Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset by this situation with DD?

81 replies

ljs22 · 26/10/2022 21:47

DD 16 just came home from a friend's house on the bus. It's about a 30 min bus ride. She was upset when she got home saying a man roughly in his 60s who was clearly drunk (smelt of alcohol and was swaying when he got on the bus) had chosen to sit right next to her despite there being many other free seats. She said he stared at her and made her feel uncomfortable, put his face close to her when talking to her and told her she was really pretty etc. She was trying to ignore him and looking at her phone, messaging friends etc, and said he was constantly looking at what she was doing on her phone. At one point he also touched her arm because she had turned away from him in an attempt to ignore him. She said she wanted to tell him to move away but felt too scared to do so.

I don't know what I'm posting for. I suppose I'm just upset on her behalf that men feel this sort of behaviour is appropriate especially towards a teenage girl. DD is very pretty and attracts a lot of attention from boys her own age, but this feels different and almost bordering on harassment the way she described it.

How can I advise her to manage this in future?

OP posts:
Outwiththenorm · 27/10/2022 08:04

Exact same situation happened to me in my early twenties and it still upsets me when I think about it (and there have been other worse assaults). I think just it being dark, on the bus more or less alone, and feeling completely trapped by the window, plus the uncertainty of how a drunk is going to behave - and mine was in a posh suit 🙄 - made me feel so helpless. Definitely recommend sitting close to driver and in aisle seat.

Discovereads · 27/10/2022 08:01

OP, sorry your DD experienced this, it’s not so much what he did but the fear he caused during the entire bus ride.

I was assaulted on a bus when I was 14. Some lads thought it would be funny to pin me in the corner, stick their hands up my shirt and cut my bra off my body & all that. I recently did EMDR to process this and it was hugely beneficial. So if your DD gets anxiety or nightmares, EMDR is something to consider MH wise to process and heal from the trauma.

Discovereads · 27/10/2022 07:52

ljs22 · 26/10/2022 21:47

DD 16 just came home from a friend's house on the bus. It's about a 30 min bus ride. She was upset when she got home saying a man roughly in his 60s who was clearly drunk (smelt of alcohol and was swaying when he got on the bus) had chosen to sit right next to her despite there being many other free seats. She said he stared at her and made her feel uncomfortable, put his face close to her when talking to her and told her she was really pretty etc. She was trying to ignore him and looking at her phone, messaging friends etc, and said he was constantly looking at what she was doing on her phone. At one point he also touched her arm because she had turned away from him in an attempt to ignore him. She said she wanted to tell him to move away but felt too scared to do so.

I don't know what I'm posting for. I suppose I'm just upset on her behalf that men feel this sort of behaviour is appropriate especially towards a teenage girl. DD is very pretty and attracts a lot of attention from boys her own age, but this feels different and almost bordering on harassment the way she described it.

How can I advise her to manage this in future?

I used to sit in the aisle seat and put my bag next to me on the window seat to avoid this. I’d only slide over a free up the seat next to me if the bus was full and usually pointedly when another woman was getting on the bus. Usually busses at night are never full.

DashboardConfessional · 27/10/2022 07:52

I do think that each individual man should be assessed and dealt with individually. This happened to me in France when I was about 19 - I told him to fuck off, and the guy followed me off the train, threatened me and showed me his swastika tattoo. I ended up going into a shop. I wish for that one I'd just got up and left.

Aprilx · 27/10/2022 07:49

UWhatNow · 26/10/2022 22:03

I didn’t allow my 16 year old dd to travel 30 mins on a bus in the evening for exactly this reason. Public transport is shit for women - especially young vulnerable ones. Any woman would struggle to be assertive in that situation let alone a 16 year old.

I cannot agree with this. Your whole post is making out that women have no choice but to be victims. There is nothing wrong with a 16 year old taking a 30 minutes bus ride at night. And public transport is not shit for women, the vast majority of the time it will be uneventful. And finally, no “any woman” would not struggle to be assertive in that situation. I think most would handle it just fine, on this occasion, OP’s daughter was not properly equipped to deal with it, but sounds like she will get some good advice and be able to handle it should a similar thing occur again.

OldReliable · 27/10/2022 07:33

I would 100% report this to the bus company. They will have cctv on the bus and they can alert the drivers to be aware of this person in the future. Involve your dd in reporting this. Theres more than one way to stick up for yourself. I can 100% understand why a 16 year old girl wouldn't necessarily tell a drunk old man to fuck off but there are things she can do after the event to assert herself and take back some control - such as reporting this to the bus co.

lunar1 · 27/10/2022 07:30

I remember exactly this scenario from when I was the same age, it was even the same seat, the rest of the bus was empty.

