Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mothers of boys -some of you are not helping

334 replies

iamjustwinginglife · 27/10/2022 12:06

I'm sure there are numerous mums to boys who don't treat their sons like little princes and ensure they help out around the house however I'm not sure some mums are helping their boys to grow up in to decent men...and this is why we find Mumsnet full of posts about useless husbands who don't pull their weight at home.

Last night, I had a car full of teenagers all 17 (2 x boys, 2 x girls) and one of the boy's parents had come back from holiday. "It's nice to have them back, I won't need to clean up after myself anymore." Now, they're all good kids, it was just chatter-so I suggested that he carried on cleaning up after himself even though they were back. His reply was "mum likes looking after me, she says it's her job as a mum to make sure she looks after me and gives me everything I want." My child thought that sounded like a great idea-and I bit my tongue to not point out that some mums (me!!) were driving round the countryside at 1am.

This mum works part-time, the children are 17 and 20 and she's obviously got the time to do it but AIBU to think that allowing children to true up thinking they'll be waited in hand and foot isn't really helping them in future life.

OP posts:
YeahmetooJill · 27/10/2022 14:13

SuperCamp · 27/10/2022 12:10

Dads, of course, should continue lounging around with their feet in the coffee table waiting for a cup of tea, while Mum runs Boys Bootcamp in the kitchen.

(my boys never expected a lift late at night, they walked, got the night bus, or an Uber)

This. OP, you are not really making a brave stand for equality and against the patriarchy whilst you are laying the blame all at the feet of mothers.

But yes. The job of parents is to teach their children the skills they need, including domestic, to be independent and take care of themselves.

Darbs76 · 27/10/2022 14:12

I enjoy looking after both my kids whilst they are in my home. That doesn’t mean they can’t look after themselves, my 18yr old son has gone to Uni and is home cooking every evening. He’s more than capable. I work full time and I do encourage my kids to cook, my DD prefers to cook her own meals. My DS was happy for me to cook for him and I had no problem doing that.

Conkersareback · 27/10/2022 14:12

iamjustwinginglife · 27/10/2022 14:11

@poseyroseyy Thank you! Nowhere do I say "all" but you'd think I'd made this post about all boys and all mums!

I also think the "some of you" is not a great thing to say! It's very accusatory and excludes your parenting, but of course that is probably perfect.

iamjustwinginglife · 27/10/2022 14:11

@poseyroseyy Thank you! Nowhere do I say "all" but you'd think I'd made this post about all boys and all mums!

OP posts:
iamjustwinginglife · 27/10/2022 14:09

Ablababla · 27/10/2022 14:02

I have come across this opinion that this is what being a mum is and that you should let them enjoy being young etc. it’s not just parents of boys though mums with girls also do this.

personally I haven’t got the time and it’s not what I see as my job. My job is to raise competent adults.

I agree and they can't be competent whilst waiting for A PARENT (let's face it, it's usually the mum!!) to wait on them and clean up after them.

OP posts:
Lalalolol · 27/10/2022 14:07

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 27/10/2022 12:12

Why is it always the mothers fault?

Because mother wants to clean up after him, not dad.
It's true that usually its mothers who spoil their sons, hence we see so many mother in law threads, and sons not being able to create boundaries. How often we see a thread where father in law is commenting on parenting of daughter in law?

BettyB0Op · 27/10/2022 14:07

I’d like to think I’m raising my boys to just be decent humans, I’m not necessarily focused on making sure they become decent husbands for someone else. They are polite, hard working and respectful boys who know wrong from right. I think we all have a responsibility to ensure our children are capable of taking care of themselves and prepare them for adulthood, that’s obvious and stands for both sexes. But we will pick those boys up regardless of time from anywhere, my husband was severely beaten by a random group of boys on a night out when he was in his late teens and essentially left for dead. It does happen and for me absolutely not worth the risk for a lesson on independence.

poseyroseyy · 27/10/2022 14:06

I think the OP has a point.

How many posts are on here about overbearing MILs and how their sons don't defend the partner. So many times posters will tell the OP 'you've got a DH problem he needs to have your back' etc etc. you don't often get a post about an overbearing FIL do you?
There are rarely posts saying 'my wife doesn't help me around the house, my wife doesn't help with child care' etc. it's normally the men / boys.
Nearly all enmeshment posts on here are about the mothers and their sons.

I'm not saying it doesn't happen for girls. But it's not near as common (not including the fact girls can be treated like princesses and end up being spoilt brats.)

