Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"How the UK became one of the poorest countries in Europe"

468 replies

user1471452428 · 26/10/2022 22:09

www.theatlantic.com/newsletters/archive/2022/10/uk-economy-disaster-degrowth-brexit/671847/

Article in The Atlantic. When people post about declining living standards, they're often shouted down- but I think it's pretty clear that it is real and here to stay.

OP posts:
PrestonNorthHen · 27/10/2022 09:52

Eweknowwhat · 27/10/2022 09:16

Oh her we go again, another Brexit-bashing thread.

Can't Remoaners accept that they lost and just move on ??🙄

Everyone lost

Getoff · 27/10/2022 09:51

Why would people accept the damage its done and will continue to do to the country?

What is the benefit of the alternative? Do you get something out of making yourself and everyone else miserable by spending your time moaning, instead of using it constructively?

PrestonNorthHen · 27/10/2022 09:51

freyamay74 · 26/10/2022 23:00

Agree with Florenz - it's not just one simple reason. Also agree that tax credits were disastrous. Well intentioned, but ultimately disastrous, in facilitating a low wage economy where employees are topped up by the tax payer rather than being paid a decent wage by the employer. Tax credits have also encouraged people to game the system; working just enough hours to be eligible and disincentivised from working more. I remember a time when if you needed to earn more to pay the bills, you worked more hours, took on a second job if necessary or went for a higher earning role. There just wasn't an option to play the system like there is now. And yes, the fact that so many of the totally necessary jobs - social care, manual labour - are not given the recognition and remuneration they should be.

This !
People want to work less and have everything handed to them.

And the elephant in the room, high amounts of unsecured debt.
Not one poverty thread has mentioned debt, its always someone else's fault.

Getoff · 27/10/2022 09:46

Those are IMF numbers. Wikipedia also has World Bank and CIA numbers, which I haven't looked at.

Getoff · 27/10/2022 09:45

To put it in context, the 2022 figures, in USD and rounded, are

Germany 64K
France 56K
UK 56K
Italy 51K
Spain 47K

CoralBells · 27/10/2022 09:45

Eweknowwhat · 27/10/2022 09:16

Oh her we go again, another Brexit-bashing thread.

Can't Remoaners accept that they lost and just move on ??🙄

Why would people accept the damage its done and will continue to do to the country? What exactly is it that you think you've won?
How do you feel about being lied to that we could remain in the single market and it would benefit the NHS? Remainers didn't believe it but brexiters did.

Getoff · 27/10/2022 09:42

It's still not true that Britain is "one of the poorest countries in Europe".

Getoff · 27/10/2022 09:41

NicolaSixSix · 26/10/2022 23:33

Would’ve thought so, a couple of things happened since 2017

OK, I have 2022 figures from Wikipedia. The only thing that has change is that we've fallen from being a very tiny amount ahead of France to a very tiny amount behind.

(These figures are per capita, as I said originally.)

Eweknowwhat · 27/10/2022 09:16

Oh her we go again, another Brexit-bashing thread.

Can't Remoaners accept that they lost and just move on ??🙄

nootsy · 27/10/2022 09:12

think though a major reason for poor productivity in the U.K. is due to lack of investment by businesses. CEO’s funnel it to shareholders rather than capital investment.

Agree, the gov hasn't invested in the people & businesses haven't invested either.

Ponkyandthebrain · 27/10/2022 05:22

In 2016 Britain Had a GDP that was 90% of Germany. Now it’s 70%. Brexit making us poorer. The conservative government have been in power that entire time with a mandate to make Brexit work and it hasn’t. People who demanded it have to trot out this ‘we’re just not doing it right’ line because the only other thing to say is that it was a stupid idea. Why would you leave the largest trading organisation in the world on your doorstep and think it’s not going to make you poorer.

The reality is that in several years time we will end rejoining the single market on significantly worse terms because we would still be better off.

