Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"How the UK became one of the poorest countries in Europe"

468 replies

user1471452428 · 26/10/2022 22:09

www.theatlantic.com/newsletters/archive/2022/10/uk-economy-disaster-degrowth-brexit/671847/

Article in The Atlantic. When people post about declining living standards, they're often shouted down- but I think it's pretty clear that it is real and here to stay.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 29/10/2022 07:44

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 07:40

This is actually the scariest pie chart I've seen.

www.statista.com/statistics/298524/government-spending-in-the-uk/

WHAT? Who is getting that money? I'm referring to the biggest slice of pie!

Who the fuck is getting that money and how? I fancy a bit of that pie.

What do you mean, scary?

Are you referring to social protection - it says above what it’s spent on. What were you expecting wrt those costs?

Believeitornot · 29/10/2022 07:43

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 07:40

This is actually the scariest pie chart I've seen.

www.statista.com/statistics/298524/government-spending-in-the-uk/

WHAT? Who is getting that money? I'm referring to the biggest slice of pie!

Who the fuck is getting that money and how? I fancy a bit of that pie.

Social protection = biggest chunk is pensioners

Health = a big chunk with be paying for PFI

We have 66 million people in the country. Of course the numbers are big.

Believeitornot · 29/10/2022 07:40

And I will add, taxing is only part of our way out of this. The government has to massive regulate the financial services sector again and put back credit controls.

It won’t happen though because our PM and his advisors come from the very sector which will stand to lose if they do.

There’s a reason why investment bankers/hedge fund owners etc either go into politics or lobby politicians - because they don’t want the status quo to change. And why would they? They’ve made a killing and when they last broke things in 208, they got a $trillion support package to carry on as they were.

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 07:40

This is actually the scariest pie chart I've seen.

www.statista.com/statistics/298524/government-spending-in-the-uk/

WHAT? Who is getting that money? I'm referring to the biggest slice of pie!

Who the fuck is getting that money and how? I fancy a bit of that pie.

Believeitornot · 29/10/2022 07:37

Whole per head our GDP may be ok, it is not actually distributed that way.

Things have gone wrong since the late 1970s. A big part of that is the deregulation of banking meaning wealth has exploded in a minority of the population. Incentives to invest in manufacturing and innovation are not there as money is to be made in financial services.

Money is made by making up dubious lending schemes at the expense of investment and public services.

Look at the NHS as an example. The NHS is spending billions servicing PFIs. Invented by the Tories, exploited by New Labour. People are decried as “socialist” for wanting a more simple funding model.

The same in the railways. They’ve created bizarre funding models where millions (perhaps billions) is borrowed to fund train stock. So millions of pounds in interest is drained out to the private sector.

Local authorities are falling victim to similar schemes as their traditional funding is cut.

So the government will say “we are investing in the public sector” and we don’t see the results because it’s being paid out again in interest.

That is the problem with our economy. It has been mortgaged to the hilt. There’s no money left to pay decent wages as we owe the bankers too much.

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 07:30

While people earn money here, they don't necessarily spend it here. Does that make sense?

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 07:29

*the kind of money we need

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 07:29

We're not really bringing in the kind of money. There is a massive population in the UK for the size of it but I dunno. I'm never going to make the sums add up.

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 07:28

Not a fan of googling, but this graph is interesting.

www.statista.com/statistics/298490/defense-spending-united-kingdom-uk/

So about £42 billion on defence per annum.

Then another 153 billion on the NHS

www.england.nhs.uk/publications/business-plan/our-2022-23-business-plan/our-funding/#:~:text=The%20central%20administration%20budget%20for,envelope%20of%20%C2%A32.5%20billion.

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 07:23

The NHS is an utter shambles. They need to invest in primary care rather than acute care.

Defence? Is that classified?

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 07:21

I am really fascinated to know what exactly (and for whom) we spend so much on Defence. How much? On what?
Because I think the answer to that question might reveal a lot.

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 07:19

TomPinch · 29/10/2022 07:10

ISTM= it seems to me

Ah, ok.

Britain has never joined the EURO.
Britain has had idiot after idiot in government.
Britain has most of their eggs in one basket.
Britain isn't really capable of being humble. They're the last of the big spenders.
A lot of the money in Britain isn't held by British people if you get me?

It's hard to know why they have lagged behind.

A fucked up NHS system doesn't help. That's a massive drain.
The other expenditure that never gets questioned is Defence.

Technically, we should be doing better.

TomPinch · 29/10/2022 07:10

ISTM= it seems to me

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 06:50

Pinkcadillac · 29/10/2022 06:30

We’ve discussed Ireland but the thing is, I look around the Uk and can’t see anyone thriving.

