Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"How the UK became one of the poorest countries in Europe"

468 replies

user1471452428 · 26/10/2022 22:09

www.theatlantic.com/newsletters/archive/2022/10/uk-economy-disaster-degrowth-brexit/671847/

Article in The Atlantic. When people post about declining living standards, they're often shouted down- but I think it's pretty clear that it is real and here to stay.

OP posts:
Walkaround · 03/11/2022 08:03

I mean, really, arguing Brexit has nothing to do with our country’s problems because there are “broader issues” at play is like arguing Liz Truss has nothing to do with the country’s current problems, because there are “broader issues” at play 🤣. Sometimes, certain actions can make things even worse still.

Alexandra2001 · 03/11/2022 07:59

BerriesOnTop · 03/11/2022 00:40

What’s happening in EU is hardly UK’s fault. It’s just the same trends can be found, and energy is the big reason why Germany is in a recession. Tbh you’d be in this very same position, even if you were still in the EU because yhe energy crisis is driving this (oh and the wanton money printing during Covid).

Brexit is very peripheral to the problems you are facing, to keep fixating on it is very Little England kind of stuff.

Ignoring the reality of the GDP drop we had as a result of Brexit & the reluctance of foreign investors to come to the UK.... is stupid.... almost all investors, economists i.e the experts we were told to ignore, say this.

We have just made matters worse and are starting from a lower position than most of the EU, following ten plus of Austerity... did it ever end???

We ve an NHS that is facing difficulties even more extreme than CV.. according to their CEO... yet have lost the ability for workers from the EU to come here easily so they don't they go where it is easy to work, so we take from countries that need their own HC workers.

The war in Ukraine wont last forever, Putin won't either & other forms of energy will be found ....but Brexit and its effects will endure.... its most certainly not a side issue

Walkaround · 03/11/2022 07:47

MarshaBradyo · 03/11/2022 06:27

Yes to this. It needs broader thinking.

No to this - it needs to be admitted that whilst of course the broader issues would still exist, they are magnified by Brexit. As I said, the UK thought it was deserting a sinking ship, but that’s a suicidal thing to do if you are just leaping into the frozen sea without a lifeboat. Brexit solved nothing - didn’t stop the mass migration of people towards the EU and on to the UK; didn’t save any money for the NHS; didn’t cut bureaucracy; didn’t make the country more competitive; didn’t put Russia off invading Ukraine (in reality it encouraged Russia to think it would get away with it, as it was an indicator of weakness and instability); weakened the country on the world stage; weakened the country internally; caused massive problems in N.Ireland and issues with Scotland; put excessive pressure on all government services, as only an idiot inflicts austerity and massive administrative changes and increases in responsibility at the same time on demoralised , exhausted people… I could go on. Brexit has been an entirely unnecessary extra burden at precisely the wrong time in history. It’s like the country was going out of its way to usher back the 1970s.

MarshaBradyo · 03/11/2022 06:27

BerriesOnTop · 03/11/2022 00:40

What’s happening in EU is hardly UK’s fault. It’s just the same trends can be found, and energy is the big reason why Germany is in a recession. Tbh you’d be in this very same position, even if you were still in the EU because yhe energy crisis is driving this (oh and the wanton money printing during Covid).

Brexit is very peripheral to the problems you are facing, to keep fixating on it is very Little England kind of stuff.

Yes to this. It needs broader thinking.

BerriesOnTop · 03/11/2022 00:40

Walkaround · 02/11/2022 15:26

🤣🤣🤣 Ah, yes, the UK rat that thought it was escaping the sinking ship, but which actually leapt out into the frozen sea without a life raft after having gnawed as many holes in the ship as possible, first. Only an idiot goes out of their way to exacerbate a situation whilst simultaneously cutting off their lifelines.

