it may not seem rational but is very real.

Mascia · 29/10/2022 13:35

crumpetswithjam · 29/10/2022 11:14

It's apparently fine to say that watching fat people eat makes you feel sick, and that fat people are 'gross'. So telling somebody that they're a judgemental arsehole when they're being a judgemental arsehole seems the lesser of those two evils. I wonder which one MN will delete first. Bet it's the arsehole one.

Who said it was fine what that other poster said about watching others eat? I haven’t seen a single post agreeing with them (and rightly so).

RealBecca · 29/10/2022 13:34

VyeBrator · 29/10/2022 13:18

The size 12 comment was mine and I think things are getting mixed up. What was it about my comment you wanted to discuss with me?

Now I'm really confused. All I did was agree with your post (you'll need to scroll back to find it) 😂

Then read Topgub's reply.

Perfect! Thank you, I missed your 'dickish behaviour/silencing" post so that makes total sense! Still a bit sleepy today!

hilariousnamehere · 29/10/2022 13:29

WhosafraidofVirginiaWoolf · 29/10/2022 13:19

@hilariousnamehere Yes but I am 5.1 and 15 stone 2 so clinically obese and I still think they look awful.

I appreciate that others may feel different but that is them not me.

I know I am fat and know that clothes look better when you are slimmer, so for me seeing models that are obese like me just makes me feel more depressed and obviously fat phobic, but at least I apply that to myself too.

I'm allowed that opinion that time I checked.

Yes, of course you're allowed your opinion. And to feel however you want about anything.

I just find it so sad that as a society we're conditioned to think that clothes can only look good when someone is slim. And I think we waste so much of our precious lives feeling bad about being fat / being perceived as fat / worrying about being fat / worrying about people thinking we're fat, as also evidenced by pp.

Who cares what someone else thinks when they look at you? But I've been saying this since I was a teenager and am usually met with some response of "but you must want to look nice" as though looking nice is impossible in my existing body. I'm fat too and wear very thick glasses, have done since I was small. So I've given up listening to other people and dress for me and I feel good - and just wish more women could do the same for themselves.

Mascia · 29/10/2022 13:29

crumpetswithjam · 29/10/2022 11:06

It makes you a judgemental arsehole, which is worse than being a fatty tbh

How is it making her a judgmental arsehole? She‘s just talking about her own body and how she fears being judged. That’s absolutely legitimate.

waterlego · 29/10/2022 13:23

Smilelesstalkmore · 29/10/2022 10:01

'Fatphobia' is being prejudiced about someone who is overweight, and making judgements about who they are as a person, solely based on their weight. That's it.

I don't want to be fat, because I don't think I would look nice and also I would hate to not be able to move my body in the way I want to, or have health problems attached to it. If that makes me 'fat phobic' in some people's eyes, then quite frankly I don't give a fuck.

Exactly this. I don’t think it’s other people’s place to say what I can or can’t say about my preferences for my own body and life.

Is it specifically the word ‘fat’ itself? Does it make it any better if I say that I don’t want to be overweight? Or I don’t want a high BMI?
How is me saying that a reflection on anyone else? Some people don’t care about or are comfortable being overweight. Genuinely: good for them. But I don’t want that for myself 🤷🏼‍♀️

WhosafraidofVirginiaWoolf · 29/10/2022 13:19

last not that.

WhosafraidofVirginiaWoolf · 29/10/2022 13:19

@hilariousnamehere Yes but I am 5.1 and 15 stone 2 so clinically obese and I still think they look awful.

I appreciate that others may feel different but that is them not me.

I know I am fat and know that clothes look better when you are slimmer, so for me seeing models that are obese like me just makes me feel more depressed and obviously fat phobic, but at least I apply that to myself too.

I'm allowed that opinion that time I checked.