Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"How the UK became one of the poorest countries in Europe"

468 replies

user1471452428 · 26/10/2022 22:09

www.theatlantic.com/newsletters/archive/2022/10/uk-economy-disaster-degrowth-brexit/671847/

Article in The Atlantic. When people post about declining living standards, they're often shouted down- but I think it's pretty clear that it is real and here to stay.

OP posts:
Ladyinpuce · 06/11/2022 20:55

@XingMing So why on earth is tidal powergen not taken more seriously?

I'm not sure what your issue is but ^^ this looks like a question to me ?

Ladyinpuce · 06/11/2022 20:46

"Oh here we go again, another Brexit-bashing thread."

The national debt is now over 100% the size of the economy and we will be running a huge budget deficit for many years to come, in which more goes out than comes in. And the cost of interest payments on our debt, before we pay back a penny, is now north of £80 billion a year - that’s more than the defence budget.
Inflation is running at over 10%, which is bad news for everyone, because it simply reduces the value of money and with the main lever to control it being raised interest rates, it means the cost of our mortgages, loans and credit cards goes up as well.
Bitter Remainers will have you believe this is all down to our decision to leave the European Union, which doesn’t explain raging inflation and recession on the Continent. I’m not sure Germany had Brexit too did they?
The truth is that for decades we have lived beyond our means. Government after government has resisted balancing the books and achieving a level of public expenditure, that actually equates with our income, like you and I have to do at home and businesses have to do in the office.
The international bond markets, upon whose largesse we relied for too long, have gun to our head. Even a future Labour government in the pockets of the unions will not be able to spend with abandon as now it's international financiers who run this country, not the government.

XingMing · 06/11/2022 20:43

Duhhh... anyone who lives on the coast or an estuary knows that tides ebb and fall and that there are spring and neap tides, and ALSO knows that the pattern and times can be predicted quite reliably for hundreds if not thousands of years in advance. And while I thank you for the patronising link, I did not ASK any questions at all. I posted a statement @PandorasSuitcase

PandorasSuitcase · 06/11/2022 20:14

@XingMing However the tides do rise and fall predictably, approximately every six hours around the 20K miles of the UK's coastline. So why on earth is tidal powergen not taken more seriously?

You are correct in saying the tides are predictable but they are not consistent in height.
They vary according to the phases of the moon and also the seasons.
Ypour question is answered here - climate.mit.edu/ask-mit/why-dont-we-use-tidal-power-more

XingMing · 06/11/2022 18:55

It is @TheNoseHasit, but the wind doesn't blow all the time. However the tides do rise and fall predictably, approximately every six hours around the 20K miles of the UK's coastline. So why on earth is tidal powergen not taken more seriously?

TheNosehasit · 04/11/2022 19:52

BerriesOnTop · 04/11/2022 15:59

The most obvious is that as you shift to green energy, your demand for natural gas goes up as you need it for when the wind isn’t blowing/sun not shining. Particularly if you are swapping from coal due to air pollution concerns

also, Europe buys other things like fertiliser, coal, wood pellets

The UK is an island with a lot of wind. 🌂

TheNosehasit · 04/11/2022 19:50

Walkaround · 04/11/2022 16:08

So, it buys coal to get away from coal?! If you ask me, the lesson learned is that more effort should have been made to get away from fossil fuels sooner - look at the mess in the Middle East; the behaviour of Russia; the smogs in China and India; the climate crisis. None of this is Russian propaganda, it’s present fact. Countries with natural resources will always have a dangerous bargaining chip and often these countries are run by rather unpleasant dictatorships (in all but name) which are, apparently, willing to utterly destroy themselves and every country around them in order to try and get their way.

You forgot the main bit.
While stripping their own people bare and working them to the bone.

TheNosehasit · 04/11/2022 19:49

BerriesOnTop · 04/11/2022 16:49

the lesson learned is that more effort should have been made to get away from fossil fuels sooner

ok but the thing is, you can’t. Germany ended up in the situation it is in because it tried to go green—but you still need natural gas peaker plants to keep up the illusion.

Unless you have hydro or a nuclear fleet, having to use lots of fossil fuels is just the reality of things. And even hydro or nuclear just gets at electricity generation, you still need fossil fuels for loads of other things.

either EU politicians are really poorly informed or they don’t tell their voters the truth. I’d say it’s the former, because they haven’t even prepared for these scenarios.

and you have prepared how?

Because all I see from here is some muppet with an axe to grind.

Cheers! 👊

TheNosehasit · 04/11/2022 19:45

BerriesOnTop · 04/11/2022 15:46

I’m no fan of Xi, and I know it’s economically destructive policy that just saves his face. I totally agree with what you say about it but … it has nothing to do with this thread

It has everything to do with the fact that you're in no position to preach.

