Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Taking 10yo out of school swimming lessons

109 replies

Pho11me · 28/10/2022 15:36

Hi all,

I don't want my 10yo DD to take part in school swimming lessons, however the school are insisting she should do it. Due to moving school she's not had lessons before and when we tried to teach her younger she gained a phobia for being in the water so we stopped.

The reason we don't want her to take part is she talked about how embarrassed she'll be as the only child wearing swim armbands in the school lessons. We've said to school we'll take her swimming independently for her to learn as I'm aware how important a life skill it is, but she and I don't want that embarrassment on front of her peers.

So should I be allowing school to take her to the swimming lessons, knowing that she'll be the only one in armbands and as she'll not get individual attention she'll have they'll for numerous lessons, or should I double down and insist she doesn't take part?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
user29 · 28/10/2022 21:21

It is very unusual for a 10 year old not to be able to swim.

Vgbeat · 28/10/2022 21:17

It is part of the national curriculum that children should be able to swim before leaving primary school. When I went last time there were a few who couldn't swim and by the end they were all able to.

Unseelie · 28/10/2022 20:40

Oblomov22 · 28/10/2022 15:59

YABVVU
She is exactly the child these lessons are for. She can't swim. You should've made sure she could but you haven't. This strategic thing put into place, is to catch those that can't. This is what it is doing.

This.

Sorry OP but if you were going to get her taught outside school, she’d already be a swimmer. She’s ten.

notmyrealmoniker · 28/10/2022 20:25

Send her. She won't be wearing arm bands as she'll stay down the shallow end. Being with her peers she will just follow the crowd and get on with it. Only consider taking her out if a genuine phobia develops. Pandering to her now just increases her anxieties

Barbie222 · 28/10/2022 20:09

Like pps have said it's not something you can withdraw from if you're school educating.

Jumpinjackkflash · 28/10/2022 20:07

We had a similar scenario this year with Bikeability at school. Our DD9 really didn't like learning to ride a bike and would get quite distressed so we didn't force it. Then came the problem of the bike lessons on road safety they do at school. On the day there were 5 of them that couldn't ride a bike. The Bikeability people were amazing. Got 4 of them out of the 5 riding bikes within an hour. She's asked for a bike for Christmas and riding an old second hand one in the meantime to keep her confidence. Put your trust in these people she will not be the only beginner

Pho11me · 28/10/2022 20:07

Treaclemine · 28/10/2022 19:25

Armbands on small children get the arms too high in the water, so difficult to get a good stroke downwards - perhaps in the high school that wouldn't be a problem. They would also exacerbate the legs going down.
Our pool had a bunch of aids which helped - there were small floaty flying saucers which the children could move along by blowing them. That could be done in the pools where there is no really shallow water, and the children have their feet down.
Being in groups opened up some other possibilities, but one thing could be done with mum in the deeper water. Mum crouches down so her shoulders are level with the water. Child puts hands on mum's shoulders and swims with their legs. Mum can put her hands under the stomach for extra support, and walks backwards as the child pushes her.

DH is taking her tomorrow and he might just put her in the pool without armbands and just keep hold of her at all times, this would be a big step for her as we've barely moved off the sides, so not sure she'll get that far before the lessons

OP posts:
LindseyHoyleSpeaks · 28/10/2022 19:47

You can’t opt out. It’s a national curriculum requirement (those in year 6/leaving primary have to be able
to swim at least a length). You should have done an intensive course this half term. That’s what most people round here have done given the mess Covid left everyone in. There are very few who now can’t swim at all.

Treaclemine · 28/10/2022 19:25

Armbands on small children get the arms too high in the water, so difficult to get a good stroke downwards - perhaps in the high school that wouldn't be a problem. They would also exacerbate the legs going down.
Our pool had a bunch of aids which helped - there were small floaty flying saucers which the children could move along by blowing them. That could be done in the pools where there is no really shallow water, and the children have their feet down.
Being in groups opened up some other possibilities, but one thing could be done with mum in the deeper water. Mum crouches down so her shoulders are level with the water. Child puts hands on mum's shoulders and swims with their legs. Mum can put her hands under the stomach for extra support, and walks backwards as the child pushes her.

mamaduckbone · 28/10/2022 19:21

When we take the children for swimming lessons from school there are always several beginners. They don't wear armbands - they stay in the shallow end and use floats / woggles to build their confidence. It is a life skill and also part of the school curriculum (all children should be able to swim 25m before they leave primary school and the school have to report this data).
Also, what is she going to do whilst the others go swimming. Far more embarrassing to have to stay at school, potentially in a different class.
You really need to let her go, and start taking her yourself ASAP.

powershowerforanhour · 28/10/2022 18:37

"Also it’s really difficult to find availability for private swimming lessons at the moment."

