Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should MIL be charging her GC for staying with her?

186 replies

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 27/10/2022 09:33

Background - DS got offered an apprenticeship in a different town to where we live (2 hours away by train)
As we was staying all week and most weekends an agreement was made he would pay her £400 a month.
After about 6 months, his company changed how they wanted him to work so he was wfh more (he wasn't enjoying living at MIL's as he didn't know anyone, etc) so he reverted to doing approx 2 days a week there and the rest of the time here at home
We changed the payments to £200 to me and £200 to her. Over the last 3 months, he has stayed there only 3 times and as he spends the majority of time at home, I suggested I get the money instead.
FI - when he stays at MIL in the last 3 months, she doesn't cook for him (he buys his own food) & he brings his washing home- whereas at home, he generally eats with us, his washing goes in, etc

He has had to go to up for a couple of nights this week and next (he will probably not then go for a couple of weeks and then may stay 1 or 2 nights only)

MIL has said that if he stays in future he needs to pay £25 a night to stay (no food being offered still!)

For context - she is a single pensioner on her own. There is no mortgage on her house. Last year she stayed with us for 3 months whilst having work completed on her house which we funded and took out a large amount added to our current mortgage which she now pays the interest only on (approx £125 pm) never clearing the capital as her house was in a terrible state with no proper heating and electricity upstairs etc. We did not charge her for staying with us and she made no contribution whilst here (as in she never even paid for a takeaway one night!)

AIBU to think she shouldn't charge DS when he stays occasionally?

YABU - of course she should charge and he should pay
YANBU - he's her GS so should stay free (but maybe it would be nice to get her something sometimes)

OP posts:
LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 27/10/2022 15:13

MIL has always lived in the same house all her life
MIL moved to this house when she was 2 years old with her parents. Grandma died when MIL was 17 yo. Grandad (MIL’s father) apparently left the property in trust when my DH was around 6 months old when he died when MIL was around 30.

We moved away from that area 20 years ago as my DH relocated for work. We were aware that we would be leaving her with no other family. We discussed these implications and she said that she wanted to move to the new area with us (at that time she was mid fifties) and was completely able and fit and healthy. Roll on 20+ years and she still hasn’t moved.
The trust thing only came out when wills were rewritten after a health scare … before that we didn’t have knowledge.

I do wonder how people feel that we’ve let her down as we would have paid to get renovations done earlier but didn’t know we were liable for the house? Our names are not on the deeds?

when we realised that the house (was in effect) our responsibility we made steps to ensure it was a good standard for her to live in but obviously this wasn’t cheap and we did not have enough savings so used some of the equity in our house to do hers up to provide a decent place to live.
unfortunately the house needed a full refurb to make it meet modern day standards.

I work FT along with DH to afford our mortgage whilst paying for our children’s needs/hobbies we don’t really have much spare cash (as most people don’t)

we have encouraged her to move as property is substantially cheaper in our area and said she could have loads of money in the bank that she could spend/sit on if she moved but she now refuses to do it.
we’ve even encouraged her to look for a smaller property in her own area so she could release some money but we’re interfering and she doesn’t want to move.

Unfortunately, there is nothing in the trust that says she has to maintain the property . She has never paid any rent to anyone. She retired on her 60th birthday and has never worked since (15+ years)

DS earns £20k on an apprenticeship wage (he did start substantially lower but this raise happened in September) so I think he can afford the rent.

I didn’t think I was money grabbing as I was trying to encourage realistic life to my DS whilst providing a safe environment.

OP posts:
KatherineJaneway · 27/10/2022 14:44

Can't believe anyone voted YANBU

ittakes2 · 27/10/2022 14:07

The renovations you funded were for a house your husband in theory owns?

ancientgran · 27/10/2022 13:45

uncomfortablydumb53 · 27/10/2022 12:53

It all sounds very transactional
I'm not sure of the implications if MiL needed to go in a home and pay for care.?
Does DS know he is in effect accruing his own savings
I actually feel a bit sorry for your DS
Yes of course he should pay his way, but usually Grandparents love having Grandchildren around

She might love having him around but can't afford it. Maybe she puts the heating on when he's there but she'd go to bed if she was on her own, maybe she has the hot water on more. She might not cook meals for him but he probably use brea, tea, milk. If she's only got the SRP it all adds up.

ancientgran · 27/10/2022 13:43

user1471457751 · 27/10/2022 12:34

@ancientgran The point is the husband has very few rights over this property right now but was expected to shoulder the financial burden with no complaint.

I agree with you that it would be better to sell up and move MIL to a more affordable property they could maintain. But it seems like the MIL didn't want to move. She also kept this situation from her son. The OP stated that they've only know about the house not actually belonging to the MIL for 4 years because the MIL kept it a secret from her son.

He's going to benefit from the improvements, he paid and I think that is reasonable. It seems likely that his mother hasn't got the money to do it.

I'm not sure about why he wouldn't know it was his house, wouldn't the executor have to inform him? Wouldn't it have stamp duty implications when he bought a house?

NextPrimeMinister · 27/10/2022 13:10

Sounds like the MIL is pretty skint so any contributions to the household sound welcome.

Agree with pp if she stopped having to pay 125 (interest only) she could have the GC for free on the odd night.

Op, if you want to teach your child about money then let him take over all his bills, save his own 200 and pay you 50 quid a week for food etc.

There's only one money grabber in this story.

Ponoka7 · 27/10/2022 12:57

Was she married to the person who has left your DH the house? Has anyone checked if it was legal for her to be passed over in the will? Or did the Grandad believe that women shouldn't inherit?

I agree that she shouldn't be made responsible for the interest on the loan. You should do that on the basis he stays for free, but buys his own food. Savings can be a red herring with the elderly, they'll often live in poverty to make sure that they aren't going to ever be a burden. You charge him, but expect her not to. As for working part time, a lot of women did because of what was expected in the family (care wise) and housework. Choices were limited and women were forced into not being the ones who worked full time, got mortgages etc.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 27/10/2022 12:53

It all sounds very transactional
I'm not sure of the implications if MiL needed to go in a home and pay for care.?
Does DS know he is in effect accruing his own savings
I actually feel a bit sorry for your DS
Yes of course he should pay his way, but usually Grandparents love having Grandchildren around

ChristinaXYZ · 27/10/2022 12:45

She is short of money. It is not unreasonable for your son to contribute to her expenses including power and cleaning. He presumably uses the shower, charges his gadgets, boils her kettle, dirties towels and bed linen. £25 a night seems a bit high but that is for him to negotiate with her.

Young people used to pay rent to their parents without question. I did. and I charge DC rent, not much, but some. It is important. Stops people treating the place like a hotel. Makes them think about what they spend. I was a better budgeter I think because of it when I was very young. I always seem to be better off than my contemporaries on similar wages and I am convinced it is because of my parents charging me rent and the mentality that gave me.

PhilomenaPringle · 27/10/2022 12:43

Your DH is getting his mum to pay the interest on an upgrade to a property held in trust for him? He’s the CF here, and if she only has the state pension this must leave her incredibly short of money

Quite

PurplePansy05 · 27/10/2022 12:43

user1471457751 · 27/10/2022 12:29

@PurplePansy05 nobody knows what it says but that hasn't stopped other posters commenting on it and accusing the OP of being selfish.

She was a single mum to one child and that one child, surprise surprise, grew up. Of course she could have worked full-time at some point in her life. Those of us who don't get to live rent free have to. Being a single mum to one is not a reason to have never worked full-time in a c.40 year working life.

YABVU.

PhilomenaPringle · 27/10/2022 12:40

I think yabu. You paid to upgrade a house that your dh will inherit

And getting the mil to pay for the loan.

AnApparitionQuipped · 27/10/2022 12:39

What is she charging for?

Heating - having radiator on his room
Hot water - presumably he has a shower/bath daily
Water itself if she's on a meter
Electricity (use of lighting, charging phone, possibly TV or other entertainment)
Washing of his bedding
Her labour in keeping his room clean, vacuumed, bedding changed, cleaning of anything else he uses.
Wear and tear on bed, bedding and anything else he uses
Any sundries such as tea/coffee

OldEnoughToHaveReadBunty · 27/10/2022 12:39

DH owns her house. No, he wasn't obliged to pay for the improvements while she is living there but allowing a property he owns to become pretty much derelict is not financially sensible now is it? The loan he has taken out will no doubt be more than repaid once the house is sold in years to come. MIL is paying the interest, why do you think she should repay the capital too when that will more than happen in the future?

