Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Halloween - arguing about costumes and sweets

33 replies

mamamuminka · 27/10/2022 09:05

Hello! A mum I know has just shared an after-school Halloween activity in her neighborhood and I thought I could pop in with my 4yo tomorrow evening.
I mentioned to my child I may have time to buy a costume before we go. My husband was really annoyed by this, as he thinks (and I mostly agree) it's wasteful and terrible for the environment to buy single-use outfits of polyester. We normally buy second hand clothes for children and often for ourselves too and don't buy many, if any, plastic decorations for Christmas, Easter, Diwali etc and I don't mind, in fact I really like this about our family.

However, it's too late to organize a borrowed costume, and I also know that sometimes it just feels nice to have a proper superhero or pumpkin outfit from a shop. I usually did not like the cardboard creations my mum always came up with at last minute when I was a child, and don't want my kid to be disappointed. We also have another event next week, and a younger child who could use the costume at least a couple of times before we pass it on so it will not be SO bad to have a costume at home.

Now, Halloween is not something we ever celebrated as children and it is something we associate with American culture, but I know the origins of the celebrations are not American, and as my kids are British I think it's part of their heritage in a way now. Apart from being annoyed about the costume, my husband also didn't like the idea of sweets - and this whole thing just makes me want to just give up and not even try as it will either end up in my child being disappointed by lack of costume (maybe I'm projecting onto him though and he won't care?), or endure silent treatment from husband for daring to buy a tacky outfit and joining in on the fun.
Deep inside I think the idea of Halloween appeals to me as it offers a different perspective on death and passing than the one I grew up in, and in a way it could offer my youngster a different perspective to think about death later on when he's a bit older.

What are your thoughts on finding compromise in a situation like this? Atm I feel like my husband is just sapping out all joy out of my idea for a nice afternoon.

OP posts:
TuxedoJunction · 27/10/2022 09:35

There are loads of Vguc costumes on Facebook Marketplace. I’d always look here first before buying new for this kind of thing. Most are around £5.

watcherintherye · 27/10/2022 09:34

Mine used to wear a cheap black hooded cloak with black/dark clothing under, and a mask. The cloak used to double up for book day (Harry Potter!) Keep it simple! Halloween Grin

TheKeatingFive · 27/10/2022 09:33

No Halloween outfit has to be single use. Buy big, use again next year, put with the dressing up clothes so it can be used year round, pass on when you're done.

He's making a real mountain out of a mole hill here.

Topgub · 27/10/2022 09:32

This doesn't sound like a Halloween problem. It sounds like a husband problem.

Is he always a prick if he doesn't get his own way?

When do you ever get to do what you want?

EatYourVegetables · 27/10/2022 09:29

Charity shops are amazing for Halloween costumes. You can buy one 2-3 sizes too big, use for a few years, then give back to the charity shop. It doesn’t have to be single use or new.

TeenDivided · 27/10/2022 09:28

Halloween costumes. Buy big and they will last 2 years at least, and then hand them on. Or there may be some in charity shops still.

rainydaysandcake · 27/10/2022 09:25

Ive always loved Halloween, even as a child. My parents didn't have much disposable income but as soon as I was in secondary school I would organise little Halloween parties for my siblings and best friends. Make decorations and we would dress up with what ever we would find. I never had a proper ship bought costume.

Unfortunately my DH really dislikes Halloween, and all the fuss as he thinks it's too Americanised.

I've always tried to have little Halloween celebrations with either just us a family or with a few friends, and my DH sees how excited the kids get and might not like it, but he does support me and helps me.

I don't like the environmental waste so I try and buy better costumes if I can so that they can be reused eg for book day. I also have a box of Halloween decorations where I try and buy nice decorations that can be reused.

Re the sweets, mine may collect sweets but they don't eat much over Halloween and I save them as treats when we go for walks or have friends over

Gwdihooooo · 27/10/2022 09:08

Stick him all in black and pain his face like a skeleton.

I agree with your husband. I enjoy Halloween and soo do my children. We take part in trick or treat and I’m happy for them to gorge themselves on sweets for a couple of days. But we do tend to make the costumes, or but second hand.

Swipe left for the next trending thread