Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

When people say LTB...

83 replies

Cheeeeislifenow · 26/10/2022 19:22

I feel like sometimes on mumsnet people say this as if it's the easiest thing in the world forget the emotional side of it including co dependendence, abusive behaviour or "love".
The practicalities are the hard bit, especially when you have children, even more if you have children with additional needs even more if you have no family of your own to support you, if I were to "LTB" I would be homeless, not just me but my kids too, benefits take ages to come through and the rental market is a non existent, crippling expensive shambles.
AIBU to think there are lots of couple living together who cannot separate due to financial and practical reasons....
Or am I kidding myself and other people do it

OP posts:
SpinningFloppa · 26/10/2022 21:55

What annoys me more is when people say leave and find someone who will treat you better then I made a thread about dating again as a single mum and was basically told that no one would be interested in me now 🤦🏻🤣 thought you should leave and find someone who will treat you better?!

EarringsandLipstick · 26/10/2022 21:55

like ‘why the fuck did you have the 1 child let alone 3 more kids with such a toxic prick

Well it comes across as ignorant, actually.

I did exactly this. I've often asked myself why.

The reasons are myriad. I had no clue it was abusive, I deeply hoped for change, family & children were important to me.

I'm not stupid, but the whole point of abuse is somewhere there's vulnerability that the abuser takes advantage of

Only people with no clue think, let alone ask, such stupid questions.

EarringsandLipstick · 26/10/2022 21:52

Wintermoonandstars · 26/10/2022 20:20

Abuse indeed comes in many forms.

At no point did I say ‘it is different if he is physically abusing you’ . I said abuse, meaning any form of abuse.

But there are threads that appear on here fairly frequently where posters are told they have “the ick”, that there is no possible return, that they deserve to be happy, etc.

For those threads, I do think it is important to be aware that MNetters will not be the ones dealing with the fallout from family breakdown. Why that’s proved a contentious point for some I do not know, unless they are the ones urging people to leave.

I think your post is tone-deaf.

I have never seen a thread where a poster talking about 'the ick' in a marriage (or long-term relationship) with children has been told to LTB

Dating or short-term relationships, yes.

The reason I mentioned physical vs other abuse - physical abuse can be (possibly) seen & named. Other forms of abuse, less so. A woman might wonder: is it really emotional abuse, or just a difference of opinion?

On MN, posters are very good at spotting the AIBU really being about a dysfunctional or more problematic relationship, and not merely the issue being asked.

Wintermoonandstars · 26/10/2022 21:01

We don’t

but

if men had the same propensity for being lone parents then many of them would also be living in poverty.

An average salary is fine. But high housing costs (especially in some areas) and the crippling cost of childcare drives people even on okay ish salaries into difficulties.

and fucking this and fucking that aside, men are paid more than women (on a national level)

and the amazing education system doesn’t suit everybody, funnily enough. some people will never earn well.

So - where does that leave you?

It isn’t purely financial and it shouldn’t be. But marriages and long term relationships do undergo challenges and ebb and wane in terms of sexual attraction. If the knee jerk response to that is ooh - the ick - break up the family - then that can have repercussions and one of the major repercussions is poverty.

lightand · 26/10/2022 20:57

I actually think there is a group of people on here that want to split people up.
Only explanation I can come up with.

AloysiusBear · 26/10/2022 20:56

Wintermoonandstars

In the UK it really is no harder for a young woman to get a well paid job, than a young man.our education system is open to all, young women in fact leave education generally better qualified than men.

So why do we fucking assume most women will end up financially reliant on their partner

Wintermoonandstars · 26/10/2022 20:52

and how much do you think you need to earn to be able to pay for a mortgage, childcare, run a car, pay for all the essentials?

£40,000? £50? £60?

And the average salary?

AloysiusBear · 26/10/2022 20:49

Its why people on here also say don't bloody put yourself in a position where you are completely financially dependent on someone else!!!

Wintermoonandstars · 26/10/2022 20:41

Point proved I think Smile

MsPincher · 26/10/2022 20:26

Wintermoonandstars · 26/10/2022 20:20

Abuse indeed comes in many forms.

At no point did I say ‘it is different if he is physically abusing you’ . I said abuse, meaning any form of abuse.

But there are threads that appear on here fairly frequently where posters are told they have “the ick”, that there is no possible return, that they deserve to be happy, etc.

For those threads, I do think it is important to be aware that MNetters will not be the ones dealing with the fallout from family breakdown. Why that’s proved a contentious point for some I do not know, unless they are the ones urging people to leave.

Tbh if you do have the ick and there’s no way back, you should leave. How could you have sex with someone you can’t bear. Long term if things don’t change, it won’t work.

UWhatNow · 26/10/2022 20:22

I think most people who say LTB can’t say what they really think - especially on the more extreme threads - it comes across as judgemental but I t think it’s just exasperated - like ‘why the fuck did you have the 1 child let alone 3 more kids with such a toxic prick?’ Or ‘couldn’t you have waited five minutes before shackling yourself to such a selfish cocklodging fucker who clearly doesn’t care about you?’

But of course it’s too late…

And yes poverty will trap you far more than those with financial means, properties, families with spare rooms etc.

MsPincher · 26/10/2022 20:20

Absolutely. No one is saying it’s easy to leave. But it’s not impossible and people do it all the time.

a lot of time people are scared of change so don’t leave. Instead of admitting that, they say it’s for the kids or that they can’t, etc. my parents said that and that’s apparently why we had to have a miserable home.

Wintermoonandstars · 26/10/2022 20:20

Abuse indeed comes in many forms.

At no point did I say ‘it is different if he is physically abusing you’ . I said abuse, meaning any form of abuse.

But there are threads that appear on here fairly frequently where posters are told they have “the ick”, that there is no possible return, that they deserve to be happy, etc.

For those threads, I do think it is important to be aware that MNetters will not be the ones dealing with the fallout from family breakdown. Why that’s proved a contentious point for some I do not know, unless they are the ones urging people to leave.

EarringsandLipstick · 26/10/2022 20:14

But it’s a lie to MNers as a whole don’t understand it. They absolutely do and many have lived it or are living it.

I agree. MN really opened my eyes, and I wish I'd had it when things were at their worst during my marriage.

I used to be amazed how quickly MNers would get behind a seemingly small issue to see what was really happening.

One problem I had was that when I tried to tell anyone about what was happening, they minimised it or said it wasn't a big issue; I felt completely alone & lacking any validation.

EarringsandLipstick · 26/10/2022 20:11

If there is abuse that is different. When there isn’t abuse it is less clear cut shall we say.

Abuse comes in many forms though.

Financial and emotional abuse is insidious and damaging too, but less clear to recognise and make overt.

Even when it is unhappiness, and not abuse, while it's not a cavalier or easy decision to make, feeling unhappy & unfulfilled in a relationship is still damaging & draining. It doesn't mean you walk out with no plan, but I'd definitely advise someone in that situation to make a plan to leave.

Ekátn · 26/10/2022 20:08

Wintermoonandstars · 26/10/2022 20:07

No, indeed they don’t, but many will.

I cannot understand how it doesn’t make sense that following the breakup of a marriage (or partnership) there will be less money and this will push many women into poverty.

If there is abuse that is different. When there isn’t abuse it is less clear cut shall we say.

No one is denying that.

But it’s a lie to MNers as a whole don’t understand it. They absolutely do and many have lived it or are living it.

EarringsandLipstick · 26/10/2022 20:07

But otherwise you have to ask yourself if it is really worth it.

For years in my abusive marriage, I held firmly to that view thinking that 1. It wasn't that bad 2. It would improve 3. I had kids, I had to stay & it was better for them.

So I stayed & got chipped away at bit by bit; I didn't recognise the abuse for what it was; I felt like I was living in hell, every time the key turned in the door I'd feel sick. I had more children.

A few serendipitous events (at least in retrospect) brought it home to me that I could not stay. He left the house; I had 3 very small children, has just finished a contract role so had no work at that time; it's 9 years later & it has been incredibly tough. I'm nearly through the divorce process - he hasn't supported the DC adequately, has never really shared care of them, and has continued to make life impossible for me.

But. It is worth it. Financial & other issues notwithstanding, being free of him is worth it. I dread to think what would have happened, to me & DC otherwise

If you are unhappy, and there is no meaningful prospect of improving matters, then yes, it's always worth it

Wintermoonandstars · 26/10/2022 20:07

No, indeed they don’t, but many will.

I cannot understand how it doesn’t make sense that following the breakup of a marriage (or partnership) there will be less money and this will push many women into poverty.

If there is abuse that is different. When there isn’t abuse it is less clear cut shall we say.

Ekátn · 26/10/2022 19:59

Wintermoonandstars · 26/10/2022 19:54

And loads will know it isn’t a life you’ll want to choose with a child or children. The wide eyed disingenuous response is not fooling anyone.

You aren’t even making sense.

You stated MNers will not be living in insecure substrates housing. Or understand juggling childcare and work.

Thats wrong. There’s no wide eyed anything.

Your statement was entirely wrong. Even forgetting that not everyone who leaves ends up in a bad situation financially.

VioletCharlotte · 26/10/2022 19:56

It can sometimes be said a bit flippantly, but the majority of the time it needs to be said. I wish someone had said it to me when I was living with an awful ex-P. It's all too easy to stick what what you know because it feels safer, despite the fact you're miserable and feel like you're treading on eggshells. Leaving is hard, because of all the reasons you listed, but it's never impossible and ultimately if you're happy, your DC will be happier, even if it means living in a smaller house with less money.

Wintermoonandstars · 26/10/2022 19:54

And loads will know it isn’t a life you’ll want to choose with a child or children. The wide eyed disingenuous response is not fooling anyone.

GoOnGetHappy · 26/10/2022 19:52

I think it's very interesting when people here minimise very real EA or CC and say it's too hard to leave an abusive relationship, and it wasn't really abusive anyway. 🤔

Ekátn · 26/10/2022 19:52

Wintermoonandstars · 26/10/2022 19:48

It is always good to be mindful of the fact that MNetters will not be the ones living in substandard, insecure housing for the duration of their children’s childhood.

They will not be the ones struggling to combine work and childcare.

They will not be the ones in that position.

In the case of actual abuse you have to get out. But otherwise you have to ask yourself if it is really worth it.

What do you mean?

Loads or MNers are in (or have been) unsecured substandard housing.

Loads of us are struggling to combine work and childcare. Lots of us struggle or have struggled to do this as single parents. Working parents are really common on MN. As are people struggling with money. As are single parents.

Ekátn · 26/10/2022 19:48

Oh and yes, I did it. Took 2 years to get everything in place. Even then I still had to leave in the night with the kids, because he escalated his abuse one evening. But I was almost ready anyway.

Not easy, but entirely worth it. I was married 15 years. With him 18. 14 years were happy and I loved him. The. He went down the conspiracy rabbit hole and changed into a completely different person. The whole thing broke my heart and left me with ptsd.

and 5 years later I can honestly say, it was worth it.

Wintermoonandstars · 26/10/2022 19:48

It is always good to be mindful of the fact that MNetters will not be the ones living in substandard, insecure housing for the duration of their children’s childhood.

They will not be the ones struggling to combine work and childcare.

They will not be the ones in that position.

In the case of actual abuse you have to get out. But otherwise you have to ask yourself if it is really worth it.