Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Taking 10yo out of school swimming lessons

109 replies

Pho11me · 28/10/2022 15:36

Hi all,

I don't want my 10yo DD to take part in school swimming lessons, however the school are insisting she should do it. Due to moving school she's not had lessons before and when we tried to teach her younger she gained a phobia for being in the water so we stopped.

The reason we don't want her to take part is she talked about how embarrassed she'll be as the only child wearing swim armbands in the school lessons. We've said to school we'll take her swimming independently for her to learn as I'm aware how important a life skill it is, but she and I don't want that embarrassment on front of her peers.

So should I be allowing school to take her to the swimming lessons, knowing that she'll be the only one in armbands and as she'll not get individual attention she'll have they'll for numerous lessons, or should I double down and insist she doesn't take part?

OP posts:
Matilda1981 · 28/10/2022 16:06

She will not be the only beginner and she will be in the shallow end so that she can touch the floor.
Swimming is a life skill and is part of the curriculum so she should be going.

Pho11me · 28/10/2022 16:05

Jellybean23 · 28/10/2022 16:03

It's a pity you tried to teach her yourself and she gained a phobia. Let her attend the school lessons and get feedback from the teacher after two or three. She's probably going to try harder for the teacher and less likely to turn on the waterworks. If the school lessons don't work, put her down for some at the local pool. There's probably a waiting list. It's a life skill she needs to learn so don't let a little thing like embarrassment over armbands get in the way. If you make a big fuss over it, so will she. Tough it out.

I think we'll make no deal about it, and try to ask the school if they'll definitely be using them in the lessons, or if they're there for safety with a swim teacher absence

OP posts:
drspouse · 28/10/2022 16:04

Did they have swimming lessons in Autumn of Y2? Because the rest of that year was in lockdown. And many of them won't have had any lessons since then so will have slipped back.
I'm really surprised they want you to provide arm bands - as others have said these are not recommended for lessons.

OhMaria2 · 28/10/2022 16:04

Also as some one who was truly terrible at swimming as a child, what got me swimming well was goggles. Once I was able to swim without out getting water in my eyes and i could put my face underwater with my eyes open, it sort of came naturally. Give them a try.
Arm bands aren't helping your daughter learn any swim skills

And if its any help, as an adult I can swim, but I've never ever gone on a flume that terminates in deep water. Nor will I swim in the sea past about hip level.
Being incredibly nervous isn't a barrier to enjoying swimming so try not to stress.

Jellybean23 · 28/10/2022 16:03

It's a pity you tried to teach her yourself and she gained a phobia. Let her attend the school lessons and get feedback from the teacher after two or three. She's probably going to try harder for the teacher and less likely to turn on the waterworks. If the school lessons don't work, put her down for some at the local pool. There's probably a waiting list. It's a life skill she needs to learn so don't let a little thing like embarrassment over armbands get in the way. If you make a big fuss over it, so will she. Tough it out.

Pho11me · 28/10/2022 16:03

Whinge · 28/10/2022 15:58

We've said to school we'll take her swimming independently for her to learn as I'm aware how important a life skill it is

OP if you think it's such an important skill why haven't you taken her to swimming lessons before now? She's 10, you can't blame missing school lessons in year 2, when you've had a decade to teach her.

Let her do the school lessons, she won't be the only beginner and at least this way she's getting some exposure to swimming.

We did try, I'm aware we should have doubled down sooner, but she developed such a fear of being submerged when she went to lessons age 5 and another kid in the lesson dunked her, nothing the teacher could do. We had tears at bathtime let alone swimming, which we've just overcome in time for these lessons. We love swimming so it's been a family experience we've missed out on as well

OP posts:
PurpleWisteria1 · 28/10/2022 16:00

She won’t be wearing arm bands. She will probably use floats but all children will use those at some point to improve their stroke or kicking.
There will be more than 1 child in the beginner group.
She needs to do them. You can always get lessons for her in addition after school to catch her up faster?

