Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get the hype around the average UK Christmas market?

108 replies

Xenapo · 29/10/2022 06:54

So I'm not a scrooge and enjoy a family Christmas, although I do think the whole thing is ridiculously commercialised.

But I've been to the Manchester Christmas market a few times over the years and just don't get the hype.

It's very crowded, overpriced, lots of stores selling very similar things, never anywhere to sit and a lot of the stuff sold there just seems like pointless tat. A friend would suggest going then we'd spend ages queuing to pay extortionate prices for small bit of novelty food to eat standing up in the cold. Could never see the appeal myself and probably won't go this year.

I know there's other markets out there so maybe some are better examples in the UK that are worth a visit.

I imagine some of the original German ones must be quite spectacular and have a lot of interesting history behind them as they started them there many hundreds of years ago.

I looked up when most of the UK ones started and looks like 90s and 00s (they didn't have them when I was little) so I guess we've tried to import it here to different UK cities with varying degrees of success.

OP posts:
GnomeDePlume · 29/10/2022 09:11

WhosafraidofVirginiaWoolf · 29/10/2022 08:42

My favourite is my DS's SEN school Christmas Market and it starts the holidays off for me every year.

They are a registered charity so the funds are all ploughed back into the school (currently raising for an upgrade to the sensory playground)

Loads of stalls with all items made by the kids themselves as well as raffles, tombola's etc.

Santa is there as well as real reindeer and the £3 entry fee includes a hot turkey bap with stuffing and cranberry sauce and a drink - absolute bargain!

It's perfect if your DC's have additional needs as it is all totally geared towards that, including the santa visit, you will feel completely at home, rather than at a regular NT event

It's on the 1st of Dec this year so if anyone wants the details - we are in Cheshire, just PM me.

This sounds wonderful.

jay55 · 29/10/2022 09:08

I used to work in Bath and I dreaded Christmas market time. So crowded and smelly. Some interesting stands but majority awful overpriced tat.

BringMeTea · 29/10/2022 08:59

Agree. Overpriced tat and confection.So disappointing.

Umbrellabee · 29/10/2022 08:56

I agree. I’ve only been to the Manchester one but it is far too busy. You have to queue for ages for anything and you can’t walk anywhere as it is so crowded. I’ve been a few times but not in years as it’s just hard work.

notdaddycool · 29/10/2022 08:50

Whilst you can buy half the stuff on Ali Express for under half the price I’ll enjoy them for what they are. Maybe pick up something but mainly feel a bit Christmassy and get a mulled wine for us and a hot chocolate for the kids, maybe a not berry German bratwurst too. Defiantly not going with the intention of doing my Christmas shopping. If we don’t get round to going then fine.

blippi123 · 29/10/2022 08:48

Ten years ago my local town used to close the town centre to traffic and have a Christmas market on every Sunday. It was really good, 50-60 stalls

Gradually over time I noticed that the stalls were less and less to do with Christmas and it just turned into a market, nearly every stall was selling old tat

It will be on this year but we don't bother anymore

Londonnight · 29/10/2022 08:42

The first Christmas market I ever went to was in Germany. It was amazing and I loved it. This was around 1994. I have never found the UK ones any good. They are all mostly tat and very overpriced.

I am off to Chatesworth Christmas market in a couple of weeks and hoping for it to be better. Chatesworth is only ever November and finishes 23 November for some reason.

WhosafraidofVirginiaWoolf · 29/10/2022 08:42

My favourite is my DS's SEN school Christmas Market and it starts the holidays off for me every year.

They are a registered charity so the funds are all ploughed back into the school (currently raising for an upgrade to the sensory playground)

Loads of stalls with all items made by the kids themselves as well as raffles, tombola's etc.

Santa is there as well as real reindeer and the £3 entry fee includes a hot turkey bap with stuffing and cranberry sauce and a drink - absolute bargain!

It's perfect if your DC's have additional needs as it is all totally geared towards that, including the santa visit, you will feel completely at home, rather than at a regular NT event

It's on the 1st of Dec this year so if anyone wants the details - we are in Cheshire, just PM me.

Kolarbri · 29/10/2022 08:39

Uk ones are shite! Go to Germany or Belgium for a much better experience!