If a mum decides to treat her son on hand and foot and doesn't bring them up doing their bit around the house, especially if they're a full time SAHM, then the mothers do get more blame than the dads. The dads aren't really going to come home to their wives and be like 'let's make sure our son doesn't do any washing, let's practice gentle parenting and we won't ever raise our voice, and when they misbehave we reassure them that they're expressing their feelings'. It 9 times out of ten comes from the mothers.

Again, the above isn't exclusive. It can and does include fathers and daughters. But the term 'mummies boy' didn't come from nowhere.

I'll probs get flamed for this but it's my opinion, but I agree OP. But you mention anything like this it'll hit a nerve because of course you're being obtusely sexist even though you've clarified many times it's not just the mums Grin

miceonabranch · 27/10/2022 14:06

Mine is scrubbing the bathroom floor with a toothbrush as we speak.

Whatsleftnow · 27/10/2022 14:03

I know quite a number of men who are considered “useless” in one way or another, and women who are quick to blame them on other women. But I have never, ever heard a man blame another man’s mother/sister/daughter; it’s always laid straight at the man’s feet.

Ablababla · 27/10/2022 14:02

I have come across this opinion that this is what being a mum is and that you should let them enjoy being young etc. it’s not just parents of boys though mums with girls also do this.

personally I haven’t got the time and it’s not what I see as my job. My job is to raise competent adults.

bringincrazyback · 27/10/2022 14:01

theydontspeakforus · 27/10/2022 12:07

Ok thanks OP I'll get right on that.

Why the sarcasm? It's perfectly possible to nurture young people differently so they don't grow up with these expectations/assumptions.

Topgub · 27/10/2022 14:00

@PurpleWisteria1

I dont think cave women (if thars what you mean by evolution) were running comfortable homes

I think its far more about socialisation than evolution

Its also possible to 'raise babies' and have a career.

Thelnebriati · 27/10/2022 13:58

"mum likes looking after me, she says it's her job as a mum to make sure she looks after me and gives me everything I want."

He said that. It does not mean he is telling the truth - but you jump straight in with believing him and blaming his mother, without thinking about the role Dads or society play in raising boys to be men.

LeMoo · 27/10/2022 13:55

PurpleWisteria1 · 27/10/2022 13:49

People don’t generally like the answer to this because it doesn’t fit in with the vaneer of modern society.
The answer is evolution of humans. We think we are so superior and far above our base instincts. But scrape away the thin coating and it’s still there for many.
Man physically stronger. Fight hunt kill protect provide.
Women physically weaker but give birth and produce milk. Nurture, teach, gather, socialise, emotional intelligence, raise and protect young.
Sadly as men are physically stronger historically they have dominated and that has meant that women became submissive. Works well for the continuation of the human race from an evolutionary point of view.
Sadly not from a human point of view as our brains grew and we developed a higher conscious level and intelligence to that of other mammals.
But still it’s all there underneath. Generally many men want to dominate. Some women want to nurture, raise kids and provide a comfortable home.
It’s why there is a constant clash all the time between men and women societally. Trying to pull away from millions of years of human evolution.
In modern times women deserve to be equal to men of course. I don’t want to be cooking and cleaning all the time. I certainly don’t expect my DH or sons to be doing nothing in the home. They should (and do) their fair share. But, dispite working hard for a career from school age onwards, I couldn’t escape the pull of motherhood, wanting to raise my babies myself and all that brings. Many other women have fell the same pull and been in this position - stuck between wanting to be equal and follow their career, and their heart, pulling them toward having a child and being the primary caregiver.
Modern living is just in total opposition to how we have evolved and lived for 99.9% of our existence.

Its perfectly alright for women to choose to be homemakers if they can (and men), but your reasoning of evolution is overly simplistic and incorrect

Summerfun54321 · 27/10/2022 13:50

Totally agree. Nothing more unattractive than an undomesticated man who can’t work a washing machine or cook basic meals. I’m old enough to know plenty of them in my generation. True equality is both mothers and fathers teaching our boys and girls how to look after themselves.

PurpleWisteria1 · 27/10/2022 13:49

Topgub · 27/10/2022 13:12

@PurpleWisteria1

Why do you think that is?

That some women want to run the house but men never do?

