Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's about time everyone was more frugal with energy.

66 replies

malificent7 · 28/10/2022 05:23

I am very concerned about the effect the energy crisis will have on the poorest and on the most vulnerable. I am hoping that schools and hospitals can stay warm.
However, i think it's good that everyone is turning stuff off and not putting the heating on because it's a bit chilly.

I know this will change if it gets really cold. If we are experiencing global warming we might not need so much heating. Clutching at straws here and trying to stay positive people!

OP posts:
okapiokapi · 28/10/2022 10:59

We haven't had a dryer for over ten years and we haven't had the heating on since the first week in March. We are rural, so our radiators and water are heated by heating oil. You have to buy 500 litres or more or they won't deliver. The last time we bought 500 litres it was £320, the time before it was £240. We've had to order it again and it's over £500! We have three children with additional needs and they have to have baths, so most of our heating oil goes towards heating water and the water is on a meter too. Our electric has jumped (from when we moved here in 2016) up from £20 a week being enough to still have some credit remaining, to £60 last week and it's all gone. We live between our kitchen and living room and the kids have no electronic devices in their room. They are home educated, so they do use their laptops a couple of times a week, but we mostly use pens and paper. We've had so many power cuts lately. Unfortunately, the rich are making the decisions, without having to worry if they make a mistake. If the sea level rises, they can just buy a yacht!

maddening · 28/10/2022 10:55

Whilst definitely we need to do our bit I think the biggest job is to convince China, India, Russia and the USA to do anything- we are a drop in the global environmental disaster.

GasPanic · 28/10/2022 10:51

FacebookPhotos · 28/10/2022 10:45

I agree that some people use was more than their fair share of natural resources. But there are also lots of people who already use less than their fair share because they have no money. Or, like me, find that old habits relating to being poor are very difficult to shift.

I think a good start would have been to cap the number of units of gas / electric that you can get at the (government subsidised) discounted cost.

I’m also a fan of having an “environment impact allowance”. If you’re already low impact (which most poorer people are) you’d have spare allowance you could choose to sell. Probably impossible to implement though!

I think you are right on both counts.

It's a good idea, but would be very expensive to implement.

Far easier just to tax everything heavily and then provide energy benefits for people to claim.

FacebookPhotos · 28/10/2022 10:45

I agree that some people use was more than their fair share of natural resources. But there are also lots of people who already use less than their fair share because they have no money. Or, like me, find that old habits relating to being poor are very difficult to shift.

I think a good start would have been to cap the number of units of gas / electric that you can get at the (government subsidised) discounted cost.

I’m also a fan of having an “environment impact allowance”. If you’re already low impact (which most poorer people are) you’d have spare allowance you could choose to sell. Probably impossible to implement though!

GasPanic · 28/10/2022 10:41

deliverooyoutoo · 28/10/2022 10:29

What's going to happen to disabled people who need to keep warm if you're taxing the hell out of energy use?

Two choices :

The government gives everyone an energy allowance, much like we have a personal tax allowance.

The government subsidises them.

torquewench · 28/10/2022 10:37

I was brought up to be frugal because my parents weren't well off. Its an ingrained habit. I don't need lecturing on it now after years of "it's like Blackpool Illuminations in here".

CapMarvel · 28/10/2022 10:37

Obviously every little helps, but really what should be happening rather than/ in addition to the short term handouts this winter is a big push towards energy efficiency and grants/ loans etc to help with that, massively increasing the feed-in payments for solar etc.

That would require some joined-up thinking from the government however.

nogginatemycat · 28/10/2022 10:36

@malificent7

If you really want to be frugal and it concerns you so much, then turn of your devices and get off MN. Practice what you preach, it is really necessary for you to be wasting energy posting on here.

www.energuide.be/en/questions-answers/do-i-emit-co2-when-i-surf-the-internet/69/

"How much energy is required for...