What’s happening in EU is hardly UK’s fault. It’s just the same trends can be found, and energy is the big reason why Germany is in a recession. Tbh you’d be in this very same position, even if you were still in the EU because yhe energy crisis is driving this (oh and the wanton money printing during Covid).

Brexit is very peripheral to the problems you are facing, to keep fixating on it is very Little England kind of stuff.

XingMing · 02/11/2022 22:11

And the price of getting those jobs done now is off the scale expensive... if you are really hot at any of them, you can charge £££ per hour, not per day. Trades are increasingly valued properly and treated respectfully.

XingMing · 02/11/2022 22:07

Also from Cornwall, but I think employers currently need to work quite hard and pay quite well to keep the people that they see as the future for the business. We do, and haven't had anyone leave for ages, but a few of our team are closing on retirement age. And no one of 25 has a clue about old school skills that were familiar to most 12 year olds 50 years ago, like soft soldering. Yes they are historic, but they are still useful.

Walkaround · 02/11/2022 15:26

BerriesOnTop · 02/11/2022 08:03

This is absolutely nothing to do with the work ethic of the british man or woman, which when given good working conditions and decent management, have productivity levels as good as anywhere in Europe.... but we don't give them that do we?

Productivity levels as good as anywhere in Europe … all of Europe is going to have a big problem with industries shutting down:
t.co/dfoyA0F0uW

The EU will be in big trouble if this downward spiral isn’t stopped. Brexit or not, the same trends are evident in UK, so in the larger scheme, I don’t know why people are so keen to blame Brexit when it’s so obviously tied to energy.

🤣🤣🤣 Ah, yes, the UK rat that thought it was escaping the sinking ship, but which actually leapt out into the frozen sea without a life raft after having gnawed as many holes in the ship as possible, first. Only an idiot goes out of their way to exacerbate a situation whilst simultaneously cutting off their lifelines.

Walkaround · 02/11/2022 15:20

ShelaghsCottage · 02/11/2022 12:03

@Alexandra2001 Thats illogical... people who would be earning just above MW, aren't going to be able to afford to retire early... the people i know who have packed up work early are very well off and able to access good pensions from 55 onward.

Yes, you would have thought it was illogical, but jobs around here don't get filled.
The jobs I'm thinking about fit in well with school hours, so no problem there.
I'm just at a loss as to why these posts don't get filled and what people are doing for money.

Working in other jobs already?…

Alexandra2001 · 02/11/2022 14:05

ShelaghsCottage · 02/11/2022 12:03

@Alexandra2001 Thats illogical... people who would be earning just above MW, aren't going to be able to afford to retire early... the people i know who have packed up work early are very well off and able to access good pensions from 55 onward.

Yes, you would have thought it was illogical, but jobs around here don't get filled.
The jobs I'm thinking about fit in well with school hours, so no problem there.
I'm just at a loss as to why these posts don't get filled and what people are doing for money.

imho there isn't the churn on young intelligent EU nationals coming here now.... remember we never counted them in or out, so there really isn't any numbers on whats happened more recently.

I live down in Cornwall, just don't hear the east european accents in our local shops and the market gardener cannot get people to work in his Greenhouses, used to be EU workers.

...i think this has a knock on effect across all sectors, not least social care... where i know personally of the shortages of care workers as so many EU ones aren't here anymore.

Alexandra2001 · 02/11/2022 12:05

XingMing · 02/11/2022 11:34

Actually the acute short-termism of many of the City's investment advisers, funds and bankers probably explains why BritishVolt is in difficulties. It is very hard to get enough capital and working capital in the UK to fund the years before the payback.

The previous BV CEO explained it well, basically they are very top heavy in management and that management don't know what they doing/no previous experience/no pre orders/no product....
Though it was pointed out that he had something to do with that!

BV is basically a start up that needs 3 billion and is competing against est manufacturers with a cheaper cost base.. even in the EU.

Govt pulled funding too.. not just 'city.

