Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

When people say LTB...

83 replies

Cheeeeislifenow · 26/10/2022 19:22

I feel like sometimes on mumsnet people say this as if it's the easiest thing in the world forget the emotional side of it including co dependendence, abusive behaviour or "love".
The practicalities are the hard bit, especially when you have children, even more if you have children with additional needs even more if you have no family of your own to support you, if I were to "LTB" I would be homeless, not just me but my kids too, benefits take ages to come through and the rental market is a non existent, crippling expensive shambles.
AIBU to think there are lots of couple living together who cannot separate due to financial and practical reasons....
Or am I kidding myself and other people do it

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thepeopleversuswork · 13/11/2022 18:05

Yes sometimes LTB is said in a hyperbolic way and sometimes its inappropriate.

But you have to remember the default position is always to stay, tough it out, "work on it" (which I think is largely code for "put up with even more shit"). Society and economics are always screaming at women to stay put. Everything we learn from a young age tells us we're better off in a relationship. That we should move heaven and earth to paper over the cracks, put up and shut up, however bad it is.

LTB is powerful because it often comes from women who have been in abusive or dysfunctional relationships themselves and can spot the signs and read between the lines.

Quite often posters come on here and post something based on an apparently trivial incident and then when questioned a whole narrative unspools which makes it clear that the poster has been tolerating an unsatisfactory relationship for years but has closed her mind off to the potential for leaving. Posters like this sometimes just need permission to allow themselves to consider the possibility of LTB when the whole of society is telling them its off-limits.

No one thinks it will be easy to LTB when you are married with children and particularly if you are not working. It's always difficult. It quite often takes months or years of planning. But it's never impossible if its what you really want to do.

Most women won't actually act on advice to LTB for the reasons you've cited. No one will leave an otherwise happy relationship because a stranger on the internet has told her to do so. But if it helps a few who have struggled for years to clear their minds and focus on what's really important, so much the better.

ReneBumsWombats · 13/11/2022 18:03

I think there are far more women staying in shit relationships with shit fathers for fear of breaking up the family than there are wonderful husbands and fathers being dumped and lives uprooted because women are just really unreasonable and insensitive.

newbookonshelf · 13/11/2022 17:49

It's always possible to do if it's necessary as you can always make it work, but it's more difficult with children not least because it can devastate them and that's hard to do.

realsavagelike · 13/11/2022 17:18

@EarringsandLipstick and @vipersnest1 right there with you!

Zanatdy · 13/11/2022 16:58

People say it too easily on here but this is the U.K. and of course there’s a way

lightand · 13/11/2022 16:52

Smineusername · 26/10/2022 22:40

I think the culture round here is nuts. There is a perfectionism about relationships that I really don't fathom, and a glibness about going it alone with kids,and virtually no appreciation of how legitimately upsetting family breakdown is for kids

Totally agree.

From what little I know, the people who regularly say ltb havent actually done it themselves.

UthredofBattenberg · 28/10/2022 20:00

Absolutely. While a lot of threads have a LTB. It dies seem there's an undertone of it being as easy as taking the bins out.

It really is not easy (from experience!) Will he actually leave if you ask him? If not, how can you force him? If he won't, where will you go? Will you take the children? Is there room there? Can you afford the rent/mortgage alone? Do you have money for a divorce? Solicitors fees? What if you cant agree? Who gets the house? Can you afford to buy him out? Will the kids hate you? Can you afford to start over? Is it really THAT bad? Do you want to do this? Etc etc etc. It's awful 😖

YeahmetooJill · 28/10/2022 19:52

I'm not remotely worried about loving, healthy, happy marriages being broken up by Mumsnet. It simply doesn't happen. But some women have found it gives them the strength to leave when they need to

Absolutely this!

interstatelovesong · 28/10/2022 06:15

@PumpkinZombie

You are totally right

But everything is so expensive these days that even though we earn okay money I don't have much in the way of savings.

I mean, if we split I'd get half the equity in the house. But that currently wouldn't be enough to buy a new place, not in this economic climate. And renting would be out of reach as although I earn okay money rents are ridiculous now in comparison to income. Plus my workspace is at my home

And although I do okay with my business H earns much more so he'd get the kids as I wouldn't be able to give them the lifestyle they've been living up to now. So they probably wouldn't want to stay with me anyway

It is what it is 😞 . We're happy , let's just hope we stay that way hey 🤞🏻

PumpkinZombie · 27/10/2022 23:50

interstatelovesong · 27/10/2022 13:06

I get it op

I left my first husband 15 years ago I had absolutely nothing as we rented our home and both had shit jobs and no money. I had a baby so was able to claim top up benefits and eventually got a council house. It isn't like that anymore... benefits are harder to get and less and there's no council housing and private rent is very expensive

15 years on I am remarried with more dc. I have a successful business which I run from a outbuilding at my home , we have a beautiful house and a mortgage. The mortgage payments are affordable and H earns quite a lot of money

I'm happy with him but I'd be fucked in every way if we split or I left so if things ever went bad I think I'd just stay tbh. I better hope he doesn't leave me !

That just makes me so sad to hear. I can't imagine letting myself get into a situation where I was trapped like that if I needed to leave, especially having had the lesson once already. Why on Earth would you do that to yourself and your children, it's such a huge risk? Not being goady I just genuinely do not understand how you could put yourself in a situation where you and your children are totally dependent on someone else where - in your words - you couldn't manage on your own, having already been through needing to previously.

ReneBumsWombats · 27/10/2022 21:41

This gets complained about a lot, but nobody leaves their loving, healthy, happy relationship because people on MN said LTB.

But people in loving, healthy, happy relationships don't usually post on MN questioning them.

Time and time again, even a thread that seems minor at first eventually gives way to show an absolute disaster of a relationship, with an OP who has accepted shit for so long she can't understand why it still doesn't smell better.

Most people don't LTB anyway. Most women stay in abusive relationships for all manner of reasons. They're very, very hard to leave.

I'm not remotely worried about loving, healthy, happy marriages being broken up by Mumsnet. It simply doesn't happen. But some women have found it gives them the strength to leave when they need to.

therubbiliser · 27/10/2022 21:37

My MIL left this year after 4 decades of abuse physical, emotional, sexual abuse. It never gets easier to leave. The police and social services were involved in her eventual leaving her home.

I think it is very difficult but there are times when leaving is the least worst option and on MN I think it is usually justified when people suggest the option of leaving.

EarringsandLipstick · 27/10/2022 21:36

PearlclutchersInc · 27/10/2022 11:43

Pehaps saying these things with make the poster give consideration to the position they're in and just how normal or abnormal it is.

If many comments are LTB then at least think about it and consider how it could be done and what's needed. Noone ever says do it right now (at least rarely anyway).

Good point

I doubt when I was in the throes of my difficult relationship that I'd have taken the 'LTB' advice, if I was here then & posting, as I was so committed to 'making it work'.

However, maybe it would have at least shone a light on the problems & lack of normality & opened the possibility of change.

IRL no-one had a clue, even when I tried to tell them, they didn't get it. Some (many) still don't.

EarringsandLipstick · 27/10/2022 21:33

Wintermoonandstars · 27/10/2022 11:27

There’s a pattern on this thread of telling posters that what they have seen or read wasn’t the case at all.

Is there?

Or is it that long-standing posters are saying they haven't seen what's described and asking for examples if they exist?

EarringsandLipstick · 27/10/2022 21:32

BaffledShopper · 27/10/2022 11:49

What always irks me is when people jump straight in with "you deserve better". (How do we know she deserves better when we don't know her, and haven't heard his side of the story?)

Everyone deserves better in situations where they are unhappy, unsupported, starved of love or communication.