This would be a big factor for me- I suppose it depends where you live but as covid restrictions were easing I innocently asked at the local leisure and the lady struggled to suppress a world weary snort. Lessons booked solid. Massive covid backlog. No waiting list maintained as no point in the hassle- batches of courses get released occasionally and sell out in minutes, if not seconds (children or adults, beginners and the more advanced levels). I think people who had already been on a course got priority and after that it was a free for all. Next nearest public pool is 3/4 hr away- same story there. Lack of pool space for the population (in a land locked county) and lack of swimming teachers.

If DD was offered a guaranteed place free (or even paid for), during school hours, I would bite both your hands off for it.

ancientgran · 28/10/2022 18:11

WallaceinAnderland · 28/10/2022 18:10

As the Amateur Swimming Association rightly points out: "Swimming is the only subject on the national curriculum that can save your life."

Reading can be pretty useful, safety directions, medication dosage. I reckon reading could save your life.

WallaceinAnderland · 28/10/2022 18:10

As the Amateur Swimming Association rightly points out: "Swimming is the only subject on the national curriculum that can save your life."

RiftGibbon · 28/10/2022 17:55

I can't swim.
I grew up in inner London well away from waterways and we couldn't afford swimming lessons.
My primary tried to teach us, in the last year of school. This was in the 1970s when the way it was done was to have someone stand at the side of the pool and shout at us. As I was a timid little mouse and scared of all manner of things this didn't help.

I've tried to learn to swim many times since but I hate it. I hate being in the water, it hurts my eyes and sometimes my skin. The smell of chlorine makes me feel as though I can't breathe.
I have no interest in going on a cruise/in a canoe/on a boat or any water based activity. Husband and DC are good swimmers, so it's just me.

Meadowbreeze · 28/10/2022 17:54

DD was similar in that she was petrified of water as a child. Bathtime was a pain and we signed her up to lessons age 5. They ended up moving her to the toddler sessions and she would still cling onto the stairs and scream. We decided to pause after 5 weeks of this and returned when she was 7. She was veeeery slow to take up. No coordination. Lots of crash courses and swimming on holiday. She stopped due to lockdown. In Feb she really wanted to go back but she tested as a stage 5. She was by far the oldest (13), worked super hard and ended up going up 4 stages in 5 months and is now doing club swimming.
Lots and lots of encouragement and patience. I wouldnt let her not go with school, it's a great way for her to just get on with it. They learn much more without you there.

Avidreader69 · 28/10/2022 17:47

One of my children hated swimming lessons so I gave the school (private) an ultimatum. Either she stopped swimming lessons or I took both children out of the school. She stopped swimming lessons.
My reasons:

  1. Swimming in a heated pool is completely different from swimming in a cold sea.
  2. The likelihood of the child falling into a river or getting into difficulty at sea is practically zero. Yes, children drown in rivers but if they are non swimmers, they shouldn't go in.
  3. Swimming isn't needed to find a job.
  4. There are lots of other sports that are more enjoyable.
Catsforeverinlove · 28/10/2022 17:39

My daughter is 11 and can’t swim after multiple attempts to teach her.
I can’t swim so I could not ever take her.
She started learning when she was 8 in crash holiday course, this was not great as she hated it and even she was with so called beginners, they all could swim.
Then she had school lessons in Y4 which went ok as she liked it with her peers and evening private 1to1 lessons every Friday - however this all got to halt when pandemic came in mArch 2020.
She had no lessons until this January, she has private lessons at £24 each weekly however it’s not good. She hates it and not progressing really.
It cost is so much money now, Howewer she just hates it and won’t even go into water proper.

Saz12 · 28/10/2022 17:33

There’ll be loads of things different children in her class can’t do. EG play chess, play a musical instrument, draw or paint a recognisable person, put a load of washing on, read @difficult” books, accurate long division, do a cartwheel, name famous artists, recognise any classical music, do a wheelie on a bike, etc etc.

She’s no more reason to be embarrassed about not being able to swim than little Johnnie has about being dyslexic, or Mary for being tone deaf, or whatever.

TheNoodlesIncident · 28/10/2022 17:32

If it suggests the armbands are optional then don't bother. In all the swimming lessons I've seen (DS is in a swim club now) they NEVER use them. I'm glad to see you're planning to do the exercises suggested to improve your dd's water confidence, that will help her a lot. She really needs to be comfortable with getting her face wet/splashed, then in the water, so building up to this at a rate she's comfortable with will be so helpful to her. She might enjoy it more there with her friends too.

And she really won't be the only beginner (or child with fearful responses). Our swim teacher told us that every year when the school classes come in, there's always roughly a third of the Year 3 kids (so 7/8yo) who've never been to a swimming pool before, never mind unable to swim. Every year. There will be a mix of reasons for that including poverty, but I was amazed that the figure was so high.

CrazySchoolTimes · 28/10/2022 17:32

hell would freeze over before I let a non swimmer into a school swim lesson. A girl drowned local to me last year as the the teachers put her in the deep pool with the others.

Pho11me · 28/10/2022 17:25

Calmdown14 · 28/10/2022 17:20

Just reassure her that everyone starts where she is. There are bound to be kids that could swim but have lost all their confidence.

My son was almost swimming but nervy when lock down happened, by the time we got him in a pool again he couldn't even get into a swimming position!

To reassure her, my five year old has never had a single lesson. I got her swimming on holiday last week. Mastered it by day three, jumping in deep end by day five. Before that she was hopeless but it just clicked. She's had far less time in the water but I think will end up better than her big brother.

Can she ride a bike? It's a bit like that. You think you'll never get it then all of a sudden it clicks.

I think the advantage of the different groups and the water is that the other kids will be so busy doing their own thing they won't pay any attention to what's happening else where in the pool.

Your job now is to be up beat about it all and play down any embarrassment factor. If anyone asks she can just say 'i missed the last lessons ' or 'mum doesn't like the water '.

And the lack of a shallow pool is a good thing. It's much harder to swim in shallow water as beginners tend to let their legs sink

Thank you! Yep we'll be super positive about it and can prep excuse reasons not that she'll need them. And yep she loves biking etc so has all the coordination to learn fast

OP posts:
Calmdown14 · 28/10/2022 17:20

Just reassure her that everyone starts where she is. There are bound to be kids that could swim but have lost all their confidence.

My son was almost swimming but nervy when lock down happened, by the time we got him in a pool again he couldn't even get into a swimming position!

To reassure her, my five year old has never had a single lesson. I got her swimming on holiday last week. Mastered it by day three, jumping in deep end by day five. Before that she was hopeless but it just clicked. She's had far less time in the water but I think will end up better than her big brother.

Can she ride a bike? It's a bit like that. You think you'll never get it then all of a sudden it clicks.

I think the advantage of the different groups and the water is that the other kids will be so busy doing their own thing they won't pay any attention to what's happening else where in the pool.

Your job now is to be up beat about it all and play down any embarrassment factor. If anyone asks she can just say 'i missed the last lessons ' or 'mum doesn't like the water '.

And the lack of a shallow pool is a good thing. It's much harder to swim in shallow water as beginners tend to let their legs sink

gertrudemortimer · 28/10/2022 17:16

My son goes to council swimming lessons and they all start with arm rings provided by the leisure centre, I got his from Amazon they're less of a faff than blowing up arm bands and they don't look as babyish either. As they got more confident they remove the rings until they can swim without. The pool doesn't have a child's section and most of the children who start in the first lessons can't touch the floor which is probably why they give them the rings.

Have you checked if your local pool have any intensive beginner courses to sign up to? It's what I did for my ds, 5 30 minute lessons Monday-Friday and once complete they put him straight in to stage 1 swimming so he didn't lose his confidence whilst on the waiting list. He screamed and clung on to the instructor for two lessons it was awful to watch but worth that pain

AmySma1i · 28/10/2022 17:16

She'll love them and even if you've tried being in the water She'll be onto a good start, just make sure you speak positively about it with her whenever it's mentioned

cansu · 28/10/2022 17:16

yes you are being unreasonable as you haven't taken care of this yourself.