I have never, even once since not sat on the outside seat. I can't book the middle seats at the cinema or theatre. I have extreme claustrophobia, I had to make the receptionist at school know so she always made sure I got an exit seat at school plays etc.

The man that did this to me did touch my legs, I was frozen the entire journey. Your daughter told you, I could never have talked to my mum about it. At least you can support your dd on how to handle these situations in the future.

I didn't actually realise this was a thing creeps did. 😡

MsTSwift · 27/10/2022 07:23

Phone out “passing you onto the paedo hunters mate better watch your back”

Its fortunate guns are illegal or I swear I would take these men out.

TeachesOfPeaches · 27/10/2022 07:17

These men often walk off if you start filming them and describing what they're doing.

AnyFucker · 27/10/2022 06:58

“Bordering” on harassment ?

Even you are minimising it

Good advice above

cc1997 · 27/10/2022 06:29

saltinesandcoffeecups · 26/10/2022 23:40

Honestly you are all pretty close with your suggested responses… but for the love of all that is holy stop with the politeness and explanations.

DO NOT TOUCH ME PLEASE - Get your (insert expletive of choice here) hands off of me

You are making me feel uncomfortable, move away now - Piss off and move on

So in that situation she could have said "excuse me" - got up and sat close to the driver and told the other passenger (if they object) she needed to concentrate on reading something. - WTF No you’re not sitting next to me or when he started to sit down… ‘Move along lots of empty seats’

It was me that suggested "you are making me feel uncomfortable, move away now" and that isn't polite at all. It just doesn't involve swearing. You don't need to tell your daughter to start swearing at someone, you need to teach her to be firm, say no and tell an adult (the bus driver).

Autumflower · 27/10/2022 04:34

I had this coming home from school in year 6 ,on my own on the bus ,a man sits next to me and starts to wank.penis completely out for me to see.
my useless mother did nothing,and really age 11 could of fetched me from school ,but chose to have me get a bus home ,and then walk .
really upset ,I got of the bus early and ran home .thank god he didn’t follow me .
i was very young for my age ,no makeup still with pigtails ,so he knew what he was doing alright

Suzi888 · 27/10/2022 03:54

saltinesandcoffeecups · 26/10/2022 23:40

Honestly you are all pretty close with your suggested responses… but for the love of all that is holy stop with the politeness and explanations.

DO NOT TOUCH ME PLEASE - Get your (insert expletive of choice here) hands off of me

You are making me feel uncomfortable, move away now - Piss off and move on

So in that situation she could have said "excuse me" - got up and sat close to the driver and told the other passenger (if they object) she needed to concentrate on reading something. - WTF No you’re not sitting next to me or when he started to sit down… ‘Move along lots of empty seats’

I’m not sure that’s a particularly wise thing to say to someone who may get off at the same stop as you/ retaliate violently/ spit /become aggressive.

“Using your words” may not result in a favourable outcome. Yes it may work, but what if it doesn’t? It’s pretty high risk in my opinion.

Also, don’t expect people to come to your defence and protect you. Self preservation is high and turning a blind eye is easier. If the other passengers haven’t seen any wrong doing, pissed old man plays innocent, teen looks like a gobshite mouthing off, swearing and throwing accusations.

Sit in the aisle seat. Stand. Move. Speak to the driver.

SaltyCrisp · 27/10/2022 00:47

The biggest disservice done to girls in recent times is to urge them to #BeKind

saltinesandcoffeecups · 27/10/2022 00:26

And clearly typos and fighting autocorrect are my friends tonight…so disregard the bad formatting and punctuation above.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 27/10/2022 00:22

Hellocatshome · 27/10/2022 00:04

I didnt say reason with a lecherous drunk I said polite but assertive.

"Excuse me I am going to sit somewhere else" is far less likely to escalate the situation than "Piss off" but you do you.

You’re missing the point. She gets to own her space. Escalating is often the point. People like this guy wants an easy, polite, target. They don’t want to find themselves interacting with a foul mouth ,loud, pissed off teen. They will avoid these types of girl like the plague because they know it’s going to escalate.

One whiff of someone standing up to them and they’ll move on to the next target or shut up and sit down. Yes there will often be words exchanged, but who cares? Who cares if the bus load of people here him slag off a young woman standing her ground.