The same CEO is now running a battery factory company in Italy... i mean Italy? we can't compete for whatever reason.

Brexit means its hard to get skilled labour and frictionless access to EU car manufacturers, who wants their product/raw materials stuck at Dover?

ShelaghsCottage · 02/11/2022 12:03

@Alexandra2001 Thats illogical... people who would be earning just above MW, aren't going to be able to afford to retire early... the people i know who have packed up work early are very well off and able to access good pensions from 55 onward.

Yes, you would have thought it was illogical, but jobs around here don't get filled.
The jobs I'm thinking about fit in well with school hours, so no problem there.
I'm just at a loss as to why these posts don't get filled and what people are doing for money.

Alexandra2001 · 02/11/2022 11:58

ShelaghsCottage · 02/11/2022 08:17

This is absolutely nothing to do with the work ethic of the british man or woman, which when given good working conditions and decent management, have productivity levels as good as anywhere in Europe.... but we don't give them that do we?

I disagree.

I can think of two companies in my area who can't get staff, despite excellent working conditions and paying over minimum wage.

IMO some people got so cosy being furloughed and sitting on their backsides during Covid that they don't want to work now.

Thats illogical... people who would be earning just above MW, aren't going to be able to afford to retire early... the people i know who have packed up work early are very well off and able to access good pensions from 55 onward.

XingMing · 02/11/2022 11:34

Actually the acute short-termism of many of the City's investment advisers, funds and bankers probably explains why BritishVolt is in difficulties. It is very hard to get enough capital and working capital in the UK to fund the years before the payback.

Kendodd · 02/11/2022 09:28

Clavinova · 01/11/2022 23:22

So all of the “expertS” referred to by Kendodd were just one expert

Only one expert was quoted with reference to Brexit on the webpage - as far as I can remember.

So you found an expert on China Global News website who also does work for the EU? Is that what you're saying? And you're putting that forward as a reason why the , multiple, experts on the panel I saw should have their expert opinion of the economic outlook for the UK discounted?

ShelaghsCottage · 02/11/2022 08:17

This is absolutely nothing to do with the work ethic of the british man or woman, which when given good working conditions and decent management, have productivity levels as good as anywhere in Europe.... but we don't give them that do we?

I disagree.

I can think of two companies in my area who can't get staff, despite excellent working conditions and paying over minimum wage.

IMO some people got so cosy being furloughed and sitting on their backsides during Covid that they don't want to work now.

BerriesOnTop · 02/11/2022 08:03

This is absolutely nothing to do with the work ethic of the british man or woman, which when given good working conditions and decent management, have productivity levels as good as anywhere in Europe.... but we don't give them that do we?

Productivity levels as good as anywhere in Europe … all of Europe is going to have a big problem with industries shutting down:
t.co/dfoyA0F0uW

The EU will be in big trouble if this downward spiral isn’t stopped. Brexit or not, the same trends are evident in UK, so in the larger scheme, I don’t know why people are so keen to blame Brexit when it’s so obviously tied to energy.

Alexandra2001 · 02/11/2022 07:32

Clavinova · 01/11/2022 23:32

But Kendodd refers to watching it, not reading it

She exaggerated the number of experts blaming Brexit?

Economists and politicians around the world judge Brexit as an economic disaster... no one but a fool would argue otherwise.

Listening (on R4) about the EU repeal bill going through Parliament, a mess, no legislation to replace some very important laws and even Sunak is looking to extend the deadline into 2024.... more uncertainty (markets/investors love that) ....more delay and ministers with absolute power to remove law... with no specific vote on it.

Alexandra2001 · 02/11/2022 07:26

@Florenz
It's everyone's fault. People blaming the Tories and saying everything will be better under Labour are living in denial. As are those blaming Labour, as are those blaming politicians in general. No-one wants to work hard for a living, no-one wants to work in manufacturing making things that people want. People look at working in finance or the "creative" sector as being higher status than wearing overalls and carrying a lunchbox to work. It's not unique to this country but the class system which still persists here has made things worse

BritishVolt, a company hailed (by Bojo and the tories) as proof Brexit is a great idea is on the verge of administration....it has no money, its management is shite/no experience, no history or expertise in making batteries and hasn't a single order for its imaginary batteries.... oh hasn't even got a production facility...

