Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

…to seriously wonder why care work is seen to be the lowest of the low

37 replies

NellesVilla · 27/10/2022 19:53

Yup, this old chestnut again.

And sorry for the dramatic title, but it really bothers me. I’m an ex-carer (live-in) and up until recently worked in admin for a care company. So have a background in care so to speak.

By trade I am a trained teacher but left due to mh issues to work p/t as a tutor (pre-covid). I’m now working again as a tutor part time and wish to take on a second job.

I have applied for many a social care job, and sadly (imho) they all get back to me within minutes of my application, keen/desperate to interview me.

Other than the personal care (which I dislike and makes me anxious- there, I’ve said it) I think it’s a lovely job. Why then does society look down on it?

”Oh, you’re a carer are you? Good for you!”, or something like “Can’t you do better; surely there’s something else out there?” or “Do you really want to do this? Aren’t you embarrassed?”: just some of the things that people have said to me on hearing my plans to (possibly) embark upon this as a job again.

Working in care can be greatly fulfilling and fun. As a tutor I’ve helped with clients’ literacy skills, accompanied them to college and also on holiday a few times.

How do you get society to not judge and instead actually view it as a viable career? Do you train carers further to almost become nursing assistants? Do you enable them to specialise in something like learning disabilities/autism/dementia etc? How do you get youngsters interested in it as a job/career?

How do you get society to recognise care as a career? Can care be a career unless you train to be some sort of manager in the field?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
UWhatNow · 28/10/2022 00:39

It’s because of the shit pay for what they do. If carers were paid like stock brokers, people - including the males in society - would be lining up to wipe the arses of the elderly. And who gives a shit about stock brokers? Nobody. At least people like carers even if they do pity them.

MarshaMelrose · 28/10/2022 00:35

No one who uses carers look down their noses at them. They're bloody heroes. We employ 3 private carers at £16ph plus petrol money subsidy.
To be honest, I know I read on here all the time that no one respects carers, but that has not been my experience. I have never heard anyone ever be sneery about them. They command great admiration for the job they do. It can be messy and nasty and often there is little gratitude from the patient. But the relatives value them utterly.

Luredbyapomegranate · 28/10/2022 00:33

I don’t think that people look down on care work in particular, it’s just that because you are a qualified teacher it’s not something people would generally expect you to opt for, because you can earn more money, and probably get more intellectual stimulation as a teacher.

I think there is a general issue with the UK not valuing what used to be called manual, semi skilled and service work, which is part of the reason we are perpetually short of truck drivers and plumbers as well as care workers.

I am not sure trying to re-spin it as a career is the right way to go. It’s a vocation as well as a job, but it doesn’t offer the progression career jobs do. I think we would be better valuing truck driving, care work, retail work etc for the valuable occupations they are, rather than dressing them up as something they are not.

Cookingutensil · 28/10/2022 00:29

I agree, it is seen as the lowest of the low and that tells us everything we need to know about our society - we should be ashamed - especially those with the power to change that perception. perception = pay

Notoironing · 28/10/2022 00:17

I think it should be much better paid along with bin collection and teaching assistants to mention just a couple

Maverickess · 28/10/2022 00:12

I think the main ones have already been mentioned, traditionally done by women so 'worth' less and also because the people being cared for aren't really valued, therefore those who care for them aren't either.

Caring for someone properly is skilled, but they're not skills that are valued and appreciated, nor are they considered 'professional' skills.

There's also not enough investment and regulation - there's plenty of rules and policies, but not proper regulation or universal standards for all carers except having a '*clean' dbs and covid jab. So while yes, it's a job anyone can do, it's not a job anyone can do well, but there seems to be no issue with it not being done well (abuse aside) as long as it's done.

The social impact is also never considered either, I do wonder how many of the people who look down upon carers actually do, or have relied upon them to care for their families when it's been needed to ease the pressure on them and enable them to continue to learn, or work and earn, or basically do anything that having someone reliant on you for their basic needs would hamper. It's a short sighted, but not uncommon view unfortunately.

The only way to really make carers respected and valued is to make them professional in their own right (and not 'unqualified' nurses, or associated with nursing - different though related skill set) but to train carers consistently to the same level and recognise that training. It will never happen though because it will cost money that no one wants to spend.

ButterflyAi · 27/10/2022 23:38

It's incredibly unfair, but ingrained in this society.

At school I remember kids who barely scraped any GCSEs, weren't engaged with their education and had no interest in what came next in their lives being shunted into 'care work.' It was considered a total dead end, but better than not working or studying at all.

Good, compassionate carers make such a positive difference to people's lives - they should be valued far more.

CaptainSensiblesRedBeret · 27/10/2022 23:37

Because society does not value the care of our most vulnerable, whether young, old, MH or LD.

Fairislefandango · 27/10/2022 23:31

Because it's low-paid and involves menial tasks and personal care. It's not the kind of job most people want to do unless they have few other options. That doesn't mean that people should be looked down on for doing it, of course.

XenoBitch · 27/10/2022 23:26

I think society looks down on it because it is poorly paid. Pretty much all poorly paid jobs are looked down on because it is assumed that the person in those jobs must be too thick to do anything else.

Care work can be a stepping stone to other things, but on its own, it is not really a career. There was a BBC documentary where Ed Balls shadowed care workers for a few weeks. He worked with one young lad who all the staff and residents loved... and all were sad that this lad was going on to study paramedic science (I am pretty sure that was what he was going on to do) but they said if he stayed working there, he would be stuck... probably could never buy his own home or have luxuries as the pay is so poor and there is no progression.

Leemoe · 27/10/2022 22:18

The people whom care assistants care for are not valued by our society, so by extension those who care for them are treated with similar derision/pity/contempt.

If you don't agree with me merely avail yourself of the different societal attitudes towards nurses who work within social care and those who care for the (presumably) largely economically active sector of society within the NHS or private hospitals.

adviceplease93 · 27/10/2022 22:12

I don't know if people look down on it as much as they personally wouldn't want to do it/don't think it's an aspirational career? And that's because of how hard work it is for such rubbish pay not because it's not an important job! I certainly don't look down on people who work in care homes etc. if anything I take my hat off to them as I couldn't do it!

Atmywitsend29 · 27/10/2022 22:11

Belledan1 · 27/10/2022 20:40

I was thinking about the recent strikes. IMAGINE if care workers went on strike! I have a relative that worked all through lock down. Recently got covid now and not getting paid as told needs to be off. She is really ill anyway. Terrible.

It was written into our contracts we were not allowed to unionise and striking is a sackable offence. I've seen that clause in my last 3 care home/hospice contracts.

Atmywitsend29 · 27/10/2022 22:08

When I was doing the sign up for my nvq 3, the assessor actually sat there and said to me "you have such fantastic grades, why do you do this job?"

Uhm, because I'm fucking good at it.
Because I'm the carer that can get Mrs D to eat when no one else can.
I'm the carer that can calm down Mr A when he's in crisis and literally smashing up the home. I'm the carer that can take him from crisis point to calmly having a tea and a chat.
I'm the only carer that Ms B trusts and will allow anywhere near her without a fight.
I'm the carer that's trained specifically in end of life care and will be there holding someone's hand to the very end.
I'm the carer that can train the other carers how to deliver excellent end of life care, how to deliver calm and person centred dementia care.

People who say it's a shit job, or demeans the work are the people who have categorically no idea what it is like to be a carer. All the good that you do, all the bad that you see.

I worked up to HOC, but left the sector 9 months ago due to burn out, because unfortunately it turns out that there are still a great many care companies who don't realise how important the job is. And companies that don't take into consideration how exhausting PROPER dementia can be and that they need to look after their staff! But sometimes I really bloody miss end of life care.

Shouldawouldacoulda30 · 27/10/2022 22:08

I genuinely think that if people were less ignorant and actually new how much studying the carers have to do to actually do their job competently ,there would be far more respect for carers!

Airymanning · 27/10/2022 22:05

Belledan1 · 27/10/2022 20:40

I was thinking about the recent strikes. IMAGINE if care workers went on strike! I have a relative that worked all through lock down. Recently got covid now and not getting paid as told needs to be off. She is really ill anyway. Terrible.

This happened with me.

I've now left care. I just couldn't handle the rudeness from people vs the risk, plus NEVER a day off and never allowed to be ill.

FixundFoxi · 27/10/2022 22:04

I find on MN that there's a certain cache about being a midwife but not so much for being a nurse. I've read on here about high fliers desperate to become midwives rarely nurses. I think it's the perception that nursing/caring is providing bedpans and making brews and that the individuals in question aren't very bright.

Creamcheesedreams · 27/10/2022 21:55

Because it's 'women's work' and society thinks women's work doesn't deserve good pay. Only 'real' work does, namely 'men's work.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 27/10/2022 21:50

agree with all that’s been said here

something needs to change though as it cannot carry on as it is, I’m in a rural area of Scotland and there is a ridiculous amount of bed blocking currently and we’re not even into winter, no care packages available and no care home places, another one has just closed due to failings which is short sighted they should be supported to make the changes or taken over by the LA as that’s 3 in the last 2 years closed down so people can’t go home as no care packages and now can’t go into residential as no bed available, honestly frightening and I work in healthcare and am training to be a nurse currently

Cavviesarethebest · 27/10/2022 21:29

It’s womens work.

it’s really that simple.

most people expect women to do it for nothing you only need to read the threads on here of women being expected to care after their and their husbands elderly parents whilst smiling all the time

moonypadfootprongs · 27/10/2022 21:25

M2551 · 27/10/2022 21:10

I don't have personal experience but isn't care for the person cared for highly expensive?
I'll sound naive, but shouldn't that result in a decent pay for the carer?

There are huge expenses involved. Nobody is making money from care (despite what many think). The admin, insurance, consumables not to mention fuel prices. Most carers receive minimum wage and often are not properly reimbursed for their travel cost let alone the time spent traveling.

MegGriffinshat · 27/10/2022 21:18

When I tell people I work in a care home, their whole demeanour changes.

Dh didn’t believe me until he saw it for himself.

If I say that my occupation is my sideline of buying and selling antiques, people are interested in speaking to me, engage with me and treat me like a human.

If I say I am a care worker, they look through me, start talking slower, or I get the head tilt and the, “oh, that must be sooooooo rewarding” line, before they give me a pitying look and then ignore me. Or they just speak to me like I’m thick.

Untitledsquatboulder · 27/10/2022 21:12

HeddaGarbled · 27/10/2022 20:33

Other than the personal care (which I dislike and makes me anxious- there, I’ve said it)

Well, I think that’s the crux of it, isn’t it? Most people with choices, choose not to deal with other people’s urine & faeces multiple times a day.

I was going to say "yeah, that ^^" but actually I wouldn't mind nursing and there's plenty of excrement/ bodily fluids involved in that. I guess it's a vocation and one that's not for me.

I absolutely don't look down on those that do it though, and definitely would like to see pay and conditions in the sector rise substantially.

M2551 · 27/10/2022 21:10

I don't have personal experience but isn't care for the person cared for highly expensive?
I'll sound naive, but shouldn't that result in a decent pay for the carer?

Msgrieves · 27/10/2022 21:03

Tbh I have done care work, mostly hospitals and it was usually the other staff that pissed me off rather than the patients. Obviously some were a pita but most were fine.

I know there is a shortage, I have looked into getting back into it, no chance they seem to want the moon on a stick round here Confused