Walkaround · 04/11/2022 17:30

@BerriesOnTop - or they naively assumed that if you need a commodity and pay for it, you get it in a thing called mutually beneficial trade, rather than having it deliberately ignited for no gain whatsoever to anyone. Unfortunately, countries protecting themselves from the insanity of those who would rather the entire world were destroyed than that they do not get their way, requires the scaling back of global trade and the waging of constant wars and destruction. You can hardly argue it was wrong of the UK to get cold feet over China being involved in the building of nuclear power stations, for example, when China is currently showing just how despotic its leadership actually is.

BerriesOnTop · 04/11/2022 16:49

the lesson learned is that more effort should have been made to get away from fossil fuels sooner

ok but the thing is, you can’t. Germany ended up in the situation it is in because it tried to go green—but you still need natural gas peaker plants to keep up the illusion.

Unless you have hydro or a nuclear fleet, having to use lots of fossil fuels is just the reality of things. And even hydro or nuclear just gets at electricity generation, you still need fossil fuels for loads of other things.

either EU politicians are really poorly informed or they don’t tell their voters the truth. I’d say it’s the former, because they haven’t even prepared for these scenarios.

Walkaround · 04/11/2022 16:08

So, it buys coal to get away from coal?! If you ask me, the lesson learned is that more effort should have been made to get away from fossil fuels sooner - look at the mess in the Middle East; the behaviour of Russia; the smogs in China and India; the climate crisis. None of this is Russian propaganda, it’s present fact. Countries with natural resources will always have a dangerous bargaining chip and often these countries are run by rather unpleasant dictatorships (in all but name) which are, apparently, willing to utterly destroy themselves and every country around them in order to try and get their way.

BerriesOnTop · 04/11/2022 15:59

Walkaround · 04/11/2022 15:52

And what in earth is your point about Russian commodities. Why would green propaganda make Europe buy more Russian commodities?

The most obvious is that as you shift to green energy, your demand for natural gas goes up as you need it for when the wind isn’t blowing/sun not shining. Particularly if you are swapping from coal due to air pollution concerns

also, Europe buys other things like fertiliser, coal, wood pellets

Walkaround · 04/11/2022 15:52

And what in earth is your point about Russian commodities. Why would green propaganda make Europe buy more Russian commodities?

Walkaround · 04/11/2022 15:50

@BerriesOnTop - it has plenty to do with this thread, as another myopic strategy of the entire world was to rely too much on China to make stuff for it, meaning China’s controlling and weird behaviour has a negative impact on us all.

BerriesOnTop · 04/11/2022 15:46

Walkaround · 04/11/2022 15:37

@BerriesOnTop - I hate to put it so baldfaced, but I’m so tired of enemies of Europe and the UK spouting their propaganda. You say you are from China, originally - more allied to Russia than the US or Europe and ruled by people so incapable of losing face that they are still inflicting zero covid and extreme paranoia on their population. Rather that than admit their vaccines don’t work and they have no clue how to get out of a mess of their own making.

I’m no fan of Xi, and I know it’s economically destructive policy that just saves his face. I totally agree with what you say about it but … it has nothing to do with this thread

Walkaround · 04/11/2022 15:41

I guess invading Taiwan might provide a useful distraction.

Walkaround · 04/11/2022 15:37

@BerriesOnTop - I hate to put it so baldfaced, but I’m so tired of enemies of Europe and the UK spouting their propaganda. You say you are from China, originally - more allied to Russia than the US or Europe and ruled by people so incapable of losing face that they are still inflicting zero covid and extreme paranoia on their population. Rather that than admit their vaccines don’t work and they have no clue how to get out of a mess of their own making.

BerriesOnTop · 04/11/2022 15:29

And if you don’t think this squabbling has weakened the EU in Russia’s eyes and wasted a huge amount of time and energy for zero gain, then you need to ask yourself why both the UK and entire EU felt the need to squabble so much over the terms of it, if it is such an unimportant issue for the EU and generally such an irrelevance to UK or EU economics and stability. And if you don’t think Russia would be encouraged by a weakened, distracted EU, there’s something wrong with you

What has helped Russia immensely is green propaganda (which they fund btw) which has made the entire EU incredibly dependent on Russian commodities.

Its not like EU + UK could do anything to stop or even deter Russia. You are utterly dependent on the US for security.

I hate to put it so baldfaced but I’m so so tired of British people going on about Brexit (either way) when you’d be in the exact same position—facing a prolonged recession and energy shortages caused by political myopia. The whole continent (such as it is) is in trouble imho

TheNosehasit · 04/11/2022 09:10

Britain facing longest recession since records began

If you want to enjoy your weekend and remain in cloud cuckoo land, I suggest you don't read this article.

