Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mothers of boys -some of you are not helping

334 replies

iamjustwinginglife · 27/10/2022 12:06

I'm sure there are numerous mums to boys who don't treat their sons like little princes and ensure they help out around the house however I'm not sure some mums are helping their boys to grow up in to decent men...and this is why we find Mumsnet full of posts about useless husbands who don't pull their weight at home.

Last night, I had a car full of teenagers all 17 (2 x boys, 2 x girls) and one of the boy's parents had come back from holiday. "It's nice to have them back, I won't need to clean up after myself anymore." Now, they're all good kids, it was just chatter-so I suggested that he carried on cleaning up after himself even though they were back. His reply was "mum likes looking after me, she says it's her job as a mum to make sure she looks after me and gives me everything I want." My child thought that sounded like a great idea-and I bit my tongue to not point out that some mums (me!!) were driving round the countryside at 1am.

This mum works part-time, the children are 17 and 20 and she's obviously got the time to do it but AIBU to think that allowing children to true up thinking they'll be waited in hand and foot isn't really helping them in future life.

OP posts:
OMG12 · 29/10/2022 08:49

I think these days there is a lot of poor parenting of children all round. Lots of Children are being brought up to expect everything now. That the world owes them a living, that they can be and do whatever they want without thinking of the impact on others.

listening to music/watching films in public places without headphones is a particular bug bear

little girls being dressed up to the nines with make up

disruptive kids in school who have obviously never been disciplined at home

kids doing fairly well in sports and parents treating them as if they are the next messi

kids not facing any consequences of poor behaviour

etc etc

DanceItOut · 29/10/2022 07:00

I suspect it’s not quite as simple as that lad is making it out to be. My teenage son went around telling people that he was his nan’s favourite and she would buy him anything he wanted if I withheld pocket money due to poor behaviour. She adores him and spoils him of course she does as many grandparents do but she would never just buy him anything he wanted whether he was being punished or being an Angel but he clearly thought that sounded cool to his mates. I also overheard him say on the phone when I had popped to ask him if there was anything in particular he wanted for dinner and as I walked away he said to his girlfriend that yeah that’s the only time mum bothers me is to basically just bring me food. Which is not true at all. I also bother him to take the bins out, do his laundry, tidy his room, feed the cats and sometimes cook dinner etc. He didn’t say these things in a jokey way or anything but still they were complete lies.

Do I still do a lot for him and my DD? Of course I do because they are 10 and 14 however they do both know how to change their sheets and do their laundry. Both know how to use the hoover and wash up. Both get asked to help out with things like washing up or taking bins out. DS is the 14yo and he also knows how to cook a few basic meals like chilli or pasta. Are they both still lazy on occasion? Absolutely if they can get away with being lazy then they will but I think that’s true of a lot of people regardless of age or gender.

Chi11ijam67743479 · 29/10/2022 06:01

Amongst my dc’s friends( boys and girls) I think this is far more of an issue with girls. The word pampered doesn’t even begin to describe it.

So YABU to cast judgement on the parenting of an entire gender.

MysteryBelle · 29/10/2022 05:00

You’re outraged over a casual remark from a teenager? I wonder if you are doing this because you already don’t like the teen boy’s mother, and that gave you ammunition to attack her. Badly done, op.

Newmumatlast · 29/10/2022 04:04

Mumoffairy · 28/10/2022 19:09

Each to their own, but my children will always be picked up if they need at night.
I could always count on my dad to be there when i called no matter the hour.
Most of my friends have gotten into a car with a drunk driver or had to wait around at stations getting into uncomfortable situations. Its one of the things im most grateful for. That i always knew i had a save ride home.

Same and I will do the same for my kids. Something I have always appreciated so much is how my parents have always cared about my welfare to the point they will drop everything to safely collect me. I have chosen a husband who does the same for me, and I for him, and my parents still would if needed.

Again because of the morals instilled in me its less about me now feeling everyone has to do everything for me and more about us all taking care of eachother as family.

Newmumatlast · 29/10/2022 03:59

iamjustwinginglife · 27/10/2022 12:06

I'm sure there are numerous mums to boys who don't treat their sons like little princes and ensure they help out around the house however I'm not sure some mums are helping their boys to grow up in to decent men...and this is why we find Mumsnet full of posts about useless husbands who don't pull their weight at home.

Last night, I had a car full of teenagers all 17 (2 x boys, 2 x girls) and one of the boy's parents had come back from holiday. "It's nice to have them back, I won't need to clean up after myself anymore." Now, they're all good kids, it was just chatter-so I suggested that he carried on cleaning up after himself even though they were back. His reply was "mum likes looking after me, she says it's her job as a mum to make sure she looks after me and gives me everything I want." My child thought that sounded like a great idea-and I bit my tongue to not point out that some mums (me!!) were driving round the countryside at 1am.