Scepticalwotsits · 29/10/2022 08:33

agree most are over hyped, last one I really enjoyed was the Lincoln one a few years prior to covid. Was only on over a long weekend rather than the month long Birmingham one, had Victorian carollers, events happening making it feel very festive , walking down steep hill and having people out the front of their homes roasting chestnuts and home made mulled wine was quite nice. Plus it’s in a beautiful place around the cathedral, bail castle and arboretum area

that said none of them have anything on the Germany markets Berlin is just another thing but even smaller ones like in Ulm were fantastic

Philandbill · 29/10/2022 08:26

The Christmas markets I have been to in the UK have generally been awful, I don't go any more. I used to live in Germany and the Christmas markets there are magical.

Hoppinggreen · 29/10/2022 08:19

The UK ones are generally awful.
We try and go to Germany instead

Largethighsbadeyes · 29/10/2022 08:18

The Chatsworth one is good. Lovely setting, feels very Christmassy. The stalls tend to be the same every year though so after a few years it becomes a bit pointless which is a shame.

We are doing the Haddon Hall one this year. more of an Artisan Market and its inside the hall rather than outside like Chatsworth.

I haven't done a city one like Manchester or Birmingham but I'm not really a city person

JPduck · 29/10/2022 08:18

Having lived in Germany, the uk Xmas markets are nothing in comparison and I won't revisit. German markets are well worth it

Floydthedemonbarber · 29/10/2022 08:17

Twenty years ago the Birmingham one was great. Busy, but enjoyable. Then it expanded and is just the same few stalls over and over again with the same overpriced food.

Good to know about Leamington though, might be worth a visit.

Riverlee · 29/10/2022 08:15

Scout troop.

TheDogsMother · 29/10/2022 08:15

I loved the Winchester one last year. They seem to curate the stalls well so you don't see the same things over and over. It's a beautiful setting and loads of lovely gift ideas.

Riverlee · 29/10/2022 08:15

I agree. Too busy and not much worth seeing, although I still have a lovely wooden moose keyring I brought from a German stall on the Southbank Christmas stall a few years ago, which I use everyday.

A local village dies a Christmas fayre/market which is lovely - carols in the church, stalls run by local organisations etc. lovely atmosphere. You don’t mind paying inflated prices if the money goes to your local scout shop.

ohforthelife · 29/10/2022 08:14

Agree. They used to be good but now they're largely the same mass produced expensive tat.

They have a Victorian Christmas market in Worcester just over one weekend that's good, but it gets very busy. It has more independent stalls selling gifts and food, and street entertainers.

Toddlerteaplease · 29/10/2022 08:10

We used to have a lovely German market. Gluhwine, bratwurst etc. the council changed itVs it's just crap now.

Okbye · 29/10/2022 08:09

The Birmingham Christmas Market on a Saturday in December is fucking hell on earth!
Been dragged there a few times and have vowed to never go again!

It gets busier and more crowded every year and the stalls are mostly selling tat anyway and everything's SO overpriced.

00100001 · 29/10/2022 08:06

mondaytosunday · 29/10/2022 07:42

Any opinions on the Winchester one?
I think the better Christmas markets are the curated ones, where they encourage individual makers to have stalls. This does mean they are expensive, but it's not tat from China or Taiwan but made in the UK by crafters. Some people don't want to pay for that though.

Quite.

They'd rather pay £8 for a generic Chinese import made by a 9 year old with polyester yarn, than £30 for one locally made with wool from the UK.

Heatherbell1978 · 29/10/2022 08:06

I'm in Edinburgh and have to say I like them here but not on a Saturday afternoon in mild weather! The crowding can be horrendous so the key really is to go at a quieter time. I don't really buy anything as it's so over-priced, but nice for a wander and maybe a mulled wine.

cluecu · 29/10/2022 08:06

I live in Manchester & will try to visit the markets once with DH. However we go quite early on for just a drink and a hot dog if hungry. We'll have a look at the stalls on King St and St Ann's Square but then leave it. We make as part of a Christmas shopping morning then pubs/market/restaurant for the afternoon 💃

They are repetitive & expensive which is why we don't spend much time on them but the two areas I mentioned are a bit more pleasant in the early afternoon.

I do miss the Father Christmas on the town hall though!

CrapBucket · 29/10/2022 08:05

I've been to a few different cities and they are all the same formula. The idea of a Christmas Market is always better than the reality... maybe that's a good thing to prepare for the same on Christmas Day itself!!!