Do you think they will turn on her and let the kind drunk man sit down next to her and touch her? not likely

glittereyelash · 27/10/2022 00:10

The way some men behave towards young girls is disgusting. It happened to me at that age and I work with teenage girls and the things I've witnessed and that they have told me are shocking. I've had to intervene multiple times and generally the men are embarrassed and apologetic when called out. It can go the other way though where they either get verbally abusive or physically threatening. Its always trickier to manage when someone is drunk so moving away or telling the bus driver is probably the best option here. All the ladies on here are giving solid advice with the aisle seat and learning to assert herself and use her voice.

Mindthegap725 · 27/10/2022 00:09

I'm so sorry this happened to your daughter ljs22, I hope she is ok tomorrow.
I really sympathise because something very similar happened to one of my daughters in the very first week she was commuting to secondary school by herself. It was during the early afternoon and she was only thirteen. Just posting to say I know how you feel Flowers

Hellocatshome · 27/10/2022 00:04

saltinesandcoffeecups · 26/10/2022 23:55

You act like I’ve never been in a similar situation.

Whatever, tell your daughters to reason with lecherous drunks, I’m sure it will work out just fine.

I didnt say reason with a lecherous drunk I said polite but assertive.

"Excuse me I am going to sit somewhere else" is far less likely to escalate the situation than "Piss off" but you do you.

Comtesse · 27/10/2022 00:02

have her practice saying “piss off you old pervert” or something similar. It’s going to happen again (sadly) so helping her to be ready to respond is probably sensible. Hideous that we have to do this of course…..

saltinesandcoffeecups · 26/10/2022 23:55

Hellocatshome · 26/10/2022 23:51

Rule 101 of dealing with drunk people who may or may not be violent. Try polite but assertive first before you go for confrontational.

You act like I’ve never been in a similar situation.

Whatever, tell your daughters to reason with lecherous drunks, I’m sure it will work out just fine.

Artygirlghost · 26/10/2022 23:52

It really is sickening how some of these vile men behave.

We need to end the idea that girls, and women, always need to be polite, should never make a fuss and say things like ''excuse me'' when being bothered by some old pervert.

Because that conditioning prevents many women from reacting quickly and stopping/reporting the unwanted behaviour as soon as it starts.

Instead we need to teach them that they don't owe men ''niceness''.

If someone bothers you immediately walk away and speak to the driver or if you are a mouthy Londoner like me you say something in the line of ''Get the fk out of my space you dirty old perv'' or ''don't you touch you filthy b**d'' as loud as possible.

Hellocatshome · 26/10/2022 23:51

saltinesandcoffeecups · 26/10/2022 23:40

Honestly you are all pretty close with your suggested responses… but for the love of all that is holy stop with the politeness and explanations.

DO NOT TOUCH ME PLEASE - Get your (insert expletive of choice here) hands off of me

You are making me feel uncomfortable, move away now - Piss off and move on

So in that situation she could have said "excuse me" - got up and sat close to the driver and told the other passenger (if they object) she needed to concentrate on reading something. - WTF No you’re not sitting next to me or when he started to sit down… ‘Move along lots of empty seats’

Rule 101 of dealing with drunk people who may or may not be violent. Try polite but assertive first before you go for confrontational.

flippetyflaps · 26/10/2022 23:44

TheBulletThatMissed · 26/10/2022 22:23

She needs to find menopausal women like me who have both the rage and enough life experience of this shit that we’ll will happily give pricks like this a dressing down in public if they dare behave inappropriately with our young girls - or anyone else for that matter.

Absolutely this! I've been in your daughter's position on buses and trains more times than I can remember, old men, young men, drunk and sober. At uni we used to call them the nutters on the bus, like jasper carrott's sketch.

If it happened to me now (clearly less likely as I'm now late 40s) I'd tell them to eff off out of my face!

saltinesandcoffeecups · 26/10/2022 23:40

Honestly you are all pretty close with your suggested responses… but for the love of all that is holy stop with the politeness and explanations.

DO NOT TOUCH ME PLEASE - Get your (insert expletive of choice here) hands off of me

You are making me feel uncomfortable, move away now - Piss off and move on

So in that situation she could have said "excuse me" - got up and sat close to the driver and told the other passenger (if they object) she needed to concentrate on reading something. - WTF No you’re not sitting next to me or when he started to sit down… ‘Move along lots of empty seats’