Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I overreacting about my sil

194 replies

abi9396 · 28/10/2022 15:25

My sil is starting to really bother me but I don’t know if I’m thinking to much into it. We have a 6 week old son and a 6 year old son. We visited mil and sil last week and sil said to my partner that we need to wean baby a lot earlier this time as we made a mistake last time and didn’t wean our eldest early enough. She said it quite firmly to my partner and acted as if I wasn’t even there. Another day this week we had to leave our eldest withmil and sil happened to be home that day too so after we left i had a message of her asking if she could take that baby out but didn’t want to use his pram she wanted to use her own. She said if you don’t reply within 10 minutes I’m taking it as a yes and taking him out anyway. She keeps saying we’re using the wrong nappies they’re to cheap. Every time we visit mil and sil she avoids giving me the baby if he needs a feed or nappy change at all costs. She’ll talk as if I’m not sat in the same room as them, saying the milk don’t come out of his bottles fast enough, she messaged me the other day to say I could come over and pick a photo of my baby to take home with me if I liked. She messages me all the time demanding a photo of the kids as she’s misses them constantly. Am I thinking to much into this. When my eldest was a baby I remember a comment she made about the baby grows I used to dress him in, she said she was sick of seeing him in the same colours.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BankseyVest · 28/11/2022 10:17

Use it. So when she talks about weaning earlier ask what's her reasoning? Tell her the nhs advice or say you will do so when your baby is ready and no sooner

I agree about the voice, but I'd not go into explaining my reasoning. A simple 'I appreciate that's your opinion sil, however x is my baby and I'll raise him/her as I see fit' then change the subject.

Sceptre86 · 27/11/2022 19:14

She's batshit bit you have a voice. Use it. So when she talks about weaning earlier ask what's her reasoning? Tell her the nhs advice or say you will do so when your baby is ready and no sooner. Do not use them for childcare, pay a babysitter, use a nursery but do not leave your kids there. I'm not sure I'd be too fussed about her changing the odd nappy but if you are you need to be proactive and go get your baby. Anytime she says stuff you disagree with in terms of your child's care shut her down. It will be hard and they will pushback because they aren't used to you answering back but honestly it's now or never. As for your partner, well I'd be asking the idiot why he thinks a woman who had no kids (presumably doesn't work with young children or has healthcare training) would know better in terms of your children's care than you do. I'm all for listening to different viewpoints and taking them on board but it doesn't seem like she presents things like that?

PeachyPeachTrees · 07/11/2022 20:28

"Do not leave her alone with your children. She has disassociated with you being their Mother so she can take control."

Totally agree with this. Listen to your gut OP.

FictionalCharacter · 06/11/2022 14:47

Ialwayssteamveg · 28/10/2022 20:14

That really is a strong red flag that I would take serious notice of.

Yep. Listen to the child.

MinnieGirl · 05/11/2022 23:47

Any update OP?

MustWeDoThis · 05/11/2022 21:21

abi9396 · 28/10/2022 15:34

no she doesn’t have children of her own. She really wants a baby of her own she always has and was trying for a baby with her boyfriend but found out he was living a double life for the 8 years they were together. She lives with mil and has a spare room full of baby stuff. But now wants to use her own pram for my baby

The Hand That Rocks The Cradle, comes to mind.

A room full of baby stuff and no baby of her own? It sounds like she has an unhealthy attachment to your children, she's alluding them almost being her own so she has some kind of influence in a child's life...because she's desperate.

Do not leave her alone with your children. She has disassociated with you being their Mother so she can take control.

Everyflippingusernameistaken · 01/11/2022 11:14

She needs to mind her own business and not try and monopolise the baby, and stop telling you what to do. Tell her to mind her own business. She sounds as if she has mental health problems.

Madamum18 · 31/10/2022 17:57

YANBU. I would be very concerned about her behaviour with your baby...and I would not want to leave my baby with her in the circumstances you describe. I think that she seems to be suffering from mental health problems linked to her not having and desperately wanting a child, and I think she needs counselling.

I think you need further discussion with your husband, with very specific concerns describing her behaviours rather than your concerns per se. He has to see that her behaviour really is not normal Flowers

MissMarple123 · 31/10/2022 09:32

She sounds utterly creepy, as does the mil for enabling it. There's something very wrong about it all in my mind! To actually buy her own pram! Creepy!😱

Pinklemons9 · 30/10/2022 21:11

Electricstar · 28/10/2022 15:47

Just from what you’ve told us it sounds like SIL is struggling with the fact that she does not have her own children and she is almost using your baby like her own. Everything you have said, especially about taking baby out in her own pram makes me think that she wants to pretend or act like your 6 week old is her baby instead.
Her comments about what you should or shouldn’t be doing, are what she would do with her own baby if she had one. I wouldn’t take these comments to heart.

On one hand I feel really sorry for her, I know how hard it has been myself watching others have babies whilst I couldn’t or after my losses. But, I think mentally she sounds unwell and I am not sure if I would be able to trust her too much with my baby because of this.

I agree with this. I personally wouldn’t leave the baby with her or mil whilst she is around. Her behaviour is a little worrying.

PixieLaLa · 30/10/2022 20:13

Tell her to go fuck herself

Plumnora · 30/10/2022 20:00

I agree with everyone else. She’s not well. This, however, isn’t your problem. Your partner needs to grow a pair and stand up to her but ultimately this is a very unhealthy situation and it sounds as though the entire family is dancing to her tune. I would stop letting her take your baby out, however unpopular that makes you, but suggest that your partner finds out about some counselling or support that she could access to help her deal with her heartbreak. Good luck.

snakeitoff · 30/10/2022 17:41

They sound creepy OP!

Avoid going there as much as possible

The crazy lady cant play dolls with your precious child

Sennelier1 · 30/10/2022 16:41

Most def. something very wrong with your SIL. I wouldn't leave my baby with her unsupervised, she might abduct your child or "take him on a holiday" or such.

AcrossthePond55 · 30/10/2022 14:11

Your partner sounds unassertive - surely he can't make you go, if you don't want to?

It can be amazing how many men who are meek and unassertive with their friends and families are mean bastards to their wives and children. What's the saying? "Street angel, house devil"?

KettrickenSmiled · 30/10/2022 12:03

Every one we visit them baby is passed between mil and sil. If he needs a nappy change mil will pass him to sil who then tells me what to get out of his bag. I feel like I just don’t exist when we’re there. My partner is quite happy for them to take over though he says it’s his time off from baby duties when he’s over his mothers house. Every time my baby cries when we are there I go to see to him but mil quickly calls for sil telling her that “your nephew needs you, he’s crying”. My mil agrees with everything sil does

You feel like you don't exist every time you go to MiL's because ... every time you go to MiL's, you act as if you don't.
Why are you allowing them to set the agenda like this?
When MiL calls SiL over because the baby is crying, tell them he needs his mother & that YOU will be the one picking him up. Stop meekly passing his things to SiL when she orders you about, & tell her not to bother as YOU can change your own child's nappy.

I'm not entirely sure why you even bother visiting.
Your partner sounds unassertive - surely he can't make you go, if you don't want to?

KettrickenSmiled · 30/10/2022 11:56

My partner listens to her criticism and advice and then comes back to me and tells me like we should try what she says. But she’s never been a parent

Then your partner is a dick, & you need to deal with HIM, not your SiL.
If your partner had your back, you could present a united front to SiL. Grey Rock her suggestions, not allow her to have the baby unsupervised, let her know that YOU TWO are the parents & sole decision makers.

What have you said to him about his disloyalty & lack of support?

TootsAtOwls · 30/10/2022 11:44

This is very sad but it's not your problem to deal with.

It's incredibly disturbing that your eldest refuses to be on his own with her!

ELLAMAR00 · 30/10/2022 11:21

Why are you letting her do this? she is a bully.

Fairylightsongs · 30/10/2022 11:12

How old is she op and how old are you?

frazzledasarock · 30/10/2022 11:11

Sounds like your partner is lazy and happy to handover his kids to whoever.

start refusing to visit them, he can visit his mother and sister, have plans on days he wants to visit.

don’t reply to SIL’s messages, you’re busy with a baby and young child you’re not going to see every message.

don’t respond or react to your SIL at all.

altho I think you’d have less of a problem if your partner had your back.

MedievalNun · 30/10/2022 11:11

Dear god in heaven. Agree wholeheartedly with the PP who say that (a) your SIL needs counselling as she is obviously having some kind of mental health crisis where she is trying to make your child hers, and (b) you meed to go NC until either your partner backs you up, or she stops.

As for the 'can't leave the house because of oxygen' - as others have said that's bullshit on your MIL's part; my mum's friend is on permanent oxygen and swaps to the travel sized that go in a bag on the back of the wheelchair so she can go shopping / to bingo with her daughter. I would tell your partner that, too.

I do understand that your SIL may be upset by her lack of children; hell I needed help after all my miscarriages while we tried - but I never tried to say that my nephews or godchildren were my own, or tell their parents how to parent!

I am also concerned by the 6-yr old's reaction. You need to find out in a gentle way why this is -my gut feeling is that he's being asked to call aunt 'mum' and being introduced as her son when out. Given that I went nc with my own mother when I found out she was making my dd call her 'mummy' it's not beyond the realms of possibility.

The main thing though is to get your PP to back you up. Definitely get the HV to wade in on your behalf in front of him but it does sound as if he will defer to MIL/SIL instead of you no matter what - and unless that changes, it's a whole other problem.

Good luck, stick to your guns xx

TestingTestingWonTooFree · 30/10/2022 11:06

”why is it SIL that you think you know better than me, his mother, and the whole of the NHS?”

I agree with discussing with the HV when next convenient. Trouble is, if you separate from DH, SIL will be having all his time with the kids.

GabriellaMontez · 30/10/2022 10:45

Either you and your baby never are there again. Ever.

Or you tell SIL in language she will understand to shut up and fuck off. She's not the parent. Her opinion is unwanted and irrelevant.

Oh and you have a DP problem but I suspect it will be easier to deal with them than him.

MinnieGirl · 30/10/2022 10:36

abi9396 · 29/10/2022 22:40

yes she does live with my mil. I’ve spoken to my partner about the way she is it feels like we’re having the exact same conversation that we had years ago when my eldest was a baby. She bought her own pram when my eldest was little and I remember telling my partner I wasn’t happy about this and him making out like I was over reacting. I’ve not long found out that mil and sil tried my baby with a little bit of food before we had started weaning him which I had no idea about. Every one we visit them baby is passed between mil and sil. If he needs a nappy change mil will pass him to sil who then tells me what to get out of his bag. I feel like I just don’t exist when we’re there. My partner is quite happy for them to take over though he says it’s his time off from baby duties when he’s over his mothers house. Every time my baby cries when we are there I go to see to him but mil quickly calls for sil telling her that “your nephew needs you, he’s crying”. My mil agrees with everything sil does. My mil can’t visit us as she’s very over weight without sounding rude and has to have oxygen running constantly so she never leaves the house due to her health so we have to visit her at her home.

So when Mil passes baby to SIL, and she starts telling you what to get out of the changing bag, you just laugh and take the baby off her. By force if you have to. And you say he’s my baby you know not yours. I know that sounds cruel, but you need to stop this right now. Your nephew needs you?! You say no MiL my son needs his mother. Call them out every single time.

As many of us suspected, they both tried to wean your oldest child without your permission and behind your back. And that child will no longer go anywhere near your SiL. That is such a red flag on its own. And MiL is clearly backing looney SiL.

MiL not being able to visit could be a blessing in disguise…. Because if you have to visit you can leave when you choose to. Are they very near to you? How often do you visit now? I would seriously start reducing visits. These two women are seriously nuts. None of their behaviour is normal. Stop leaving either of the children with them. You can simply say that your older child is a bit clingy at the moment and the baby needs his mum. So the taking baby out in her pram won’t happen. Then have a chat with your health visitor. I think it’s important that someone else knows about this crazy behaviour just in case. Tell her about the attempt to wean and the pram etc. I do think SiL needs help, but the priority has to be your children. They are not safe around these two.

And think about showing this thread to your husband. It might help him to see how very disturbing their behaviour is.

You know this isn’t right, or you wouldn’t have started this thread! Trust your gut instincts and protect your children. Personally, I would seriously consider moving away from them.