Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"How the UK became one of the poorest countries in Europe"

468 replies

user1471452428 · 26/10/2022 22:09

www.theatlantic.com/newsletters/archive/2022/10/uk-economy-disaster-degrowth-brexit/671847/

Article in The Atlantic. When people post about declining living standards, they're often shouted down- but I think it's pretty clear that it is real and here to stay.

OP posts:
TomPinch · 29/10/2022 19:10

BerriesOnTop · 29/10/2022 10:47

Actual countries are just raped of their resources, have their infrastructure run down, and then, when they have been so comprehensively shat on that they no longer have anything worth destroying, the wealthy flounce off to piss on somewhere else

Citation needed

Here is my explanation.

Most poorer countries are corrupt. The corruption causes the poverty.

Take South Africa for example. In large parts of the country the electricity system regularly fails. Why? Because it's not managed properly. Why? Because the people in charge either aren't interested in fixing it or they've siphoned off the money. A failing electricity system means businesses can't function as well and generate tax revenue. Even if they are, they may be inclined to evade their tax because why should they line the pockets of fraudsters? And so there's no tax revenue to fix the electricity system and round and round it goes. In the meantime the politicians have every incentive to blame everyone but themselves and the obvious target is colonialism. The voters don't kick them out of office because they don't know any different.

TomPinch · 29/10/2022 19:02

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 08:49

These figures indicate a basket-case!

What do the Irish figures say? Something proportionally similar, just smaller numbers I expect.

TomPinch · 29/10/2022 18:55

Walkaround · 29/10/2022 10:27

Aging populations don’t help, but they are in no way the sole cause.

They are very much the cause, and rightly so because people need to be supported in their old age. If the state doesn't do this then families must, as they used to.

I understand that most NHS spending is on elderly people too - how many 30 year olds are having hip replacements?

Whelm · 29/10/2022 18:42

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 07:40

This is actually the scariest pie chart I've seen.

www.statista.com/statistics/298524/government-spending-in-the-uk/

WHAT? Who is getting that money? I'm referring to the biggest slice of pie!

Who the fuck is getting that money and how? I fancy a bit of that pie.

You don't really - broadly 50% is pensions, 25% housing benefit, universal credit and similar, 25% disability and incapacity benefits.

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 17:46

And there was me thinking that the West banning Huawei infrastructure was the result of a psychotic advisor somewhere.

😮

Walkaround · 29/10/2022 17:32

@BerriesOnTop - but all this expansion is based on past history (in fact, is history), like the British Empire is past history. Do we have to have another world war, so that we can all contract, destroy lives and then expand rapidly again, complete with rapid population growth? Or do we learn to accept we are now living in a different world requiring somewhat different solutions? Can Chinese, or American, or European technology keep up with the speed in change of the climate, growing world instability, and the rapid increase in environmental disasters? Can our countries afford to keep dealing with these issues and keep avoiding increasing death tolls? Or will we have to start abandoning communities, struggle with rebuilding infrastructure, and start requiring the mass movement of people within the country, not just into the country?

BerriesOnTop · 29/10/2022 17:14

I don’t think you can use China as an example of what the rest of the world could or should copy

China followed the playbook of Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan. Has there ever been a more successful way to raise standards of living? I think not. And if anything, China didn’t pick industry winners quite like Japan and South Korea did during their development.

I agree it was not just greedy Westerners who created the rise of China, it was a deliberate policy of the Chinese state to exploit the greed of the West

Odd way to phrase something beneficial to both parties.

China clearly does not believe in leaving things to the markets, unless it can control the markets

It cannot control global markets and did quite abandon or at least place state sectors on life support. These are not the dynamic companies out of China that you ever hear of.