TheNosehasit · 04/11/2022 09:05

BerriesOnTop · 03/11/2022 00:40

What’s happening in EU is hardly UK’s fault. It’s just the same trends can be found, and energy is the big reason why Germany is in a recession. Tbh you’d be in this very same position, even if you were still in the EU because yhe energy crisis is driving this (oh and the wanton money printing during Covid).

Brexit is very peripheral to the problems you are facing, to keep fixating on it is very Little England kind of stuff.

Andrew Bailey, the Bank of England governor, when asked by Channel 4 News if the market meltdown in September was caused solely by global factors
“I don't really think that is the case. Certainly, global markets have had shocks this year, we’ve had common shocks, Ukraine would be an example, but this was a particularly UK issue.”

Walkaround · 03/11/2022 15:01

@BerriesOnTop - I don’t live in the UK anymore and never did when the Brexit debate was happening. It just seems to be an obsession among a certain set to blame what are clearly global trends on Brexit, which is odd to me.

What do you think the whole Brexit debate was about, other than an obsession among a certain set to blame what are clearly global trends on the EU?

“Brexit solved nothing - Never said it did.

Yes, but you are clearly attempting to say Brexit didn’t make it considerably worse.

What kind of country do you think you are, that you are some kind of deterrence to Russia?

This is laughable. What makes you think I am focusing on the UK? Brexit weakened both the EU and UK and wasted huge amounts of energy on the European continent arguing over how to do it, instead of focusing on considerably more important world events. Yes, this is a symptom of general global trends of extreme idiocy, but the UK didn’t have to add this to the mix. And if you don’t think this squabbling has weakened the EU in Russia’s eyes and wasted a huge amount of time and energy for zero gain, then you need to ask yourself why both the UK and entire EU felt the need to squabble so much over the terms of it, if it is such an unimportant issue for the EU and generally such an irrelevance to UK or EU economics and stability. And if you don’t think Russia would be encouraged by a weakened, distracted EU, there’s something wrong with you.

You were all demoralised and exhausted in 2016? And you think you can have some impact on the world events?

What planet are you living on? The global recession started around 2008 and we have had austerity inflicted on us ever since. Of course we were weakened and demoralised already in 2016 - not because of the EU, but because of “broader world trends” that you are so fond of referring to. The worst possible response to the problems the world is currently facing is for countries to co-operate less with each other, instead of more.

And I don’t give a toss whether or not the UK has an impact on world events, but I care massively about whether the UK commits acts of self-sabotage to make a bad situation worse for itself. And I care massively if it does actually harm the continent it lives on by pretending it isn’t really part of the continent and can survive without it. We can’t survive if we harm our relationships with our closest neighbours - we need them.

BerriesOnTop · 03/11/2022 08:45

I don’t live in the UK anymore and never did when the Brexit debate was happening. It just seems to be an obsession among a certain set to blame what are clearly global trends on Brexit, which is odd to me.

I have in-laws who go on and on about this, which is incredibly annoying.

Brexit solved nothing

Never said it did.

didn’t put Russia off invading Ukraine (in reality it encouraged Russia to think it would get away with it, as it was an indicator of weakness and instability)

Stuff like this is so so laughable. What kind of country do you think you are, that you are some kind of deterrence to Russia? 😆

weakened the country on the world stage

You are just going to your rightful place in the global pecking order. You are not going to be a global leader inside or outside the EU, that’s just facts.

only an idiot inflicts austerity and massive administrative changes and increases in responsibility at the same time on demoralised , exhausted people

You were all demoralised and exhausted in 2016? And you think you can have some impact on the world events?

walkinginsunshinekat · 03/11/2022 08:07

Walkaround · 03/11/2022 07:47

No to this - it needs to be admitted that whilst of course the broader issues would still exist, they are magnified by Brexit. As I said, the UK thought it was deserting a sinking ship, but that’s a suicidal thing to do if you are just leaping into the frozen sea without a lifeboat. Brexit solved nothing - didn’t stop the mass migration of people towards the EU and on to the UK; didn’t save any money for the NHS; didn’t cut bureaucracy; didn’t make the country more competitive; didn’t put Russia off invading Ukraine (in reality it encouraged Russia to think it would get away with it, as it was an indicator of weakness and instability); weakened the country on the world stage; weakened the country internally; caused massive problems in N.Ireland and issues with Scotland; put excessive pressure on all government services, as only an idiot inflicts austerity and massive administrative changes and increases in responsibility at the same time on demoralised , exhausted people… I could go on. Brexit has been an entirely unnecessary extra burden at precisely the wrong time in history. It’s like the country was going out of its way to usher back the 1970s.

Exactly.. the only people wanting to minimise Brexit are the fools who voted for it & lack the wisdom to realise Brexit was a vehicle for a handful of people to get into power.

MarshaBradyo · 03/11/2022 08:06

Meh I appreciate posts from other posters. It’ll change back to SM or not going on about it every day won’t change the outcome. I’ll leave you to it.