Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Halloween - arguing about costumes and sweets

33 replies

mamamuminka · 27/10/2022 09:05

Hello! A mum I know has just shared an after-school Halloween activity in her neighborhood and I thought I could pop in with my 4yo tomorrow evening.
I mentioned to my child I may have time to buy a costume before we go. My husband was really annoyed by this, as he thinks (and I mostly agree) it's wasteful and terrible for the environment to buy single-use outfits of polyester. We normally buy second hand clothes for children and often for ourselves too and don't buy many, if any, plastic decorations for Christmas, Easter, Diwali etc and I don't mind, in fact I really like this about our family.

However, it's too late to organize a borrowed costume, and I also know that sometimes it just feels nice to have a proper superhero or pumpkin outfit from a shop. I usually did not like the cardboard creations my mum always came up with at last minute when I was a child, and don't want my kid to be disappointed. We also have another event next week, and a younger child who could use the costume at least a couple of times before we pass it on so it will not be SO bad to have a costume at home.

Now, Halloween is not something we ever celebrated as children and it is something we associate with American culture, but I know the origins of the celebrations are not American, and as my kids are British I think it's part of their heritage in a way now. Apart from being annoyed about the costume, my husband also didn't like the idea of sweets - and this whole thing just makes me want to just give up and not even try as it will either end up in my child being disappointed by lack of costume (maybe I'm projecting onto him though and he won't care?), or endure silent treatment from husband for daring to buy a tacky outfit and joining in on the fun.
Deep inside I think the idea of Halloween appeals to me as it offers a different perspective on death and passing than the one I grew up in, and in a way it could offer my youngster a different perspective to think about death later on when he's a bit older.

What are your thoughts on finding compromise in a situation like this? Atm I feel like my husband is just sapping out all joy out of my idea for a nice afternoon.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Allsnotwell · 27/10/2022 10:56

All black and cat ears
Witches hat and an odd combination of clothes
All black and skeleton makeup
All red and devil horns
An existing outfit made to look deathly - Harry Potter with white face and scar
Even all white (LOL as if with kids) can look ghostly
DS went as a car crash victim one year with a white T-shirt and bandages.
Orange T-shirt and pumpkin mask
Freddie Crugger - striped top and mask

There are other options

OoooohMatron · 27/10/2022 10:54

I can't imagine a situation where I'd consult my DH on this. Just buy the kid a costume FFS. He can wear it for general dressing up afterwards and donate it when it's too small.

TheKeatingFive · 27/10/2022 10:48

I said " tend to be". All the outfits in our local shops are Halloween specific.

'Local shop' is the clue you need here to understand that your perception may not be entirely representative.

In any case, what would be wrong with the kid dressing up as a superhero if that's what floats their boat? Answers on a postcard.

RedHelenB · 27/10/2022 10:45

TheKeatingFive · 27/10/2022 10:30

Not usually in England. 4 year old tend to be cats, skeletons , pumpkins or witches

Seriously, do you data or something? No of course you don't 😂

I've seen plenty of kids dressed as superheroes for Halloween in England. And all kinds of other crap not directly related to Halloween.

I said " tend to be". All the outfits in our local shops are Halloween specific.

TheKeatingFive · 27/10/2022 10:30

Not usually in England. 4 year old tend to be cats, skeletons , pumpkins or witches

Seriously, do you data or something? No of course you don't 😂

I've seen plenty of kids dressed as superheroes for Halloween in England. And all kinds of other crap not directly related to Halloween.

RedHelenB · 27/10/2022 10:20

TheKeatingFive · 27/10/2022 09:59

A superhero costume will have nothing at all to do with halloween

Loads of kids wear superhero costumes for Halloween.

Not usually in England
4 year old tend to be cats, skeletons , pumpkins or witches

TheHappyLoser · 27/10/2022 10:19

I can see your husbands point of view, Halloween wasn't a thing when I was young, I went trick or treating once in my childhood.

However as someone up thread mentioned, Halloween is a huge occasion at a time of the year where it's lovely to have something to celebrate when we all lose the daylight and move properly into winter. Especially in the times which we are now living!

I am very similar to your husband eco-wise, but I bought a few plastic decorations for my home which I will use for years if not decades to brighten my front door for the kids who live in my street/area. Childhood is magical.

There are so many great suggestions up thread (I love the idea of Halloween pjs) so your husband can't use the environmental argument. In fact Halloween can be a very cheap and sustainable activity.

It sounds as if you do the bulk of the childcare in your house, therefore him deciding that the shortcuts you sometimes have to make to make your life easier or a bit more bearable don't affect him as much as it affects you. Lucky him!

And the silent treatment is abuse. I've been there and it's incredibly damaging to a relationship, kills it in fact. I would be making an appointment with a decent couple therapist to iron out that, it's no way to live.

mamamuminka · 27/10/2022 10:06

CellarBellaatemycoal · 27/10/2022 10:04

Can you compromise at some fangs and a bit of black/ white face paint, perhaps an old bit of black cloth/garment tied as a cape and be a vampire and red lippy for blood?
Although honestly why do you have to answer to this man?, but that’s another issue .

Red lipstick!! Gold, haven't thought of it haha. Can tell I'm a Halloween newbie.

But why do I have to answer to this man? Well I don't have to, but he's the father and he has the right to his opinion about the way we raise our kiddos. It's hard to find a balance sometimes though as what is too much, and while my automatic response is similar, "I'm an independent woman and can do whatever," I don't think in a long run it will help us as a marriage or family so want to take a pause and find better solutions.

OP posts:
CellarBellaatemycoal · 27/10/2022 10:04

Can you compromise at some fangs and a bit of black/ white face paint, perhaps an old bit of black cloth/garment tied as a cape and be a vampire and red lippy for blood?
Although honestly why do you have to answer to this man?, but that’s another issue .

DNBU · 27/10/2022 10:02

Agree with the poster saying all in black clothes and skeleton facepaint (or mask) or bat ears! Easy.

mamamuminka · 27/10/2022 10:01

CrapBucket · 27/10/2022 09:59

Halloween is often the first time that parents are confronted with the fact their child is growing up in a different time and society to the one they did. In my youth Halloween was a fairly minor event. Times have changed and its now one of the biggest occasions for children and teenagers.

Your husband could do with putting himself in his child's shoes and not his own. Four years old is a fun and magical age, of course they want a costume! Shop bought can still be sustainable as you can reuse it many times and then donate to charity.

Wise words. And yes, I'm excited about the magic and fun for my son!

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 27/10/2022 09:59

A superhero costume will have nothing at all to do with halloween

Loads of kids wear superhero costumes for Halloween.

CrapBucket · 27/10/2022 09:59

Halloween is often the first time that parents are confronted with the fact their child is growing up in a different time and society to the one they did. In my youth Halloween was a fairly minor event. Times have changed and its now one of the biggest occasions for children and teenagers.

Your husband could do with putting himself in his child's shoes and not his own. Four years old is a fun and magical age, of course they want a costume! Shop bought can still be sustainable as you can reuse it many times and then donate to charity.

mamamuminka · 27/10/2022 09:59

Thank you for your thoughts, I love to hear different views - shows we all can see the same issue in a different light and that's ok, just like in marriage.

I agree there are two issues 1) Halloween 2) husband:)

  1. I love the suggestion of paint and/or some normal black or orange clothes that can be re-worn so will get creative tonight. Loved all other second hand suggestions but unfortunately on this occasion I won't have enough time for Marketplace/Vinted etc. Lesson for next years, and I'm sure having a few outfits at home will avoid us similar dilemmas and last minute panic in the future!

  2. He's usually very amicable and easygoing, but for some reason Halloween and Valentines get him - the decorations, the commercialization, I think in his mind they symbolize mindless consumption and that's why he gets upset and comes across as really "hard core". There are a few other environmental habits that he's super passionate about (like not using paper towels which is not always easy with two kids, he doesn't like takeaways because of trash it generates) and his black-or-white thinking gets me even when overall I agree with him. If he was like this in all aspects of life it would be super difficult but in fact for almost anything else most our friends would say I'm more dictatorial:) I'm easier on myself when doing the eco-friendly thing is too much for me as a tired parent.

OP posts:
Crunchymum · 27/10/2022 09:54

Does the joyless, petulant DH have any redeeming qualities?

Things change. I hate Halloween and all its associated crap but I have DC and they like it so I bite my tongue. We don't do a full on Halloween but if there is a party (there often is as a relative usually has one as does the kids school) then they are allowed to dress up etc.

bloodyeverlastinghell · 27/10/2022 09:52

School uniform, a stick (aka) wand, harry potter lightning scar and a pair of glasses. It doesn't have to be bought (although I bought a costume for my lot so no judgement).

mamamuminka · 27/10/2022 09:51

Greenqueen40 · 27/10/2022 09:38

Is the party while he's at work? If so but a costume, hide it, do your party! No harm done, sweets wise just hide most of them from him and dole them out periodically when they deserve a treat. Don't make the children miss out because your husbands an arse.

Haha it did of course cross my mind but would not want to hide it or ask kids to participate in lying, we'll have to find another way!:)

OP posts:
RedHelenB · 27/10/2022 09:50

A shop bought outfit will last a couple of Halloweens at least. You could always donate to a charity shop just before Halloween when it's outgrown. Some people are killjoys, ignore and enjoy your child s excitement.

YellowTreeHouse · 27/10/2022 09:50

Don’t compromise. Get him a get costume and let him eat sweets - he’s a kid, let him have fun.

If your husband wants to be a miserable twat he can do it on his own without affecting anyone else.

Badgirlriri · 27/10/2022 09:48

Your poor child. What a boring life it sounds like he’s going to have! Buy the costume, buy the sweets.

GrazingSheep · 27/10/2022 09:47

Silent treatment from your husband if tot don’t do what he wants is not acceptable.

AloysiusBear · 27/10/2022 09:45

Also - is money an issue? If you are short of it he is absolutely not unreasonable.
I'm not sure why its worth arguing over anyway. In our house we each contribute to the joint account for bills & things the children actually need, then we buy "extras" from our own spending money left from our wages. It resolves these kids of disputes because he knows full well he has no say in how i spend the money i have spare from my earnings.

AloysiusBear · 27/10/2022 09:41

A superhero costume will have nothing at all to do with halloween.

In your shoes id try to buy an actual garment rather than a very obvious "outfit" made of polyester (the stupid zombie ones are particularly bad for just looking like ripped rags). They are always hopelessly impractical.

Eg a top with ghost, skeleton or spider patterns etc that can be worn again. DS has a skeleton top he wears whenever.

Or buy halloween themed pjs that can be worn as an outfit but reused as pjs year round at home.

Blinkingheckythump · 27/10/2022 09:39

Greenqueen40 · 27/10/2022 09:38

Is the party while he's at work? If so but a costume, hide it, do your party! No harm done, sweets wise just hide most of them from him and dole them out periodically when they deserve a treat. Don't make the children miss out because your husbands an arse.

Really don't do this. Roping your kid on a lie is awful.

Just get a costume, reuse it. Don't give sweets all at once. Problem solved

Greenqueen40 · 27/10/2022 09:38

Is the party while he's at work? If so but a costume, hide it, do your party! No harm done, sweets wise just hide most of them from him and dole them out periodically when they deserve a treat. Don't make the children miss out because your husbands an arse.