Germany is very pessimistic about their own economy (mini jobs, energy supply). France is hardly an example of dynamism, same goes for Italy. Sweden is dealing with its own social problems.

Maybe Denmark? Portugal?

I’m not familiar with Eastern Europe. Hungary and Poland have had high GDP growth in recent years. Also the Baltic estates.

Norway has oil and gas and getting richer thanks to rising gas prices but that’s very specific to them obvs.

Nowhere is really booming now. The UK is overexposed though.

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 06:48

TomPinch · 29/10/2022 06:32

ISTM that the UK has really been lagging since the GFC. Not that I'm suggesting that Brexit isn't a massive issue but the UK was massively exposed to the GFC and left it carrying a lot more debt, something that was a contributing factor to Truss's big mess.

What does ISTM mean?

TomPinch · 29/10/2022 06:32

ISTM that the UK has really been lagging since the GFC. Not that I'm suggesting that Brexit isn't a massive issue but the UK was massively exposed to the GFC and left it carrying a lot more debt, something that was a contributing factor to Truss's big mess.

Pinkcadillac · 29/10/2022 06:30

We’ve discussed Ireland but the thing is, I look around the Uk and can’t see anyone thriving.

Germany is very pessimistic about their own economy (mini jobs, energy supply). France is hardly an example of dynamism, same goes for Italy. Sweden is dealing with its own social problems.

Maybe Denmark? Portugal?

I’m not familiar with Eastern Europe. Hungary and Poland have had high GDP growth in recent years. Also the Baltic estates.

Norway has oil and gas and getting richer thanks to rising gas prices but that’s very specific to them obvs.

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 05:18

TomPinch · 29/10/2022 04:02

I like the thought of the Irish being as much of an awkward squad as the UK. Not something I've heard about.

I'm interested that the UK was regarded as a contributor (other than in money). All I heard was what a pain in the arse the UK was and how all the other Europeans hated the UK.

The Irish won't back down on the corporate tax rate.

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 05:13

notmyrealmoniker · 28/10/2022 23:35

The middle list of richest countries all appear to be tax havens. Now that we are out of Europe we can become one too. Ireland has been ticked off by the EU for being a tax haven so we could step into their place now.

This is a good explainer of why Ireland works.

BHMiseverymonth · 29/10/2022 04:47

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 04:46

I suppose the EU is a bit like family though. Strange as it may seem, despite the bitter relationship between Ireland and the UK in the past, we are still next door neighbours and are very intertwined so are probably the closest linked to the UK of all the EU countries - well until the UK decided to fuck off.

Yes, when I think about it, it's like family. It's ok for me to criticise my family members, but if anyone else criticises them, they'll regret it. 😁

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 04:40

TomPinch · 29/10/2022 04:32

So in other words, only in an economic sense after all.

They didn't love us, just or pounds!!! 😰

It's a bit like family lol. There's always one asshole!

Christmas is coming and soon we'll have the threads popping up about the in-laws and the poor relations lol.

I'm joking lol. I know that the British are a sensitive bunch.

The EU's raison d-etre was financial strength and military defence. United we stand, divided we fall.

The EU certainly valued the UK membership. Simpler times.

TomPinch · 29/10/2022 04:32

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 04:15

The Irish have come under sustained pressure from the EU (and from Trump in fact during his tenure) in relation to their corporate tax rates over the years. Macron was the most outspoken within the EU I believe. So far, they have held firm through successive governments.

Of course the UK was a contributor. They were one of the bigger powerhouses - it was the UK and Germany mainly with France probably being the other big one. They were a stable and strong economy and were a great asset to the team as such.

I think the UK isn't really a team player though, so what can you do! A lot of smaller economies benefited from the EU. Some countries paid in more, some paid in less. Ireland has only recently become a net contributor as far as I know.

I'm a little bit sad about it all.

Is the EU perfect? Fuck no.

So in other words, only in an economic sense after all.

They didn't love us, just or pounds!!! 😰

TomPinch · 29/10/2022 04:28

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 04:18

Oh! He was American! You learn something new every day.

Jaguar, Bentley, Rolls Royce - they're all British though I think.

I'm not sure they are - these days it's hard to allocate a company to any particular country. Shareholding? HQ? Factory location? Nationality of board of directors? Would you say Guinness was Irish, for example?

TheNosehasit · 29/10/2022 04:22

Ireland also has a bizarre constitutional position which means that nothing can change without a referendum, unlike other countries within the EU.

It does mean that they have MANY REFERENDUMS though and that irritates the ever-living shit out of the EU too. 😆

Swipe left for the next trending thread