This mum works part-time, the children are 17 and 20 and she's obviously got the time to do it but AIBU to think that allowing children to true up thinking they'll be waited in hand and foot isn't really helping them in future life.

Based on what he said to you I dont see this as relevant to his sex. The mother may be this way as a mum regardless of sex of the child. My own mum did everything for me and I'm female. I get that it means he could grow into a man expecting everything done for him but then so could I have grown into a woman expecting that. I didnt. I grew into a woman who expects a man to share housework- and that is despite my Dad doing nothing either. Because actually though my mum did everything because she felt kids should be kids and Dad worked, she also was very keen on pressing the equality agenda and encouraging careers for us. So was Dad. It seemed clear to me that she did what she did because she was the one working in the home and it wasn't about her sex. So I think actually rather than it just being about what a parent physically does it's about what they say and the values they instil

LoisLane66 · 29/10/2022 02:53

My 5, 2 boys 3 girls, were all working full time at 16 and all of them worked away from home. 2 came home at weekends but not the boys. The lads/men (now married and in their 40s) do all their own laundry and do their fair share of house chores, sometimes more, as both wives work f/t too.
Up until they were 16 they hadn't done 'chores' as such but were expected to tidily pull back duvets to air their beds and straighten sheets etc, help clear the table after meals and clean up and not leave wet towels in the bathroom.
Funnily enough they all coped with learning to cook and iron and clean to the point that my sons won't let their wives do their laundry as they're better at doing it. I actually thought their shirts had been to the local valeting service.
So no, although I thought and still think they're wonderful, I reckoned that they would find their feet in the real world as I did at the same age. It's testament to that early working start in life, that they were all on the housing ladder by the age of 19 with no parental or GP help at all.
Their children have all benefitted from that outlook too.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 29/10/2022 01:23

No! My sons are my precious princes and I wouldn’t want them to marry a partner who didn’t realise how marvellous they are. They need to be raised to know how they ought to be treated.

Mothership4two · 29/10/2022 00:31

So from one conversation with one teenager OP (who may have been being wound up) has made a shaky extrapolation that some women are doing a poor job raising their sons. Hmm

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 28/10/2022 23:33

I think you might also find that there are expectations of boys too. Look after the girls, step into the fight, kill the spider, earn the money, drive the car, pick me up , be strong, don't cry, help me with this etc etc. But also, be gentle, do half the domestic work, never get angry, understand all of my problems , be home on time , be patient , etc etc. MN seems to forget that those societal beliefs are still very much there for boys. I think they have a much harder ride tbh.

Absolutely this.

I have a sensitive son and honestly you’d think a boy getting easily upset is the crime of the century. The MH of men and boys is still taboo and not taken seriously because of the expectations. Toxic masculinity damages men as much as women

marvellousmaple · 28/10/2022 22:59

FurAndFeathers · 27/10/2022 15:58

But the research shows that in general patents have greater domestic expectations of their daughters than their sons.
being aware of that is a helpful first step to changing it.

I think you might also find that there are expectations of boys too. Look after the girls, step into the fight, kill the spider, earn the money, drive the car, pick me up , be strong, don't cry, help me with this etc etc. But also, be gentle, do half the domestic work, never get angry, understand all of my problems , be home on time , be patient , etc etc. MN seems to forget that those societal beliefs are still very much there for boys. I think they have a much harder ride tbh.

Full disclosure - a mum of 4 boys. Youngest is still in school but the other 3 are 20 something adults living 2 hours away from me very successfully. Happy, two highly educated, one in a trade, lovely friends and girlfriends, earning well . And none of them had done a load of washing before they left home. Looking after your family is something that is ingrained in some people ( like me). It does not mean we raise terrible children. I was always adamant on politeness, kindness, thoughtfulness, following through on things - like if you join a team you stay until the end of the season. I encouraged friendships - hundreds and hundreds of kids will have been to my house , for visits and parties and sleepovers over the years. Friends are a great way to learn and grow. We also always had pets which I think are underrated as a way to show love.

No parent is perfect but I'm happy with how I raised my boys.

Kabbalah · 28/10/2022 22:15

The kids are quite good, they keep the place tidy and clear-up if they cook anything but they don't have chores or clean the house. We have a cleaner for that.

MyLovelyPen · 28/10/2022 21:51

@Firstworldprobs yep! I have two teenage sons. They are expected to help out with most chores “because they live here”. Dh, their dad, has ALWAYS pulled his weight so they see that too. No financial reward but consequences if they don’t help out - or moan too much about doing it! 😄

LaDamaDeElche · 28/10/2022 21:45

Mumofsons87 · 28/10/2022 20:32

You do understand that you too are part of the problem that you are complaining about by putting all of the responsibility on the mother of the family.
You have completely missed your own point.

This!

twinmum2022 · 28/10/2022 21:41

Amazing. I'm surprised you have time to post OP in between polishing all your parent of the year awards.

Livetoplay · 28/10/2022 21:19

‘I think the boy mums have come out in force because they feel attacked because a lot of them are raising men just like their husbands.’

well, I have a wife and I still think OP is a patronising idiot, talking out her hole…

LaDamaDeElche · 28/10/2022 21:17

03X · 27/10/2022 12:10

Wtf - maybe change to parents of children?

I never understand this defensive type of comment. We're in 2022 and in the overwhelming majority of relationships women do more of the household chores, more of the drop offs and school pick ups, are called first when a child is sick and needs to come home, sacrifice their careers more, do more of the childcare, do more "home admin" including sorting out birthdays and presents, xmas, Halloween, after school activities etc as they have done since the dawn of time, HOWEVER, they often do all this while working. For many families free time between men and women isn't equal and it's the woman running herself ragged, so yes, these comments are relevant and should be aimed to parents with sons (NOT mothers, but both parents) as it's absolutely ridiculous that boys are still growing up to become men who don't get the concept of equality in this day and age.

Mummadeze · 28/10/2022 21:15

I am a Mum to a girl and do everything for her. I used to have everything done for me as a child. I think it is a nice aspect of not being grownup to be completely looked after. Plenty of time for the daily grind once you have left home.

XanaduKira · 28/10/2022 21:11

Totally agree @Firstworldprobs I feel the same about rewarding good grades in school. That's something that's to be expected, not rewarded (as in the hard work and effort should be rewarded, not necessarily the grade as such).

Firstworldprobs · 28/10/2022 21:08

DuvetHugger · 27/10/2022 12:16

I'm sure the OP means both parents, lets not be pedantic. I have a son and whilst he is only 2, he helps loading the washing machine and hoovering lol

I am determined to make sure he is aware of his responsibilities when he is older and he will be required to do chores if he wants pocket money.

That said, everyone is trying their best

I have two boys.

Can I recommend that you don’t link chores to pocket money. They should do the chores because they need doing, not because there’s a monetary reward. It’s like that spoof article meme:

“Five Reasons Why You Should Help Your Wife with Housework:

  1. Because you live there
  2. Because you live there
  3. Because you live there
  4. Because you live there
  5. Because you fucking live there”

Pocket money is a privilege (not a salary or bribe), that can be removed / docked if necessary for bad behaviour etc. My sons get a modest basic weekly allowance and can earn extra by going over and above, for example washing our cars or their GP’s cars. I will not pay them to do the basic chores they should be doing anyway.

Abouttimemum · 28/10/2022 20:54

Well my husband does 50% of everything and our son sees that every day. It starts and ends with what children, no matter the sex, see day in and day out about relationships and house ‘jobs’ that belong to everyone.

Mummyto2rugrats · 28/10/2022 20:52

As @SlashBeef (fab name by the way 😂) says its not just boys. My DD is 12 soon to be 13 and DS is 11 will be 12 in April so only 15mth apart so it makes it easier to do this.
Our DC can earn allowance each month by doing chores these chores are making your bed tidy the bath room, keep your bedroom tidy bringing dirty clothes down on Wednesday and Sunday to be washed, putting clothes away, empty dishwasher and put away, reload, clean work tops hoover down stairs mid week and we are just trying to get them to try making 1 meal a week. Their allowance then has a standing order back to us to cover their sim only contract.
I'm a firm believer that theg learn the value of money young, Learn to budget and learn to work for their money.
It's been a hard slog don't get me wrong and will still be I'm sure moving forward but all the jobs are supporting the family unit where both parents work FT and general respect for their own home.
We do get why do we have to non of our friends do, my argument back I really don't care if your friends don't that's their house but they aren't learning that you have to work for a living and your surroundings and clothes don't magically clean themselves.
With this it also means that the many clubs they belong to they get shipped to and from without concern!
Some will say its wrong kids should be kids and they are just with some light responsibility

marktayloruk · 28/10/2022 20:39

Whoever thinks chores need doing should do them. Can't say fairer than that !

Mumofsons87 · 28/10/2022 20:32

You do understand that you too are part of the problem that you are complaining about by putting all of the responsibility on the mother of the family.
You have completely missed your own point.

XanaduKira · 28/10/2022 20:14

Miisty · 28/10/2022 19:52

No it doesn’t help not being taught anything at home My husband and his brother were brought up 2lazy boys and did nothing in the house nor did their father barely heat a tin of soup up It makes life so difficult when you work 7nights (11hrs )and come home to pick up dirty clothes Never taught to clean a bath Marriage is meant to be equal but it’s up to both parents to teachthem

Or as adults they could now take responsibility for themselves & step up, rather than leaving things to their (from the sounds of it, suffering) spouse.