No, I don't think MIL should be charging her GS £25 per visit but then I don't think you should be charging him £400 per month either as an apprentice. You sound extremely mercenary.

The fact MIL lives rent free is irrelevant, although you are clearly bitter about it. Her DF made that arrangement & your DH will ultimately benefit.

Silvers11 · 27/10/2022 12:38

As ultimately, the house will be DH on death, we paid for the improvements as an investment as she did not want to move to live with us if her health failed and didn't want to go into a care home.

Why would your MIL be paying the interest on the mortgage now then? The proceeds of the house will go to your DH in due course, and you funded it basically on that premise. Seems pretty mean thing to do to be honest. 'We'll improve the house which we will benefit from in due course and it will help MIL stay in her home - but she has to pay the interest on it'.

I can see right there why she feels DS should pay something when he stays with her.

user1471457751 · 27/10/2022 12:34

@ancientgran The point is the husband has very few rights over this property right now but was expected to shoulder the financial burden with no complaint.

I agree with you that it would be better to sell up and move MIL to a more affordable property they could maintain. But it seems like the MIL didn't want to move. She also kept this situation from her son. The OP stated that they've only know about the house not actually belonging to the MIL for 4 years because the MIL kept it a secret from her son.

OriginalUsername3 · 27/10/2022 12:32

My aunt has a similar set up with her house. She is allowed to live in it, but when she dies it belongs to her DIL. She had still funded all the changes needed in the house to accommodate herself and her disabilities. So I do think you did something you weren't required to do there.

You also let her live with you for 3 months for free. So I don't see how she thought that reasonable but charges her own grandson.

I don't know a single grandparent that wouldn't love having their grandchild over to stay and certainly none that would charge! What is she charging for? Not food. Not washing. It's not like she was letting out the room. So she's charging for his morning shower? I think she's a bit shitty tbh but what can you do? She is who she is and it's cheaper than a hotel.

user1471457751 · 27/10/2022 12:29

@PurplePansy05 nobody knows what it says but that hasn't stopped other posters commenting on it and accusing the OP of being selfish.

She was a single mum to one child and that one child, surprise surprise, grew up. Of course she could have worked full-time at some point in her life. Those of us who don't get to live rent free have to. Being a single mum to one is not a reason to have never worked full-time in a c.40 year working life.

yoyo1234 · 27/10/2022 12:24

I think it's up to her what she charges but likewise it was up to you what you (didnt ) charge her for additional heating etc when she stayed with you. As she had liferent on a property belonging to your DH which you renovated you may have been liable for her rent (when she could not use the place). I can understand your upset though.

Beautiful3 · 27/10/2022 12:22

Perhaps she doesn't really want him there, and the charge is a deterrent? I'd just pay for a hotel room or suck it up at grandma's.

Juliejuly · 27/10/2022 12:21

sorry for typos too!

Juliejuly · 27/10/2022 12:20

Calculate exactly how much it costs your son to live with you, so food, share of council tax, utilities etc and then charge him that. Stop saving his money for him, that's really not teaching him anything.
Then tell him to find somewhere to stay for night's he's away, and if he can find somewhere for less than £25/night, then he can decide for himself of he wants to stay with is grandmother, or pay a stranger.

yoyo1234 · 27/10/2022 12:19

Sorry about typos

yoyo1234 · 27/10/2022 12:18

Initially I thought unfair when you said about how she stayed rent free at yours and you funded refurbishment of her place. No not sure. It is not her place it is your DH's she gets to stay somewhere owned by him rent free. She stayed at yours (owned presumably by you and DH) rent free- though yes she would normally pay bills despite liferent (eg heating, telephone, council tax all of which she would need to pay for in an unlived in house) . You oaid to upgrade a house owned by your DH.

AnApparitionQuipped · 27/10/2022 12:14

It's entirely up to her if she wants to charge him. No one is forcing him to stay there.

What's the going rate for a B&B in the area - I would say it would be fair to charge the same, less a couple of £ if no breakfast is being provided. If he's not happy he would have to sort something else out, but why should she put him up for nothing? He is presumably using heating, electric, hot water etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread