Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How can people afford to remortgage

216 replies

Tead · 29/10/2022 09:09

I have a £200k mortgage. When aI remortgage I will end up paying around £500 a month more. I can just about manage I think although there will be nothing left at the end of the month and we might need to go into our savings.
how would people who are just about coping deal with an increase in monthly payments

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SleepyAnkylosaurus · 01/11/2022 14:51

It's a really great time to be a housing association tenant?

BeenNeverSeen · 01/11/2022 08:26

Testina · 01/11/2022 08:00

Sorry, that was to @BeenNeverSeen 😀

Thank you, really helpful advice & much appreciated. I guess he has a crystal ball…

Testina · 01/11/2022 08:00

Sorry, that was to @BeenNeverSeen 😀

Testina · 01/11/2022 07:59

If your adviser thinks you’d be fixing at a maximum of 1% “too high” I’m surprised they’re not recommending 5 years. I’m also surprised they’re telling you that - in my experience MAs are great at finding the right product for you - but don’t have interest rate crystal balls. Did you ask why he thinks they’ll stabilise at 4-5%? I wonder if his answer would be, “because”.

I decided to fix for 5 last December. Before the Ukraine war, but already increasing economic uncertainty with Covid and Brexit effects.

I decided by looking at how much I would lose out on if rates went down, how much just not having to worry about rises was worth to me, and what my options were at the end of the fix if I didn’t fix long enough.

So say I fixed at 5% - how much would I be “wasting” if it dropped to 4%? Say that’s £1000. Is £1000K worth it to buy peace of mind?

How much can I afford for it to go up? I could afford to pay 10%. Therefore, if I want I can take the risk that rates go down and I win by not fixing - cos I can afford the opposite. If you have no wriggle room to afford placing the wrong bet - don’t place it. If rates do go down, accept that you made the right decision at the time.

Then the end of the fix. What would I do if rates rose sharply? After a 2 year fix, I’d struggle. I’d simply have to find the money from somewhere. But after a 5 year fix, I’d have paid off an extra 3 years so if I really had to, I could add that time back into my remortgage to lower my payments. I also know I can afford to overpay during the 5 years if things look hairy. At the moment I’m prioritising additional pension but if we start h the next tax year on 8% mortgages, I’ll switch and over pay whilst still on my fix.

On that logic, why not a 10 year fix?
I only have 13 years to go. If retrospectively a 10 year fix would have been better, I’ve only got 8 years to go. So the actual £ impact is lower than someone with a 25 year mortgage. I also am very likely to have received a small inheritance in 10 years, but not 5. So I may have another option. I have some savings if I have to use them.

So all in all…

I actually probably made the wrong decision in December. I fixed for 5 years at 2%. If I’d done it 6 months later I’d have possibly fixed for 10.

But, I don’t have regrets because I know my decision making was sound, and I know that I have a plan for the unfixed years 5-10.

You need to get close to all your options, and your attitude to risk.

BeenNeverSeen · 01/11/2022 06:50

We are in the process of remortgaging & have an offer at 5%. How do you decide whether to fix for 2 years or 5 years…? Genuinely don’t know what to do! Our mortgage advisor said 2 years as he thinks interest rates will stabilise at between 4 to 5% but obviously just his opinion!

IneedanewTV · 31/10/2022 22:16

Personally I would stretch the term. I’ve had a mortgage for Over 30 years now and have another 7 years to go. If rates drop again you can reduce the term or over pay. It’s still the cheapest way to borrow money. If you rented you would pay rent for the rest of your working life so why is a mortgage seen differently.

YetAnotherNameChange52 · 31/10/2022 22:09

Razzle5 · 31/10/2022 07:14

Why? Pay?

For me it was the hours @Razzle5 - working all hours day and night at full pelt was starting to affect my health, and was certainly affecting my time with my family. The NHS sadly isn't great at taking care of it's staff.

YetAnotherNameChange52 · 31/10/2022 22:04

Halloweenshock · 31/10/2022 06:39

I’ve left my dream job in the public sector for one that pays the bills in the private sector. I am not the only one of my colleagues to do so. Worse public services are on their way.

