Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should MIL be charging her GC for staying with her?

186 replies

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 27/10/2022 09:33

Background - DS got offered an apprenticeship in a different town to where we live (2 hours away by train)
As we was staying all week and most weekends an agreement was made he would pay her £400 a month.
After about 6 months, his company changed how they wanted him to work so he was wfh more (he wasn't enjoying living at MIL's as he didn't know anyone, etc) so he reverted to doing approx 2 days a week there and the rest of the time here at home
We changed the payments to £200 to me and £200 to her. Over the last 3 months, he has stayed there only 3 times and as he spends the majority of time at home, I suggested I get the money instead.
FI - when he stays at MIL in the last 3 months, she doesn't cook for him (he buys his own food) & he brings his washing home- whereas at home, he generally eats with us, his washing goes in, etc

He has had to go to up for a couple of nights this week and next (he will probably not then go for a couple of weeks and then may stay 1 or 2 nights only)

MIL has said that if he stays in future he needs to pay £25 a night to stay (no food being offered still!)

For context - she is a single pensioner on her own. There is no mortgage on her house. Last year she stayed with us for 3 months whilst having work completed on her house which we funded and took out a large amount added to our current mortgage which she now pays the interest only on (approx £125 pm) never clearing the capital as her house was in a terrible state with no proper heating and electricity upstairs etc. We did not charge her for staying with us and she made no contribution whilst here (as in she never even paid for a takeaway one night!)

AIBU to think she shouldn't charge DS when he stays occasionally?

YABU - of course she should charge and he should pay
YANBU - he's her GS so should stay free (but maybe it would be nice to get her something sometimes)

OP posts:
CarefreeMe · 27/10/2022 11:25

How much does he earn??

That is a hell of a lot of money for someone (especially doing an apprenticeship) to hand over!

If he’s paying for all his food etc then £25 for the entire week to go towards electricity and water is more than enough.

I do not believe he spends £100 worth of bills in your home every week and it sounds as though you’re just as greedy as MIL.

Yes you are saving half of it for him which is great but £400 a month is a lot!

MummyJ36 · 27/10/2022 11:24

Why are you charging your son to live with you? He’s only 18 and he’s doing an apprenticeship. Hardly earning big bucks and still very young!

Babyroobs · 27/10/2022 11:23

Honestly who on earth charges someone on an apprentice wage £400 a month whoever it's going to ?? Bizarre.

DucklingDaisy · 27/10/2022 11:20

TitInATrance · 27/10/2022 10:31

Your DH is getting his mum to pay the interest on an upgrade to a property held in trust for him? He’s the CF here, and if she only has the state pension this must leave her incredibly short of money.

Yeah, now you’ve revealed the house is actually your husband’s (i.e. your marital) asset, you’re really not coming across well here…

It seems obvious to me that gran wants the money because she’s a skint pensioner and the cost of living is spiralling.

Nanny0gg · 27/10/2022 11:17

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 27/10/2022 10:55

Does a tenant for life not have to pay anything then?
or should they be expected to keep the property in a liveable condition?
(this is genuine question as we are unsure and yes we are probably at fault as we actually assumed it was her house for years!)

Yes. It's usually written into the inheritance that they have to maintain the property whilst they live in it.
However, back in the real world...

<bitter>

Bluegingerbread · 27/10/2022 11:15

She sounds like someone who knows the cost of everything and the value of nothing. I actually feel sorry for your DH in this. Guessing all your ages here, it really was not normal for him to grow up in a house in a town with no plug sockets upstairs. She was extremely lucky to have life use of a free house and it sounds as though she has an extreme sense of entitlement and chose to do no upkeep and live in poor conditions. I suspect his childhood had other issues too. Most couples today, let alone single mothers back then would be thrilled to have free use of a house, guaranteed for life. Even if you hated the house, not paying rent or a mortgage would mean you could save to buy.

