Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just Stop Oil's daily protests

431 replies

CatsAreAlwaysCute · 27/10/2022 16:09

Is anyone else concerned about where these daily protests will lead us?

The public are clearly getting more and more irritated by their antics. It's only a matter of time before one of the protestors are seriously injured.

I'm also worried that the government will ban certain types of protest as a result?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Liebig · 09/11/2022 19:31

I didn't assume that, because:

"I've often thought that if we all refused to buy petrol on an agreed date each week..."

You literally said that.

So now you've moved the goalposts, you meant to say "let's just use less petrol". I mean, that's kinda what I've been saying anyway. But given you still need to use fossil fuels to build out any such infrastructure replacement, it won't change anything any time soon.

That's where the energy trap comes in. We need a certain amount of fossil fuels, x, to keep the lights on. We also need to dedicate a proportion to building the replacement infrastructure for when the FFs run out, y. This all comes from a total energy production of z which also has the excess we use for discretionary stuff, like education, leisure, healthcare, military.

If x is approaching z, then that means y can only be satisfied by either growing z or cutting back on the requirements of x and/or y. And decline is ongoing while this is happening, so the longer this is postponed, the harsher the correction.

And unlike climate change emissions targets which we keep putting off year on year, this will be forced on us. Nature does not offer overdraft facilities: you either have the energy or you don't.

sagalooshoe · 09/11/2022 19:18

Liebig · 09/11/2022 19:10

I have to explain this?

Okay. You don't buy petrol this week. What are you doing next week? I bet, if you drive in a car, buying petrol.

Oh no, those poor oil companies. They go a week with fewer sales, then get a bumper sales week after it. Genius plan.

Oh I seeeeeee - you assumed the date for staying away from petrol station was about purchasing less petrol?

No. You think in very simplistic ways.

It would purely be an en masse show of support from people who want to see a change in how we power our vehicles in order to reduce our impact on climate and environment. Of course it would only send a message if it were regular and in vast numbers. Otherwise it would be a total waste of time.
I'd have a hydrogen car (or whatever the best equivalent is) right now if they were sustainable, available and affordable.

Liebig · 09/11/2022 19:10

sagalooshoe · 09/11/2022 18:24

😆no not me - I'm not the chain mail type.

Quite condescending though aren't you. Go on then - why won't it work clever clogs?

I have to explain this?

Okay. You don't buy petrol this week. What are you doing next week? I bet, if you drive in a car, buying petrol.

Oh no, those poor oil companies. They go a week with fewer sales, then get a bumper sales week after it. Genius plan.

Liebig · 09/11/2022 19:09

@BerriesOnTop

You are conflating two things. One is the investment to extract fossil fuels. No one is running out of oil, natural gas or coal (or uranium for that matter). But extraction and processing needs a level of investment that hasn’t come through because of political reasons (and the big funds horrendous ESG strategies). Big oil just came through several difficult years due to the lack of demand during Covid (and the price war between Saudi and Russia). And China has the coal, but again there was a crunch for political reasons, not for supply reasons.

You’ve mentioned peak oil, but your third sentence shows that you don’t actually know what it is.

No one is going to “run out of oil”. That’s not what it means at all. What it does mean is hitting a production peak as all available efforts to increase output fail. Like has been happening since 2018, where investment with a high price market was doing well after the low points of the 2014 slump caused by the fracking market being attacked by OPEC+.

Using Rystad Energy data, you can see in the first figure attached, that out of all oil producing nations, only 23 have produced more than they were doing in 2017, while 65 have lost production regardless of investment, some quite catastrophically. In fact, since the 2018 peak, they are now a combined 5 Mbpd below it and over 7 Mbpd from their combined all time high peaks. Sixty percent of all oil production comes from the 23 gainers in this scenario.

And your ESG bogeyman isn’t the blame. This is simple geology. Has been for decades.

www.offshore-energy.biz/oil-gas-discoveries-in-2021-to-hit-lowest-level-in-75-years-rystad-says/

Remember, oil was doing gangbusters until 2020, then an unsteady 2021, but they’ve been well above average price ranges of late the past twelve months. And yet, nothing has radically changed. Because this was the state of things before the pandemic. It isn’t ESG or COVID that has caused this at all.