Austerity, over reliance on London to power the rest of the country, no investment in the advancement of our economy so no new industry and technology, stale and disproven theory of deregulation and low tax trickle down economics and a big fat stupid Brexit. Pretty good but bleak analysis

Bacibaci · 27/10/2022 02:15

yep & the wage stagnation & then they wonder why productivity is so bad

The wage stagnation is bad - austerity under Cameron and Osborne - began this decline as growth was sluggish. It’s economics 101 to not make cuts when coming out of recession but Cameron and a very willing media pushed for austerity. I think though a major reason for poor productivity in the U.K. is due to lack of investment by businesses. CEO’s funnel it to shareholders rather than capital investment.

VeniVidiWeeWee · 27/10/2022 00:34

Whelm · 27/10/2022 00:20

Top 10 Richest Countries in Europe by 2020 GNI per capita (Atlas Method, current US$ - World Bank)
Liechtenstein - $117,740 Tax haven
Switzerland - $84,310 Commodities, Food, Pharma, Engineering, Banking
Norway - $78,180 Energy
Luxembourg - $73,500 Tax haven
Ireland - $64,150 Tax haven
Denmark - $63,070 Shipping, Brewing, Food, Engineering
Iceland - $62,420 Energy
Sweden - $54,060 Automotive, Telecoms, Retail, Engineering
Netherlands - $51,060 Tax haven - Govt currently trying to kill agriculture
Finland - $49,700 Energy, Engineering, Pulp and Paper

The UK $39,970 is good at pretty well everything that 'richer' countries excel at, but our civil service does go out of its way to self-harm. Why so many BMW police cars rather than Nissan, Toyota or Vauxhall, why not support more UK manufacturers?

Especially since the BMWs they're buying seem to implode.

www.thetruthaboutcars.com/2022/02/uk-based-bmw-police-cars-banned-from-pursuits/

IAmAReader · 27/10/2022 00:30

socialmedia23 · 27/10/2022 00:00

I think that mortgaged homeowners are going to have a bit of a shock if the government doesn't help out and I can't see how they can afford to. At the same time, i would say they are guaranteed to lose the next election if they don't as mortgagors apparently vote tory for some reason and are a key demographic in swing constituencies. I mean, if i had to remortgage tomorrow, my mortgage would rise by £700. My mortgage deal ends in 2024 and everyone tells me 'things would have improved by then.' Well what if they don't and it woudl be close to election season.

Yes they may well get a shock but I think many Tory voters with mortgages have lost trust in the party of 'fiscal responsibility' and won't come out to vote for Tories again in 2024 regardless. So it might all be too little even if Rishi does help now.

£700..ouch! There has been so much damage done to the economy over consecutive years that even if Tories are out at the next GE, any party coming in ie. Labour will have a huge job on it's hands to turn things around.

TooBigForMyBoots · 27/10/2022 00:20

The author pretty much nailed it. Austerity followed by a rush job Brexit that no one had a plan for left us so weakened. The fact is that Brexit still isn't done and continues to negatively impact us as an investment opportunity.

As does our political instability. The UK is now seen as a basket case and the reason? Twelve years of Tory incompetence, arrogance and corruption.

Whelm · 27/10/2022 00:20

Top 10 Richest Countries in Europe by 2020 GNI per capita (Atlas Method, current US$ - World Bank)
Liechtenstein - $117,740 Tax haven
Switzerland - $84,310 Commodities, Food, Pharma, Engineering, Banking
Norway - $78,180 Energy
Luxembourg - $73,500 Tax haven
Ireland - $64,150 Tax haven
Denmark - $63,070 Shipping, Brewing, Food, Engineering
Iceland - $62,420 Energy
Sweden - $54,060 Automotive, Telecoms, Retail, Engineering
Netherlands - $51,060 Tax haven - Govt currently trying to kill agriculture
Finland - $49,700 Energy, Engineering, Pulp and Paper

The UK $39,970 is good at pretty well everything that 'richer' countries excel at, but our civil service does go out of its way to self-harm. Why so many BMW police cars rather than Nissan, Toyota or Vauxhall, why not support more UK manufacturers?

blackpearwhitelilies · 27/10/2022 00:16

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 23:16

I remember crying watching this when everyone in the EU bit us adieu!