People don’t generally like the answer to this because it doesn’t fit in with the vaneer of modern society.
The answer is evolution of humans. We think we are so superior and far above our base instincts. But scrape away the thin coating and it’s still there for many.
Man physically stronger. Fight hunt kill protect provide.
Women physically weaker but give birth and produce milk. Nurture, teach, gather, socialise, emotional intelligence, raise and protect young.
Sadly as men are physically stronger historically they have dominated and that has meant that women became submissive. Works well for the continuation of the human race from an evolutionary point of view.
Sadly not from a human point of view as our brains grew and we developed a higher conscious level and intelligence to that of other mammals.
But still it’s all there underneath. Generally many men want to dominate. Some women want to nurture, raise kids and provide a comfortable home.
It’s why there is a constant clash all the time between men and women societally. Trying to pull away from millions of years of human evolution.
In modern times women deserve to be equal to men of course. I don’t want to be cooking and cleaning all the time. I certainly don’t expect my DH or sons to be doing nothing in the home. They should (and do) their fair share. But, dispite working hard for a career from school age onwards, I couldn’t escape the pull of motherhood, wanting to raise my babies myself and all that brings. Many other women have fell the same pull and been in this position - stuck between wanting to be equal and follow their career, and their heart, pulling them toward having a child and being the primary caregiver.
Modern living is just in total opposition to how we have evolved and lived for 99.9% of our existence.

iamjustwinginglife · 27/10/2022 13:48

Justkidding55 · 27/10/2022 13:47

And there’s lots of mums not raising their daughters to be nice people too..
why is always boys and mums of boys blamed. Trust me there’s lots of very nasty teenage girls and women out there too. It’s just we have one rule for boys and another for girls.

I think you'll find loads of posts about unpleasant girls, particularly teenage ones. I don't think the parents of boys jump on those posts to point out how unfair it is that boys aren't mentioned too!

OP posts:
Conkersareback · 27/10/2022 13:48

Youchewb · 27/10/2022 13:37

Coorrr OP I think you've touched a nerve with some of the mums on here 😂

Yes, of course by blaming women, ie mothers, OP is actually excusing men for not parenting correctly. Which is what she's blaming the mothers for.

Justkidding55 · 27/10/2022 13:47

And there’s lots of mums not raising their daughters to be nice people too..
why is always boys and mums of boys blamed. Trust me there’s lots of very nasty teenage girls and women out there too. It’s just we have one rule for boys and another for girls.

LeMoo · 27/10/2022 13:45

I don't think the op is wrong, necessarily.

There are lots of people who don't raise their children to be lazy and entitled, but there are also lots of threads started by parents who seem stuck how to handle children of any age because they're seemingly averse to any sort of discipline.

I see lots of posts where people claim teenagers should be excused bad behaviour because their brains haven't fully developed yet - as if that means they're incapable of individual thought or empathy for others.

As other pp have pointed out, some parents love doing everything for their children even into adulthood. It makes them feel needed and it's an expression of love. Because their children are essentially good people, they don't see it as an issue but then they're not the ones who have to date them.

It doesn't just apply to boys - girls are often equally spoiled, but as an woman-centered site where many relationship issues discussed her focus on power imbalance, it makes sense that her opening post was about boys. And she didn't include a disclaimer!

Im at an age where my friends are settling down and starting families. I've both dated men and have male friends who's mother's have continued to attend to their every need well into adulthood. Even though these men are good partners and pull their weight, their mothers baby-ing of them still causes problems for their relationships. And each bloke knows they just have to smile or use a certain tone of voice for their mum to jump to do their washing/ironing/cleaning.

Funnily enough, when I meet girls and women who are like this having been spoiled, they're judged much more harshly than their male counterparts!

Not all men applies here, but enough men. And the op is right, if we want to foster permanent change in our sexist world we need to look at we raise our children. Most parents get it right I think, but it only needs some.

MichaelFabricantWig · 27/10/2022 13:45

I’ve got 2 boys almost 14 and 16 and they definitely put a shift in with housework. I work full time, I’m nearly 50 and permanently knackered and I’m no one’s skivvy.

Conkersareback · 27/10/2022 13:44

ittakes2 · 27/10/2022 13:41

One teen boy makes a comment and you feel justified in criticising parents of all teen boys?

No just the mothers!

ittakes2 · 27/10/2022 13:41

One teen boy makes a comment and you feel justified in criticising parents of all teen boys?

Youchewb · 27/10/2022 13:37

Coorrr OP I think you've touched a nerve with some of the mums on here 😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread