Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mothers of boys -some of you are not helping

334 replies

iamjustwinginglife · 27/10/2022 12:06

I'm sure there are numerous mums to boys who don't treat their sons like little princes and ensure they help out around the house however I'm not sure some mums are helping their boys to grow up in to decent men...and this is why we find Mumsnet full of posts about useless husbands who don't pull their weight at home.

Last night, I had a car full of teenagers all 17 (2 x boys, 2 x girls) and one of the boy's parents had come back from holiday. "It's nice to have them back, I won't need to clean up after myself anymore." Now, they're all good kids, it was just chatter-so I suggested that he carried on cleaning up after himself even though they were back. His reply was "mum likes looking after me, she says it's her job as a mum to make sure she looks after me and gives me everything I want." My child thought that sounded like a great idea-and I bit my tongue to not point out that some mums (me!!) were driving round the countryside at 1am.

This mum works part-time, the children are 17 and 20 and she's obviously got the time to do it but AIBU to think that allowing children to true up thinking they'll be waited in hand and foot isn't really helping them in future life.

OP posts:
Topgub · 27/10/2022 20:03

@PurpleWisteria1

The evidence is available.

🤷‍♀️

I dont think its an ancient human need to never leave your children. Its a minority of well off women in the past few years who claim its a biological need.

Its a bit sad you don't think your oh raised your children or that he never got any time alone with them.

I take it you home school?

PurpleWisteria1 · 27/10/2022 19:57

StillWeRise · 27/10/2022 18:48

and in hunter-gatherer societies, most calories are from gathering rather than hunting, which can be done whilst carrying a baby/with a toddler in tow- also hunting/trapping small animals and birds easily compatible with bf
see also- the menopause

Yes I totally agree with this. But still, I would be interesting to know how many men carried babies whilst they hunted or indeed gathered.

PurpleWisteria1 · 27/10/2022 19:56

Topgub · 27/10/2022 18:39

@PurpleWisteria1

They did hunt and gather. They absolutely did not stay home and only look after the babies. If you want to use evolution to argue your points, its best if you have the actual evidence.

The idea of a single pcg who does nothing but look after 1 baby is absolutely a very very modern (as in the past 10/20 years)idea. Its certainly not how women evolved. We evolved to raise babies in family groups. Mums, dad's, grandparents. Aunts uncles.

So you can't argue evolution and then criticise women for having help in raising their children. Thats literally how it should be.

And children have 2 parents. Of course someone else should be raising them!

I’m sorry, I disagree. Gatherers yes. Hunters- mainly no.
Groups yes. Of women mainly. Babies and toddlers fed breast milk. By their mother or another female. Unless you are claiming men could do that as well?
Look to remote tribes today who have little to do with modern ways of living. They still exist and I can tell you, it’s not hoards of women hunting and men looking after babies.
Where did I say there weren’t two parents? My DH and I have raised 3 kids. But it’s been me who has done the vast majority of the raising because he has been out at work 12 hours per day 5 days a week whilst I have been the primary caregiver. Even when he is here, I’m also still here 99% of the time. So I would say I’ve mainly raised them. If I had continued me career then I would have needed a nanny for 12+ hours per day. I wouldn’t have seen my children Monday-Friday at all most likely for most weeks.
In that case, I would say I had a hand in raising them but the main part of the raising would have been the nanny.
That was my point regarding beeding to be present to actually raise your child and the juxtaposition between studying for years for a career and then feeling the pull of motherhood and having to make that decision. Ancient human need V modern ideology / desires.

StillWeRise · 27/10/2022 18:48

and in hunter-gatherer societies, most calories are from gathering rather than hunting, which can be done whilst carrying a baby/with a toddler in tow- also hunting/trapping small animals and birds easily compatible with bf
see also- the menopause

Topgub · 27/10/2022 18:39

@PurpleWisteria1

They did hunt and gather. They absolutely did not stay home and only look after the babies. If you want to use evolution to argue your points, its best if you have the actual evidence.

The idea of a single pcg who does nothing but look after 1 baby is absolutely a very very modern (as in the past 10/20 years)idea. Its certainly not how women evolved. We evolved to raise babies in family groups. Mums, dad's, grandparents. Aunts uncles.

So you can't argue evolution and then criticise women for having help in raising their children. Thats literally how it should be.

And children have 2 parents. Of course someone else should be raising them!

PurpleWisteria1 · 27/10/2022 18:27

Topgub · 27/10/2022 15:17

@PurpleWisteria1

Except there's lots of evidence to show that it was never that linear.

Women hunted and gathered. They didn't sit around playing house.

If we had evolved only to be pcg then no women would want anything else. No men would care about parenting. And thats clearly not the case.

Men and women are obviously biologically different but not to the extent that it means we can't be equal parents. Especially not now.

And if you think only children who are with 1 pcg 24/7 (until what age?!) are raised then 99.9% of people weren't raised.

No women didn’t hunt (generally speaking) They stayed behind and took care of the young. Because they could feed them and men couldn’t!
Why do you say ‘playing house’ Why make an extremely important role sound like a kids game? Extremely derogatory.
No men and women arn’t often equal parents. Because as you say, we are made differently biologically. Hormones alone will tell you that everything biologically is geared to the mother being the main care giver. Not to even mention the small fact of breast milk which historically speaking if there was no mother or lactating woman around then the baby would most likely sadly have not survived.
On your last point:
Firstly it’s far more than 0.01% of women who choose to be the primary caregiver for their baby / small child.
Secondly - yes of course they have all been raised. Just perhaps not mainly by the mother because they if they are out working most days then they are not the primary caregiver. If a majority of child care is outsourced then someone else has had a big part in raising your child!

FurAndFeathers · 27/10/2022 17:35

serenghetti2011 · 27/10/2022 17:32

Ah so it would be totally my fault if my four boys once adults are totally useless men? Not theirs? All 4 have seen myself - single parent of 4 bring them up. Their dad for youngest 2 is great does everything I do when they are there. They can cook, clean etc but like any child/teen they can be lazy or forget. As did I as a child.

I don’t do everything for them as I don’t have time. However I have brought them to respect other people, and be nice caring and considerate human beings. I hope that continues into adulthood and marriage but at the end of the day I can guide and advise and model good behaviour but once adults they choose their own path. So if they are useless husbands/fathers etc that’ll be very disappointing but they’ve then made their own choices.

Did you genuinely read the OP and think ‘oh yes what she’s describing is exactly how I parent’ Confused

if not then why the high dudgeon? It clearly doesn’t apply to you.

serenghetti2011 · 27/10/2022 17:32

Ah so it would be totally my fault if my four boys once adults are totally useless men? Not theirs? All 4 have seen myself - single parent of 4 bring them up. Their dad for youngest 2 is great does everything I do when they are there. They can cook, clean etc but like any child/teen they can be lazy or forget. As did I as a child.

I don’t do everything for them as I don’t have time. However I have brought them to respect other people, and be nice caring and considerate human beings. I hope that continues into adulthood and marriage but at the end of the day I can guide and advise and model good behaviour but once adults they choose their own path. So if they are useless husbands/fathers etc that’ll be very disappointing but they’ve then made their own choices.

BigFatLiar · 27/10/2022 17:26

FunnysInLaJardin · 27/10/2022 17:19

This is our situation. Last bus at 10.15, no Uber and too far to walk, 16 yo DS1 knows it’s the last bus or he pays for a taxi. Got to teach them some independence OP…

You're being spoiled around here (small city) buses stop around 7pm and if you want to go to the nearest small town (10 miles) they stop before 6pm.

BlodynGwyn · 27/10/2022 17:26

I watched as my sister raised her son to be a totally useless man. She never asked him to do anything around the house and spent a small fortune on buying things for him, including a brand new car for his 18th birthday. His behavior was atrocious. She told me millionaires give their children everything they want and they grow up to be good people. She also told me I was jealous, even though I'm far better off financially than she is. She said if I really had money I would have bought my children (now adults) more stuff. She also told me she did it because she wanted her children to "like" her when they were adults. Her son was a awful child and teen. He managed to get himself a criminal record, even though his mother said, "he will want for nothing", apparently he did want more, so he stole, committed crimes.

He's over 40 now. He stays home while his live-in girlfriend works and pays his mortgage. Only his name is on the mortgage because my sister paid for the down payment for the house. Girlfriend wants a big family, but he told his mother (who told me) he wasn't going to have more children as he already had a son (from his younger years) and besides, who's going to pay the mortgage if she stays home having babies & raising children. The girlfriend was orphaned as a little girl, has no one to talk to and he's lied to her on about the future he has planned. Meanwhile she's getting older.

