Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just Stop Oil's daily protests

431 replies

CatsAreAlwaysCute · 27/10/2022 16:09

Is anyone else concerned about where these daily protests will lead us?

The public are clearly getting more and more irritated by their antics. It's only a matter of time before one of the protestors are seriously injured.

I'm also worried that the government will ban certain types of protest as a result?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Liebig · 08/11/2022 18:25

If only someone would think to solve the thing that causes constant biosphere collapse stories.

No, not like that. Without curbing consumption, silly.

Daftasabroom · 08/11/2022 15:02

@BerriesOnTop I feel this way about urban air pollution to be honest, it’s really something that could be solved with the tools already at hand

Absolutely, the start-stop technology that turns an engine off and then on again when stationary has been around for well over twenty years, this would cover almost every vehicle on the road today and a blanket requirement would ensure no competitive disadvantage.

40,000 people die each year in the UK from diseases linked to particulate emissions.

Dotjones · 08/11/2022 14:58

Protests should be restricted to certain designated areas and be agreed with the police in advance.

The right of someone to protest is not greater than the right of the majority not to give a shit. If a cause is genuine, engage with people to get their agreement.

Climate protestors are incredibly selfish, not simply through their disruptive actions, but their whole end goal. They want a certain type of future for them and their children. But there's no rational argument for why they think their "right" to this specific type of future in 30 or 100 years is more "correct" than other people wanting the present to not be held to ransom for this future.

The earth will be fine. Climate change may cause the extinction of humanity in the next few thousand years. That's just nature following its course, a dominant species expands by exploiting the resources it has available until, eventually, those resources are no longer available and the species declines. We'll die out, other species will come along and replace us. Humans aren't "special" in that way.

BerriesOnTop · 08/11/2022 14:37

Daftasabroom · 08/11/2022 13:56

@LemonSwan The single most productive thing we can actually do is changes to agriculture to ensure permanent pastures and continuous ground covers.

Doesn't permanent pastures go against the general the general flow that meat and dairy are the arch enemies of sustainability?

Desertification and soil erosion is important but burning fossil fuels is responsible for roughly 3/4 of GHG emissions. We need to stop burning fossil fuels.

It’s actually really annoying how the monomania around carbon emissions means that legitimate problems are put on the backburner, so to speak.

I feel this way about urban air pollution to be honest, it’s really something that could be solved with the tools already at hand

LemonSwan · 08/11/2022 14:30

Yes your right. It’s the antithesis of current popular belief. Doesn’t make current thinking untrue. We can only react to what we have in this moment and most meat/diary isn’t that sustainable. Doesn’t mean gold standard meat and diary isn’t a huge part of the solution.

It doesn’t matter if there zero or 10x current carbon/ green house gases if we destroy the worlds greatest land cover category twice a year. It’s a huge sink which gets fucked. If you look at maps/ graphs of the worlds heat through the year you will see the spikes. It’s unreal. But the solution is simple. It will give you some hope. They have been working on this and making good progress in cop26 as they do get this is one of the main issues.

Its win win all round as this method reverses desertification, improves soil health, reduces water usage, chemical usage, improves biodiversity, support pollinators, farmer yields. In essence it’s creating a more resilient ecosystem.

Temperature is changing. We can’t stop that now even if we can potentially slow it but the effects won’t be instant. By ensuring our ecosystem is as healthy and resilient as it can be is the best chance we can give to flora and fauna to get through this. We can do that incredibly quickly. Grasslands are so fast to establish and repair.

And sure it’s not perfect; Some flora and fauna won’t make it, but without soil or pollinators no ones making it.

If you have Netflix there’s a documentary called kiss the ground which might run you through an intro about it all.

Daftasabroom · 08/11/2022 13:56

@LemonSwan The single most productive thing we can actually do is changes to agriculture to ensure permanent pastures and continuous ground covers.

Doesn't permanent pastures go against the general the general flow that meat and dairy are the arch enemies of sustainability?

Desertification and soil erosion is important but burning fossil fuels is responsible for roughly 3/4 of GHG emissions. We need to stop burning fossil fuels.

JenniferBooth · 08/11/2022 13:42

@Daftasabroom What i meant when i said that JSO have more in common with the Government than they like to think, is that both of them stopped people from seeing dying relatives.

JangolinaPitt · 08/11/2022 13:28

JenniferBooth · 07/11/2022 22:05

Her future has been stolen but not in the way she thinks

This

LemonSwan · 08/11/2022 13:27

Support. The majority of the country support moving towards green energy. Believe it or not - probably so do the government. We wouldn’t be dealing with Putins antics or held to ransom by the rich ME countries for a start.

As you can clearly see support isn’t good enough. Hence why they are shouting. Words are empty really when your trying to tackle a physical problem. Standing on a motorway sign so you can shout those words a little louder or wider doesn’t actually change that it’s just words.

I am saying how about they actually DO. I am sure if they focused on that a lot more people would join and with collective expertise, wisdom, funds etc we could potentially get something done.

And you can get sarky with me with HTH. Your only pissed off because you know what I am saying is true.

And if you really cared about the planet and the environmental instability/ green house gases etc you would know that oil is the tip of the iceberg. The single most productive thing we can actually do is changes to agriculture to ensure permanent pastures and continuous ground covers. The twice yearly shaving of the planet is like a bald mans head in Magaluf for a week in summer. Cooked to the point of permanent damage. Skin cancer for humans, desertification for soils.

This isn’t an area I am naive about. It’s my field.

YouSirNeighMmmm · 08/11/2022 13:20

LemonSwan · 08/11/2022 13:12

How about they actually propose a solution? And then work to that goal.

Community funded wind farms? Community green energy charitable organisations who sign up whole streets for a discount? Fund electric charging docks for cars?

Whatever it is I don’t mind but saying just don’t do this, and your not putting any energy into the solution is not solving the problem. And that’s why people roll their eyes. It’s got nothing to do with the actual topic. Voters do take green quite seriously but they want solutions, not catastrophised flapping.

I think that JSO support all things that would reduce reliance on carbon, with nuclear potentially being a point of contention. HTH.

LemonSwan · 08/11/2022 13:12

How about they actually propose a solution? And then work to that goal.

Community funded wind farms? Community green energy charitable organisations who sign up whole streets for a discount? Fund electric charging docks for cars?

Whatever it is I don’t mind but saying just don’t do this, and your not putting any energy into the solution is not solving the problem. And that’s why people roll their eyes. It’s got nothing to do with the actual topic. Voters do take green quite seriously but they want solutions, not catastrophised flapping.

YouSirNeighMmmm · 08/11/2022 13:08

CatsAreAlwaysCute · 27/10/2022 16:09

Is anyone else concerned about where these daily protests will lead us?

The public are clearly getting more and more irritated by their antics. It's only a matter of time before one of the protestors are seriously injured.

I'm also worried that the government will ban certain types of protest as a result?

I am very concerned that these protests are going to lead nowhere, because of idiot politicians refusing to listen to the science and play to moron voters who don;t see what's coming. I fear that Just Stop Oil need to become much more militant, brave and extreme in their protests.

LemonSwan · 08/11/2022 13:07

It’s not cynical or dismissive. And it is actually relevant that electricdreaming bought up feminism.

I myself got myself into a really bad cycle of focusing on the women’s/trans rights dilemma and really thought that everything was fucked. Yeah sure it’s fucked. But me catastrophising about it and taking up all my time, energy, thinking about it all the time and affecting my mental health does absolutely nothing about it.

The world will change as it’s ready. It’s not going to change at my pace because I want it to. I did receive mental health treatment for that and the panic and stress that I put myself under did lead to a psychosis of sorts. Not hearing voices or intrusive thoughts or anything but just all encompassing it was taking over my life and I couldn’t focus on anything else.

I am not being back handed when I say I hope she gets help. I really hope she does. She looks like a bright young thing. I am sure she has a bright future ahead of her.

antipodeancanary · 07/11/2022 22:23

JenniferBooth · 07/11/2022 22:05

Her future has been stolen but not in the way she thinks

Absolutely, she will never have a respectable job after this stunt and will be a laughing stock for the rest of her life.

Liebig · 07/11/2022 22:18

LemonSwan · 07/11/2022 21:44

I saw a young 24 yo girl crying in a video saying her future was stolen. Honestly at this stage it’s a mass psychosis.

Sure there’s an issue with fossil fuels and climate change. Everyone with a brain cell knows that. Is the problem resolved by someone holding hostage a motorway sign. No. Obviously not. For the simple reason it’s like blackmailing someone for £1 million when they have £112.93 in the bank.

I hope that girl gets the mental health help she needs. It’s clearly distressing to her. Her future isn’t stolen and she needs someone to guide her to something productive.

Why? What, in your mind, do you think happens when that girl is 50?

Daftasabroom · 07/11/2022 22:15

@LemonSwan
@JenniferBooth
@sashagabadon

I think your dismissive and cynical attitude reinforces the position of JSO and does nothing to counter it.

JenniferBooth · 07/11/2022 22:05

Her future has been stolen but not in the way she thinks

electricdreaming · 07/11/2022 22:04

lol @ the idea of mumsnetters talking about the risk of radicalisation/brainwashing and how hysterical JSO protestors are. Have a look at some of the topics on feminism board and talk to me about radicalisation x

sashagabadon · 07/11/2022 21:57

It does seem completely OTT. If she was my daughter I’d be very worried about who see is speaking to and the influence they have over her. It’s a kind of radicalisation imo. It is very likely She has a great future ahead of her and all this talk of no future is like she has been brainwashed.

LemonSwan · 07/11/2022 21:44

I saw a young 24 yo girl crying in a video saying her future was stolen. Honestly at this stage it’s a mass psychosis.

Sure there’s an issue with fossil fuels and climate change. Everyone with a brain cell knows that. Is the problem resolved by someone holding hostage a motorway sign. No. Obviously not. For the simple reason it’s like blackmailing someone for £1 million when they have £112.93 in the bank.

I hope that girl gets the mental health help she needs. It’s clearly distressing to her. Her future isn’t stolen and she needs someone to guide her to something productive.

MichelleScarn · 07/11/2022 21:37

GreenNewDealNow · 07/11/2022 21:06

I support their protests. Why are there so many climate deniers here?

Do you think because people don't agree with their ridiculous and dangerous stunts that makes them climate change deniers?

MaxTalk · 07/11/2022 21:35

So do they have an actual workable plan and a solution that has been properly costed or are they just getting upset like a bunch of babies?

Fair play if it is the former but I fear it's the latter.

GreenNewDealNow · 07/11/2022 21:06

I support their protests. Why are there so many climate deniers here?

JenniferBooth · 07/11/2022 19:51

Hmm Just Stop Oil have more in common with the Government than theyd like to think

electricdreaming · 07/11/2022 19:38

MichelleScarn · 07/11/2022 19:17

Look at all those comments didn't see one in support of JSO and they still think people agree with them?

Not sure if Twitter filters the comments based on what they think you want to see but on mine the very top comment is in support of them:

Just Stop Oil's daily protests