Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Screaming at us to shush

81 replies

Nopeaceinthishouse · 26/10/2022 19:24

Dd, just turned 4 has started shouting at us to shush and to go away etc if she’s angry (usually if she doesn’t get something she wants)
She wasn’t like this before and it’s been the last couple of months.
It’s just so rude and disrespectful screaming at us to shush, anything I do isn’t working to try to calm/stop this.
Is this normal? What should I do?

OP posts:
MolkosTeenageAngst · 26/10/2022 20:18

She’s only four! I think you’re projecting adult manners and social etiquette onto her by dwelling on how it’s ‘rude’ and ‘disrespectful.’ She’s still little and learning how to self-regulate and deal with feelings like disappointment, frustration, anger etc.

Her telling you to shush is likely because she’s trying to stop the input that is making her feel those big and difficult feelings (eg: your voice saying no) rather than because she’s trying to be rude or disrespectful; a pre-schooler doesn’t have a solid enough grasp of social etiquette to be either of those things. I’m not saying as a behaviour it’s okay or that you shouldn’t be trying to teach her the skills to manage her feelings and reactions in a different way, but telling her off for saying shush in the moment isn’t really helping her to calm or to learn other ways to manage her anger.

If you’ve said no you don’t necessarilly need to keep repeating it and working her up to the point she is telling you to shush. I would be trying to step away and give her some space before she gets to that point, just calmly reiterate what you’ve said and then leave her to process it without you repeating it. If she’s angry and shouting to shush it isn’t really the right time to be trying to teach her it’s disrespectful, she isn’t going to be able to process what you’re saying or learn from it at that point when engaged in an angry power struggle. In your shoes I would give her space to calm down when she is angry and address the saying shush etc and how it is rude and makes you feel etc later when she is calm and in a state to actually take in and process what you’re saying.

I’d also be reflecting on the behaviour of those around her and whether she has picked up the behaviour of shushing people from anybody in the family, does she ever get told to shh or do any of the adults tell each other to shush etc? It could be she is mirroring behaviour she has seen, in which case she isn’t likely to stop unless the adults around her stop too.

SimonJones · 26/10/2022 20:18

Is she your only child, @Nopeaceinthishouse? If so, this probably feels worse than it is. If you had lots of children, you'd barely notice it. So you perhaps need to pretend that you're also dealing with a baby and a toddler as well, and not take it too seriously. Let her blow off steam and then move on.

In your example, you're giving her too many choices. You offered her three choices so she screamed for the one thing that wasn't on offer (and why not cereal? My DC all used to have Weetabix before they went to bed). If you want to offer a choice, give her two choices. Even better, model the 'right' choice - "I'm going to have a lovely apple/oatcake/whatever before I get ready for bed - would you like to share it with me?" Even if it's 6PM and you're not actually going to bed for another three hours.

ldontWanna · 26/10/2022 20:18

Nopeaceinthishouse · 26/10/2022 19:50

@ldontWanna It’s if she’s being told something she doesn’t want to hear. For example, it was time for bed before with Dh and she wanted something to eat, I gave her of options of the rest of her dinner she hadn’t eaten, fruit, yoghurt, a couple of biscuits. She wanted cereal, which I said is for the morning, she went nuts about how she wanted it, I was very calm and kept reiterating how it was for the morning and she had other choices and it was bedtime now. When I’m telling her that, she gets angrier and starts to shout to shush, then I start to say she can’t talk like that as it’s rude etc etc and she shouts more to try to drown me out. I feel like I’m in a real power struggle and she wasn’t like this before

I'm going to suggest some things. Some you might've already tried ,some you might think are bonkers, some might not work. Just pick and choose what you feel might work for you/the family and what makes sense.
I can also explain the reasoning behind them if you want me to.

  1. Give warnings . Bed time in 10 minutes. You have 5 minutes until bed. Bedtime in 1 minute . Ok time to go to bed now.

2.choices . Keep them limited. Two options that you are happy with. Don't get into an argument,or explain . Just present it as a done deal and then just keep repeating it calmly. "Do you want toast or yogurt?" .

  1. Catch her being good and praise the behaviours you want to see,especially when it comes to reactions and her articulating her needs/feelings in an appropriate way.
  1. When you ask her to do something end with thank you not please(this doesn't necessarily have to be every single time). So instead of "put your shoes on please" say "put your shoes on. Thank you". Sounds really stupid but it works 90% of the time.
  1. When she shouts just calmly say ok and stop. Sit/stand next to her, pretend you're busy and let her come to you. Shouting over each other, going at each other, getting angry etc just escalates things pointlessly. Don't feed into it. Once she's done ,then you can talk to her ,about her feelings ,what she could've done instead or give any consequences if needed. Especially natural consequences. "No you can't watch Bluey because it finished while you were shouting ". Or "we only have time for one story because it took so long for you to settle down".
  1. Clear,reasonable and consistent consequences. No TV for a week because she shouted when angry isn't reasonable for example.
  1. The quieter you are, the more a child will try to listen and they'll likely quieten down as well. Or at least you won't end up in a screaming match.
  1. Remember she's 4. She more than likely doesn't have the tools to always recognise her needs/feelings ,much less communicate them in an appropriate manner. Yes the shouting is upsetting and rude but in her eyes you're making her feel like x (no matter how unreasonable that is-my daughter once cried for half an hour because I didn't look at her sock 🙄🙄) and she wants you to stop because she doesn't want to feel x. So she's doing it the only way she knows how. Understanding where she comes from and the limits does help in the moment in keeping you calm. Not always, but it helps.
  1. When she is calm and settled do some work with her about feelings,not just what they are but how they feel in her body. Heart beating faster,shaky hands,butterflies in her tummy , sweating etc. Same with her basic needs hungry,tired , cold/hot etc. So many kids seem angry for example but they're actually tired or hungry. They just don't recognise that and/or are unable to vocalise it. Talk through coping mechanisms,what she could say,what she could do instead. Remind her after the tantrums about them. Emphasise that all feelings are ok, but she needs to express them in an appropriate way. So "It's ok to be angry,but you can't scream at mummy. It doesn't help and it just upsets the both of us. Next time you could...".

Sorry for the very lengthy and probably annoying post.

KatieBell12 · 26/10/2022 20:15

She's 4. She isn't being disrespectful, she is learning to interact and express herself and your responses will shape her ability to effectively do that. Read some parenting books for various strategies to manage it.

Summerfun54321 · 26/10/2022 20:05

She sounds frustrated and exhausted. Kids need to blow off some steam the same way that adults need to blow off some steam. Adults can have a chat with friends or drink a glass of wine or go for a run after a tough day. Kids just need to have the odd melt down and emotional release. If she’s just started school and she’s 4, she’s probably exhausted from keeping it together all day 5 days a week.

MossGrowsFat · 26/10/2022 20:01

Lunificent · 26/10/2022 19:51

My daughter has always done this. She is autistic so finds our voices too much of a sensory challenge.
it’s most likely that this is just a feature of her age and it will pass. Try to put yourself in her shoes and imagine yourself with equivalent feelings as an adult.

This is what I mean by behaviour meeting a need.
With this child she need a calmer and quieter surrounding, so making people shhh met her need. Here a pair of noise cancelling headphones maybe another way of meeting her needs.

OnomatopoeiaFlea · 26/10/2022 20:01

This is very normal but that doesn’t make it less annoying

When mine went through this stage if we were doing anything with them at the time I’d just get up and leave the room until they stopped. If they did it randomly I would pretend not to hear for a little while after they stopped as they’d hurt my ears. Done playfully (as we follow PACE) but it was effective, after a few times the boundaries were set and she stopped doing it

MossGrowsFat · 26/10/2022 19:58

The cereal issue, if you are going to offer something only two items, it is just too much, also don't try and reason it is genuinely impossible.

So Sarah, you can have your dinner or an apple.
'I want cereal give me cereal'
''Mummy is going to have a slice of apple, would you like to share my apple'
'Cereal'
Slice apple and sit down and ignore anything else that is said. Don't get side tracked with any other issue, such as cereal is for morning (it isn't but that's not the issue 😆) as she can't hear you or process what is going on when she gets like this.
It is perfectly normal behaviour, you setting boundaries and being calm will help her develop.

Lunificent · 26/10/2022 19:51

My daughter has always done this. She is autistic so finds our voices too much of a sensory challenge.
it’s most likely that this is just a feature of her age and it will pass. Try to put yourself in her shoes and imagine yourself with equivalent feelings as an adult.

MossGrowsFat · 26/10/2022 19:51

Nopeaceinthishouse · 26/10/2022 19:42

@MossGrowsFat What should I do? Just ignore being screamed at to shush 🙈it’s so hard as it’s so rude and disrespectful

It's not, she isn't doing it to be disrespectful, she doesn't understand.

Personally I would just say once 'that's rude' and I'd get up and walk away and I wouldn't engage until she calmed down. Inside my head I would be screaming but outwardly I'd be very calm and concentrating on my breathing. Rinse and repeat.

