Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Vegetarians eat fish

217 replies

KateLumley · 26/10/2022 20:06

AIBI to be annoyed that some people still think vegetarians eat fish. Because their friend is 'vegetarian' and eats fish so it must be true.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheOrigRights · 29/10/2022 15:35

HollaHolla · 28/10/2022 23:49

Meh. I don’t eat red meat, although I eat fish (and very occasionally chicken - 2 or 3 times a year.) if I’m going to a do, or on a plane or something, I say I’m vegetarian, because it’s easier than saying, oh, I won’t eat that, but I do eat this.
I call someone who is a veggie a PROPER. Veggie. 🤣🤣🤣

So you're just choosing the vegetarian option, which is of course absolutely fine. All vegetarians will have the vegetarian meal, but not all people who choose the vegetarian meal are vegetarians!

I always choose the Asian Vegetarian meal on a flight. Yum.

I have noticed that sometimes the vegetarian meal is also vegan i.e. you get spread instead of butter and a fruit salad instead of the Gu desert.

TheOrigRights · 29/10/2022 15:23

It's describing a strategy rather than a sacred identity.

Being vegetarian is neither a strategy or an identity, it is a term to describe someone that doesn't eat animals.
Your MIL doesn't understand how to cater to non-meat eaters and you have found a way to accommodate this, but the definition remains the same.

ReneBumsWombats · 29/10/2022 08:49

All that is my way of saying that if you're a "low meat" eater then it could be easier to call yourself a "vegetarian who sometimes eats chicken"

It's not easier, it's entirely wrong and has nothing to do with portion sizes. It's like saying you're a virgin because you only have sex three times a year.

Why do people do this??? It's not easier to use the entirely wrong term and then extend it to cover something else to be wrong about. A vegetarian could eat 45 times a day, it's nothing to do with how often you eat! It's just about what you exclude and if you eat chicken, you aren't vegetarian!

lljkk · 29/10/2022 08:19

Something I have discovered about a lot of meat eaters is they eat meat daily, and sometimes very large portions. MIL believes that there needs to be something like meat at the daily hot meal, and her idea of being a vegetarian was that the vegetarian had to have a meat-substitute at each meal, too (or a ready meal, or some centre-piece item that took place of what the meat would be). I'm astonished about large portions of meat at restaurants. Then on MN there are threads like "How many sausages per person" where it is obvious that people have many more sausages per person than we serve in my family.

Yes I "eat meat" but I don't want a lot, or expect it daily. Plus I can make a whole meal out of crisps or 100% veg stir fry. All that is my way of saying that if you're a "low meat" eater then it could be easier to call yourself a "vegetarian who sometimes eats chicken" then try to explain that no one needs to make sure you have a meal that looks like what they think a meal must look like , or to explain you eat meat but don't want a giant portion of meat. It's describing a strategy rather than a sacred identity.

Ekátn · 29/10/2022 06:51

When I was young we ate fish only. Then didn’t eat that at all.

Mum would always put us down as vegetarian for flights. There weren’t options for eat this but do eat this. And I don’t remember there being a selection on the planes. Everyone got the same meal or the vegetarian. But this was the day of DAN Air etc.

However, outside situations like that mum would just say ‘we don’t eat red meat or chicken’.

As an adult vegetarian who also gets bad stomach aches with cows milk, I also mark vegan for conferences etc. Because ‘vegetarian but doesn’t eat cheese’ isn’t usually an option. and more often than not the vegetarian options are often cheese based.

Although to be fair I most of my meals are vegan. I wouldn’t call myself a vegan in conversation though as I do regularly eat non vegan foods.

SpinningFloppa · 29/10/2022 00:06

Why not just say “I don’t eat red meat” 🤦🏻 So random to say you’re veggie but eat fish and chicken. Wtf 🙄

HollaHolla · 28/10/2022 23:49

Meh. I don’t eat red meat, although I eat fish (and very occasionally chicken - 2 or 3 times a year.) if I’m going to a do, or on a plane or something, I say I’m vegetarian, because it’s easier than saying, oh, I won’t eat that, but I do eat this.
I call someone who is a veggie a PROPER. Veggie. 🤣🤣🤣

StillMedusa · 28/10/2022 23:45

I'm veggie and simply don't eat anything with a face or that can be presumed to have conciousness.
I try to avoid any animal derivatives.. gelatine, rennet, but I'm sure there are occasions when I have had some eating out etc.

I no longer buy leather shoes ( I mostly live in Skechers vegan range anyway) but I still wear ones I have had for years because I don't see the point of binning something that is still useful.

I eat a mainly plant based diet but would never call myself vegan because I still eat rennet free cheese. When a decent vegan cheese exists I will stop eating cheese ( the only dairy I have)

My family have been mainly vegetarians for 70+ years, long before it was a normalised choice... my grandparents were veggies back in the 1950s! I am so grateful we have more choice now as I remember when eating out meant a mushroom rissotto or an omelette!

Leftbutcameback · 28/10/2022 22:00

I do find pescatarian is used a lot now - recently filled in a spreadsheet at work and there were a few of us, plus vegans and vegetarians.

I wouldn't necessarily use it on holiday though - I tend to use the translation of "I don't eat meat" which is not strictly true but I don't speak any other language well enough to explain properly. In a lot of french restaurants fish dishes come with lardons or similar so I don't tend to risk it.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 28/10/2022 20:52

No, it should be 'I don't eat meat, just fish'. Otherwise surely it's just as ok to say you're a vegetarian apart from steak. Or bacon.

No, I agree with you. It's never going to be a good description if there's a perfect specific word that people somehow refuse to use; but surely that is less bad than just saying "I'm a vegetarian" when you do eat fish.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 28/10/2022 19:47

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 28/10/2022 19:05

Surely, if the word 'pescetarian' is somehow taboo, the simplest thing for everybody to know where they stand is just to say "I'm broadly similar to a vegetarian except that I eat fish". Not ideal, but if the ideal word must be rejected....

No, it should be 'I don't eat meat, just fish'. Otherwise surely it's just as ok to say you're a vegetarian apart from steak. Or bacon.

I came back to this thread to delete it from my watched list and got enraged all over again! It REALLY bothers me, I don't like being preached to by people who don't consider a fish worthy enough to not eat. If that makes sense.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 28/10/2022 19:45

DiddlyDoris · 27/10/2022 16:55

YABU.

Get over yourself. Technically it's a pescatarian if you eat fish too but for ease, veggie as a term is more used than pescatarian.

No, if you eat fish, that is a flesh of an animal. Therefore you aren't a vegetarian, you are an omnivore like most people.

If you don't eat meat then just say that! Or I only eat fish. I don't know why it's so hard for 'vegetarians who eat fish' to do that - maybe because they can't claim the ethics points for that.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 28/10/2022 19:05

Surely, if the word 'pescetarian' is somehow taboo, the simplest thing for everybody to know where they stand is just to say "I'm broadly similar to a vegetarian except that I eat fish". Not ideal, but if the ideal word must be rejected....

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 28/10/2022 19:02

I still don't get why pescetarian is considered so out there - and if nobody ever uses it, even though it perfectly describes people who are otherwise vegetarian except they eat fish, it will never not be considered out there.

Most people will either know what the word means - which is great - or otherwise not have a clue what it means; which is also great, because you can tell them simply what it means, without them sort of having a (probably wrong) pre-conceived idea. Most people have heard of the star sign 'Pisces' and will know that its symbol is a fish (regardless of their thoughts or beliefs about star signs) - so once you mention it and make the obvious link in their minds, they will have learned a new word and know what it means the next time somebody else tells them they're a pescetarian.

Why deliberately avoid using THE ideally descriptive word for your chosen diet? Otherwise, it's like going to great lengths to describe the colour of healthy grass but somehow refusing to use the word 'green'.

It will only potentially lead to misunderstanding if you deliberately use the wrong word (no value judgments at all - just an inappropriate word, like telling people you're Dutch when you're actually Belgian). Plus it's insulting to actual vegetarians when their appropriate label is misappropriated and used to mean something very different.

Telling people that you're vegetarian should be enough, without people then asking if you eat fish (or worse, just assuming and offering/serving you fish). It's as ridiculous (and offensive) as telling somebody clearly that you're a Muslim and them then asking you if you're one of those Muslims who worships Allah.

TheOrigRights · 28/10/2022 17:54

Thurst · 26/10/2022 20:35

I am a pescatarian and I frequently tell people that I am vegetarian. Partly it’s a habit
because I was vegetarian for many many years and partly because saying, ‘I’m pescatarian’ sounds pretentious and not everyone knows what it means. So sorry, the idea that some vegetarians eat fish, probably because of people like me.

Yes, but you don't believe you are vegetarian, you are just using terminology that people understand.

TheOrigRights · 28/10/2022 17:51

amicissimma · 28/10/2022 17:07

I know about a dozen long-term vegetarians. Every single one eats fish. None of them make a big deal about what they eat - just state their preference if we're, say, ordering a takeaway.

They've all been vegetarians for at least 25 years. Maybe the insistence on stipulating that they don't eat fish is a thing for more recent vegetarians.

What? This is utter bobbins.
This thread has opened my eyes.

neighboursmustliveon · 28/10/2022 17:50

amicissimma · 28/10/2022 17:07

I know about a dozen long-term vegetarians. Every single one eats fish. None of them make a big deal about what they eat - just state their preference if we're, say, ordering a takeaway.

They've all been vegetarians for at least 25 years. Maybe the insistence on stipulating that they don't eat fish is a thing for more recent vegetarians.

You don't know any vegetarians then.

I've been vegetarian since 1992 and it's never been a thing that vegetarians eat fish.

Words like pescatarian were not as well known but we knew the difference.

At uni I had a friend who called herself demi-vegetarian as she ate chicken and fish. She did understand that she wasn't a vegetarian though.

tkmethrthis · 28/10/2022 17:46

One shouldn't assume a vegetarian eats fish so YANBU there, but it's not rude to ask if they do.

It is though because vegetarians, by definition, don't eat fish.

If you were in the hospitality industry and asked me that I would be concerned that you would not either understand or adhere to my dietary requirements.

suzyscat · 28/10/2022 17:44

YABU because plenty of people do and it's hard to keep up the lacto ovo vegetarian, pescatarian, vegan lingo.

One shouldn't assume a vegetarian eats fish so YANBU there, but it's not rude to ask if they do.

caringcarer · 28/10/2022 17:28

My dh gets very annoyed when we eat out and a fish dish is included as a vegetarian option. He always makes a point of telling waiter/waitress fish are living beings so not vegetarian.

Phrenologistsfinger · 28/10/2022 17:16

amicissimma · 28/10/2022 17:07

I know about a dozen long-term vegetarians. Every single one eats fish. None of them make a big deal about what they eat - just state their preference if we're, say, ordering a takeaway.

They've all been vegetarians for at least 25 years. Maybe the insistence on stipulating that they don't eat fish is a thing for more recent vegetarians.

I’ve been vegetarian for 40 years! And vegan for 10. Vegetarians have never eaten fish, not 25 years ago and not 30 years ago. Your friends are using the term incorrectly.

Phrenologistsfinger · 28/10/2022 17:15

If you eat fish then you are not a vegetarian. Nor are you a vegan. You are a pescatarian. The end.

ReneBumsWombats · 28/10/2022 17:11

amicissimma · 28/10/2022 17:07

I know about a dozen long-term vegetarians. Every single one eats fish. None of them make a big deal about what they eat - just state their preference if we're, say, ordering a takeaway.

They've all been vegetarians for at least 25 years. Maybe the insistence on stipulating that they don't eat fish is a thing for more recent vegetarians.

Every single one is not a vegetarian.

amicissimma · 28/10/2022 17:07

I know about a dozen long-term vegetarians. Every single one eats fish. None of them make a big deal about what they eat - just state their preference if we're, say, ordering a takeaway.

They've all been vegetarians for at least 25 years. Maybe the insistence on stipulating that they don't eat fish is a thing for more recent vegetarians.

lljkk · 28/10/2022 04:39

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/10/2022 17:34

The word pescatarian didn't exist in the 1980s. So if you ate fish but not other animal flesh, vegetarian was the best word you could find. That's why we used it but also ate fish.

Did you just state that you were vegetarian or did you say "I'm a vegetarian, but I do eat fish"? as a 'less wrong' description. Surely the word 'fish' still existed then?! That would have been better than using an entirely wrong label without giving any other clues, wouldn't it?

All I can say is that 1982-2000 , when I described my self as a "vegetarian" who sometimes ate fish, Nobody Cared. Not a single person complained or objected or commented. I worked in a very busy vegetarian food store for > 4 years so obviously lots of customers & fellow staff were self-identified vegetarians: nobody cared about dietary-self-mis-labelling. Obsession with other people strictly conforming to labels: I did not encounter it. The closest was when I met some strictly Jewish guys in hostel in 1991 who said to check British bread carefully because it often had lard in it. Obviously their dietary concern was religious.

I never worried about tiny % ingredients when I was "vegetarian" either. Partly thinking that lots of things could have insect body parts hidden in them & I wasn't going to try to control that. I tried to choose veg-rennet-cheeses, but I didn't fret about trace ingredients in cheese if eating in a restaurant. Sometimes with other "vegetarians" we would discuss whether to be strict about the wine or beer: most who called themselves vegetarian had decided not to worry about trace animal ingredients in the alcohol. Nobody told each other they were wrong to call selves "vegetarian" but not be strict on the wine & cheese.

My old boss has called himself vegan for 45+ years but admitted to having some cream in a hotel one time "because it looked so good."

I want to add that the SeeFood diet is much easier than being a vegetarian. I find it amazing I ever had the energy to be so strict about my diet when it wasn't necessary.

Swipe left for the next trending thread