I think that morally, she shouldn't charge him as he's not getting food, use of washing machine etc and she stayed for so long at yours without contributing. I used to occasionally stay at my grandmother's while I was training as she lived close to my office and if I worked late or went out after work I didn't then have to travel across London alone late at night. She wouldn't have dreamt of charging me and in fact, usually tried to give me 'dinner money' in the morning! I adored her and used to always visit once a week no matter how busy I was with work or how far I had to travel as we had a strong relationship. I doubt your MIL has that relationship with her GC. And yes, I'd bring my gran treats or fish and chips etc or top up her electricity when she wasn't looking as I loved her and she had nothing but her state pension but she would never have charged me or any of her GC for a bed.

Electricstar · 27/10/2022 11:11

First of all I do not think £200 rent that you are charging is bad at all - I paid £200 when I was earning £1000-1200 a month to my parents and that helped them, plus the cost of electricity and my food. The fact you also pay his transport costs and mobile I think that is decent.

The other £200 (so £400 total) into his savings is a fab idea. I wish my parents did that for me.

I think it really does stem down to MIL’s financial position. My first answer is YANBU as I think the fact your DS will literally be there once or twice a month at MIL and pays for his own food etc. I cannot imagine my Nan charging me to stay over a night or two a month! I would say 95% or Nans on here would agree they wouldn’t charge this. But is MIL struggling? If she is I think that I can see her point here

Also agree with others, MIL probably found the £400 rent really helpful and probably misses that amount.

YeahThanks · 27/10/2022 11:09

I think it’s absolutely the right thing to do to charge your dc rent at this age/stage, if any of mine choose to live at home after Uni I’ll do the same. I might not even save any of it.
I think the GM is being a bit mean charging him to stay now it’s more occasional and he doesn’t eat her food etc. However, it’s up to her if she wants to charge him £25pn as it’s still less than he’d have to pay elsewhere. Your DS should pay the £25, but I wouldn’t do the same in her shoes.
The house isn’t relevant to your DS.

DullAndOvercast · 27/10/2022 11:09

I'd encourage him to see what his other options are TBH - are there B&B with or without meals that are alternatives.

Despite the trust and money spent it's her house for now - in that she is the resident (no idea about legal position ) and if she'll only let him stop for that amount and there are no easy alternatives he'll have to pay.

I don't think it's great behavior - but then I probably wouldn't charge my teens £200 for food even if they stop with us (our parents never did that to us) even if food bill and energy bills went up - though obviously if we were on bones of our arse I might have to but we'd be super reluctant - though probably would charge rent and save it for them.

PurplePansy05 · 27/10/2022 11:09

I wouldn't be charging my DC for living at home if they were apprentices, no, unless I was in a serious financial difficulty and their contributions would be necessary, but even then, I would be extremely reluctant. I would expect them to pay for their travel and mobile phones for sure though, and to make their own savings so that they have some starting money to move out when their wage increases.

I think it's delusional of you to say that your MIL should've been expected to keep the house in a livable condition or whatever words you used. It's not her house in reality and she shouldn't be expected to rewire it, ffs. Also if she needed special adjustments that's on your DH as the ultimate beneficiary, and it's his DM. Meanwhile you are charging her interest for doing the basics, it's extraordinary frankly.

OnTheRoll · 27/10/2022 11:08

I may be missing something but a few things sound very odd.

You mention your husband's grandfather who is keeping the house in trust for him. Was that your MIL's father? So GF left the house not to his daughter (MIL) but to his grandson (your DH)? Why not to MIL? You also did say that the house is in her name - and yet she cannot sell it?

A vet weird arrangement all around for a woman who was a daughter to the original owner and, let's not forget, is your husband's mother? Why does she have so little rights? From the way she is written about here you would think that she were some annoying old maiden aunty who is everyone's liability.

She raised your husband for god's sake.

dreamingofsun · 27/10/2022 11:08

The arrangement my son had with MIL when he stayed for a year doing his masters was that he would pay for any increase in bills that resulted from him. he bought his own food. i dont think electric/gas actually went up in the end so he wasnt charged extra.

Maybe your husband could see if she is struggling financially? It seems unfair for a youngster on an apprenticeship to be the solution to any financial issues she has - maybe she isnt getting all the benefits she is entitled to, or her utility suppliers can be changed for example

Moonatics · 27/10/2022 11:07

I think she just doesn't want him there. And as its rude to say that, shes come to this conclusion, if she asks him for money, he probably wont come.
If she was really in need of money (probably not with 6k savings) she could rent a room out.
If he decides to pay anyway, she will up the cost until its cheaper for him to get a hotel room.
Just tell him to get a hotel room. At least food is often included and he brings his washing home anyway.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 27/10/2022 11:00

These trusts are such a bad idea, I know several women who have ended up trapped in a house which is unsuitable for them because they don’t own an interest in it and so have no capital to put towards a new house.

it’s still odd, though. I thought most grandparents would be wanting a GC to stay. Perhaps they don’t get on? Or maybe she finds a young male around the house a bit disruptive.

HiveBee · 27/10/2022 11:00

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 27/10/2022 10:35

I wish i had said it like that actually as that is indeed what happened and we wanted her to be able to stay in the house as long as she was able to and maintain her independence.

Yes but where your accusations of her being tight fall down is the fact that you’ve charged are £125 in interest on the loan. That actually should be your cost to bear on the basis that you will be the long-term beneficiaries.

that would be like me putting up the rent for my tenants on the basis that I’ve improved my asset and they just happen to get to use those improvements in the meantime. For new tenants yes that’s plausible but not for existing ones.

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 27/10/2022 10:59

In the context that it is your DHs house, ignore the fact that she stayed with you for 3 months and didn't pay anything. She sees herself as much poorer than you.
I can't imagine my mum or my grandparents taking a penny from grandkids doing an apprenticeship. Buy if her life savings are £6k, it puts it in a different context. If you are taking £400 a month from him, maybe discuss directly what it costs him to stay, heating and so on and pay her directly from that money.

largeprintagathachristie · 27/10/2022 10:57

Bit of a drip feed for you to mention later that her house is actually in trust for DH.

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 27/10/2022 10:55

Mari9999 · 27/10/2022 10:42

In essence, it sounds as though she has a life tenancy in a house that for all practical purposes is owned by your husband. He made repairs on his property.

The MIL does not appear to have many available resources. If your son can find cheaper accommodations, then he should do so. If he is a working adult, he should be able to negotiate terms with his grandmother without your involvement.

.You should leave the 2_of them to come to terms. If they cannot work out some mutually agreeable terms, he can find other accommodations. He is past the age where his mom should be negotiating his living arrangements.

Does a tenant for life not have to pay anything then?
or should they be expected to keep the property in a liveable condition?
(this is genuine question as we are unsure and yes we are probably at fault as we actually assumed it was her house for years!)

OP posts:
Marcipex · 27/10/2022 10:53

And no food? How bloomin miserable.

EdieLedwell · 27/10/2022 10:53

So he shouldn’t be paying any rent at his normal home at all then?🙄*
or should he be paying that on top?*

Depends. How old is he? How long is he working? How much is he earning?

My mother couldn't wait to lash into our wages when we were just starting "To teach us the value of money"

We still talk about that as siblings and how it was anything but that.

girlmom21 · 27/10/2022 10:49

I don't think the renovations are relevant because they're an investment.

I don't see why she shouldn't charge him £25 a night. That's cheaper than a bed elsewhere for the night. Equally will the company not pay for his accommodation?

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 27/10/2022 10:49

EdieLedwell · 27/10/2022 10:46

This.

So he shouldn’t be paying any rent at his normal home at all then?🙄
or should he be paying that on top?

OP posts:
EdieLedwell · 27/10/2022 10:46

Bimblybomeyelash · 27/10/2022 10:45

My viewpoint is he needs to have an idea of budgeting and costing for future life

Then why not let him keep the 400 quid and then he can sort out paying for his own transport and phone costs and food shopping.

This.

Bimblybomeyelash · 27/10/2022 10:45

My viewpoint is he needs to have an idea of budgeting and costing for future life

Then why not let him keep the 400 quid and then he can sort out paying for his own transport and phone costs and food shopping.

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 27/10/2022 10:45

Every year I go through Moneysaving expert with her and we check what she’s entitled to and I shop around for her insurances.

She does have savings in the bank (over £6k)

OP posts: