Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are you 'fatphobic'

167 replies

lawofmotion · 29/10/2022 09:40

According to this definition it seems I am.

Aibu to think that actually that's completely reasonable?

Teen Vogue writer Catherine Mhloyi said: "In having the word 'fat' appear on the scale, she made a choice to explicitly name her demon, the fear of being called fat, which is fatphobia in its most literal sense."

news.sky.com/story/taylor-swift-video-for-anti-hero-edited-to-remove-the-word-fat-12731618

OP posts:
runjy · 29/10/2022 18:37

I think a bigger body can be more attractive than a slimmer one. A lot depends on shape & proportions imo. Personally I'd rather be overweight with a pretty face than very slim with an average face.

SimonaRazowska · 29/10/2022 18:34

@runjy yes, but you are also limiting their beauty to their faces

is their body not beautiful? Because they are bigger?

I guess that’s what lots of people mean with fat phobia?

FWIW I think a fat person can be attractive, just as much as anyone else, but I myself would not want to be overweight (I guess I am then also fatphobic?!)

runjy · 29/10/2022 18:21

Agree. But I feel like it ingrained in the human psyche because it's to do with being attractive yada yada yada

This is the bit I struggle with though. Yes being slim, well groomed & well dressed can make someone more attractive but being slim doesn't make your face beautiful if it's not. I think Ashley Graham & Barbie Ferriera have beautiful faces even though they are "fat".

lawofmotion · 29/10/2022 17:58

HailOWeen · 29/10/2022 16:21

In my experience, women (in the UK at least, generally speaking and I include myself here) are borderline obsessed with weight.

Agree. But I feel like it ingrained in the human psyche because it's to do with being attractive yada yada yada

OP posts:
lawofmotion · 29/10/2022 17:56

PBSam · 29/10/2022 16:56

I've been fat and I don't want to be fat again. Am I fatphobic?

According to a lot of people on tiktok, yes.

OP posts:
Applesandcarrots · 29/10/2022 17:11

HailOWeen · 29/10/2022 17:00

The media are terrible for making snide weight comments about mostly female stars.

I often see articles about overweight female celebrities with headlines like 'OMG LOOK HOW SKINNY SHE LOOKS NOW' but the celebrity in question never looks any different. It's literally just clickbait for trolls.

Yeah. No matter what happens with your weight as famous person, it's a negative.

And then when they talk about it and their own MH issues, they get shot down.

HailOWeen · 29/10/2022 17:00

The media are terrible for making snide weight comments about mostly female stars.

I often see articles about overweight female celebrities with headlines like 'OMG LOOK HOW SKINNY SHE LOOKS NOW' but the celebrity in question never looks any different. It's literally just clickbait for trolls.

nootsy · 29/10/2022 16:58

I find it weird how people conflate fat with morbidly obese. Is fat not having a 6 pack, not having an underweight BMI if you're a celeb. It's very confusing.

PBSam · 29/10/2022 16:56

I've been fat and I don't want to be fat again. Am I fatphobic?

roundtable · 29/10/2022 16:54

The media are terrible for making snide weight comments about mostly female stars.

Amy Winehouse I think was a very sad unfortunate casualty of that. She was constantly called fat when she was a rising star. I've always wondered if her drug addiction was linked to curbing her appetite.

I also wonder if Taylor Swift would have had a better reaction if instead of standing on the scales and it reading 'fat' - she had done it through a newspaper/magazine article which made out she was fatter than she should be and then her on the scales without the word fat. It would have conveyed the message that I think she was trying to get across.

Or maybe I have too much time on my hands to think for an hour!

Notbeinfunnehbut · 29/10/2022 16:48

MyLovelyPen · 29/10/2022 10:04

I think the criticism is aimed at those slim women (and we all know at least one) who constantly wangs on about how fat they are in front of their fat friends (I’m the fat friend). Does my fucking head in. Choose your audience (you have plenty of slim friends) and don’t be an insensitive prick.

Yeah I think that’s it

although I’m fat I had no issue with the video I feel as if people like to pile on TS

PupInAPram · 29/10/2022 16:48

Blackbirdblue30 · 29/10/2022 16:25

To me 'fatphobic' means assigning negative traits to a fat person based on their appearance alone, which is obviously very simplistic. There are far, far worse things a person can be than overweight.
However I don't agree with glorifying obesity in the name of body positivity and apparently that is synonymous now with fat phobia?
Disabilities and sicknesses that are misfortune or the way you're born can't be helped but giving them to yourself by overeating might be the clincher with this.
I won't go near overweight to date as I find it physically repulsive, but I also wouldn't go near a heavy drinker, addict or even a smoker. Maybe it's to do with a childish lack of self-control there? Admittedly that's influenced by two obese men in my extended family life who also both overspend to the point of debt. It's like they don't understand consequences and then need others to sort them out.

There are slender drug addicts, slender alcoholics, slender people who can't control their spending. There are overweight people who have brilliant control over their finances, who don't drink who have never smoked. There are fat people who are brilliant parents and thin people who are lousy parents. If you dispute this I would suggest you get to know more fat people.

Nightynightnight · 29/10/2022 16:47

I've been very skinny, average and very overweight. When I'm overweight (which I am now) it's usually because I am feeling unhappy, out of control, and stressed. When I see friends or family gain weight I wonder if there is something else going on for them. It's ok to notice weight gain. It's ok to notice what people look like, and sometimes (depending on the kind of relationship you have) it's ok to ask them if something is going on for them. There's never any need to say "you've put on weight what's going on" but it is ok to say "do you fancy a walk and a chat".

HermioneWeasley · 29/10/2022 16:42

I think it’s a complex topic

being extremely overweight is bad for your health (as is being severely under weight). It’s not something which should be normalised or celebrated. But making people feel ashamed about their weight helps solve the problem in no way whatsoever. I don’t think weight says anything about your character or ability.

equally, I don’t think people should be subjected to adversity because of other people’s weight - think aeroplane seats. I don’t think it makes me fat phobic to want full use of my small seat and not want to be continuously touched, however unintentionally.

HailOWeen · 29/10/2022 16:37

I think, when someone feels the need to share their size on here or pretend that they're concerned about the negative effects on a person's health, that they are (consciously or subconsciously) saying 'I'm better because I'm not fat.' I think there is a lot of 'fatphobia' on mn.

Blackbirdblue30 · 29/10/2022 16:25

To me 'fatphobic' means assigning negative traits to a fat person based on their appearance alone, which is obviously very simplistic. There are far, far worse things a person can be than overweight.
However I don't agree with glorifying obesity in the name of body positivity and apparently that is synonymous now with fat phobia?
Disabilities and sicknesses that are misfortune or the way you're born can't be helped but giving them to yourself by overeating might be the clincher with this.
I won't go near overweight to date as I find it physically repulsive, but I also wouldn't go near a heavy drinker, addict or even a smoker. Maybe it's to do with a childish lack of self-control there? Admittedly that's influenced by two obese men in my extended family life who also both overspend to the point of debt. It's like they don't understand consequences and then need others to sort them out.

Topgub · 29/10/2022 16:22

@AssumingDirectControl

Exactly.

The idea that someone random cares about the health of some other randoms health.

I wonder why people can't just own their judgement

HailOWeen · 29/10/2022 16:21

In my experience, women (in the UK at least, generally speaking and I include myself here) are borderline obsessed with weight.

AssumingDirectControl · 29/10/2022 16:01

TeapotTitties · 29/10/2022 15:37

The truth is often enraging but it's still the truth. No point in getting angry because people are speaking it.

Better to make peace with the fact you're never going to lose weight and just carry on with what you're doing/not doing.

It’s not the truth that’s enraging. It’s the holier-than-thou proponents of it, under the guise of “just caring about peoples health!” which is utter bollocks, because with those types it’s never care, it’s always perceived superiority and smugness.

Maverickess · 29/10/2022 15:38

MichelleScarn · 29/10/2022 15:24

Ah but other people can't be blamed then @CheezePleeze so many people deride the 'eat less move more' advice as shaming/mean/unkind. I just don't get it, it's simple reality!

It's not mean, fat shaming or deriding people to say that, yes it's a simple fact.

Refusing to take the factors into consideration that affect the move more/eat less (and less is not necessarily true, better would be more appropriate) to haughtily dismiss them as excuses, and to say it with scorn and a self righteous attitude, over and over again, well that's just pulling people down for the sake of it really, because you don't like their appearance and what you believe that makes them as a person.

Kinda shallow, but each to their own.

TeapotTitties · 29/10/2022 15:37

The truth is often enraging but it's still the truth. No point in getting angry because people are speaking it.

Better to make peace with the fact you're never going to lose weight and just carry on with what you're doing/not doing.

AssumingDirectControl · 29/10/2022 15:32

MichelleScarn · 29/10/2022 15:24

Ah but other people can't be blamed then @CheezePleeze so many people deride the 'eat less move more' advice as shaming/mean/unkind. I just don't get it, it's simple reality!

Well because it’s absolutely patronising. It’s not like it’s astonishing news to anyone. Fat people know they’re fat. They know what they theoretically need to do in order to be less fat. There might be any number of reasons why this is difficult for them. “Well-meaning” and bloody obvious advice like this - which is never fucking well meaning - is actually enraging.

Applesandcarrots · 29/10/2022 15:26

MichelleScarn · 29/10/2022 15:24

Ah but other people can't be blamed then @CheezePleeze so many people deride the 'eat less move more' advice as shaming/mean/unkind. I just don't get it, it's simple reality!

It's only shaming if it isn't in £20 a pop book with fancy cover name claiming it's totally different method (but in reality it is eat les, move more)...

MichelleScarn · 29/10/2022 15:24

Ah but other people can't be blamed then @CheezePleeze so many people deride the 'eat less move more' advice as shaming/mean/unkind. I just don't get it, it's simple reality!

CheezePleeze · 29/10/2022 15:18

And if obesity is at 63.9% it's quite clear that deriding and shaming people and just telling them to move more and eat less really doesn't work because that's been going on for years and years, yet obesity has and continues to rise.

Well I expect that's because people aren't moving more and eating less.

And all the ifs, buts and maybes won't change that until people start doing it.

Shaming people, not shaming people, body positive movements, therapy, understanding of socio-economics etc etc aren't working either and nor will they until people start eating less and moving more.