China does seem to be losing the plot somewhat now, though - no wisdom to follow on pandemics

Totally agree. I’m also not a fan of Xi

no superior ability to deal with climate chaos (which could plunge huge swathes of its population back into poverty quite rapidly, not to mention the millions in China still living in huge poverty, anyway)

What are you even on about? China has spectacularly lowered climate-related deaths over the decades. You should see how many Chinese people used to die in regular flooding and famines. There was one particularly bad flood in the 1930s which killed at least 2 million people. You don’t see numbers like these in modern times, despite the huge population increase.

BerriesOnTop · 29/10/2022 16:54

Thymely · 29/10/2022 14:53

An American journalist writing off the UK when the US is in just as much financial and political problems. The EU is also in turmoil with strikes, protests, high energy prices, etc, etc.

It is in a much better position due to the petrodollar, and it’s essentially allowing the US to export inflation. Note that nearly all other major global currencies have plummeted against the dollar.

Walkaround · 29/10/2022 16:52

BerriesOnTop · 29/10/2022 16:24

Lifestyles were maintained by transporting the pollution elsewhere rather than actually dealing with the pollution caused by the things we like to use, as though it would somehow stay elsewhere and not actually come back to bite us

China is very happy to make and sell you these things. Don’t pretend that it was dastardly Westerners coming here and abusing the locals—this is the only way that China found its way out of poverty.

It was cheaper to close our coal mines, not because they no longer had coal, or because of the environment, but because we could get cheaper coal elsewhere. It was never for the sake of the environment. The same with steel. Then cheaper for pretty much everything else

Well there was also an ideological ideas behind this too, no one was thinking energy security when they shut these things down and imported them from elsewhere. After the energy shocks of the 70s, France started their nuclear energy push—too bad UK didn’t do the same.

So don’t pretend it’s environmentalists that ran the country down

They certainly didn’t help and are a big reason why we can’t have nice things like nuclear power.

it’s profiteers going for the lowest common denominator who did that. Now the same profiteers are coming back here because they’ve run things down enough and created enough inequality that they think they might be able to make a profit out of making a mess here again

Profiteers aren’t coming back because they’ve ‘run things down’ that makes no sense. If anything, China has become too rich for some of these industries to thrive. But that is a good thing.

especially given the inconvenient instability, pollution and climate problems in poorer countries (which were caused by their activities there)

China has had bad pollution since the hard-core communist days. What countries are you specifically talking about here? And how does the UK link to them?

@BerriesOnTop - I don’t think you can use China as an example of what the rest of the world could or should copy. I agree it was not just greedy Westerners who created the rise of China, it was a deliberate policy of the Chinese state to exploit the greed of the West. China clearly does not believe in leaving things to the markets, unless it can control the markets.

China does seem to be losing the plot somewhat now, though - no wisdom to follow on pandemics, no superior ability to deal with climate chaos (which could plunge huge swathes of its population back into poverty quite rapidly, not to mention the millions in China still living in huge poverty, anyway).

Here is the rest of the world waiting for China to show us how to clean up the environmental mess, now that China has so much wealth and power accumulated it should surely be able to invest in cleaning up its act and make a genuine improvement in the lives of all of its population, but instead it seems to be turning in on itself and losing the plot. What’s the point in drowning yourself in toxic pollution for years if you can’t clean up after yourself when you have achieved the great wealth you seek? China needs to find some other patsy to take on the pollution, now. In the meantime, it has a massive population to keep under its thumb, through fair means or foul.

BerriesOnTop · 29/10/2022 16:36

I think the U.K. has its best productivity in the engineering, creative and finance sectors. (Feel free to correct if not). What would you add? Energy production? So the things listed below,.. oil etc

tbh I am not too familiar with British Industry per say, only that this idea that the UK went to China and ‘exploited’ it is really false. It was mutually beneficial arrangement (except for the working class but that’s a separate matter) and it really raised standards of living in China. In fact, it’s now getting so expensive due to higher wages etc that its not quite the good deal it was before!

