Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed at my friend being overly generous?

139 replies

Fantasticfourty · 28/10/2022 15:48

My ds (10) started guitar lessons at school but after first four weeks needed to supply his own guitar, we planned to get him one for Xmas so I asked in my friends group chat if anyone had one we could borrow for a couple of months, one of my friends immediately said yes and dropped it off that night.
the next few weeks after the instructor had visited school my son would come out and say his tutor had said what a great guitar he had, was it his mum or dads etc, I assumed he was just being nice and encouraging, we were at parents evening last night and the note from the tutor (who wasn’t there) said my son was progressing extremely quickly and had he been getting extra lessons from the owner of the “fantastic guitar” my husband and I (and the class teacher) were all a bit puzzled and we moved on.
this morning I googled the guitar and it’s worth £12,000! It’s in a soft case (not a hard one) my friend brought it in and I’ve been putting it in the boot with shopping and bags etc all rattling around! I’m mortified! I’d never have let my son take it, he has dyspraxia and can be clumsy (as can I!) I’m actually annoyed she didn’t tell me! I’m having a panic attack thinking about it in the boot with tins of soup rolling around on way home from school etc my husband thinks it’s funny, my friend is well off but has kids of her own so knows what they can be like! Aibu to be annoyed at her for not telling me the value?

OP posts:
SteakExpectations · 28/10/2022 20:06

I’ve had a very similar experience and DS is very chuffed that he’s been trusted with such an instrument and enjoyed that his music teacher was impressed with it.

We had a chat about the value of it and that he has to really take care of it, and so far we’ve had no problems.

My friend is also incredibly generous, and I wouldn’t be surprised if we are told to keep the guitar in the end.

Skatewing · 28/10/2022 20:04

I think you are the one that needs to read my post! I didn’t fling it around and have nowhere said I did! I put it in the car boot with my shopping and my shopping rolled about the boot, I have 4 kids in the car on the way to school so literally nowhere else to put it !

Is that really what you took from my reply?

To respond to that - I apologise and concede that as you didn't fling it then that is incorrect on my part.
It doesn't avoid that you have a duty of care to look after loaned property irrespective of the value and that includes taking reasonable steps to ensure it is secure from things rolling around your boot that could cause damage.

I stand by my reply in regards to doing a bit of self analysis.
Your friend sounds lovely and has helped you immensely, yet you are annoyed.

It is such a strange reaction that I wonder whether the post was intended to be inflammatory.

Blossomtoes · 28/10/2022 20:01

So you’re rude and ungrateful and have now lied to your friend. You really don’t deserve her, she should have better friends.

Derbee · 28/10/2022 19:56

So you messaged your friend, but now she’s with you, reading the replies.

Your son was using the guitar for weeks, but now the school isn’t happy with him using it as it’s too valuable?

ok.

RedHelenB · 28/10/2022 19:56

I'm honk yabu. You should be careful with anything you borrow, regardless of how much it's worth.

BeaLola · 28/10/2022 19:55

How lovely that your friend & her DH lent it long term to your son - great that you have genuinely lovely friends who care about your DS and having a guitar to play on - when he's famous he can give them front row tickets to his concerts

Fantasticfourty · 28/10/2022 19:53

I’m reading these with my friend now! She has apologised for not giving me the heads up and I’ve apologised for letting my kidney beans and chopped tomato roll next to it! I’ve said that school will not be happy with it being left in the hall with all the other instruments (they won’t) so they are lending me a less expensive one, they are a very lovely generous thoughtful couple but an expensive guitar left around a load of running around kids is a potential disaster!

OP posts:
Pompom1919 · 28/10/2022 19:51

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines, as we have suspicions about this user.

Fantasticfourty · 28/10/2022 19:50

Skatewing · 28/10/2022 17:25

Unbelievable!

A kind friend lending something very nice for your child to gain a valuable skill and you fling it around, look up the value and decide your friend has wronged you for lending it as it has a high price tag.

Please OP, do read your post and also try to become more self aware.

I think you are the one that needs to read my post! I didn’t fling it around and have nowhere said I did! I put it in the car boot with my shopping and my shopping rolled about the boot, I have 4 kids in the car on the way to school so literally nowhere else to put it !

OP posts:
Fantasticfourty · 28/10/2022 19:48

RuLu · 28/10/2022 19:22

What make is the guitar?

It’s a Martin

OP posts:
surreygirl1987 · 28/10/2022 19:41

Your friend sounds lovely and you sound a bit ungrateful!

RuLu · 28/10/2022 19:22

What make is the guitar?

