Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"How the UK became one of the poorest countries in Europe"

468 replies

user1471452428 · 26/10/2022 22:09

www.theatlantic.com/newsletters/archive/2022/10/uk-economy-disaster-degrowth-brexit/671847/

Article in The Atlantic. When people post about declining living standards, they're often shouted down- but I think it's pretty clear that it is real and here to stay.

OP posts:
Fladdermus · 28/10/2022 23:52

Whelm · 28/10/2022 23:38

The good people of Rotterdam whom I've lived among beg to differ:

www.rotterdam.nl/loket/registration/

Are you staying in Rotterdam for longer than 4 months? Make an appointment for registration in the Municipal Personal Records.

By clicking the button 'Make an appointment', you enter a questionnaire to see which documents you need and which appointment you must make. At the end of the questionnaire you can make the right appointment. Per person you make a separate appointment.

... Make sure that:

you bring all the required documents

everyone who needs to be registered is present in person

you cancel your appointment if you are unable to go

Are you moving to a home for which a housing permit (huisvestingsvergunning) is required? Make sure you make an appointment for first registration with housing permit.

Beg to differ about what? It's always been EU law that member states can ask EU citizens to register. It's hardly jumping through hoops. Registration form, passport, proof of employment and you're good to go. Took me 5 minutes. The UK chose not to do this and then blamed the EU for it.

Clavinova · 28/10/2022 23:46

Free movement of labour is an essential part of free trade

A free trade agreement reduces or eliminates tariffs and quotas from goods and services being traded within the area. A single market does the same but goes a lot further. A single market includes the free movement of goods, services, labour, and capital.

Trading is a two way transaction. It's not fair trade if only one party gets to trade their assets freely and the other is restricted. One country's assets to trade may be services, another goods, another labour

Skilled labour is an asset - unskilled labour not so much.

Whelm · 28/10/2022 23:38

Fladdermus · 28/10/2022 23:28

If you are a working EU citizen that would be illegal under EU law and should be reported via the Citizen's Signpost Service.

The good people of Rotterdam whom I've lived among beg to differ:

www.rotterdam.nl/loket/registration/

Are you staying in Rotterdam for longer than 4 months? Make an appointment for registration in the Municipal Personal Records.

By clicking the button 'Make an appointment', you enter a questionnaire to see which documents you need and which appointment you must make. At the end of the questionnaire you can make the right appointment. Per person you make a separate appointment.

... Make sure that:

you bring all the required documents

everyone who needs to be registered is present in person

you cancel your appointment if you are unable to go

Are you moving to a home for which a housing permit (huisvestingsvergunning) is required? Make sure you make an appointment for first registration with housing permit.

notmyrealmoniker · 28/10/2022 23:35

The middle list of richest countries all appear to be tax havens. Now that we are out of Europe we can become one too. Ireland has been ticked off by the EU for being a tax haven so we could step into their place now.

witchesbubblebath · 28/10/2022 23:28

Whoever said housing costs are a huge contributor is right. Rent is alottttt

Fladdermus · 28/10/2022 23:28

Whelm · 28/10/2022 23:23

That's interesting because if you want to spend more than three or four month in some EU countries, there are hoops to jump through to be allowed to open a bank account or rent property.

If you are a working EU citizen that would be illegal under EU law and should be reported via the Citizen's Signpost Service.

Whelm · 28/10/2022 23:23

Fladdermus · 28/10/2022 23:16

Free movement of labour is an essential part of free trade. Trading is a two way transaction. It's not fair trade if only one party gets to trade their assets freely and the other is restricted. One country's assets to trade may be services, another goods, another labour. It exceptionalism to think your country should have restrictions on trading its assets while simultaneously demanding restrictions be placed on others.

That's interesting because if you want to spend more than three or four month in some EU countries, there are hoops to jump through to be allowed to open a bank account or rent property.

Fladdermus · 28/10/2022 23:17

It exceptionalism to think your country shouldn't have restrictions on trading its assets while simultaneously demanding restrictions be placed on others.

Fladdermus · 28/10/2022 23:16

Free movement of labour is an essential part of free trade. Trading is a two way transaction. It's not fair trade if only one party gets to trade their assets freely and the other is restricted. One country's assets to trade may be services, another goods, another labour. It exceptionalism to think your country should have restrictions on trading its assets while simultaneously demanding restrictions be placed on others.

Clavinova · 28/10/2022 22:51

cakeorwine
I think that being able to trade easily with your nearest neighbours is a good thing and will help growth

Agreed - but that doesn't have to come with the free movement of unskilled/ cheap labour - which (as the writer in the op's link has unwittingly exposed) slows investment and innovation.