So did I.
It’s not even the prosperity, though I mind that - it’s that I really believe in the project of the EU. Of course it has its faults, but overall I think it’s a force for good.

TheNosehasit · 27/10/2022 00:14

hamstermemories · 27/10/2022 00:11

i was under the impression that there is a possibility Putin might want to lob a nuclear missile in the direction of London. Its mad but he is a mad person..

We could scare him away with a bit of willy waving?

TheNosehasit · 27/10/2022 00:13

That said, Defence is a bit of a misnomer. Back in the day, Churchill was Secretary of State for War. At least he was honest about it. 😁

hamstermemories · 27/10/2022 00:11

TheNosehasit · 27/10/2022 00:09

We spend an extraordinary amount of money on Defence. Does anyone really want to invade us at this point? I think there is a lot of our money in arms. But who sees that money? I think that there are questions to be asked and greater justification for spending made. I know that there still is good-will between the NATO countries towards the UK as part of a defence strategy, but I'm not sure that our spending on Defence is entirely justified. Too late at night for me to try to google. I'm someone will tell me though!

i was under the impression that there is a possibility Putin might want to lob a nuclear missile in the direction of London. Its mad but he is a mad person..

TheNosehasit · 27/10/2022 00:10

*I'm sure someone

TheNosehasit · 27/10/2022 00:09

socialmedia23 · 27/10/2022 00:02

its true the economy is cyclical, but surely our performance would be measured relative to other countries. they all are exposed to the same macro-economic threats- ukraine war, china zero covid strategy leading to less production, higher interest rates during to relentless money printing etc etc.. But some countries would do better than others.

We spend an extraordinary amount of money on Defence. Does anyone really want to invade us at this point? I think there is a lot of our money in arms. But who sees that money? I think that there are questions to be asked and greater justification for spending made. I know that there still is good-will between the NATO countries towards the UK as part of a defence strategy, but I'm not sure that our spending on Defence is entirely justified. Too late at night for me to try to google. I'm someone will tell me though!

socialmedia23 · 27/10/2022 00:02

bugbugMNthx · 26/10/2022 23:58

A nice re-run of the 1970s for us all. I was there (though very little) the first time - it did get better!

Everythings runs in cycles, or is cyclical. Me, I'd like another punt at the 1990s, when we thought John Major qualified as a terrible Prime Minister and the Happy Mondays were on the radio!

its true the economy is cyclical, but surely our performance would be measured relative to other countries. they all are exposed to the same macro-economic threats- ukraine war, china zero covid strategy leading to less production, higher interest rates during to relentless money printing etc etc.. But some countries would do better than others.

Unseelie · 27/10/2022 00:00

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 23:22

Is there any consolation in the fact at a lot of those languages literally translate to 'until we meet again'? 😂

We could go back, no shame, and say 'ah we only joking there lads, we'd never leave you!'

“We could go back” 🤣🤣🤣 France didn’t want Britain in the EU for many years because they said we’d destabilise it. They were absolutely right.

I have no doubt that Britain will rejoin, but I won’t live to see it. They’d be mad to let us back anytime soon and when they eventually do we won’t be allowed as much power in it.

socialmedia23 · 27/10/2022 00:00

IAmAReader · 26/10/2022 23:43

I agree with this. I haven’t had much of a Pay rise in years but my standard of living has significantly improved once I moved out of my high rent flat in London to a far cheaper flat near Manchester - so grateful for remote working. People’s money are often tied up in rent or saving up for extortionate deposits.

I think that mortgaged homeowners are going to have a bit of a shock if the government doesn't help out and I can't see how they can afford to. At the same time, i would say they are guaranteed to lose the next election if they don't as mortgagors apparently vote tory for some reason and are a key demographic in swing constituencies. I mean, if i had to remortgage tomorrow, my mortgage would rise by £700. My mortgage deal ends in 2024 and everyone tells me 'things would have improved by then.' Well what if they don't and it woudl be close to election season.