BerriesOnTop · 29/10/2022 16:24

Lifestyles were maintained by transporting the pollution elsewhere rather than actually dealing with the pollution caused by the things we like to use, as though it would somehow stay elsewhere and not actually come back to bite us

China is very happy to make and sell you these things. Don’t pretend that it was dastardly Westerners coming here and abusing the locals—this is the only way that China found its way out of poverty.

It was cheaper to close our coal mines, not because they no longer had coal, or because of the environment, but because we could get cheaper coal elsewhere. It was never for the sake of the environment. The same with steel. Then cheaper for pretty much everything else

Well there was also an ideological ideas behind this too, no one was thinking energy security when they shut these things down and imported them from elsewhere. After the energy shocks of the 70s, France started their nuclear energy push—too bad UK didn’t do the same.

So don’t pretend it’s environmentalists that ran the country down

They certainly didn’t help and are a big reason why we can’t have nice things like nuclear power.

it’s profiteers going for the lowest common denominator who did that. Now the same profiteers are coming back here because they’ve run things down enough and created enough inequality that they think they might be able to make a profit out of making a mess here again

Profiteers aren’t coming back because they’ve ‘run things down’ that makes no sense. If anything, China has become too rich for some of these industries to thrive. But that is a good thing.

especially given the inconvenient instability, pollution and climate problems in poorer countries (which were caused by their activities there)

China has had bad pollution since the hard-core communist days. What countries are you specifically talking about here? And how does the UK link to them?

MarshaBradyo · 29/10/2022 16:08

BerriesOnTop · 29/10/2022 16:00

Pillaging and plundering are politer terms for what the UK is capable of and renowned for

Well I think UK colonialism stopped a few decades ago, generally you are paying for those commodities now, and paying dearly for them btw.

Where have we found them? In Yorkshire? Devon? Norfolk?

Resource poor islands must trade in order to
get the basics, UK will live and die by it.

How are you defining standard of living? Yours? Or mine?

Typical Western myopia. Cannot stand this—you have decent standard of living. I have lived much of my life in China—I have seen what industrialisation can do to raise the living standards of one country. The most people raised out of poverty EVER. Industrialisation and open global markets did that.

Maybe we could have made bankers, cynics, sceptics, politicians, philosophers, poets, artists, entrepreneurs, writers or arseholes out of them instead?

Have a feeling the UK will be back in the kind of poverty where most of you will not be poets artists or writers …

Berries I appreciate your take as it offers a different perspective on these threads

Just getting back to something simple for a minute just to clear something in my mind.

I think the U.K. has its best productivity in the engineering, creative and finance sectors. (Feel free to correct if not). What would you add? Energy production? So the things listed below,.. oil etc

other?

I get what you’re saying about changing landscape, just trying to think in terms of basics to form a picture

BerriesOnTop · 29/10/2022 16:00

Pillaging and plundering are politer terms for what the UK is capable of and renowned for

Well I think UK colonialism stopped a few decades ago, generally you are paying for those commodities now, and paying dearly for them btw.

Where have we found them? In Yorkshire? Devon? Norfolk?

Resource poor islands must trade in order to
get the basics, UK will live and die by it.

How are you defining standard of living? Yours? Or mine?

Typical Western myopia. Cannot stand this—you have decent standard of living. I have lived much of my life in China—I have seen what industrialisation can do to raise the living standards of one country. The most people raised out of poverty EVER. Industrialisation and open global markets did that.

Maybe we could have made bankers, cynics, sceptics, politicians, philosophers, poets, artists, entrepreneurs, writers or arseholes out of them instead?

Have a feeling the UK will be back in the kind of poverty where most of you will not be poets artists or writers …

Walkaround · 29/10/2022 15:04

And it’s comments like “only 6% of the UK’s surface area is built on” that reveal a failure to understand the problem. What percentage can effectively be built on? How do we link up the built up areas? What does that do to the habitats of non-human species? Are we planning to rely on the rest of the world to feed us, or do we need unbuilt on, fertile earth and biodiversity for anything? Do we need floodplains? Or is it OK to be flooded frequently? Can we build cities in the middle of the Highlands? How about our coastlines? How close to the coast can we build and develop and how quickly will they be swallowed by the sea? Are we building in sustainable places, or in inappropriate places dictated by the current economic profile of the country? Are we building appropriate structures for the changing climate? Are we dealing with all our sewage appropriately? Can we deal effectively with more people creating more pollution as things stand?

Thymely · 29/10/2022 14:53

An American journalist writing off the UK when the US is in just as much financial and political problems. The EU is also in turmoil with strikes, protests, high energy prices, etc, etc.

Pinkcadillac · 29/10/2022 14:41

We have a vast global population of humans and a rapidly diminishing habitable and fertile area of earth to live on. I don’t think fracking and coal mining in the UK are going to save us…

Only 6% of the UK's surface are is built on. Fracking is doing the US a lot of good although it may be different in the UK. Nuclear power shouldn't be ignored, it is doing well in France. I agree that coal is a thing of the past (although Germany seems to be keen on it again).

Walkaround · 29/10/2022 14:27

“It would be better to do coal mining, offshore drilling and fracking in the UK, but you and your ilk has really decided otherwise anyway.”

It might be better for a minority in the short term, but for nobody in the long term. It used to have great currency as an idea, under the promise that the free markets would come up with cleaner, better alternatives, but the clock was ticking and it was decided there was more profit to be had in lying and spreading doubt about the risks involved, and in offshoring the risks (out of sight, out of mind), than in making timely changes and investments. Lifestyles were maintained by transporting the pollution elsewhere rather than actually dealing with the pollution caused by the things we like to use, as though it would somehow stay elsewhere and not actually come back to bite us. It was cheaper to close our coal mines, not because they no longer had coal, or because of the environment, but because we could get cheaper coal elsewhere. It was never for the sake of the environment. The same with steel. Then cheaper for pretty much everything else. So don’t pretend it’s environmentalists that ran the country down, it’s profiteers going for the lowest common denominator who did that. Now the same profiteers are coming back here because they’ve run things down enough and created enough inequality that they think they might be able to make a profit out of making a mess here again, especially given the inconvenient instability, pollution and climate problems in poorer countries (which were caused by their activities there).

We have a vast global population of humans and a rapidly diminishing habitable and fertile area of earth to live on. I don’t think fracking and coal mining in the UK are going to save us…

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 29/10/2022 14:15

SavoirFlair · 26/10/2022 22:12

Yeah this is nice and stuff but we have a Politics forum on Mumsnet that isn’t a graveyard with plenty of recent posts

YABU

You don't own AIBU and you can't dictate what others post here.

Yes, there is a section for politics. There are also sections for relationships, education, employment and all manner of other things that people post about in AIBU.

If you're not interested, find another thread, but please stop trying to police the boards.

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 14:08

Believeitornot · 29/10/2022 13:59

The National Audit Office does.

Official statistics can be difficult to pick your way through if you don’t understand how they’re derived.

I'm sure you'd know how to do that though.

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 14:06

Believeitornot · 29/10/2022 14:01

How is the population of Japan doing in terms of outcomes? Are they healthy, enough wealth to go around, decent public services? Have they gone bankrupt?

If I was their bank, I'd be at the point of saying - listen dudes - you need to start paying me back some of that dosh now!

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 14:05

BerriesOnTop · 29/10/2022 12:40

There are occasional leaks of information, of course (eg the Panama Papers)

Generally that’s about denying taxes to your country of residence, not (as PP contended) going to another country, ‘raping’ it of resources (a really crude and totally unnecessary way to put it) and leaving.

but given the parlous state of the environment and widely publicised depletion of the earth’s resources

Our resources aren’t being depleted. We have plenty of oil and gas resources, coal deposits, uranium, etc. I even heard about ‘peak copper’ in 2008 but we’ve since found many more deposits so 🤷‍♀️

I think it’s fair to say the notion that unfettered markets and low regulation will sort everything out is a self-destructive pipe dream

Considering the high standards of living achieved by the West and much of East Asia, I’d say a lot of good has been done here too.

And even within the UK itself, it’s plain to see the effects of exploiting areas industrially and then moving on without a backward glance

Somehow it would have been better to let them wallow in poverty without any industry to speak of?

It would be better to do coal mining, offshore drilling and fracking in the UK, but you and your ilk has really decided otherwise anyway.

Generally that’s about denying taxes to your country of residence, not (as PP contended) going to another country, ‘raping’ it of resources (a really crude and totally unnecessary way to put it) and leaving.

Pillaging and plundering are politer terms for what the UK is capable of and renowned for.

Our resources aren’t being depleted. We have plenty of oil and gas resources, coal deposits, uranium, etc. I even heard about ‘peak copper’ in 2008 but we’ve since found many more deposits so

Where have we found them? In Yorkshire? Devon? Norfolk?

Considering the high standards of living achieved by the West and much of East Asia, I’d say a lot of good has been done here too.

Oooh look - there's a really big something over there - why don't you go and look at that while we get on with our high standard of living.

How are you defining standard of living? Yours? Or mine?

Somehow it would have been better to let them wallow in poverty without any industry to speak of?

Maybe we could have made bankers, cynics, sceptics, politicians, philosophers, poets, artists, entrepreneurs, writers or arseholes out of them instead?

Believeitornot · 29/10/2022 14:01

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 11:18

Look, this should cheer us up.

We could be Japan! 😮

www.economicshelp.org/blog/774/economics/list-of-national-debt-by-country/

How is the population of Japan doing in terms of outcomes? Are they healthy, enough wealth to go around, decent public services? Have they gone bankrupt?

Believeitornot · 29/10/2022 13:59

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 11:57

I too believe that there are things which are not adding up.

Who audits our accounts?

The National Audit Office does.

Official statistics can be difficult to pick your way through if you don’t understand how they’re derived.

Believeitornot · 29/10/2022 13:58

Considering the high standards of living achieved by the West and much of East Asia, I’d say a lot of good has been done here too

not for everyone. How many people are in poverty in the UK and Singapore for example? It is getting worse and has done for the last few decades as the oil and gas industries plus financial services has concentrated wealth in the hands of the few.

Our resources aren’t being depleted. We have plenty of oil and gas resources, coal deposits, uranium, etc. I even heard about ‘peak copper’ in 2008 but we’ve since found many more deposits so 🤷‍♀️

Says who? Plus burning oil and gas is terrible for the environment…. And it makes us so dependent on other countries.

It would be better to do coal mining, offshore drilling and fracking in the UK, but you and your ilk has really decided otherwise anyway

the UK is not suited to fracking.

BerriesOnTop · 29/10/2022 12:40

There are occasional leaks of information, of course (eg the Panama Papers)

Generally that’s about denying taxes to your country of residence, not (as PP contended) going to another country, ‘raping’ it of resources (a really crude and totally unnecessary way to put it) and leaving.

but given the parlous state of the environment and widely publicised depletion of the earth’s resources

Our resources aren’t being depleted. We have plenty of oil and gas resources, coal deposits, uranium, etc. I even heard about ‘peak copper’ in 2008 but we’ve since found many more deposits so 🤷‍♀️

I think it’s fair to say the notion that unfettered markets and low regulation will sort everything out is a self-destructive pipe dream

Considering the high standards of living achieved by the West and much of East Asia, I’d say a lot of good has been done here too.

And even within the UK itself, it’s plain to see the effects of exploiting areas industrially and then moving on without a backward glance

Somehow it would have been better to let them wallow in poverty without any industry to speak of?

It would be better to do coal mining, offshore drilling and fracking in the UK, but you and your ilk has really decided otherwise anyway.

Swipe left for the next trending thread