This is absolutely nothing to do with the work ethic of the british man or woman, which when given good working conditions and decent management, have productivity levels as good as anywhere in Europe.... but we don't give them that do we?

Same with any industry we've ever had, poor management & even worse R&D..... be it cars, motorcycles, bicycles (Raleigh factory now a housing estate) the list is endless :(

People making things, going to work in overalls and lunch box??? are you stuck in the 50's?

Ime the british work bloody hard, look at health workers? on average working 6 days for 5 days pay......

Where i do agree is that this has happened under various Govt's BUT at least none previously were stupid enough to take us out of one of thr worlds wealthiest trading bloc's...

Poor Maggie must be turning in her grave over what the Tories have gone and done

Walkaround · 02/11/2022 06:49

He/she was very specific that all of them put “a great deal of it” down to Brexit and that there was more than one expert.

Clavinova · 01/11/2022 23:32

But Kendodd refers to watching it, not reading it

She exaggerated the number of experts blaming Brexit?

Walkaround · 01/11/2022 23:26

Clavinova · 01/11/2022 23:22

So all of the “expertS” referred to by Kendodd were just one expert

Only one expert was quoted with reference to Brexit on the webpage - as far as I can remember.

But Kendodd refers to watching it, not reading it, so I don’t think an isolated quote from the website is what was being referred to?

Clavinova · 01/11/2022 23:22

So all of the “expertS” referred to by Kendodd were just one expert

Only one expert was quoted with reference to Brexit on the webpage - as far as I can remember.

Walkaround · 01/11/2022 22:26

Clavinova · 01/11/2022 21:11

Kendodd
Was watching China Global News last night, so hardly remainer central, they were talking about the UK and none of the experts could see a positive economic future, or, a way to turn this around. A great deal of this outlook was put down to Brexit by all of the experts.

The expert quoted on the China Global News website (Professor Ding Chun) has held the position of Jean Monnet Chair at least twice in the last ten years - which turns out to be an EU-funded teaching post - that's pretty much "remainer central" in my book;

A Jean Monnet Chair is a teaching post with a specialisation in EU Studies. Based on a competitive selection process, the European Commission, through its Education, Audiovisual and Culture Executive Agency (EACEA), awards the Chair to qualified professors who teach a minimum of 90 hours per academic year on topics relevant to European integration. In addition to course development, a Jean Monnet Chair supports research on EU subjects as well as outreach and training activities. Jean Monnet Chairs are funded for a three-year period up to a maximum of €50,000.

So all of the “expertS” referred to by Kendodd were just one expert, then, and China Global News is also funded by the EU?…

Clavinova · 01/11/2022 21:11

Kendodd
Was watching China Global News last night, so hardly remainer central, they were talking about the UK and none of the experts could see a positive economic future, or, a way to turn this around. A great deal of this outlook was put down to Brexit by all of the experts.

The expert quoted on the China Global News website (Professor Ding Chun) has held the position of Jean Monnet Chair at least twice in the last ten years - which turns out to be an EU-funded teaching post - that's pretty much "remainer central" in my book;

A Jean Monnet Chair is a teaching post with a specialisation in EU Studies. Based on a competitive selection process, the European Commission, through its Education, Audiovisual and Culture Executive Agency (EACEA), awards the Chair to qualified professors who teach a minimum of 90 hours per academic year on topics relevant to European integration. In addition to course development, a Jean Monnet Chair supports research on EU subjects as well as outreach and training activities. Jean Monnet Chairs are funded for a three-year period up to a maximum of €50,000.