Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should MIL be charging her GC for staying with her?

186 replies

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 27/10/2022 09:33

Background - DS got offered an apprenticeship in a different town to where we live (2 hours away by train)
As we was staying all week and most weekends an agreement was made he would pay her £400 a month.
After about 6 months, his company changed how they wanted him to work so he was wfh more (he wasn't enjoying living at MIL's as he didn't know anyone, etc) so he reverted to doing approx 2 days a week there and the rest of the time here at home
We changed the payments to £200 to me and £200 to her. Over the last 3 months, he has stayed there only 3 times and as he spends the majority of time at home, I suggested I get the money instead.
FI - when he stays at MIL in the last 3 months, she doesn't cook for him (he buys his own food) & he brings his washing home- whereas at home, he generally eats with us, his washing goes in, etc

He has had to go to up for a couple of nights this week and next (he will probably not then go for a couple of weeks and then may stay 1 or 2 nights only)

MIL has said that if he stays in future he needs to pay £25 a night to stay (no food being offered still!)

For context - she is a single pensioner on her own. There is no mortgage on her house. Last year she stayed with us for 3 months whilst having work completed on her house which we funded and took out a large amount added to our current mortgage which she now pays the interest only on (approx £125 pm) never clearing the capital as her house was in a terrible state with no proper heating and electricity upstairs etc. We did not charge her for staying with us and she made no contribution whilst here (as in she never even paid for a takeaway one night!)

AIBU to think she shouldn't charge DS when he stays occasionally?

YABU - of course she should charge and he should pay
YANBU - he's her GS so should stay free (but maybe it would be nice to get her something sometimes)

OP posts:
MRex · 29/10/2022 10:48

Your DH is responsible for the house and should never have charged his mother money (HIS bank interest) if she has a life interest in the house. He's charging her when the entire point of the trust was that she wasn't supposed to have to pay for a home. That is absolutely disgraceful behaviour from him, and is clearly not what his grandparents intended. You should be ashamed of him, not supporting him. Your MIL should really speak to a solicitor to understand her legal rights, and you should help her to do so.

As for the boy, I don't believe for a moment the drip feed that you're buying him £200 of food and saving him the rest, it doesn't tie in with the rest of the penny pinching going on. He'll learn soon enough that he might as well rent his own place as keep handing over money to all the relatives. Regardless, for a once per week trip, he can just get a day return on the train, a network railcard would make it cheaper.

Flutterbybudget · 29/10/2022 10:36

Tbh, I don’t think it’s any of your business what SHE charges him, when he stays with her. It’s his choice whether he stays there or not. She is not obliged to have him, and he is not obligated to stay there if he feels it’s too expensive
Charge him whatever you feel is appropriate for when he is living in your own house and let him fight his own battles/ make his own arrangements when he is elsewhere.

BunnyBum · 29/10/2022 10:26

I accept a form of contribution previously but now she doesn’t sound very grandmotherly charging him per night with this sporadic arrangement and he buys his own food. I’d look into staying in a travel lodge if there’s one near by!

YeOldNoName · 29/10/2022 10:22

Wereongunoil · 27/10/2022 09:47

Assuming he could be staying 4 nights a week if he was there with her full time. Monday - Thursday.
That's 16 nights a month which works out at £25 per night if paying £400 for the month

Why do you think you should get the money for when he stays there?

Exactly what I was thinking!

PurplePansy05 · 27/10/2022 20:13

Now you're moaning about her coming for Christmas as well, on top of everything else? Honestly, there are no words for some tight arses sometimes. Normal people speak to each other and make arrangements accordingly, you know. They are also generous at Christmas and this includes not moaning behind other people's backs.

Anyway. Your DH needs to do his homework pronto and speak to the solicitor about the will and the deeds. And you need to stop treating life like a balance sheet. I wouldn't want my family members to have your attitude in respect of everything you've discussed on here.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 27/10/2022 20:04

Yes, you're right of course
The contents of the 'deed of trust'/ lifetime interest haven't been mentioned by the OP,.

ArcticSkewer · 27/10/2022 19:36

uncomfortablydumb53 · 27/10/2022 18:02

Legally it's called "reasonable market rent" so she has to pay something
In this situation DH is the trustee and MiL is the settlor
Therefore MiL should've transferred the house deeds to DH
I advise you to seek legal advice

You have no idea what the trust says.

Tbh we don't have a clue if it's even in a trust at this stage. My bet is a life interest trust and the mil owns half, with the other half in trust.

It's very common for a house to be left to a child but with, for example, the wife of the decreased allowed to live in it, as a life interest, or sometimes to also sell it and move elsewhere still with the house in trust, but not have to pay any rent. The exact conditions would be set out in the will in the first instance.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 27/10/2022 18:02

Legally it's called "reasonable market rent" so she has to pay something
In this situation DH is the trustee and MiL is the settlor
Therefore MiL should've transferred the house deeds to DH
I advise you to seek legal advice

ArcticSkewer · 27/10/2022 18:00

uncomfortablydumb53 · 27/10/2022 17:52

@Blueink
If MiL is on the deeds it is indeed her property
I said upthread that the deeds should be passed to DH
He can then charge her a 'reasonable market rent' but this doesn't mean she should be paying interest on his mortgage

Why should she pass the deeds on, if it's her property? It's either in a trust or it isn't. If it's hers, she doesn't have to give it to him.

She also doesn't necessarily have to pay rent, if it is in trust. It depends. She may have been left a life interest in the property with no need to pay rent. It's not a usual condition of a life interest that rent is payable.

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 27/10/2022 17:57

uncomfortablydumb53 · 27/10/2022 17:52

@Blueink
If MiL is on the deeds it is indeed her property
I said upthread that the deeds should be passed to DH
He can then charge her a 'reasonable market rent' but this doesn't mean she should be paying interest on his mortgage

That would be much worse for her as at present the house 2 doors along is being rented out for £2k a month and she’s only paying £125 p month (interest only)as we put the £70k for the refurbishment on our mortgage and we will pay the £70k off

OP posts:
uncomfortablydumb53 · 27/10/2022 17:52

@Blueink
If MiL is on the deeds it is indeed her property
I said upthread that the deeds should be passed to DH
He can then charge her a 'reasonable market rent' but this doesn't mean she should be paying interest on his mortgage

ArcticSkewer · 27/10/2022 17:49

The house situation sounds messed up. It's in a trust but also the deeds are in her name? Then it's not in a trust. She can get equity release if she owns it but she can't if she doesn't.
I'd start there, tbh, and find out what the reality is.
As for the rent, can he stay elsewhere instead? Easy get-out.

Blueink · 27/10/2022 17:49

@uncomfortablydumb53 MIL doesn’t have an asset and why should she pay rent on a property passed directly from her DF to her DS?

uncomfortablydumb53 · 27/10/2022 17:43

From what I understand about deed of trust( I have looked into this for myself)
MiL would need to pay a reasonable market rent to live in the property to DH BUT I believe the deeds should be passed to DH
Otherwise should MiL need care this would be paid by the sale of her asset
I would look into this and get legal advice

Blueink · 27/10/2022 17:36

DG shouldn’t have to pay interest on a mortgage when she is not the owner of the property. I don’t think you can have it both ways OP and would suggest the compromise is you stop expecting interests payments, but your son’s visits have no transactional implications either.

rainbowandglitter · 27/10/2022 17:34

Why did be bring his washing home? Does she have a washing machine? Does he do his own washing at yours?

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 27/10/2022 16:57

Thanks for all your replies.

I will speak to DH to see if he’s spoken to her about the overnight cost - I suppose I’m just peeved that she wants to charge DS now - he always used to go up and stay for a couple of days in the holidays to see other friends/ visit exhibitions etc so personally didn’t see much difference - but maybe as people have posted she feels that he/we can afford it.

I asked my own DM about it and she is shocked that MIL has said this which is why I wanted other points of view.

i know it’s petty but she always comes to us for XMAS (didn’t last year due to COVID) and always stays for at least 5 days (pre covid she would always come for her weeks summer holiday too!) and one of the kids gives up their room for her and she never contributes anything so feel we do plenty for her (that’s without us popping up to see her to cut the grass, fix shelves, etc) and we don’t expect her to pay us to visit but obviously this costs us money too. This is at the detriment of my mum who never visits me for XMAS as she’ll go to one of my other brothers (beauty of a bigger family) as we haven’t got enough room for the pair of them to stay at the same time - so feel I always bend to her as I know she doesn’t have anyone else.

in truthfulness, she has always been very tight with money and I believe, she is very jealous of anyone more successful than her - whether it’s DH who has worked hard to get where he is in his job, to her best friend being able to buy the council house she lived in and then sell to make a profit! (She can’t see that she has actually done much better by actually having a house rent free for 60+ years!)

In regards to the house, I’ll leave that one for the DH to broach with her! We have also discussed equity release with her but again she’s always been adamant that she doesn’t want to do it but I will ask DH to make enquiries where we stand legally on that as she may live another 20 years and we won’t need the money when she’s dead but the house might need a new roof and we wouldn’t be able to afford that!

OP posts:
SpacePotato · 27/10/2022 16:53

As others have said, have you actually seen the documents relating to the trust?
Do you have copies?

Why is her name on the deeds if she isn't the legal owner?

How could she sell up and move if it isn't her house and proceeds of any sale would go to your DH. It would mean he would have to buy her a new home or she would have to rent.

NextPrimeMinister · 27/10/2022 16:20

I'd advise you to look at the will as it sounds like you've not seen it. Most trusts like these have the responsibility of the upkeep on the person living in it. Your MIL.

But it does create the issue of her living in a house she could not afford to upkeep, it falling into disrepair.

Forgetting the DS / payment issue, I don't think there's anything else you could have done regarding the house.

Silvers11 · 27/10/2022 16:20

What exactly are the terms of the trust? As someone else said do they specify who is responsible for maintaining the property in decent condition? Is there any money also in the trust for repairs etc? Your MIL could live another 20 years, so you probably do need to know this.

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 27/10/2022 15:48

RB68 · 27/10/2022 15:16

I think you have to remove all else besides the straight transaction for staying over at Granny's whilst working. HMRC does have an allowance rate for staying over at relatives as an expense for business - its meant to buy a gift (used to be 15 quid but maybe more now) . It sounds like Granny is short of cash so personally despite all the rest of the background I would encourage DS to pay whatever is equivalent to the allowance for overnights by HMRC and tell Granny that's what it's based on as a "fair rate" given no food etc.

As to the house it is held in trust for your DH - he is the owner not MIL despite her lifetime interest. He has invested in his own property despite not currently using it/having use of it. He needs to maintain it and should not be charging MIL for this however it is dressed up. She has no responsibility to maintain it at all. Whatever he spends will be reaped when it is sold or passed on on MIL death.

I would use the overnight rate for Granny as a way to gift a bit of cash - the pension rate is low and I doubt she has much to live on - especially with prices rising like they are.

I’m not sure how you would feel if you suddenly find out that you’re responsible for a property that you didn’t know about and have to magically find the money to do that?

We discussed the interest only cost with MIL before we even knew DS was going to stay there and she agreed to this as she knows we didn’t have any extra capacity to pay for it - bearing in mind we have our own mortgage, childcare costs for other DC, kids hobbies etc.

OP posts:
LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 27/10/2022 15:31

girlmom21 · 27/10/2022 15:26

we would have paid to get renovations done earlier

But you know now and you're still making her pay the interest.

I didn't know you were even allowed to take out a bigger mortgage on one property to improve another. I thought the whole point was that the money is to improve the value of the property you're borrowing against

you can remortgage for anything 🙄

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 27/10/2022 15:26

we would have paid to get renovations done earlier

But you know now and you're still making her pay the interest.

I didn't know you were even allowed to take out a bigger mortgage on one property to improve another. I thought the whole point was that the money is to improve the value of the property you're borrowing against

RB68 · 27/10/2022 15:21

It will be held by a Trust with DH as the beneficiary - I would look into the trust as there may be capital for maintenance as part of that. Fundamentally you are stuck with the house till she moves out due to the life interest. IF the house is sold with MIL agreement the funds would go to DH not MIL

RB68 · 27/10/2022 15:16

I think you have to remove all else besides the straight transaction for staying over at Granny's whilst working. HMRC does have an allowance rate for staying over at relatives as an expense for business - its meant to buy a gift (used to be 15 quid but maybe more now) . It sounds like Granny is short of cash so personally despite all the rest of the background I would encourage DS to pay whatever is equivalent to the allowance for overnights by HMRC and tell Granny that's what it's based on as a "fair rate" given no food etc.

As to the house it is held in trust for your DH - he is the owner not MIL despite her lifetime interest. He has invested in his own property despite not currently using it/having use of it. He needs to maintain it and should not be charging MIL for this however it is dressed up. She has no responsibility to maintain it at all. Whatever he spends will be reaped when it is sold or passed on on MIL death.

I would use the overnight rate for Granny as a way to gift a bit of cash - the pension rate is low and I doubt she has much to live on - especially with prices rising like they are.