Nopeaceinthishouse · 26/10/2022 19:50

@ldontWanna It’s if she’s being told something she doesn’t want to hear. For example, it was time for bed before with Dh and she wanted something to eat, I gave her of options of the rest of her dinner she hadn’t eaten, fruit, yoghurt, a couple of biscuits. She wanted cereal, which I said is for the morning, she went nuts about how she wanted it, I was very calm and kept reiterating how it was for the morning and she had other choices and it was bedtime now. When I’m telling her that, she gets angrier and starts to shout to shush, then I start to say she can’t talk like that as it’s rude etc etc and she shouts more to try to drown me out. I feel like I’m in a real power struggle and she wasn’t like this before

OP posts:
Choconut · 26/10/2022 19:46

Don't send her to her room, bedrooms should be a place of safety not punishment. Every time she does it it tell her calmly that it's rude to shush people and you don't want to play while she's being rude.
It sounds like she thinks you automatically will know any rules she makes up on the spot and doesn't understand that that's not the case. This is obvious to an adult of course! Later when she's calm explain that you don't know the rules of the game if she doesn't tell you them all or if she doesn't tell you when they change. If she always changes the rules in her favour then I would address that too.

Expect to have to go over and over things like this though - think stuck record and plenty of patience! Just because she's not getting it doesn't mean you're doing something wrong, she just needs to have it gently drummed into her until she gets it (which may require her to mature a little emotionally as well).

ldontWanna · 26/10/2022 19:43

Nopeaceinthishouse · 26/10/2022 19:41

@ldontWanna That's what we can’t work out, we can’t remember saying that and it isn’t something we regularly say. She’s just started school so I don’t know

Does it happen in context? For example she doesn't like what you're saying (no matter how reasonable you might be) and it makes her angry/upset/cross so she just wants you to stop ?

Nopeaceinthishouse · 26/10/2022 19:43

@Pipsickl Yes she does that too, just so intense and grouchy too

OP posts:
123ZYX · 26/10/2022 19:42

DS has done this sometimes. Try to stay calm and say something like "I can see you're frustrated/ angry/ etc at the moment and need some time by yourself to calm down. You can sit in the <appropriate room> while you calm down then let me know when you're ready for a cuddle". You can talk to her about her shushing you and whatever else was bothering her when she's calm.

(Or at least that's what I try to do - not always easy to stay that calm!)

Nopeaceinthishouse · 26/10/2022 19:42

@MossGrowsFat What should I do? Just ignore being screamed at to shush 🙈it’s so hard as it’s so rude and disrespectful

OP posts:
Nopeaceinthishouse · 26/10/2022 19:41

@ldontWanna That's what we can’t work out, we can’t remember saying that and it isn’t something we regularly say. She’s just started school so I don’t know

OP posts:
MolliciousIntent · 26/10/2022 19:39

Squashpocket · 26/10/2022 19:34

Fuck me @MolliciousIntent that's a bit much. Giving a small child the silent treatment all day is horrible. Don't do that OP. I would go with a firm 'don't tell me to shush, it's rude' and tell her the consequences if she does it again, whatever would usually get her attention. If she does it again follow through with the consequences.

Also yes it's normal, if this is the worst she's done so far you're doing fine.

It wasn't all day, it was 2 hours at most. OP has tried consequences, talking while calm, etc etc, and she's still being treated like shit. Time for bigger guns.

ldontWanna · 26/10/2022 19:39

Do you/someone else in her life ever ask her to shush/be quiet/shut up ? Or use it in front of her?

MossGrowsFat · 26/10/2022 19:38

I agree with the biting a spoon and this too shall pass.

The best advice I've ever been given is that if a child continues doing something it is because it is meeting their need.

So by doing this behaviour you are giving them back what they want, so is it extra attention, being shouted at, getting a reaction, giving in? What is it you are doing that is meeting their need, and what can you do to change it.

Nopeaceinthishouse · 26/10/2022 19:38

@DoubleHelix79 How did you deal
with it?

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 26/10/2022 19:38

As for the games she makes up - that’s a control thing. If my kids ever complained or got snappy I’d just have said ‘okay I’m not playing it right, you play it’ and walk away. No option for shouting/rudeness.

Kanaloa · 26/10/2022 19:37

It’s typical tantrum behaviour. I’d remove her to a different place such as her bedroom and ask her to come and speak to you when she is calm. At that point I’d say clearly ‘please don’t scream at me, it’s rude and it makes me feel sad.’ If you make loads of fuss over it in the moment it’s just going to fuel it as she’ll associate screaming shush with getting attention.

Pipsickl · 26/10/2022 19:36

My nearly 4 year old has just started doing stuff like this too. Being rude when asking for things and asking me to hurry up. Also repeating the same bloody question over and over again.

it’s a pain in the arse but I think it’s prob normal as my friends little girl has started doing it too

Nopeaceinthishouse · 26/10/2022 19:36

@DoTheHoochyPoochy 😫

OP posts: