Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should MIL be charging her GC for staying with her?

186 replies

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 27/10/2022 09:33

Background - DS got offered an apprenticeship in a different town to where we live (2 hours away by train)
As we was staying all week and most weekends an agreement was made he would pay her £400 a month.
After about 6 months, his company changed how they wanted him to work so he was wfh more (he wasn't enjoying living at MIL's as he didn't know anyone, etc) so he reverted to doing approx 2 days a week there and the rest of the time here at home
We changed the payments to £200 to me and £200 to her. Over the last 3 months, he has stayed there only 3 times and as he spends the majority of time at home, I suggested I get the money instead.
FI - when he stays at MIL in the last 3 months, she doesn't cook for him (he buys his own food) & he brings his washing home- whereas at home, he generally eats with us, his washing goes in, etc

He has had to go to up for a couple of nights this week and next (he will probably not then go for a couple of weeks and then may stay 1 or 2 nights only)

MIL has said that if he stays in future he needs to pay £25 a night to stay (no food being offered still!)

For context - she is a single pensioner on her own. There is no mortgage on her house. Last year she stayed with us for 3 months whilst having work completed on her house which we funded and took out a large amount added to our current mortgage which she now pays the interest only on (approx £125 pm) never clearing the capital as her house was in a terrible state with no proper heating and electricity upstairs etc. We did not charge her for staying with us and she made no contribution whilst here (as in she never even paid for a takeaway one night!)

AIBU to think she shouldn't charge DS when he stays occasionally?

YABU - of course she should charge and he should pay
YANBU - he's her GS so should stay free (but maybe it would be nice to get her something sometimes)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Technonan · 31/10/2022 15:37

Do you know how little she gets on a state pension? Even if it's the full amount, it's bugger all, basically. She's probably panicking about the cost of fuel etc. She lives in a house that isn't hers and was apparently in a terrible state before you fixed it up (which was kind of you, but tbf, it will be your DH's house, so it's in your best interests to keep it up.) She probably had very little money for maintenance - you sound rather as though you don't really understand what it's like to be poor.

Jalepenojello · 31/10/2022 14:58

Maybe it’s less about the money and more about the messing around…

uncomfortablydumb53 · 31/10/2022 14:56

Was MiL given a lifetime interest in the hose?
Either way it's not right your DH is charging her interest on his own mortgage!
Legally he is entitled to charge MiL reasonable rent, that's it
Have you sought legal advice yet?

Itloggedmeoutagain · 31/10/2022 14:36

HiveBee · 31/10/2022 13:57

I bought my daughter a house, whats incomprehensible about it ?

I didn't say I didn't understand it I said I can't imagine a situation where I would do it.
I don't know anyone who has bought their parents a house that's all

Waynettaaa · 31/10/2022 14:26

YNBU but I wouldn't have charged my dgs in the first place.

TomTraubertsBlues · 31/10/2022 14:24

justasking111 · 31/10/2022 14:10

@LifeIsGreatForUnicorns I'm confused was a formal trust set up for your son. ??

The DH's grandad left the house to the DH in trust, skipping out the MIL. This happened when the DH was a baby.

The MIL presumably had the right to live in the house for the rest of her life, but has never owned it. Nothing has been left in trust for the OP's son as far as I can tell.

@MRex - you're right - the DH is the one who's been shitty here. Charging his mum interest on the renovations to his asset is poor behaviour.

TomTraubertsBlues · 31/10/2022 14:21

In this situation DH is the trustee and MiL is the settlor

How is she the settlor if she never owned the house in the first place? It was passed directly from her father's estate into a trust, in accordance with her father's will.

The granddad's estate was the settlor.

justasking111 · 31/10/2022 14:13

uncomfortablydumb53 · 27/10/2022 18:02

Legally it's called "reasonable market rent" so she has to pay something
In this situation DH is the trustee and MiL is the settlor
Therefore MiL should've transferred the house deeds to DH
I advise you to seek legal advice

So do I to avoid the HMRC coming down on you both

justasking111 · 31/10/2022 14:10

@LifeIsGreatForUnicorns I'm confused was a formal trust set up for your son. ??

MRex · 31/10/2022 13:59

TomTraubertsBlues · 31/10/2022 12:09

Grandad (MIL’s father) apparently left the property in trust when my DH was around 6 months old when he died when MIL was around 30.

What a horrible thing to do to his own daughter. He took away all her choices about where she lives for the rest of her life.

She was only 30, still young, she might have been able to move away and explore other opportunities in life if it hadn't been for her father not trusting her to own her own home.

Depends how feckless she was with money, or whether he was worried she might marry and the house proceeds be given away to a new husband. The grandfather wanted to make sure that she and the child had a home, she could have earned money to move away if she wanted to. Now that child is an adult, unfortunately he's choosing to (depending on terms of the trust, probably illegally) illegally charge his mother money to live in the home her father left her. Yet you think the grandfather was horrible!! Wrong man.

HiveBee · 31/10/2022 13:57

Itloggedmeoutagain · 31/10/2022 12:46

What led to this happening. I can't imagine just buying someone a house

I bought my daughter a house, whats incomprehensible about it ?

Itloggedmeoutagain · 31/10/2022 12:46

whatwasIgoingtosay · 31/10/2022 12:40

When my PILs retired we bought a house for them and never charged them rent for the 30 years they lived there, and we took care of all repairs (thinking back, they had a very good deal out of it, as they had sufficient pensions for quite a good life, but never mind, it seemed the right thing to do at the time). All they had to pay was council tax.

What led to this happening. I can't imagine just buying someone a house

whatwasIgoingtosay · 31/10/2022 12:40

When my PILs retired we bought a house for them and never charged them rent for the 30 years they lived there, and we took care of all repairs (thinking back, they had a very good deal out of it, as they had sufficient pensions for quite a good life, but never mind, it seemed the right thing to do at the time). All they had to pay was council tax.

Pixiedust1234 · 31/10/2022 12:11

I remember your other threads about MIL and housing and know your situation is very complicated.

What I am not seeing here is what MIL has coming in versus her outgoings. If she only has £125 per week (for instance, I don't know) coming in then her bills are going to be tight especially with the interest on the loan to you. Is she on a water meter and does he take hour long showers? What else is he adding to her costs? I also assume when he stayed with her the single exemption on council tax was removed and have you helped her to get it back?

Oh and saying how she has £6k in savings isnt that reassuring. If you have ever suffered from financial problems the fallout can leave you terrified you never have enough.

TomTraubertsBlues · 31/10/2022 12:09

Grandad (MIL’s father) apparently left the property in trust when my DH was around 6 months old when he died when MIL was around 30.

What a horrible thing to do to his own daughter. He took away all her choices about where she lives for the rest of her life.

She was only 30, still young, she might have been able to move away and explore other opportunities in life if it hadn't been for her father not trusting her to own her own home.

TomTraubertsBlues · 31/10/2022 11:58

You were upset with him paying her only because you’d rather get the money that he’s giving to her.

This. It's a pretty horrible mindset being shown here.

TomTraubertsBlues · 31/10/2022 11:56

You charge a low-income pensioner £125 a month interest on a loan which was taken out to renovate/repair a home which is held in trust for your DH? (So it's not even really her property to do what she wants with.) Fucking hell.

You are unreasonable for that alone. The words 'greedy' and 'grasping' come to mind. She's a low-income pensioner FFS!

I'm not surprised she now wants to be paid for overnight stays - it was you and your DH who made this relationship transactional.