...an email?
A one-megabyte email (= 1 MB) during its total life cycle emits 20 g of CO2 , i.e. the equivalent of an old 60 W lamp lit for 25 min. Twenty emails a day per user over one year, create the same CO2 emissions as a car travelling 1000 km.

...a data centre?
A single router consumes 10,000 watts (10 kW). A very large data centre comes close to 100 million watts (100 MW), or one-tenth of the output of a thermal power station. In fact, on top of the consumption required to run the servers, the electronic circuits must be cooled using air conditioning.

... a web search?
The search for a web address represents 3.4 Wh (0.8 g CO2 equivalent). But the total rises to 10 g after an internet search producing five results.If a web user makes an average of 2.6 web searches per day, this user can be extrapolated to be emitting 9.9 kg of CO2 equivalent per year.

... a year browsing the web?
When browsing the web, an average internet user yearly needs about 365 kWh electricity and 2,900 litres of water, which corresponds to the CO2 that is emitted when you travel a good 1,400 km by car."

stuntbubbles · 28/10/2022 10:36

We've been very, very lucky though that for the majority of the country October has been mild so far.
The milder autumns of the past few years are because of climate change. It’s not luck; it’s man-made and it’s a problem.

OP, while I agree households should think about their energy consumption – you read stuff on here about “well, my house my business” as if their carbon footprint is confined to their house and doesn’t affect us all – the best things to do are cut our consumption of stuff: all the shopping of new things that are made with energy, use energy to deliver, use energy to dispose of. And when we’re eventually given the chance to vote, vote out the Tories who couldn’t give a shit.

newtb · 28/10/2022 10:31

There was a school in Leasowe, built in the 60s from memory, that had no heating but must have had solar power. Have often wondered why more public buildings built since the massive reorganisation of local govt in the 70s didn't follow the same aporoach. Would've saved millions.

deliverooyoutoo · 28/10/2022 10:29

What's going to happen to disabled people who need to keep warm if you're taxing the hell out of energy use?

GasPanic · 28/10/2022 10:28

Let's face it, no one is going to minimise their usage of energy unless we tax the hell out of it. Everyone has a reason why they need an SUV (because its safer) or jet travel holidays (because some celeb does it so why shouldn't I).

So that's the choice we have, either pay a lot more for stuff that is polluting/causes global warming, or destroy the planet in 50-100 years time.

The window for choosing is fast diminishing.

Putting the odd yogurt pot in the recycling and thinking you are actually doing any good is fantasy.

OnBoardTheHeartOfGold · 28/10/2022 10:20

We're quite frugal with our energy but if you think what we, as domestic energy users on a little island, can make a huge difference to the environment, then I think you're dreaming.
Yes, we can save a few £'s personally, and yes we can contribute to a global and industrial change but not in isolation.

BooksAndHooks · 28/10/2022 10:19

I’m hoping that shops and other public buildings stop heating to such excessive levels you have to leave before you can finish your shop. The past few days have been lovely warm weather, however the shops had the heating on so high. We visited a museum and had to leave the radiators were on so high you couldn’t touch them.

Ive always wondered why shops do this and hinder their sales.

otherwayup · 28/10/2022 10:13

nootsy · 28/10/2022 05:49

I thought globally air con to cool was a bigger drain than people putting the heating on?

This is correct I believe?

I remember someone on the news, some environmentalist/scientist saying that 'once everyone in China has a fridge there is no hope'

This is the problem but why shouldn't everyone on the planet hope for the same standard of living as those in the western world?

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 28/10/2022 10:08

When I went out yesterday (very mild in London) shops had doors open and heat on, and they'll be doing this all winter, even when it gets cold. Why not start on encouraging them to close the doors and turn the heat down? why is it always households that have to cut back and be frugal?

xogossipgirlxo · 28/10/2022 10:07

StillNotWarm · 28/10/2022 09:55

It's astounded me how much some people have been able to save by making changes - that just bring them in line with how we live normally, and comfortably.

