Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think countryside people are condescending and moany all the time?

193 replies

Keyansier · 27/10/2022 13:48

Does anyone else think this too? Partly stemming from the story about the people who are trying to ban weddings from being held in their village and putting up signs like "Bride and Grooms not welcome here" in order to dampen their big day and ruin their wedding photos.

People who live in cities know how to share and live alongside people. Yes, tourists can be annoying but we don't scream at them (well I don't, anyway) or tell them they are not welcome and to go away. Yet people in the country think this is perfectly acceptable and not rude behaviour. And they constantly make awful comments about cities and city living and how they would rather die than live somewhere so busy but then when there is a lot of rainfall and their places are flooded they shriek and moan that people aren't helping them fast enough for their liking.

They literally think just because they live in the countryside that they own the countryside and get to say who can go there and what can happen there. And if you're "unfamiliar" they were literally stare at you. AIBU to think this is entitled behaviour and very annoying?

OP posts:
FortheBeautyoftheEarth · 27/10/2022 20:46

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Meseekslookatme · 27/10/2022 19:18

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 27/10/2022 17:39

Lol if you think city folk are all tolerant and lovely to tourists go and stand on the wrong side of the escalator on the tube at rush hour!

To be fair there are signs every couple of metres about that, you'd have to be a bit daft to miss them.

TomTraubertsBlues · 27/10/2022 19:13

Downdaysoon · 27/10/2022 18:53

Regarding etiquette, can I ask how to know which fields are allowed to be walked through ( on the path of course). I'm never sure if I'm allowed to enter a field. Thank you

Ordnance survey maps show the rights of way and the access land.

Alternatively, if you see a fingerpost saying "footpath" or "bridleway" on it, that will indicate a right of way.

Downdaysoon · 27/10/2022 18:53

CaronPoivre · 27/10/2022 14:17

Hah. Maybe it's because some of us do own the countryside, or parts of it.

Maybe my dear, townies don't respect the guardianship of the land entrusted to those who own or manage the land and ignore basis etiquette.

Perhaps, sweetheart, rural dwellers want to be able to go about their business undisturbed by tourists or people who damage much and bring nothing. Brides filling village churches with helium balloons or leaving a once pretty but now rotting flower arch for someone else to remove. Perhaps rural dwellers don't want the green destroyed by 4x4 tyre ruts or be unable to get their cars past the many selfish parkers.

Regarding etiquette, can I ask how to know which fields are allowed to be walked through ( on the path of course). I'm never sure if I'm allowed to enter a field. Thank you

Wonderifitsme · 27/10/2022 18:29

I have lived in London/other cities and spent 15 years on a remote farm, married to a farmer.

I think to some extent it depends on ‘how rural’. Rural Cambridgeshire I found people to be open, friendly, kind, etc. The far more remote part of the UK….I recognise pp comment that ‘ People are much more likely to be conservative with a small and big c, mildly racist/xenophobic, wary of outsiders and not very good with change’.

sweeping generalisation yes, but like I say, I recognise it.

SpookyMcGhoul · 27/10/2022 18:13

Such a great thread 😂

I'm rural, I don't dislike city people in general - I've lived in both!

I dislike anyone who's rude, doesn't understand the country side code, leaves gates open, doesn't know what a footpath is, leaves rubbish etc or is just generally rude. Be they city or country folk!

gogohmm · 27/10/2022 18:09

I read that article on the wedding venue, the licence was extended from 2 x per week to 6 x per week, imagine 6 nights a week loud music until 12 then people noisily exiting, traffic everywhere at midnight, that's without the people urinating in their gardens or frightening their horses.

They aren't being miserable, they are at the end of their tethers.

I have second home owners and holiday makers here, mostly they are nice but the whinging in Waitrose that some specialist ingredient available in the Kensington branch wasn't stocked makes me want to shout then go back to London!

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 27/10/2022 17:39

Lol if you think city folk are all tolerant and lovely to tourists go and stand on the wrong side of the escalator on the tube at rush hour!

Cremombuly · 27/10/2022 17:36

But also, if you are walking across a field with any kind of livestock in, it's common sense to have your dog on a lead.

I disagree completely. The reason my dog is so good with livestock is because he's been taught to walk through fields of them and learn self-control. It means when we suddenly encounter sheep or cows that have escaped from a field and are where they shouldn't be (which happens frequently), it doesn't occur to him to chase them.

For anyone who's interested, the screenshot sums up the rules.

To think countryside people are condescending and moany all the time?
XingMing · 27/10/2022 17:31

It's a spectator sport @RampantIvy , akin to bear baiting!

RampantIvy · 27/10/2022 17:29

Ex Londoner here, now living in a village.

I can’t believe the rubbish that has been spouted on here.
I grew up in South London and worked in the City and the West end before moving to Yorkshire. I have met and lived near nice people in London, Leeds and rural South Yorkshire.

I don’t recognise anything in your post that happens where I live. We don’t have any of the problems that people post about on mumsnet about where they live – horrible neighbours, parking issues, high crime rates. A lot of people in our village are originally from other parts of the country so we don’t get the small-minded mentality that is often talked about on here.

I would say the main downside of living where we do is the lack of public transport.

And they constantly make awful comments about cities and city living

Erm, aren’t you doing the same about country living?

I tend to find townies on threads like this as condescending and xenophobic about the people they are complaining about. My family in South London were embarrassing uneducated about life outside of London.

Rural folk are weirdos in my experience. Closed-minded.

Back at you @RambamThankyouMam

What do you hope to achieve by starting such a goady and ignorant thread @Keyansier?

EndlessMagpies · 27/10/2022 17:29

They literally think just because they live in the countryside that they own the countryside

I've got news for you. They literally do own the countryside.

TomTraubertsBlues · 27/10/2022 17:27

Cremombuly · 27/10/2022 17:25

I do understand about access land. I'm talking specifically about on footpaths where there is a public right of way and where, from googling, there doesn't seem to be a legal requirement to leash your dog.

You stick to the ROW and follow the rules of the landowner. Simple as that.

But also, if you are walking across a field with any kind of livestock in, it's common sense to have your dog on a lead.

Cremombuly · 27/10/2022 17:25

TomTraubertsBlues · 27/10/2022 17:13

If you're in a field with livestock, e.g. sheep, why would you risk having your dog off lead?

You know the farmer can shoot it if it chases the sheep, right? If you care about your dog, why would you risk that.

Also, yes - it is legally enforceable. Things like the CROW Act give rights to humans, not dogs. The landowner can place any conditions they want on your dog, and being on a lead seems a fairly reasonable one.

I do understand about access land. I'm talking specifically about on footpaths where there is a public right of way and where, from googling, there doesn't seem to be a legal requirement to leash your dog.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 27/10/2022 17:19

Some paths are also permissive paths, rather than actual ROW- on these, obviously landowners can impose any restrictions that they like.

Bookishish · 27/10/2022 17:17

You get twats everywhere, unfortunately. They are pervasive.

Brokendaughter · 27/10/2022 17:16

In my experience, having both lived in the country & in cities, country people don't rock up to city peoples homes, plant themselves in their gardens for a picnic, bang on their doors & demand to use their toilets, start playing football or some other game in their front garden, set their dogs on other animals then complain if the livestock owner isn't okay with it or treat the place like a toilet even though cities often look like one.

There are plenty of people who live in cities who are capable of visiting the countryside without acting like an idiot, however a small but significant amount shit on beaches, whinge about litter they drop, trespass & generally act like they have no brains at all.

What is the awful thing that people who live in the countryside do when they visit cities?
Blow their noses a lot because the levels of pollution mean you can smell London from 50 miles away?
Don't hide their shock at the appallingly high cost, low quality fruit & veg on sale in the supermarkets there?
Look really happy they get to go home?

Can't recall the news stories about those terrible country people causing the deaths of city animals, blocking businesses so they can't make a living, or any other other foul behaviour that is standard in country areas where 'city tourists' regularly despoil the environment.

The countryside does not exist for your twitter/insta/whatever photo ops & it isn't all public land.

TomTraubertsBlues · 27/10/2022 17:15

The thing to remember is - if you are in a farmer's field, you're not in a public place like a park or a town square, you are on someone else's land.

You have the legal right to use a right of way to cross that land, but you don't really have any other rights. If they say dogs on the lead, that's their call.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 27/10/2022 17:15

Cremombuly · 27/10/2022 17:09

Just to clarify because I've seen dogs and livestock mentioned a few times here:
I live in the country and stick to the footpaths but encounter a fair few signs with demands to "keep your dog on the lead." This isn't legally enforceable, is it? Am I right in thinking there's no legal requirement to do this so long as your dog is under control and not attacking the other animals?

Under the Countryside and Rights of Way Act 2000, on 'access land', dogs must be kept on a lead that's no more than two metres long at all times around livestock. Between March and July, dogs should also be on leads to protect nesting birds.

So, depending on the type of land and animals present, it can be legally enforceable.

TomTraubertsBlues · 27/10/2022 17:13

Cremombuly · 27/10/2022 17:09

Just to clarify because I've seen dogs and livestock mentioned a few times here:
I live in the country and stick to the footpaths but encounter a fair few signs with demands to "keep your dog on the lead." This isn't legally enforceable, is it? Am I right in thinking there's no legal requirement to do this so long as your dog is under control and not attacking the other animals?

If you're in a field with livestock, e.g. sheep, why would you risk having your dog off lead?

You know the farmer can shoot it if it chases the sheep, right? If you care about your dog, why would you risk that.

Also, yes - it is legally enforceable. Things like the CROW Act give rights to humans, not dogs. The landowner can place any conditions they want on your dog, and being on a lead seems a fairly reasonable one.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 27/10/2022 17:09

People coming to the countryside and staying in air bnbs increasingly don't offer anything to the local economy, and actively push people who have grown up in these communities out.

So what does being polite and welcoming get us?

It's different to when people would come to stay in hotels or caravan parks and eat out regularly, and they weren't staying in space that could instead be someone's home. Many people who stay in air bnbs spend a lot less in the local community, park in spaces that then can't be used by residents, and are occupying a flat or house that could otherwise be used to house a local worker or family.

And then you get visitors moaning about poor service etc when they do go out- not understanding that businesses struggle to recruit staff due to high local housing costs.

So what benefit is there in being nice to visitors at this stage?

And yes, as PP said to trespassing etc, and treating livestock as a tourist attraction, not as a living animal which a) you can hurt and b) can hurt you.

Cremombuly · 27/10/2022 17:09

Just to clarify because I've seen dogs and livestock mentioned a few times here:
I live in the country and stick to the footpaths but encounter a fair few signs with demands to "keep your dog on the lead." This isn't legally enforceable, is it? Am I right in thinking there's no legal requirement to do this so long as your dog is under control and not attacking the other animals?

CheeseCakeSunflowers · 27/10/2022 17:06

The majority of the countryside is privately owned so yes many people who live there do indeed own parts of it. Some people think that just because there is a public right of way across some bits that this turns it into public land. It doesn't it just means you have the right to walk on that bit. Strange how generalising about certain groups can be seen as being racist or ageist etc. Is countrysideist a word I wonder?

Brieandcamembert · 27/10/2022 17:01

They literally think just because they live in the countryside that they own the countryside
**
People who live in the countryside often do literally own the countryside, though.

This hits the nail on the head. I live in "the countryside" but my neighbours own pretty much everything I can see. They aren't just fields they are someone's land. They aren't cute sheep to make the area look nice, they are someone's livelihood.

DashboardConfessional · 27/10/2022 17:00

My faves are the people who live in the posh villages round my not-posh town, who complain there are no affordable housing options for their kids but oppose anything new being built between them and us.