We all saw this coming. She has a daughter as well, who has her own issues due to the way she was raised.

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 27/10/2022 17:24

That is a very berating title and I'm not in the mood.

FunnysInLaJardin · 27/10/2022 17:19

iamjustwinginglife · 27/10/2022 13:19

They're all learning-just no-one has passed yet. They're only just 17.

This is our situation. Last bus at 10.15, no Uber and too far to walk, 16 yo DS1 knows it’s the last bus or he pays for a taxi. Got to teach them some independence OP…

FurAndFeathers · 27/10/2022 17:09

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 27/10/2022 16:01

OK but what else is @Theluggage15 supposed to do other than share the chores equally? Is she supposed to give her son more chores so society can be fractionally balanced out?

I’m not sure why you think I’m the person to be advising a poster I know nothing about @LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet ?

My point was that one person’s experience of fair treatment is not supported by the data generally. So threads like this are helpful in raising awareness

Lindengericht · 27/10/2022 17:09

This thread is the most ridiculous misogynist thread I have seen in a while.

OP, go see the mother in question. I am sure she will appreciate your input.

XanaduKira · 27/10/2022 16:59

Maybe in your world @BigFatLiar but not in mine and not something I've noticed particularly on Mumsnet either.

bringincrazyback · 27/10/2022 16:53

BigFatLiar · 27/10/2022 16:44

You're on mumsnet, dad is usually absent or every other weekend.

What a strange and untrue comment.

BigFatLiar · 27/10/2022 16:44

XanaduKira · 27/10/2022 16:43

This! Just one more thing to blame is for. A man being useless will always be a woman's fault!

You're on mumsnet, dad is usually absent or every other weekend.

XanaduKira · 27/10/2022 16:43

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 27/10/2022 12:12

Why is it always the mothers fault?

This! Just one more thing to blame is for. A man being useless will always be a woman's fault!

Muminabun · 27/10/2022 16:40

Smellywellyhoo · 27/10/2022 16:23

Always the mothers to blame, never the dads! 🙄

This is such an important point. I only ever see mums with seemingly out of control boys. Dads and male role models are so important for boys to grow up well. More important than anything else as a predictor of future life chances and success.

CherryBlossomWinter · 27/10/2022 16:39

I do think boys are most massively influenced by their father’s in how they treat women, and how their father cleans up or doesn’t around the mother is the biggest factor in this.

Look to those fathers!

Dalaidramailama · 27/10/2022 16:38

@YukoandHiro

Well just be grateful you’re not a martyr then like your mother. You might well have been if youde have been skilled up by the age of 10 😉. Enjoy the cleaner and don’t give it a second thought.

TheLoupGarou · 27/10/2022 16:36

Right. Will add this to my list of things I'm responsible for..... to be clear, can dd sit out this chore-bootcamp?

OP I don't know why you felt you needed to bite your tongue in the car! Let she who is without sin cast the first stone and all that...

YukoandHiro · 27/10/2022 16:36

@Dalaidramailama I'm not blaming her as such but I definitely feel like it would have been better for everyone (including my mum!) is we'd all been expected to share at home. My mum was a SAHM and did absolutely everything. She still thinks it's appalling that I "make my husband put on washing himself" even though we both work.
It's a weird dynamic coming from that kind of martyrdom as I'm both admittedly useless at it all but also feel like a huge failure of a mum and wife for not being on top of everything 100 per cent of the time too. We have a cleaner to keep on top of the basics but I just done have the house proud gene and I wish I did

Muminabun · 27/10/2022 16:34

I have two dds. I am frequently shocked by the behaviour boys seem to get away with. One friend has a son who is so violent I stopped seeing her as was a bit scared of him to be honest and he was only 7. I do find myself avoiding mums with boys quite a lot as their behaviour I find appalling. I don’t say anything I just make a mental note to avoid. Mums just seem so so gentle with their sons and underreact to behaviour I personally see as really worrying. I must say I have seen this Lot in the uk. Yadnbu op.

Dalaidramailama · 27/10/2022 16:32

@YukoandHiro

My mum did everything for me. My house now is clean, tidy and organised. I am sorry but you’re an adult now. Stop blaming your mum because you can’t be arsed to push a hoover around. I doubt having that forced upon you at age 7 would have made a difference. Even with all the will in the world some people are just a bit messier than others and that’s okay. Me and my husband share the load so it never feels that overwhelming.

Swipe left for the next trending thread