YouMadeMeComment · 31/10/2022 11:33

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 27/10/2022 09:33

Background - DS got offered an apprenticeship in a different town to where we live (2 hours away by train)
As we was staying all week and most weekends an agreement was made he would pay her £400 a month.
After about 6 months, his company changed how they wanted him to work so he was wfh more (he wasn't enjoying living at MIL's as he didn't know anyone, etc) so he reverted to doing approx 2 days a week there and the rest of the time here at home
We changed the payments to £200 to me and £200 to her. Over the last 3 months, he has stayed there only 3 times and as he spends the majority of time at home, I suggested I get the money instead.
FI - when he stays at MIL in the last 3 months, she doesn't cook for him (he buys his own food) & he brings his washing home- whereas at home, he generally eats with us, his washing goes in, etc

He has had to go to up for a couple of nights this week and next (he will probably not then go for a couple of weeks and then may stay 1 or 2 nights only)

MIL has said that if he stays in future he needs to pay £25 a night to stay (no food being offered still!)

For context - she is a single pensioner on her own. There is no mortgage on her house. Last year she stayed with us for 3 months whilst having work completed on her house which we funded and took out a large amount added to our current mortgage which she now pays the interest only on (approx £125 pm) never clearing the capital as her house was in a terrible state with no proper heating and electricity upstairs etc. We did not charge her for staying with us and she made no contribution whilst here (as in she never even paid for a takeaway one night!)

AIBU to think she shouldn't charge DS when he stays occasionally?

YABU - of course she should charge and he should pay
YANBU - he's her GS so should stay free (but maybe it would be nice to get her something sometimes)

In my opinion, all of this is ridiculous. MIL charging him a nightly fee is her choice, and if she’s living on limited income then I could understand somewhat. My grandparents would never charge me, but I’d always offer and especially put food and toiletries,etc. in the house or wherever I spent the night to make my stay a convenience rather than not. However, it’s not like you’re any better. You were upset with him paying her only because you’d rather get the money that he’s giving to her. As his parent and the home being “his home” as you stated, why is he required to pay that much or even pay at all. You didn’t charge her when she stayed for 3 months, and technically paid her to stay with you as she got renovations done to her home paid by you and DH without contributing anything towards it. If you’re in a bind then it would be ok to ask your son for help here and there, but clearly you aren’t in need of extra money. Why not let him save every penny that he can do that he can get on his own two feet and purchase his own residence?

YouMadeMeComment · 31/10/2022 11:23

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 27/10/2022 09:33

Background - DS got offered an apprenticeship in a different town to where we live (2 hours away by train)
As we was staying all week and most weekends an agreement was made he would pay her £400 a month.
After about 6 months, his company changed how they wanted him to work so he was wfh more (he wasn't enjoying living at MIL's as he didn't know anyone, etc) so he reverted to doing approx 2 days a week there and the rest of the time here at home
We changed the payments to £200 to me and £200 to her. Over the last 3 months, he has stayed there only 3 times and as he spends the majority of time at home, I suggested I get the money instead.
FI - when he stays at MIL in the last 3 months, she doesn't cook for him (he buys his own food) & he brings his washing home- whereas at home, he generally eats with us, his washing goes in, etc

He has had to go to up for a couple of nights this week and next (he will probably not then go for a couple of weeks and then may stay 1 or 2 nights only)

MIL has said that if he stays in future he needs to pay £25 a night to stay (no food being offered still!)

For context - she is a single pensioner on her own. There is no mortgage on her house. Last year she stayed with us for 3 months whilst having work completed on her house which we funded and took out a large amount added to our current mortgage which she now pays the interest only on (approx £125 pm) never clearing the capital as her house was in a terrible state with no proper heating and electricity upstairs etc. We did not charge her for staying with us and she made no contribution whilst here (as in she never even paid for a takeaway one night!)

AIBU to think she shouldn't charge DS when he stays occasionally?

YABU - of course she should charge and he should pay
YANBU - he's her GS so should stay free (but maybe it would be nice to get her something sometimes)

In my opinion, all of this is ridiculous. MIL charging him a nightly fee is her choice, and if she’s living on limited income then I could understand somewhat. My grandparents would never charge me, but I’d always offer and especially put food and toiletries,etc. in the house or wherever I spent the night to make my stay a convenience rather than not. However, it’s not like you’re any better. You were upset with him paying her only because you’d rather get the money that he’s giving to her. As his parent and the home being “his home” as you stated, why is he required to pay that much or even pay at all. You didn’t charge her when she started for 3 months, and technically paid her to stay with you as she got renovations done to get home paid by you and DH without contributing anything towards it. If you’re in a bind then it would be ok to ask your son for help here and there, but clearly you aren’t in need of extra money. Why not let him save every penny that he can do that he can get on his own two feet and purchase his own residence?

hazelmurf · 30/10/2022 08:47

I could never charge any of my family to stay . If I was REALLY strapped for cash I would ask them to pick up some food for us .

PeachyIsThinking · 30/10/2022 08:38

So its actually your DH’s not hers but it is her home, yes?

Our adult sons contribute to keep but half of what you ask, £400 seems rather a lot.

Assuming MIL is laying out fuel bills I don’t actually have huge issues with her asking for a little on a small pension, but I have to ask- does she actually want him there? Does she feel she can’t say no as it’s really your DH’s house, but begrudge it after a lifetime of living alone barring a gap to raise a child?
Otherwise I suspect she’d choose to eat with him and cook for him.

I think what’s needed is a big sit down and chat but many families would never get in with that so you’ll have to work this out another way.

Also did she have a single person council tax discount that she loses when he stays with her? That’s come up loads on boards for single parents with student offspring.

I don’t know if £20 is that bad if it includes a meal, laundry etc and if his staying has lost her financial help. I hope I wouldn’t need to charge it and I don’t think my parents would but given the state of the U.K. pension she may have no choice- or she may not want him living there and be hoping he says no and stays elsewhere.

If she is on pure state pension she’d get housing benefit to cover rent so I’m not sure she can afford that £125 for interest on an investment in what is your husband’s long term ability to sell rent or occupy that house. It keeps her out of a care home but is it fair?

GreatGardenstuff · 29/10/2022 12:06

If you remove all the backstory, £25 a night to stay occasionally with a relative on limited means doesn’t sound like a bad deal. Obviously it would be nice if she could just accommodate him, but that’s not what she’s offering.

See how it goes, and if there’s future awkwardness, look at a b&b or travelodge instead.

zingally · 29/10/2022 11:58

Givenuptotally · 27/10/2022 09:55

Just so I'm clear, it's OK for you to charge your son but it's not OK for his grandmother to do the same?

THIS ^

I think the house renovation and the staying over DGS are separate issues, and to mix them up is a bit petty. Especially as in later posts you detailed that it was actually doing up a house that is going to be yours in probably not that many more years, and NOT a favour to a vulnerable old lady.

It sounds like she'd made plans for this money, and now the deal has collapsed, but she's still being expected to randomly host DGS from time to time. Maybe she's not really physically capable of this - the care element - of having someone to stay.
Reading between the lines, it sounds like she needs more support, rather than criticism.

Any reason why your DH - her son - can't handle this particular ho-hah?

Aprilx · 29/10/2022 11:27

I think YABU. An agreement was reached regarding what he would pay, he has now changed the days he stays there, why wouldn’t the amount paid also change. It seems to me that she has come up with something to reflect the ad hoc nature of his stays. And it sounds like he is staying there when it is convenient for his work / apprenticeship, it is not like he is visiting her per se.

DilemmaDelilah · 29/10/2022 11:15

I think that as the house 'belongs' to your DH he should probably be paying for the renovations even though she is living there, unless she asked for them? The amount she is paying is probably more than 25% of her pension. (I am assuming that her only income is her state pension) Perhaps she could pay a token amount of £50 per month, which is still a huge amount out of a single persons pension, and you should pay the rest of it. Your son obviously isn't that happy staying there, so he should pay for a Travelodge or similar when he goes away. As your son is 'earning' you can expect him to contribute living expenses while he is living with you, and what you charge him is up to you, but personally I would work out what you think it costs you to have him living at home and charge him that. He can buy his own clothes, toiletries, phone etc, you charge a percentage of fuel bills, meals if you are cooking for him, and council tax if it that needs to be paid for him. I do think that children who are earning should learn that costs need to be paid otherwise it is a horrible shock when they do leave home and very difficult to manage.