Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want him to live with us anymore?

191 replies

RasDonavin · 27/10/2022 23:30

DN turned 17 last week, he's lived with us since lockdown due to having an argument with his DM. It was only supposed to be temporary, he made up with his DM and told us he was happier here so we all agreed for him to live here and see his DM whenever he wanted it seemed to work well.

He met a girl (well woman as she's 20) about 2 months ago, and since then his behaviour has gotten awful again. He stays out until the early hours, is disrespectful, brings his gf over even though we haven't agreed, stopped attending college which resulted in him being removed off of his course which he doesn't seem to care about and has been spending all his time on his playstation.

This evening DH is working nights and I put DD to bed. About half an hour later, he woke her up by talking very loudly on the PlayStation I went into him and asked him to keep the noise down as DD was trying to sleep. He then woke her up again so I turned the wifi off which was probably a bit unreasonable but DD was very tired as she hadn't napped today. He then shouted and swore at me so I turned it back on.

WIBU to tell him I don't want him living here anymore and ask him to go back to his mums?

OP posts:
Dustybarn · 28/10/2022 08:32

Could you call his mum and meet her somewhere for a coffee so you can explain the situation, then both go back to the house, announce that he is moving home today and both help him pack his stuff and move ? His mum should be there as this is really her responsibility.

ineedakickupthe · 28/10/2022 08:27

YANBU

Ponoka7 · 28/10/2022 08:24

This is why family members do really have to think carefully before taking a young person in. You could be putting a sticking plaster over what needs serious intervention. To then throw him out when he is still a child, but at a age were the LA has limited duty of care, is just going to potentially destroy his life. You see ineffective parenting being propped up by family members and it's the child who ultimately suffers.

MatronicO6 · 28/10/2022 08:23

Give him his marching orders. He is not going to be left on the streets, he has a home to go to

You've done enough.

Checkmateready · 28/10/2022 08:22

He’s overpowering you and needs to go. When someone is doing you a favour you respect their environment which he’s now not doing. You shouldn’t be having to deal with this and your family shouldn’t be put out by him.

billy1966 · 28/10/2022 08:21

He needs to return to his mother.

He is using you and your home as a doss house.

You have been really kind.

Shouting and swearing at you in YOUR home?

Completely unacceptable.

I would not have that for one minute around my child.

Bringing a woman home is so disrespectful.

Calmly help him pack his bags.

He needs to sort his life out, but having given up college it should no longer be in your home.

StClare101 · 28/10/2022 08:21

OriginalUsername3 · 28/10/2022 02:45

Yeah I'd be packing his bags first thing in the morning and taking him to his mother's. Its not like you're chucking him on the streets.

I’d make him find his own way back.

diddl · 28/10/2022 08:20

Can't believe that he made up with his mum but was allowed to stay because he wanted to!

What were the perks of that for him?

Own/bigger room?

No/fewer other kids about?

theremustonlybeone · 28/10/2022 08:19

What is your DH view on your DN recent abusive behaviour? I would speak to him when he gets in and decide on next steps. For me I would have called his mum to come and collect him.

Ponoka7 · 28/10/2022 08:19

@BananaCocktails

"Why hasn’t he got his own place? "

Because very few LLs would rent to a under 18 year old. Who would go guarantor for a 17 year old? That leaves a hostel. Our local ones are quite full. Emergency places are held for homeless teen pregnancy situations. Tbf they aren't bad, but it is a teenage dumping ground.

Has anyone checked his relationship isn't abusive? He's a minor in a relationship with an adult and has had a change in behaviour. If the sexes were reversed, you'd be getting more involved. He seems to have been left to let his life drift. Is anyone acting in a parental role? He's been homeless since he was 14? Is anyone addressing that properly? Does he feel that he's got a future? I was homeless at 15, I had a roof over my head, but didn't feel as though I could plan for my future iyswim.

It's good that it's come to a head without anything major happening. This allows for the sit down discussions suggested and a proper plan going forward. If the OP wasn't going to take responsibility for him, she shouldn't have took him in as a child. At 14 the LA certainly had a duty of care and he would have got a proper plan which would give him a sense of stability and funding for higher education. But his Mother would have had to face up to her son being a child in need.

FlirtyMelons · 28/10/2022 08:17

OnTheBrinkOfChange · 28/10/2022 08:13

This is her nephew not her child. It's not her responsibility to do any of that.

To be fair she took him on whilst he was still very much a child so surely you must know you will have some parental responsibility there. If he was 17 when he moved in then totally different.

I would say that a sit down conversation with him is the first thing and say what your expectations are with regards to all the things you mentioned in your OP. If he is unhappy with it he can go back to him mums.

Its so sad to read on here that so many would just throw a 17 yo family member out when things had been fine with the exception of a few weeks.

RudsyFarmer · 28/10/2022 08:16

Two words. Fuck that. He needs to be off back to his mum.

user1471538283 · 28/10/2022 08:16

He is not your responsibility, your DD is. So he goes back to his DM's today.

Brefugee · 28/10/2022 08:15

Give him a week to get out, to be reasonable, but be very clear to him about why you are taking this action.

You can also say that between now and then the wifi will go off when your daughter goes to bed (or change the password so you can use it but don't tell him what it is)

Meowsaidthecat · 28/10/2022 08:15

I would be telling his mum you're dropping him off soon as you've packed his stuff up this morning.
If he can't respect your home/dd bedtime etc then he can't stay. End of the day he's not your child, he's not your responsibility. He should not be rebelling against his aunt!

OnTheBrinkOfChange · 28/10/2022 08:13

Pixiedust1234 · 28/10/2022 00:34

So he's given up on college, goes out all night or games on PlayStation?

He needs a "where is your life going" talk and see if you can support towards another course or apprenticeship. Tell him doing nothing is not an option. Also tell him aggression and being disrespectful are not options either.

Its a tough one but the only way is to be tough. Go gentle and you will be raising a cocklodger.

This is her nephew not her child. It's not her responsibility to do any of that.

BigSandyBalls2015 · 28/10/2022 08:10

Is he DHs nephew?

rainbowstardrops · 28/10/2022 07:56

If he was to change his behaviour back to being reasonable, would you be happy for him to continue living at yours or not?

If you're quite happy generally then I'd sit him down and give him firm boundaries re noise and the girlfriend etc.

If you've had enough of him being there then just tell him he has to go back to his mum now because it's not working.

MrsSkylerWhite · 28/10/2022 07:45

Cw112 · Yesterday 23:53
Can you sit him down with a cuppa and take a supportive approach first and say you've noticed a big change in him from when he was really settled and doing well and ask what he thinks has happened. Ask him if he's still happy living with you or if he's changed his mind on it. If he says he's happy living with you then I'd say that if he wants to continue he needs to respect the boundaries in your home and everyone else who lives there and in turn you will all respect him. Just be really straight with him most young people that age prefer that because then they know exactly where they stand. Sounds to me like the gf might not be a great influence and like something is working in the background there so I'd want to know what that is before jumping straight to kicking him out if it's only been the last 8 weeks and he was doing great before that. I'd say that if he doesn't want to be at his course any more that's fine but he can't be sitting about all day so he either needs to join a youth programme or find himself a job. If he digs in and refuses your boundaries then you tell him he needs to go back to living with mum because your boundaries are not negotiable because you have other kids in the house to think of. If you put boundaries down though you have to be ready to follow through, so for example I wouldn't have turned the WiFi back on I'd have stated clearly that he's woken the child up twice and he was warned and this is the direct result of the choice he made to continue to be loud. You obviously have had a good relationship with him and he's enjoyed staying with you and benefited from that so I'd try and work with him if you can because it does sound like something has happened.“

None of the above. OP is not his mother. He needs to go home.

Eweknowwhat · 28/10/2022 07:45

Gee whizz OP, you've certainly made a rod for your own back here, haven't you?

You allow him to stay at your house (no doubt rent-free?) let him bring his cougar GF over to have sex, allow him to doss around all day, shout and generally cause disruption to your own DC.

What is the matter with you?

Get a backbone and put his goods out on the step today and ask his mother to come and collect him.

And change the locks in case the waster keeps a key to sneak back in.

ign0re · 28/10/2022 07:42

I fell out with my parents and went to stay with an aunt when I was a child. I was badly behaved in general but when I stayed with my aunt, I knew she was doing me a favour and if I started acting like this, It would have been completely reasonable to throw me out. I was older than your nephew but never stayed out late, nor did I have anyone round.

cf get him out!

Pipsquiggle · 28/10/2022 07:41

I would have a chat with him.

Talk about his recent behaviour and how it is unacceptable. Set some really clear ground rules and the consequences of breaking them.

His mum needs to step up too, whatever happens, as teenage years are tricky .

His GF sounds like a bad influence but pointing this out may do more harm than good

Changemyname1000x · 28/10/2022 07:35

Hmm he is still a child...a troubled one at that.
What help will chucking him out do.
'Behaviour is communication'
Before you get to the stage where you ask him to leave there must be several other stages

Shame on those saying a teenage boy with a troubled home life is 'a leech'

Yes OP you do need to put in boundaries and that's hard enough for everyone with your own DC nevermnd a DN. But it sounds like he needs an adult in his life to do this or his life is going to be in course for a car crash.

He's clearly got a lot going on and it's not going to be easy but please don't abandon him

(do you have any idea what hostel are like those who are suggesting that!?!)

MeridianB · 28/10/2022 07:32

He needs to leave today because this won’t get any better, just worse.

He’s already stepped over so many lines that it will be really hard to pull this back.

I find it very creepy that a 20yo woman is sleeping with a 17yo.

SMrs · 28/10/2022 07:32

Cw112 · 27/10/2022 23:53

Can you sit him down with a cuppa and take a supportive approach first and say you've noticed a big change in him from when he was really settled and doing well and ask what he thinks has happened. Ask him if he's still happy living with you or if he's changed his mind on it. If he says he's happy living with you then I'd say that if he wants to continue he needs to respect the boundaries in your home and everyone else who lives there and in turn you will all respect him. Just be really straight with him most young people that age prefer that because then they know exactly where they stand. Sounds to me like the gf might not be a great influence and like something is working in the background there so I'd want to know what that is before jumping straight to kicking him out if it's only been the last 8 weeks and he was doing great before that. I'd say that if he doesn't want to be at his course any more that's fine but he can't be sitting about all day so he either needs to join a youth programme or find himself a job. If he digs in and refuses your boundaries then you tell him he needs to go back to living with mum because your boundaries are not negotiable because you have other kids in the house to think of. If you put boundaries down though you have to be ready to follow through, so for example I wouldn't have turned the WiFi back on I'd have stated clearly that he's woken the child up twice and he was warned and this is the direct result of the choice he made to continue to be loud. You obviously have had a good relationship with him and he's enjoyed staying with you and benefited from that so I'd try and work with him if you can because it does sound like something has happened.

Absolutely try this approach! I'd also set some boundaries about him going back to college/working or both.