China indeed has the coal, as does Russia. Thing is, they don’t want to go back to a state where they literally had several thousand people die per day because of smog. Another poster mentioned particulate health matters. Apparently you’re okay with breathing toxic air. I’m not.

As for nuclear, the reason we don't have more is because it's not cost economical without massive gov't subsidies. And if we did have the number of reactors needed to replace all FF produced energy, we'd be running seriously short of fissile material within a short time too. Thorium may extend that, but doesn't drastically change the final outcome even if it worked.

Natural gas is the least dirty of the two and also the most expensive to transport without pipelines to local users, but oil is basically the premier energy source and coal is getting a resurgence because idiots like Merkel went all in on the Energiewende, or they railed against nuclear. At the end of the day, fossil fuels power the world.

But they are getting more expensive. There are no more oil deposits at $10/bbl. Those barrels have been used. All the cheap energy has gone. Exxon just made a discovery literally today in Guyana, a finding of 11 billion barrels, or less than a third of a year’s global usage. Not that that matters, given it will only be able to output at under 1 Mbpd, akin to getting the Euromillions winning ticket, but only being able to withdraw £100 a day. Useless.


Now that Big Oil has record profits that should be plowed back into extraction and refinement—and would be, if not for politicians wanting to place windfall taxes that are not going to get to the people who need money to heat their homes or turn on the lights.

Except they’re not doing that. There’s too much volatility. There’s a reason no one is building refineries, and it’s because it’s not cost economic. The price they need to charge is higher than the consumer is willing to buy as the gap has narrowed over the last few years. There is zero reason to invest in such ventures, hence dividend payouts instead.


I cannot believe you do not value modern civilisation—without it hundreds of millions of people could die due to lack of food and heating, even more would die because they can no longer protect themselves from climate-related disasters.


People like you need to be placed very very far from the levers of power. Or maybe you can just destroy Europe … as a cautionary tale.

Firstly, I never said any such thing. I said civilisation was a mistake, not that I don’t appreciate it. It’s awesome that I can get a hot shower whenever I want and watch global events from a small black mirror in the palm of my hand.

But I’m also not a moron who thinks infinity exists outside of human stupidity. Your fossil fuels will run out, sooner than you think, and even if they didn’t, other things will certainly produce the Liebig minimum: the point where the limiting factor stopping economic growth becomes very evident.

One of those outside of other minerals or water or food, is simply the energy cost of energy. The oil industry now consumer 15.5% of all net energy produced. Net energy is the only reason any kind of civilisation can exist. Subsistence farming did not produce much excessive wealth outside of the elites.

www.researchgate.net/publication/354885905_Peak_oil_and_the_low-carbon_energy_transition_A_net-energy_perspective

To quote the authors:

“… either the global energy transition takes place quickly enough, or we risk a worsening of climate change, a historical and long-term recession due to energy deficits (at least for some regions of the globe), or a combination of several of these problems.”

I’m guessing you’ve not cracked open any ecology textbooks. Are you aware of Matthew Island? You see, while you can sit there and say I’m condemning people to a less prosperous life, I’m here trying to stop people like you from putting their foot on the accelerator when all signs point to a cliff.

You either willingly want to destroy the world through climate change by embracing the most energy dense and most polluting sources of said energy, or you don’t even understand a thing about thermodynamics and what overshoot is.

Just Stop Oil's daily protests
Just Stop Oil's daily protests
Just Stop Oil's daily protests
sagalooshoe · 09/11/2022 18:24

Liebig · 09/11/2022 18:18

So you’re who forwards those chain e-mails.

Maybe think about it for just a few seconds and you’ll see why that won’t work.

😆no not me - I'm not the chain mail type.

Quite condescending though aren't you. Go on then - why won't it work clever clogs?

Liebig · 09/11/2022 18:18

sagalooshoe · 09/11/2022 17:32

I've often thought that if we all refused to buy petrol on an agreed date each week then the collective voice of the masses might put the frighteners on the oil companies and make them listen.
Why can't JSO and extinction rebellion organise that instead of trying to get run over all the time.

So you’re who forwards those chain e-mails.

Maybe think about it for just a few seconds and you’ll see why that won’t work.

sagalooshoe · 09/11/2022 17:32

DahliaRose3 · 09/11/2022 12:03

But we can make a difference, and it seems no one is listening to the experts & there is no urgency from our govs. It seems to be primarily about keeping the rich rich, and the companies ruining our planet even richer. No consequences for the damage they do. Even governments aren’t held to account - Bolsonaro for example. Damaging the Brazilian rainforest without a care.

People are annoyed by some delays from protesters, but in the grand scale of things what is more important? Earth prob won’t around in 4 years time & that’s not including the famine and horrific natural disasters to come & subsequent deaths.

Individually we can make a difference by not buying clothing from Shein for example or reducing plastic consumption for a start. Even things like disposable nappies, balloons, creating unnecessary waste (party plates, more plastic).

If we ALL (not emergency staff) just pooled together for one day demanding action from our gov & corps it would make a difference.

Sitting around makes no difference. What else could possibly be more pressing? The reason people in the U.K. aren’t that bothered is because we haven’t been affected in a big way yet. But once the shit hits the fan & is at our front doors we will have a very different outcome!

I've often thought that if we all refused to buy petrol on an agreed date each week then the collective voice of the masses might put the frighteners on the oil companies and make them listen.
Why can't JSO and extinction rebellion organise that instead of trying to get run over all the time.

Dave20 · 09/11/2022 17:12

Hears what the haulage industry should be saying;

Dear Mayor of London/Departmen of Transport,

With immediate effect, we shall not be delivering goods to anywhere within the M25, as we cannot guarantee that our drivers won’t get stuck there.

We cannot afford the huge financial losses , including overtime and over night stays due to drivers going over hours.

We are also concerned for the welfare of our drivers, including comfort breaks, meal breaks and our unions have raised this concern as a matter of urgency.
However we will re-consider this if you can guarantee to reimburse us for any losses due to ‘Just stop oil’

Regards,

Haulage industry.

Loics · 09/11/2022 14:47

Dave20 · 09/11/2022 12:29

Imagine if lorries stop trucks deliveries to places within the M25 because of their drivers getting stuck and paying the overtime for them.
Haulage companies will either refuse to go there or pass the losses of earnings to the customers.

Guess what?.. As a truck driver I guarantee you all that you’re all paying more now as a direct result of these types of delays.

Loss of earnings, missed deliveries, paying the stranded hgv drivers.

@Dave20 With the amount of drivers getting infringements and having to unexpectedly night out due to these stunts, I wouldn't blame them.

BerriesOnTop · 09/11/2022 14:30

@Liebig

You are conflating two things. One is the investment to extract fossil fuels. No one is running out of oil, natural gas or coal (or uranium for that matter). But extraction and processing needs a level of investment that hasn’t come through because of political reasons (and the big funds horrendous ESG strategies). Big oil just came through several difficult years due to the lack of demand during Covid (and the price war between Saudi and Russia). And China has the coal, but again there was a crunch for political reasons, not for supply reasons.

Now that Big Oil has record profits that should be plowed back into extraction and refinement—and would be, if not for politicians wanting to place windfall taxes that are not going to get to the people who need money to heat their homes or turn on the lights.

I cannot believe you do not value modern civilisation—without it hundreds of millions of people could die due to lack of food and heating, even more would die because they can no longer protect themselves from climate-related disasters.

People like you need to be placed very very far from the levers of power. Or maybe you can just destroy Europe … as a cautionary tale.

BigFatLiar · 09/11/2022 14:24

There's a bit saying that James Whale was stuck in the jam and missed his cancer treatment appointment.

For many it's more than a little inconvenience.

Tara336 · 09/11/2022 14:10

My dad is very ill. I live 120 miles away and need to use the M25 to get to my DPs home, these pricks hanging off gantries could potentially stop me reaching my parents when I'm needed. I'm just one person of many being affected by this. I care about the problems we are facing but JSO don't have my support what they are doing is alienating people.

Devoutspoken · 09/11/2022 13:58

Are the facts abolutely verified about cause of accident, because it could of been various reasons, lorries are dangerous too

BigFatLiar · 09/11/2022 13:56

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 09/11/2022 13:42

Imagine thinking that you have a choice

As far as I'm concerned I do and I'll take what I've got, thanks. I know how some of my ancesters lived and my desire to go back to that is precisely zero.

It all started to go wrong when we came down from the trees.

JenniferBooth · 09/11/2022 13:47

If you listed to what happened to Tony he explains that an ambulance with its blue lights on was caught up in the same jam

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 09/11/2022 13:42

Imagine thinking that you have a choice

As far as I'm concerned I do and I'll take what I've got, thanks. I know how some of my ancesters lived and my desire to go back to that is precisely zero.

Liebig · 09/11/2022 13:38

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 09/11/2022 13:20

and the other option leads to just ending modern civilisation

I do like the use of the word 'just' in that sentence. As if increased life spans, massively decreased child mortality, massively increased personal wealth, increased health, education and human rights (to name a few) are us being spoiled brats and we ought to be happy to revert to a pre-industrial existence and give it all up.

Imagine thinking that you have a choice

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 09/11/2022 13:30

I think the same will one day be said about climate activists

I think climate activists will be one paragraph, if that. Especially if they and their juvenile antics kick off a backlash.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 09/11/2022 13:23

It will just take one driver who’s having a bad day to mow them down and TBH I’d have no sympathy for them.

JenniferBooth · 09/11/2022 13:21

twitter.com/BBCEssex/status/1590029700750987264?s=20&t=-W5tLIsmeiIwBvejjxlbgA

BBC Essex
@BBCEssex
·
20h
"I will never, ever forgive these people." bbc.in/3EgSD1J
Tony missed his father's funeral in Pitsea - where he was due to be a pallbearer - because of protestors on the M25 on Monday.
Full story on BBC Sounds, click the link above.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 09/11/2022 13:20

and the other option leads to just ending modern civilisation

I do like the use of the word 'just' in that sentence. As if increased life spans, massively decreased child mortality, massively increased personal wealth, increased health, education and human rights (to name a few) are us being spoiled brats and we ought to be happy to revert to a pre-industrial existence and give it all up.

Liebig · 09/11/2022 13:13

@BerriesOnTop

Yeah, and having a child die within the first few years of life was a nearly universal experience. The common man lived miserably, worse than people in developing countries today.

Civilisation has generally been a bad idea. I agree.

We have plenty of fossil fuels, no one talks about peak oil anymore.

Uh, what. We still haven’t broken November 2018’s production peak. OPEC+ is reducing output as Saudi is unable to keep pumping at present rates. Most of OPEC+ is nosediving, and Russia is certainly up shit creek. The US is running out of decent plays in the Permian and other shale fields, and even if they had them, they have manpower and supply issues and CAPEX restrictions.

Where are you getting your information from?

The world is short natural gas. China is unable to get enough coal to run its economy, a state it’s been in since 2021.

And all this is predicated on you ignoring that there’s this thing called climate change, so having access to (relatively) cheap fossil energy is negated by, oh, the biosphere collapsing.

You seem unable to actually grasp that I’m not promoting a view because, lol, let’s all freeze and starve. And telling you that one option leads to destroying the planet, and the other option leads to just ending modern civilisation.

What’s your choice? Guessing the former. Sure your kids will thank you in the water wars.

BerriesOnTop · 09/11/2022 12:52

Humans were 100% renewable energy for way longer

Yeah, and having a child die within the first few years of life was a nearly universal experience. The common man lived miserably, worse than people in developing countries today.

What, pray tell, do you suppose we use to continue endless economic growth

We have plenty of fossil fuels, no one talks about peak oil anymore.

Its like you don’t even care about poverty in the developing world. East Asia industrialised, and the standard of living shot up, child mortality went down, life expectancy went up. China lifted more people out of poverty than any regime in history.

The developing world needs more fossil fuels, not less.

If Europe wants to impoverish itself with unreliable energy, fine. I guess it’s your choice to experience cold, death and hunger like humans did when they were 100% renewable energy 🙄

Liebig · 09/11/2022 12:37

BerriesOnTop · 09/11/2022 12:07

lol what you lot want to do is pretty fucking far from improve. You demonstrably want to
lower our living standards and want us to
use inferior forms of energy.

Improve indeed …

Turns out the reason industrial civilisation came about was because of a practically free mega boost of energy courtesy of the sun millions of years in the making. Humans were 100% renewable energy for way longer.

What, pray tell, do you suppose we use to continue endless economic growth or even to keep us at the same levels today without fossil fuels? Give me your roadmap.

Dave20 · 09/11/2022 12:30

Can companies take out private prosecutions against the protesters for loss of earnings? Serious question.

Swipe left for the next trending thread