SushiSarah · 28/10/2022 19:14

I imagine once you’d gotten over the initial surprise at the value, the real issue you’re put out is that you feel that the shine has been taken off your Christmas present to your son isn’t it? Don’t ruin a kind gesture and the chance for your son to practise using something pretty amazing over this. He can have the best of both if you let him.

Cw112 · 28/10/2022 19:01

In fairness I kind of think if she'd lent you anything no matter the value you'd look after it in the same way because its hers and that's the respectful thing to do. She doesn't seem to mind so I think you're over thinking it. If you're that uncomfortable then give it back and see if you can rent one until Christmas.

Littlewhitecat · 28/10/2022 18:51

You need to get it insured as it won't be covered on your house insurance and I doubt your friends insurance will cover lending it out. If you really don't want to keep it I'd use the cost of insurance as a reason to return it. Really lovely thing for your friends to do not I would double check how they would proceed if it got broken or pinched.

girlmom21 · 28/10/2022 18:42

I'm with everyone else. Be more respectful of your friends belongings and more grateful of her generosity.

Georgieporgie29 · 28/10/2022 18:38

Like others I find it bizarre that you would just have it in the boot with tins of soup bashing into it no matter what the value is. I wouldn’t do that with my sons guitar that I have paid for never mind one that he had borrowed

NoNever · 28/10/2022 18:30

If the guitar was only worth 500 would it be okay to risk damaging it by having soup cans rolling all over it?

Your friend lent you a guitar after you asked for one. You should take good care of it regardless of value.

If it bothers you, return it to her.

OldFan · 28/10/2022 18:16

Sell it for £12k and say you "lost" it

@RambamThankyouMam Eh?

@Fantasticfourty Just give it your friend back and say you didn't realize how expensive it was and you can't risk it getting damaged as you and DS tend to be clumsy.

ladydimitrescu · 28/10/2022 18:11

You needed to borrow a guitar - they lent it to you and dropped it round immediately.
You've been chucking it in the boot and only care now you know the value - why weren't you looking after it the entire time?
Your friend sounds wonderful, generous and lovely.
You - who needed a favour, and is now slagging her off on the internet for doing something nice, do not sound lovely.

pigsDOfly · 28/10/2022 18:03

So someone does a nice thing for your son, you then find out it isn't the type of guitar you thought is was and you're 'annoyed'?

Rather a strange reaction.

I'd be bloody furious if I lent someone a guitar, of what ever value, and they just slung it into the boot of their car with tins of soup banging up against it and potentially damaging it.

Isn't it usual to take care of something that belongs to someone else that they've been kind enough to lend you, whether it's worth £12,000 or it came from Argos.

TabithaTittlemouse · 28/10/2022 18:02

Yabu for treating an instrument (especially a borrowed one) so badly regardless of price. Teach your child to take care of his guitar when he gets his.

daisy46 · 28/10/2022 17:59

Fantasticfourty · 28/10/2022 16:08

She’s messaged straight back saying her husband has a lot of guitars, a laughing emoji and that one isn’t worth quite as much as I thought (9k v 12k) and they are just glad someone is using it cause it hangs on his office wall, she said she’s told him to sell some lots and he won’t, she’s insisting it’s fine for my son to use it and will bring me a hard case “so I feel better” that £99 Argos guitar Santa is bringing will be some let down for him! Im still annoyed! What if I’d broken it? I think we will just return it for now! It’s too much responsibility for my son (and me ;))

music people love music and instruments and it probably makes her husband happy it's getting used by another musician. What a kind friend.

emptythelitterbox · 28/10/2022 17:57

Just keep it and let your child enjoy it.

Whether it cost 99 or 99000 the instrument still needs to be cared for and not chucked around.

Cantstandbullshit · 28/10/2022 17:57

Fantasticfourty · 28/10/2022 16:08

She’s messaged straight back saying her husband has a lot of guitars, a laughing emoji and that one isn’t worth quite as much as I thought (9k v 12k) and they are just glad someone is using it cause it hangs on his office wall, she said she’s told him to sell some lots and he won’t, she’s insisting it’s fine for my son to use it and will bring me a hard case “so I feel better” that £99 Argos guitar Santa is bringing will be some let down for him! Im still annoyed! What if I’d broken it? I think we will just return it for now! It’s too much responsibility for my son (and me ;))

So you mentioned it to her and she confirmed she is happy for your son to use it and also said she will bring a hard case, and now you know the value you can be a little bit more careful but you’re still so angry you have to bring it to mumsnet. What do you want us to tell you? That your friend is unreasonable and you are right to be angry?

Take care of it and try to buy your son a cheaper guitar soon so you can return it and have peace.

Swipe left for the next trending thread