I've just left my NHS job to go to the private sector too, as have a lot of my colleagues, so I agree with you @Halloweenshock

DeadHouseBounce · 31/10/2022 14:42

user1468761869 · 31/10/2022 14:02

We have decided to liquidate our savings into our mortgage. Hence buffering the hike in interest rate with a lesser mortgage.

Two lines that encapsulate the damage that property bubbles do. The property market crashing will be the best thing to happen to the UK in decades, bring it on!

user1468761869 · 31/10/2022 14:02

We have decided to liquidate our savings into our mortgage. Hence buffering the hike in interest rate with a lesser mortgage.

Grrrrdarling · 31/10/2022 11:03

Alibro79 · 29/10/2022 09:18

Many will simply not manage. We are anticipating large increases in mortgages arrears, large increases in people seeking forbearance measures. We are moving staff from new business teams to arrears teams in preparation.

If my deal was up now, I would seek a new fixed deal but would hang around on a variable rate for a while, saving up as much as I can.

Brilliant advice. The market is going insane & if anyone can extend the length of their mortgage right now to bring costs down or go interest only for a few years I’d advise them to give it a go. Hopefully things will get better but it won’t be anytime soon & I feel for those who are going to lose their security, retirement pot etc.

whynotwhatknot · 31/10/2022 09:27

no idea will have to remortgage in 2 years and i pray the rates arent too high

Razzle5 · 31/10/2022 07:14

Halloweenshock · 31/10/2022 06:39

I’ve left my dream job in the public sector for one that pays the bills in the private sector. I am not the only one of my colleagues to do so. Worse public services are on their way.

Why? Pay?

Halloweenshock · 31/10/2022 06:39

I’ve left my dream job in the public sector for one that pays the bills in the private sector. I am not the only one of my colleagues to do so. Worse public services are on their way.

donttellmehesalive · 31/10/2022 06:29

I thought this Guardian article, reporting on the announcement from NatWest here was interesting. Not just the forecast for a 7% drop followed by five years of stagnation, but also that they can see the beginning of changed behaviours in their customers - spending less, consolidating debt, swapping to cheaper supermarkets and so on. Interesting to see trends and patterns starting to establish, even though anecdotally people are saying that they don't know anyone affected.

lannistunut · 31/10/2022 05:24

C4tastrophe · 30/10/2022 22:22

You think Labour would have had a full costed budget? Liz was a disaster but the train was already coming down the tracks.
The markets won’t tolerate any more borrowing on the never never.
If Rishi doesn’t come up with solid policies to boost gdp, and not by just increasing immigration, he’ll go the same way as Liz.
It wouldn’t surprise me if he increased NI again, which would be great as everyone wants more spent on the NHS.

Yes, Labour would have had a costed budget for any fiscal event. What Truss did - and the Tories praised it initially - was completely out of the ordinary.

C4tastrophe · 30/10/2022 22:22

lannistunut · 30/10/2022 18:50

Funny how even the current Tories accept Truss made the problem worse here in the UK. The cost of government borrowing rose out of line with other similar countries when the mini budget bollocks was announced.

So it definitely would have been different if the Tories had not been in power in September.

You think Labour would have had a full costed budget? Liz was a disaster but the train was already coming down the tracks.
The markets won’t tolerate any more borrowing on the never never.
If Rishi doesn’t come up with solid policies to boost gdp, and not by just increasing immigration, he’ll go the same way as Liz.
It wouldn’t surprise me if he increased NI again, which would be great as everyone wants more spent on the NHS.

caringcarer · 30/10/2022 21:57

I saw on news couple of weeks ago the number of people affected now are low but if BofE keep putting rates up as they will have to if they are to curb inflation then next spring more people get drawn in and by Xmas 2023 more still. Basically as people's fixed end unless government and BofE can drive inflation down and get on top of it then each year more people will be affected.

YetAnotherNameChange52 · 30/10/2022 21:53

We took out a Nationwide mortgage with a fixed rate meaning we have been paying £2700/month. It finishes next month. If we had just gone onto another Nationwide mortgage now it would now cost £3643 - so nearly £1K/month more!

We were lucky in that our financial advisor advised us to arrange one with a different building society 4 months in advance, which should kick in after the last mortgage. Even then, it's going up by £300 a month.

We were stress tested for our mortgage like everyone else, but we're basically one redundancy away from disaster.