Great if putting on a jumper and turning your heating down to 20C, and not havng 15min showers every day saves you more than the increases. But tougher if you are already in a jumper and under blankets on the sofa. There are limited cutbacks you can make if you are already using minimum energy already. (We are in the middle of those btw).

Exactly. It's wrong to assume some people still aren't frugal with energy. Some barely have heating on through the year- what cutbacks are they supposed to make?

crackofdoom · 28/10/2022 10:01

Well, we are currently experiencing warmer weather due to climate change in the UK. But, as the Arctic ice cap melts, it will reduce the salinity of the Atlantic, which could affect the Gulf Stream, potentially causing it to cease. Which would mean the UK could suddenly get very much colder.

StillNotWarm · 28/10/2022 09:55

It's astounded me how much some people have been able to save by making changes - that just bring them in line with how we live normally, and comfortably.

Great if putting on a jumper and turning your heating down to 20C, and not havng 15min showers every day saves you more than the increases. But tougher if you are already in a jumper and under blankets on the sofa. There are limited cutbacks you can make if you are already using minimum energy already. (We are in the middle of those btw).

AuntieEntity · 28/10/2022 09:33

lannistunut · 28/10/2022 06:22

If we are experiencing global warming we might not need so much heating. This is naive. Not sure how increased flooding, drought, hurricanes will help with anything, especially the expected famines and water shortages leading to war. The consequences of climate change are going to be massive and cost a fortune - both individually and for governments.

It is not 'global warming' it is climate change - so more volatility and extreme weather events.

I think this is the part that quite a few people seem to miss - that the impact of global warming isn't going to just happen to low-lying regions. Water wars and the collapse of our ecosystem is going to impact everyone. Not least, what happens to nuclear facilities in countries whose infrastructure is fucked? It's our children who are going to experience this.

Inthisissue · 28/10/2022 09:31

I think we're arranging deckchairs on the deck of the Titanic re climate change tbh but totally agree everyone should be doing everything possible to cut down energy consumption. Who knows we might just be able to save ourselves ☹️

FuckabethFuckor · 28/10/2022 09:26

It's supremely privileged to even have the option of being 'mindful' of energy/heating use. So many people don't have a choice, or are trapped by poverty or circumstances.

Besides, it's all so gnats and camels, isn't it? Connie at number 34 titting about with the thermostat, meanwhile huge organisations continue to belch out millions of tons of pollution and dump toxic waste in both land and sea — all the while scrambling to avoid tax in country after country. Feels like kicking out at the wrong thing.

latetothefisting · 28/10/2022 09:25

I agree OP and think it's obvious you weren't suggesting that everyone should only turn the hearing on for half an hour a day. Obviously some people will need to use more but a lot of people completely waste energy and if people start to only use what they personally need how is that not a good thing?

Some of the wording around it is really funny to me - posters suggesting that completely normal things like putting a jumper on, filling a hot water bottle or adjusting a thermostat are some sort of miserable, hugely inconvenient "faff" akin to being asked to wash all their clothes in the river and then put them through the mangle, rather than incredibly easy actions which take seconds!

Nobody is suggesting that a few people in Milton Keynes putting a jumper on is going to be what reverses climate change but surely every little helps? It's indicative of a wider change where people actually consider the cost (not just economic) of what they use whether that's natural resources, clothes, cheap labour, food etc.

MercuryRising · 28/10/2022 09:21

In principle I agree that people being mindful of their energy consumption if they can is a good thing. However, I think this is very different to people being afraid to heat their homes because of the potential of unaffordable bills especially when it will have health implications for many.

notacooldad · 28/10/2022 09:20

thought globally air con to cool was a bigger drain than people putting the heating on?
Its possible that air con is a bigger drain but that doesn't mean heating isnt an issue. It's not one or tbe other.

Swipe left for the next trending thread