Pho11me · 28/10/2022 16:00

waterrat · 28/10/2022 15:57

Take the opportunity for your child OP - with lockdown in between year 2 and 5 many of the kids will be non swimmers.

I would give her a pep talk - nothing to be ashamed of that you are a beginner, I do get it but because of lockdown I think more children than ever have missed out on swimming. My own 8 year old still can't swim so I know how it feels to worry about it.

This is the best possible opportunity for her to get that confidence and learn to swim.

Thank you I think based in comments I've been a bit mistaken in expecting all do be swimming still after 3 years and lockdown. I'll chat to her and let her know that she can do really well, and will supplement schools lessons with our own swimming time

OP posts:
spanieleyes · 28/10/2022 15:59

Ours swim for a term every year from Yr 3 up to year 6, there are still children in Yr 6 who can't swim because they don't go in between school swimming sessions! If they do t practice from one year to the next, it's hardly surprising that they lose the skills taught. This year, we had to split the year 5s into 2 non swimming groups as there were so many of them!

Oblomov22 · 28/10/2022 15:59

YABVVU
She is exactly the child these lessons are for. She can't swim. You should've made sure she could but you haven't. This strategic thing put into place, is to catch those that can't. This is what it is doing.

Whinge · 28/10/2022 15:58

We've said to school we'll take her swimming independently for her to learn as I'm aware how important a life skill it is

OP if you think it's such an important skill why haven't you taken her to swimming lessons before now? She's 10, you can't blame missing school lessons in year 2, when you've had a decade to teach her.

Let her do the school lessons, she won't be the only beginner and at least this way she's getting some exposure to swimming.

WallaceinAnderland · 28/10/2022 15:58

Really unusual to wear arm bands in lessons, I've never seen that.

waterrat · 28/10/2022 15:57

Take the opportunity for your child OP - with lockdown in between year 2 and 5 many of the kids will be non swimmers.

I would give her a pep talk - nothing to be ashamed of that you are a beginner, I do get it but because of lockdown I think more children than ever have missed out on swimming. My own 8 year old still can't swim so I know how it feels to worry about it.

This is the best possible opportunity for her to get that confidence and learn to swim.

Pho11me · 28/10/2022 15:57

Wishyfishy · 28/10/2022 15:54

Wow, I’ve never honestly seen a child in arms bands at a lesson. I thought the general feeling these days was that arm bands don’t help?

I swim a lot and lessons are often being held at the same time so I see quite a number of lessons a week.. Generally teachers use floats and noodles, never arm bands. It’s actually quite good because even when my oldest could swim, he would often still use a float or noodle if the teacher wants to specifically concentrate on legs etc. So a lap or half lap with a noodle concentrating on leg movement, and then some swimming without support. Because of that’s it’s not always that easy to figure out if the child swimming is a complete beginner / non swimmer or a child that can somewhat swim independently but sometimes uses a noodle in lessons.

I would give the lessons a go if possible.

We've said to school we'll take her swimming independently for her to learn Just take her swimming or enrol her in lessons?

Ah this is useful to know, the school has requested they bring them, I wonder if it is a safety thing should the teacher ratio dip due to them maybe having covid, to have larger teacher pupil groups, I'll ask the school if she'll definitely be using them, but the letter did sound like they would

OP posts:
CecilyP · 28/10/2022 15:55

I doubt if all the year 2's got it or have been practising ever since. Is she really the only DC who has joined the school after year 2? The armband thing seems odd regarding DC that age!

Pho11me · 28/10/2022 15:55

Notonthestairs · 28/10/2022 15:53

"the way the organise it is they've had lessons in year 2 and then have more advanced lessons in year 5."

I would imagine there will be children in the class that haven't had the opportunity to swim between Yr 2 & Yr 5.

That's a good point and one I hadn't considered thank you, I think I'll be open with the school

OP posts:
Wishyfishy · 28/10/2022 15:54

Wow, I’ve never honestly seen a child in arms bands at a lesson. I thought the general feeling these days was that arm bands don’t help?

I swim a lot and lessons are often being held at the same time so I see quite a number of lessons a week.. Generally teachers use floats and noodles, never arm bands. It’s actually quite good because even when my oldest could swim, he would often still use a float or noodle if the teacher wants to specifically concentrate on legs etc. So a lap or half lap with a noodle concentrating on leg movement, and then some swimming without support. Because of that’s it’s not always that easy to figure out if the child swimming is a complete beginner / non swimmer or a child that can somewhat swim independently but sometimes uses a noodle in lessons.

I would give the lessons a go if possible.

We've said to school we'll take her swimming independently for her to learn Just take her swimming or enrol her in lessons?

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 28/10/2022 15:54

Due to moving school she's not had lessons before and when we tried to teach her younger she gained a phobia for being in the water so we stopped

It's not the schools job, its your job. Swimming is a crucial skill, and you've done her a real disservice here in not sorting the phobia thing out.

What age was she when you tried to take her swimming?

Pho11me · 28/10/2022 15:54

CecilyP · 28/10/2022 15:51

So should I be allowing school to take her to the swimming lessons, knowing that she'll be the only one in armbands and as she'll not get individual attention she'll have they'll for numerous lessons, or should I double down and insist she doesn't take part?

How could you possibly know this? While loads of kids, especially on mumsnet, have had multiple swimming lessons from about age 4, there will be others who have never been swimming before and those who have just been for a fun splash around the pool.

I based this on the fact a lot had already had swim lessons in year 2 , but I don't know how advanced they got so there may be more who can't, I'll be open with the school

OP posts:
OhMaria2 · 28/10/2022 15:53

The basic skills are what she'll be taught and there will be different groups at different levels. When I was in year 6 I was in the can't swim a width, or swim underwater shallow end group, my friend was in the diving to the bottom of the deep end look at me diving like dolphin group at the other end
And there were many groups in between

Notonthestairs · 28/10/2022 15:53

"the way the organise it is they've had lessons in year 2 and then have more advanced lessons in year 5."

I would imagine there will be children in the class that haven't had the opportunity to swim between Yr 2 & Yr 5.

PotteringAlonggotkickedoutandhadtoreregister · 28/10/2022 15:52

my children's school do the same with swimming lessons - learn the basics in year 2 and more advanced lessons in year 5.

talk to the school, be honest about what they can expect so they know that she has no swimming at all but let her go. If nothing else, my 10 year old is now at the stage where he’s being invited to go swimming with his friends at the weekend and you want that to be an option in the future for her.

DullAndOvercast · 28/10/2022 15:52

Depends on the school but when we moved her due to logistics - we don't drive- location and poor council lessons (left DD1 very nervous of water) - my kids couldn't swim when we got here.

Luckily there were great lessons here and we signed up but it wasn't very long before eldest had school swimming she was worried sick she'd be at bottom she wasn't - many had never had any lessons before.

At the council run lessons our children made rapid progress - they were very good lesson and did few intensive school holiday courses as well.

I'd suggest letting her do the school lessons - it often prompted some additional interest and unless the school is one that does many lessons ie more than bare minimum there be a fair few who can't swim.

Ylvamoon · 28/10/2022 15:52

She won't be the only one in the beginners group.

I'd say she should go it's a life skill and could just save her life one day.

CecilyP · 28/10/2022 15:51

So should I be allowing school to take her to the swimming lessons, knowing that she'll be the only one in armbands and as she'll not get individual attention she'll have they'll for numerous lessons, or should I double down and insist she doesn't take part?

How could you possibly know this? While loads of kids, especially on mumsnet, have had multiple swimming lessons from about age 4, there will be others who have never been swimming before and those who have just been for a fun splash around the pool.