Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want him to live with us anymore?

191 replies

RasDonavin · 27/10/2022 23:30

DN turned 17 last week, he's lived with us since lockdown due to having an argument with his DM. It was only supposed to be temporary, he made up with his DM and told us he was happier here so we all agreed for him to live here and see his DM whenever he wanted it seemed to work well.

He met a girl (well woman as she's 20) about 2 months ago, and since then his behaviour has gotten awful again. He stays out until the early hours, is disrespectful, brings his gf over even though we haven't agreed, stopped attending college which resulted in him being removed off of his course which he doesn't seem to care about and has been spending all his time on his playstation.

This evening DH is working nights and I put DD to bed. About half an hour later, he woke her up by talking very loudly on the PlayStation I went into him and asked him to keep the noise down as DD was trying to sleep. He then woke her up again so I turned the wifi off which was probably a bit unreasonable but DD was very tired as she hadn't napped today. He then shouted and swore at me so I turned it back on.

WIBU to tell him I don't want him living here anymore and ask him to go back to his mums?

OP posts:
Beautiful3 · 28/10/2022 17:07

Yes. Tell him to leave. He's Beibg incredibly disrespectful. Your children comes first.

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 28/10/2022 17:04

KettrickenSmiled · 28/10/2022 16:48

He did have therapy and joined a club to control his anger, so we wasn't ‘neglecting’ him. He doesn't do that anymore as he doesn't want to.

I know you went beyond the call of duty taking him on OP, & you say it went better in the first year than this. But he has been allowed to drop out of college, chuck his job, stay out till all hours without informing you, & bring his g/f back to yours without invitation ... all this is what culminated in the straw that broke your back - WifiGate.
He doesn't seem to have heard the word "no" in the past year, & you reaching the end of your tether now - understandable as it is - is part of that whole process of not enforcing any boundaries on him.

Quite what do you think the op can do when he refuses to go to college? He isn’t a small child she can simply pick up and take to school. They probably have had conversations about this, more than once. But if someone is determined to not do something you can’t make them.

OP has he apologised for shouting and swearing at you? Does he realise that he was being abusive and scared you and your daughter?

neverbeenskiing · 28/10/2022 16:54

He then shouted and swore at me so I turned it back on.

Are you frightened of him, OP?

KettrickenSmiled · 28/10/2022 16:48

He did have therapy and joined a club to control his anger, so we wasn't ‘neglecting’ him. He doesn't do that anymore as he doesn't want to.

I know you went beyond the call of duty taking him on OP, & you say it went better in the first year than this. But he has been allowed to drop out of college, chuck his job, stay out till all hours without informing you, & bring his g/f back to yours without invitation ... all this is what culminated in the straw that broke your back - WifiGate.
He doesn't seem to have heard the word "no" in the past year, & you reaching the end of your tether now - understandable as it is - is part of that whole process of not enforcing any boundaries on him.

RasDonavin · 28/10/2022 16:36

He very rarely drinks, I'm not sure about drugs but I don't think so. I've not let him behave like this for 2 years, as I said in my OP it's only been the last 2ish months. He was well behaved as soon as he settled up until then, he did well in his gcses etc.

He doesn't have a job but that's due to him not being able to find another, as when he quit he was looking but now I think he's stopped. He told us he doesn't know what he wants to do so he can't do an apprenticeship.

He did have therapy and joined a club to control his anger, so we wasn't ‘neglecting’ him. He doesn't do that anymore as he doesn't want to.

He hasn't gone as I spoke to him earlier and he said he doesn't want to go back to his mums and DH was in bed, we are going to speak to him later though I think.

OP posts:
slowquickstep · 28/10/2022 16:11

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 28/10/2022 12:07

This.
He's 17 and everyone deserves a second chance if he can sort out his issues.
You have been more than helpful to him.
And say that he is never to shout and swear at you like that again. You will not put up with it. He is on a verbal warning.

Whether he stays or not all depends on his response and future intentions.

I think his time at his Aunts was his second chance.

NumberTheory · 28/10/2022 16:06

Naunet · 28/10/2022 15:47

So is any aunt or uncle that doesn’t have their niece or nephew living with them, is washing their hands of them?! Of course not, OP is not under any obligation to put a roof over his head, and by not doing so, she is NOT washing her hands of him.

OP isn’t “any aunt or uncle”. Taking their nephew in and allowing him to stay wasn’t simply a neutral act, it papered over his problems and allowed his mum to neglect him.

Aggressive teens are really hard to deal with and the state provide very little support to help parents until it’s far too late. But what OP appears to be describing here is a set of adults who, rather than trying to address a child’s significant needs that were evident years ago, have simply done what they can to lower immediate friction. OP is part of that. She isn’t some innocent bystander.

OriginalUsername2 · 28/10/2022 15:59

Sounds like it’s time for him to go home. Try not to be too mad at him, I was the same at 17 but didn’t understand what I was doing until years later.

If you keep on good terms he’ll likely remember this period very gratefully as an adult.

Naunet · 28/10/2022 15:47

NumberTheory · 28/10/2022 15:30

Just because there is another person (who has also neglected the child), to put a roof over his head doesn’t mean OP isn’t washing her hands of him.

So is any aunt or uncle that doesn’t have their niece or nephew living with them, is washing their hands of them?! Of course not, OP is not under any obligation to put a roof over his head, and by not doing so, she is NOT washing her hands of him.

Dogtooth · 28/10/2022 15:30

There's no doubt he's behaving unacceptably and it can't go on like this, but I wouldn't just boot him out. See if he's willing to talk about it, say you can't let him keep living there if he behaves that way. See if he'll talk about his family etc, he sounds mixed up.

TBH he's displaying the same behaviours he showed at his mum's, I'm not sure why you thought it would be magically better at your house (although you were kind to take him in). Even if he ends up moving out, I'd try to remain a presence in his life, ask him round for dinner etc.

NumberTheory · 28/10/2022 15:30

Naunet · 28/10/2022 15:02

Wash her hands, is not the same as no longer providing him with a free roof over his head. He’s being sent back to live with his mum, not live on the streets!

Just because there is another person (who has also neglected the child), to put a roof over his head doesn’t mean OP isn’t washing her hands of him.

Naunet · 28/10/2022 15:02

NumberTheory · 28/10/2022 14:45

Agree that women aren’t rehab centres but in this instance, OP has facilitated this child’s neglect and now wants to wash her hands.

Wash her hands, is not the same as no longer providing him with a free roof over his head. He’s being sent back to live with his mum, not live on the streets!

TheGander · 28/10/2022 14:57

He has been bullying you in your own home. Here is the link to the “ men who do nothing “ thread www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4661328-young-men-who-get-stuck-doing-nothing?page=9&reply=120976002
My brother is one of them, take it from me, you don’t want this situation on your hands. You can be constructive and explain why the arrangement no longer works, that he needs to start working towards his future, then ask him to leave rather than just chucking out.

NumberTheory · 28/10/2022 14:45

Naunet · 28/10/2022 14:04

Then his mum and step dad can deal with it! Women are not rehab centres for men, our free time and emotional labour is not public property to be cut up and divided amongst males in society for Christ sake.

Agree that women aren’t rehab centres but in this instance, OP has facilitated this child’s neglect and now wants to wash her hands.

Brigante9 · 28/10/2022 14:32

Send him home, you’ve been more than kind and now he’s taking the piss.

jtaeapa · 28/10/2022 14:29

Out - and now.

Disrespectful cocklodger in the making. Familiarity has bred contempt in this case. No wonder he fell out with his mum.

KettrickenSmiled · 28/10/2022 14:06

Theskyisfallingdown · 28/10/2022 13:59

Exactly! Sitting him down with a ‘cuppa’ indeed 😄Shouting, swearing and intimidating women is inexcusable. His parent/s can collect him. Prioritise your daughter over someone else’s abusive son.

I'm surprised how many PP cannot see that this young man's path toward aggression, dropping out, & holing up in his room with a playstation has been enabled by his entire family, including OP.

No, OP should not tolerate aggression in her home - despite being one of the adults who has taught him that aggression gets him his own way (she turned the wifi back on because he yelled about it ffs!).
Sadly, she has posted about 2 years too late, & probably her best alternative, given that she won't intervene to help this young man turn his life around, is to protect her household & make him leave. I'm with @NumberTheory all the way -

How was a 15 year old allowed to make the decision to just not go home in the first place? What help did he get for learning to manage his feelings and his anger properly after he had such a significant falling out with his mother that he had to leave home? Who has he been going to for advice and support for the last 2 years? How much has he been allowed to, effectively, simply lodge in your house rather than being drawn into a family life that slowly increases his responsibilities and opportunities, coaching him for independence and making bigger more important decisions?

AcrossthePond55 · 28/10/2022 14:04

At the very first instance of bad behaviour I'd have sat him down and said "The next time you violate house rules or are disrespectful, out you go. There will be no further warnings".

But I think at this point it's too late for warnings, he's already developed a pattern of disrespectful behaviour. He needs to be told that it's time for him to go back to his mother's.

Naunet · 28/10/2022 14:04

KettrickenSmiled · 28/10/2022 13:21

Oh I think there's every point in negotiating. It's high time somebody stepped in & started adulting around this young man. The poor lad has been pitifully neglected, & has significant ACE trauma.

OP has been taking the path of least resistance &has just allowed him to act out until she reached the end of her tether. He is crying out for somebody to take charge & start creating boundaries for him. he's now on the path to becoming either a very angry & dislocated young man, or one of those hikkomori guys, who are locked in to not much more than computer gaming.
www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-23182523

Then his mum and step dad can deal with it! Women are not rehab centres for men, our free time and emotional labour is not public property to be cut up and divided amongst males in society for Christ sake.

Oojamaflipp · 28/10/2022 14:03

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn - posted on wrong thread.

Omg, completely wrong thread, sorry!

Oojamaflipp · 28/10/2022 14:02

This reply has been withdrawn

Message withdrawn - posted on wrong thread.

Theskyisfallingdown · 28/10/2022 13:59

PunchDrunkTurtle · 28/10/2022 12:13

I'm concerned by how many people think an aggressive man should be allowed to be abusive and get a second chance.

Exactly! Sitting him down with a ‘cuppa’ indeed 😄Shouting, swearing and intimidating women is inexcusable. His parent/s can collect him. Prioritise your daughter over someone else’s abusive son.

NumberTheory · 28/10/2022 13:56

I do get the send him home advice and I don’t disagree with it, you have a young child who you have to prioritize. But from the way you’ve written this I suspect the adults in DN’s life (including you and your DH) may have been letting him down a bit over the last few years and he probably needs more support and less of the simple “you made your bed, now lie in it” approach.

How was a 15 year old allowed to make the decision to just not go home in the first place? What help did he get for learning to manage his feelings and his anger properly after he had such a significant falling out with his mother that he had to leave home? Who has he been going to for advice and support for the last 2 years? How much has he been allowed to, effectively, simply lodge in your house rather than being drawn into a family life that slowly increases his responsibilities and opportunities, coaching him for independence and making bigger more important decisions?

balalake · 28/10/2022 13:45

Needs to leave, much as I recognise it is not easy to do.

RedToothBrush · 28/10/2022 13:39

He did have a job in the summer but he quit after about a month or 2 as he said it wasn't for him.

He is abusing you and taking no responsibility for himself.

He drops out of college, then it doesn't matter if the job isn't for him. He fucking does it or he leaves. That's how life works.

He needs to grow up and you do him no favours by backing down and sticking the WiFi back on.

PlayStation stays off until he gets a job or goes to college or leaves.

His choice.

Hold your ground or it will only get worsem