Solonge · 30/10/2022 21:44

Inasec24 · 29/10/2022 09:27

Thinking about us, we would prioritise our house over pretty much anything except basic food and basic utilities. I imagine most people are the same. So it'll have a big impact on the economy as people won't be able to spend money as itll all go on their house, even if they rent it'll be the same story as renters basically pay their landlord's mortgage in many cases.

Any companies who rely on disposable income will be hit hard, which has a knock on effect of unemployment, prices being forced down, recession basically.

Those who cut back as much as possible and still can't afford their rent or mortgage will loose their homes. I guess in that case they will move to smaller/cheaper accommodation if possible, but logically that can't happen for everyone. So I imagine there will be a bug demand for social housing.

Its basically very bad news for the whole country. In the back of my head I keep thinking there's no way this will be allowed to happen. It's a Conservative government who value economic growth over all else. But in reality, they keep proving me wrong so I think we have a very tough few years ahead.

Wrong.....the Tories believe in hands off government, they will let whatever happens, happen. Remember what Johnson said about business? Fuck Business is what he said....and if you look at this country, you know he meant it.

caringcarer · 30/10/2022 21:38

I had 3 btl up for remortgage. I managed to get a five year fix for 4.10 percent for 5 year fixes about 2 weeks before mini statement. I am worried for my sister who's mortgage is up in April. I rang her to tell her to get a new quote straight away as it would last for 6 months and she could then follow rates and decide whether to take the quote or not and I know she does not watch news or follow politics or finance markets. She left it too late as preoccupied with her dd dancing show and when she tried almost 3 weeks later the rates had jumped to 6.8 percent.

celticprincess · 30/10/2022 21:24

Picking up what others have said, my remortgages have been with the same lender so basically just a product switch. I can’t remember if I was asked my salary but I do know that any other lender would have rejected me as a new borrower. Hoping that come next July I can switch product again without too much issue - other than the inevitable increase in price. My current salary would not get me a new mortgage for half of what I owe. I was massively surprised when I was able to remortgage with my current provider.

celticprincess · 30/10/2022 21:17

When I bought my house 15 years ago the interest rate was 7.5%. I just found the paperwork. There was no stress testing back then. I was fixed for a while then stuck on a variable as my house went into negative equity a month after buying it. House prices dived and I had taken the very last 100% mortgage (they were withdrawn the following day or week if I recall). There were two of us then paying the mortgage - based on my one full time income but that’s a whole different story. Now there’s just me, now working part time, getting tax credits with children added in. I eventually was able to remortgage to 1.99% a few years ago which lightened the load for me. That fixed rate is due to expire in July. Luckily it’s not a huge mortgage now and I have paid off some balance - prices still haven’t got up to what I paid for it!! But my energy has gone from £90 a month to £220 a month (£177 with the rebate monthly for the 6 months) and then it’s due to go up again (projection was around £400) so we are really cutting back on consumption. My income hasn’t gone up since I had kids and went part time. Any slight increase comes off the tax credit payments so catch 22. When youngest starts secondary I might have to go full time. Going full time comes with additional fuel and childcare costs and a decrease/total loss in tax credits and not actually likely to give me much more income.

WaddleAway · 30/10/2022 20:55

Badnewsoracle · 30/10/2022 18:30

No. They've tried. I find it hard to believe that you weren't asked your salary - I've had dozens of mortgages and my salary has been asked every single time.

We weren’t asked salary when we remortgaged either. As I said above, if you’re staying with the same lender and not taking on extra borrowing no further checks are done. This is standard.

YuzuP · 30/10/2022 20:26

runjy · 30/10/2022 19:00

I’m pretty sure this is normal. Unless you are changing banks or borrowing more it isn’t technically ‘remortgaging’ it’s switching product.

Isn't the issue though that your bank isn't always the most competitive so it may be better to switch banks?

Yes - in a perfect situation you would have had pay rises and be in a good position to take the pick of the bunch in terms of across the board mortgage products. But - if, like me, you earn about 30% of what you did before, and may fail affordability checks run by a new lender, you can get a fix with your current lender without having to disclose your new circs. I fixed at 1.3% for 5 years. someone richer than me could have got 1.1 but I’m ok with that!

Swipe left for the next trending thread