MarshaBradyo · 28/10/2022 22:48

I think sst1234 backs up what Hands said on the interview - Brexit goes together with low tax to work.

Imo Labour and Brexit don’t go and will cause the doom spiral he talks about. I’d much prefer Labour to re float the SM and sell the positives. Sunak knows why he wants the Brexit version and he can sell that.

The trouble is population Brexit fatigue which is a huge barrier. Maybe impossible atm. Plus given the attack re the referendum in PMQs Labour may not want to go there.

It’s hard to predict, even Hands mentions disintegration of EU by 2030. A whole symposium with economists, climate etc with fair arguments and I’d try to decide. Unfortunately a vote is three words and whatever spin works.

Southwestten · 28/10/2022 22:47

The guests spotted a small rust patch beside the opposite seat where the paint have peeled off. They took out their phones and started taking photos of it, presumably to send to their friends back home

Croque - If I was being taken sightseeing abroad I hope I would have the good manners not to obviously take photographs of shabby buses in order to sneer about them with my friends back home.

What an odd thing for your guests to have done.

cakeorwine · 28/10/2022 22:35

I think that being able to trade easily with your nearest neighbours is a good thing and will help growth.

I think we have put up barriers to that trade.

There are disadvantages to the EU - well discussed, but I think that we could do much much better as a country than we are doing.

Which was one of the drivers of Brexit. But the wrong answer to a big problem. Which is the unfairness of the UK, the deprivation of areas and the feeling of being left behind.

Clavinova · 28/10/2022 22:33

MarshaBradyo

Another article on Guy Hands here - 2015;

Guy Hands is not seen as a natural Labour ally but the issues have made him thus.

www.theguardian.com/politics/2015/apr/05/guy-hands-a-laboursnp-government-would-be-best-for-renewable-energy

Clavinova · 28/10/2022 22:27

cakeorwine
This Northern Ireland

Yes.
Your BBC article (which pre-dates mine) also says;

In recent months, Northern Ireland's economic data has become intensely political as supporters and opponents of the NI Protocol attempt to construct economic arguments to support their positions.
However, the data is inconclusive with Northern Ireland doing better than the UK average on some metrics and worse on others.

NB I have quoted the ONS in my post - you have quoted NI Statistics and Research Agency (Nisra) - who are using an alternative measurement.

MarshaBradyo · 28/10/2022 22:15

Clavinova · 28/10/2022 21:30

Alexandra2001
the NI economy is doing very well, as its stayed effectively in the single market

September 2022
Northern Ireland's economic growth was among the weakest of the UK's regions in the final quarter of 2021, official data suggests.

When looking at annual growth, Northern Ireland was a mid-table performer.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-62756206

The UK's economy would do far better in the SM than out, so it is material... or as Guy Hands on R4 said recently "otherwise the UK economy is doomed"

This Guy Hands?

2015
Guy Hands, one of the UK's most prominent private equity investors who once described as the "the king of British private equity" by Reuters, thinks the European Union will disintegrate in 15 years' time.

He said there is a perfect storm brewing – weak leadership, political extremism and record immigration. All this will tear apart the 28-nation trading bloc by 2030, he says.

www.businessinsider.com/terra-firma-boss-guy-hands-eu-will-disintegrate-in-15-years-and-war-will-break-out-2015-10?r=US&IR=T

Thanks for this. This was the interview I referred to earlier. Interesting to see his other views.

cakeorwine · 28/10/2022 21:43

This Northern Ireland @Clavinova

www.bbc.com/news/uk-northern-ireland-62078425

The Northern Ireland economy continued to grow in the first quarter of 2022, official figures from Nisra suggest.
Output was up by 0.4% compared to the final quarter of 2021 and by 7.8% compared to the same period a year ago.
NI economic output is now at a 15-year high and just 0.1% below the record output level recorded in the middle of 2007.
From late 2007, Northern Ireland experienced a housing crash which caused significant economic damage.
Northern Ireland's performance in the first quarter was weaker than the UK average: UK GDP grew by 0.8% quarter-on-quarter and by 8.7% year-on-year.
However, the NI Statistics and Research Agency (Nisra) says that over a three-year time period Northern Ireland has grown more strongly with output up by 4.8% compared to UK GDP growth of 1.3%.
Nisra uses the three-year comparison in an attempt to mitigate the economic volatility arising from the pandemic.

The pandemic has certainly affected things and made looking at statistics hard. But well done for cherry picking statistics. As usual

Clavinova · 28/10/2022 21:30

Alexandra2001
the NI economy is doing very well, as its stayed effectively in the single market

September 2022
Northern Ireland's economic growth was among the weakest of the UK's regions in the final quarter of 2021, official data suggests.

When looking at annual growth, Northern Ireland was a mid-table performer.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-62756206

The UK's economy would do far better in the SM than out, so it is material... or as Guy Hands on R4 said recently "otherwise the UK economy is doomed"

This Guy Hands?

2015
Guy Hands, one of the UK's most prominent private equity investors who once described as the "the king of British private equity" by Reuters, thinks the European Union will disintegrate in 15 years' time.

He said there is a perfect storm brewing – weak leadership, political extremism and record immigration. All this will tear apart the 28-nation trading bloc by 2030, he says.

www.businessinsider.com/terra-firma-boss-guy-hands-eu-will-disintegrate-in-15-years-and-war-will-break-out-2015-10?r=US&IR=T

Clavinova · 28/10/2022 21:15

TheNosehasit
Clavinova, I missed this post but you have made me chuckle by criticising the article and then quoting the Daily Mail?

I linked to the MailOnline because they had photographs - I can quote from the Guardian instead if you prefer;

Maros Tancos, and Joanna Gomulska, both 46, kept the victims as “prisoners” in squalor in the house in Bristol and subjected them to beatings and death threats, a court heard.
Victims were forced to work unpaid at Tancos’s car wash business and then do paid jobs at night...the couple spending their wages on secondhand cars and gambling.
Tancos had links to children’s homes in his home country of Slovakia and had a “ready supply” of vulnerable victims.
A total of 42 victims were interviewed by specialist officers and 29 gave evidence of the abuse they suffered in court.
“Referring to the house as a ‘gate to hell’, one victim’s account shows how they felt trapped, unable to seek help without identity documents, locked in the house and threatened.”

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/jun/22/bristol-couple-jailed-for-enslaving-29-slovakian-people

Presumably, if the ready supply of unskilled labour from the EU had been curtailed somewhat, then more investment in "robots" would have taken place (e.g. expansion/improvement of automated car washes)?

XingMing · 28/10/2022 20:17

I did say, earlier on this thread, that our micro-business in metal-bashing is booming, and has been for the last 18 months. Customers want to talk to suppliers direct, and want to know there's no way their job is going to be stuck in a customs queue for weeks, so they are looking to place work in the UK. And before you ask, nobody in our organisation earns less than double minimum wage, plus overtime at 1.5x or 2x the hourly rate for weekends or unsocial hours.

PrestonNorthHen · 28/10/2022 12:05

Kendodd · 28/10/2022 09:26

Not one poverty thread has mentioned debt, its always someone else's fault.

Except I would expect the poorest people in the UK have the least debt as no bank will loan to them.

You have missed the point.
They are poor due to debt not because of low income.
So those you would expect to be fine are struggling but unsecured debt is never mentioned just it's the government's fault.

CantHaveTooMuchChocolate · 28/10/2022 11:58

sst1234 · 26/10/2022 23:26

Brexit is done. Lots of us didn’t want it, but it’s down. If you don’t accept it, you continue to make the country poorer. The problem is that we have all the bad bits of Brexit without any of the benefits, because those who voted remain will not accept the structural change that has to happen to grow the economy. Brexit should be an enabler of lower corporation tax and less regulation. Singapore on Thames or whatever you want to call it. You may not like it, but fighting against it means that you cut your nose off to spite your face. Unless the remain side accept this, the pain of Brexit is yet to be felt.

We just had that in the mini budget, corporation tax slashed, etc, remind us again how that played out??

Kendodd · 28/10/2022 09:26

Not one poverty thread has mentioned debt, its always someone else's fault.

Except I would expect the poorest people in the UK have the least debt as no bank will loan to them.

Alexandra2001 · 28/10/2022 09:00

TheNosehasit · 28/10/2022 00:15

Either way, it's immaterial to the decline in the economy.

Funnily enough, despite no Govt (because of the DUP hating the protocol, refusing to sit at Stormont & refusing to accept they are out of power)... the NI economy is doing very well, as its stayed effectively in the single market.

The UK's economy would do far better in the SM than out, so it is material... or as Guy Hans on R4 said recently "otherwise the UK economy is doomed"

Coucous · 28/10/2022 08:58

TheNosehasit · 28/10/2022 02:05

I also predict a lot of snatch and grabs of properties by vultures when people start being unable to pay their mortgages and begin losing their homes. We're far too exposed to this crisis. Our economy is not robust enough to withstand the storm that's brewing.

If anyone plans on jumping ship - now would be the time to do it.

That would be me soon. Thankfully have eu citizenship. I'm willing to stick around for a couple more years to see how it goes but will pack mine and leave if the country is not well managed and everything goes haywire