Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think JKRowling should be in the House of Lords

347 replies

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 28/10/2022 10:58

She is probably the best selling living author writing in English

She has given a great deal of money to charity

She has conquered the disadvantages of being an unemployed single mother by her own efforts

She is a great role model for women and girls

OP posts:
MithrilCostsMore · 29/10/2022 00:31

She is wonderful ❤️❤️❤️

tactum · 29/10/2022 00:29

How long till this gets put in the corner aswell???

Love JKL and EVERYTHING she stands for

JellySaurus · 29/10/2022 00:24

They weren't debating whether a woman must be called a woman. They were debating whether an adult human female could ever be called a father. The ' value' of either designation was not relevant. It was purely about whether mother and father were sex-designated.

AnApparitionQuipped · 29/10/2022 00:17

Over 760 Peers eligible to sit in the HoL. Of them less than 90 are hereditary peers.

But they are there because their peerage was conferred by someone who exists by virtue of hereditary privilege.

AnApparitionQuipped · 29/10/2022 00:15

JellySaurus · 29/10/2022 00:10

It's contradictory. On the one hand, it's saying they can choose the 'label' of woman or not; on the other it's saying they must accept the label of 'mother

It is not saying that they can choose the 'label' of woman or not. It is recognising that some women reject that label, but that this rejection does not change anything. If a woman gives birth she becomes a mother, no matter if she rejects the label 'woman'.

Yes - so the concept of 'mother' is more important than the concept of 'woman' in the eyes of that speaker. It isn't. Motherhood can be socially constructed - you can become a mother without giving birth, through adoption. All he is doing is pigeonholing women into a very traditional role, while saying their biological sex is simply a label.

mycatisannoying · 29/10/2022 00:13

Underanothersky · 28/10/2022 11:05

She's not actually a great writer.

Hope she doesn't see this. She'll be sobbing into her silk pillows.

JellySaurus · 29/10/2022 00:13

Don't fool yourselves that the Lords have women's interests at heart.

Some have messed it quite clear that they do by speaking up publicly.

They just want to protect primogeniture.

Over 760 Peers eligible to sit in the HoL. Of them less than 90 are hereditary peers.

JellySaurus · 29/10/2022 00:10

It's contradictory. On the one hand, it's saying they can choose the 'label' of woman or not; on the other it's saying they must accept the label of 'mother

It is not saying that they can choose the 'label' of woman or not. It is recognising that some women reject that label, but that this rejection does not change anything. If a woman gives birth she becomes a mother, no matter if she rejects the label 'woman'.

AnApparitionQuipped · 28/10/2022 23:47

tkmethrthis · 28/10/2022 23:34

there is so much wrong with this post it’s hard to know where to start!

Interesting you use Jimmy Saville as an example, surely you are not comparing him to JKR? But he is a good example of what happens when you disregard basic safeguarding which is what those who deride JKR stand for.

My other point is that you realise that the Conservative party have had 3 female prime ministers so I’m not quite sure why you hold the Labour Party in such esteem when it comes to equality to women ? The Labour Party doesn’t even realise that only women have cervixes!

No, of course I'm not comparing Savile to JKR. I'm saying that the selection process for honours is neither democratic nor reliable.

The Lords don't care about safeguarding - they simply want to protect primogeniture. If you're aligning yourself on the basis of 'my enemy's enemy is my friend' then fair enough, but don't delude yourself that they are in your corner.

The Conservative party has had 3 x as many terms in office as the Labour Party so it's not surprising they've had more female PMs. A better measure might be the proportion of serving MPs - 104 of 202 Labour MPs are female - more than half; compared to just 87 of 365 Conservative MPs.

Smilelesstalkmore · 28/10/2022 23:46

OooPourUsACupLove · 28/10/2022 23:27

Someone I love is suffering from a terminal neurological illness.

The ill informed people who think JKR only cares about trans issues can fuck right off.

www.annerowlingclinic.org/about/our-history

Thank you for posting this, I'm sorry for what you are going through with your loved one.

JKR really is a wonderful woman, and the amount of shit she is getting just for refusing to sit down about women and girls is just disgusting. Particularly when a lot of it is coming from people who have done fuck all with their own lives.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 28/10/2022 23:38

OooPourUsACupLove · 28/10/2022 23:27

Someone I love is suffering from a terminal neurological illness.

The ill informed people who think JKR only cares about trans issues can fuck right off.

www.annerowlingclinic.org/about/our-history

💐

tkmethrthis · 28/10/2022 23:34

AnApparitionQuipped · 28/10/2022 23:00

those based on virtue

Who decides they are 'virtuous'? The equally heriditary and unelected monarchy. The same system that decided Sir Jimmy Savile was 'virtuous'.

It recognises that a minute percentage of women refuse to own that they are women, but, nonetheless, if they give birth they become mothers.

It's contradictory. On the one hand, it's saying they can choose the 'label' of woman or not; on the other it's saying they must accept the label of 'mother'.

Either way under the current system a woman like JKR would be immensely useful in what remains a chamber made up disproportionately of hereditary peers & males

That's a bit like saying Keir Starmer would be useful as a member of the Conservative party.

there is so much wrong with this post it’s hard to know where to start!

Interesting you use Jimmy Saville as an example, surely you are not comparing him to JKR? But he is a good example of what happens when you disregard basic safeguarding which is what those who deride JKR stand for.

My other point is that you realise that the Conservative party have had 3 female prime ministers so I’m not quite sure why you hold the Labour Party in such esteem when it comes to equality to women ? The Labour Party doesn’t even realise that only women have cervixes!

whoareyouinviting · 28/10/2022 23:32

Underanothersky · 28/10/2022 11:05

She's not actually a great writer.

Okey dokey then. Her bank balance tells us otherwise.

DdraigGoch · 28/10/2022 23:30

celestialsphere · 28/10/2022 18:37

I didn't ask what "good works" she has done. I asked if those who would like her to be in the house of lords know or care what her views are on topics other the gender critical ones.

I gather that she's a bit more socialist than I am. But that's fine because it's important to have a range of viewpoints.

OooPourUsACupLove · 28/10/2022 23:27

Someone I love is suffering from a terminal neurological illness.

The ill informed people who think JKR only cares about trans issues can fuck right off.

www.annerowlingclinic.org/about/our-history

UWhatNow · 28/10/2022 23:23

Janesmom · 28/10/2022 23:03

Awful woman. Outside the single issue echo chamber that MN is fast becoming, most women I know either don’t care about her or actively hold her in contempt for the horrific, divisive rubbish that now appears to be spewing.

Oh please. Do you even know what you’re talking about? Why is she “awful”? Please be specific. Otherwise you just sound thick.

AnApparitionQuipped · 28/10/2022 23:14

JellySaurus · 28/10/2022 22:56

I am not against the principle of having a 'layer' in addition to the House of Commons but I strongly oppose its being made up of 'Lords'.

This whole issue of males trying to colonise women's spaces and vulnerable children being transed, has been an excellent demonstration of the need for legislators who can speak freely without fearing that they might lose the next election because they have upset the loudest screamers.

Don't fool yourselves that the Lords have women's interests at heart. They just want to protect primogeniture.

AnApparitionQuipped · 28/10/2022 23:10

It's contradictory. On the one hand, it's saying they can choose the 'label' of woman or not; on the other it's saying they must accept the label of 'mother'

To add to this - I could reframe that as: 'woman' is a label that can be picked up or discarded, but 'mother' is inviolate. That is not a good message for women who are not mothers.

Smilelesstalkmore · 28/10/2022 23:08

Janesmom · 28/10/2022 23:03

Awful woman. Outside the single issue echo chamber that MN is fast becoming, most women I know either don’t care about her or actively hold her in contempt for the horrific, divisive rubbish that now appears to be spewing.

Yes, could you refer specifically to the 'horrific, divisive rubbish that now appears to be spewing'.

Direct quotes if possible please.

Untitledsquatboulder · 28/10/2022 23:05

Janesmom · 28/10/2022 23:03

Awful woman. Outside the single issue echo chamber that MN is fast becoming, most women I know either don’t care about her or actively hold her in contempt for the horrific, divisive rubbish that now appears to be spewing.

Such as? Could you ease give an example?

Janesmom · 28/10/2022 23:03

Awful woman. Outside the single issue echo chamber that MN is fast becoming, most women I know either don’t care about her or actively hold her in contempt for the horrific, divisive rubbish that now appears to be spewing.

AnApparitionQuipped · 28/10/2022 23:00

those based on virtue

Who decides they are 'virtuous'? The equally heriditary and unelected monarchy. The same system that decided Sir Jimmy Savile was 'virtuous'.

It recognises that a minute percentage of women refuse to own that they are women, but, nonetheless, if they give birth they become mothers.

It's contradictory. On the one hand, it's saying they can choose the 'label' of woman or not; on the other it's saying they must accept the label of 'mother'.

Either way under the current system a woman like JKR would be immensely useful in what remains a chamber made up disproportionately of hereditary peers & males

That's a bit like saying Keir Starmer would be useful as a member of the Conservative party.

JellySaurus · 28/10/2022 22:57

Perhaps ' legislators' is not the right word. A part of the legislative body that writes and passes our laws?

JellySaurus · 28/10/2022 22:56

I am not against the principle of having a 'layer' in addition to the House of Commons but I strongly oppose its being made up of 'Lords'.

This whole issue of males trying to colonise women's spaces and vulnerable children being transed, has been an excellent demonstration of the need for legislators who can speak freely without fearing that they might lose the next election because they have upset the loudest screamers.

JellySaurus · 28/10/2022 22:51

That statement doesn't entirely make sense. "...honours equally those mothers who do not own to the label "woman" ' - what does "own to the label" mean?

It's a clear and excellent statement. It does not imply that all women are worth is being mothers. It does not denigrate the choices women make. It simply confirms the link between mother and female. It recognises that a minute percentage of women refuse to own that they are women, but, nonetheless, if they give birth they become mothers.

'Own' is used here in the sense of acknowledge. As in 'to own up'.