It doesn't mean that there's inherently some moral judgment on either person, just that everyone has a right to certain core elements in a relationship.

interstatelovesong · 27/10/2022 13:07

Longerthanfiveweeks · 27/10/2022 11:56

There are lots of women in unhappy relationships who decide staying is better than leaving, thought that choice is hard. You don't hear about them often on here as they cannot talk about their experiences without being attacked for not leaving.

All women will be in different situations. But for women who don't have a job or don't have a well paid job, or have a poor work history or have disabilities or have children with disabilities, and maybe have no other family support, leaving can be a bleak prospect. Especially for older women who are unlikely to have the opportunity to build up a careers, especially whilst also looking after children as a single parent.

Moving your children to a low income areas, with associated schools, to live in poverty, to feel the stigma of that, to potentially become isolated from your friendship groups as you can no longer afford to socialise with them, to face poverty in retirement, and to potentially lose custody of your kids as the Judge decides they were be better off living where they are established with the affluent parent. You can see why women stay. And they shouldn't be judged for it.

I wish more posters on here had more empathy for the very difficult situation women find themselves in. Just because 'you' left it does not mean other women are in the same situation as you were when you left.

This 👏🏻

interstatelovesong · 27/10/2022 13:06

I get it op

I left my first husband 15 years ago I had absolutely nothing as we rented our home and both had shit jobs and no money. I had a baby so was able to claim top up benefits and eventually got a council house. It isn't like that anymore... benefits are harder to get and less and there's no council housing and private rent is very expensive

15 years on I am remarried with more dc. I have a successful business which I run from a outbuilding at my home , we have a beautiful house and a mortgage. The mortgage payments are affordable and H earns quite a lot of money

I'm happy with him but I'd be fucked in every way if we split or I left so if things ever went bad I think I'd just stay tbh. I better hope he doesn't leave me !

Kualma · 27/10/2022 12:40

Tbf most if not all relationship on Mumsnet is terrible. I don’t come on here for advice on my relationship

pinkpotatoez · 27/10/2022 12:27

The amount of times LTB is said on here, you'd expect 'Mumsnet' to be down as the reason for 90% of divorces in the UK. Don't get me wrong a lot of the time I read posts I think 'LTB' but commenting it is so unhelpful, they already know they are in a shit situation but divorcing is way easier said than done. I'm sure some of the people commenting it aren't in fairytale marriages either but they're not leaving.

Longerthanfiveweeks · 27/10/2022 11:56

There are lots of women in unhappy relationships who decide staying is better than leaving, thought that choice is hard. You don't hear about them often on here as they cannot talk about their experiences without being attacked for not leaving.

All women will be in different situations. But for women who don't have a job or don't have a well paid job, or have a poor work history or have disabilities or have children with disabilities, and maybe have no other family support, leaving can be a bleak prospect. Especially for older women who are unlikely to have the opportunity to build up a careers, especially whilst also looking after children as a single parent.

Moving your children to a low income areas, with associated schools, to live in poverty, to feel the stigma of that, to potentially become isolated from your friendship groups as you can no longer afford to socialise with them, to face poverty in retirement, and to potentially lose custody of your kids as the Judge decides they were be better off living where they are established with the affluent parent. You can see why women stay. And they shouldn't be judged for it.

I wish more posters on here had more empathy for the very difficult situation women find themselves in. Just because 'you' left it does not mean other women are in the same situation as you were when you left.

BaffledShopper · 27/10/2022 11:49

What always irks me is when people jump straight in with "you deserve better". (How do we know she deserves better when we don't know her, and haven't heard his side of the story?)

BaffledShopper · 27/10/2022 11:46

Cuppasoupmonster · 26/10/2022 19:34

Plus I do not believe for one second all the ‘I would LTB’ posters would actually leave their husband over dirty dishes/underwhelming birthday present. But they have no problem saying somebody else should.

I have often thought this.

PearlclutchersInc · 27/10/2022 11:43

Pehaps saying these things with make the poster give consideration to the position they're in and just how normal or abnormal it is.

If many comments are LTB then at least think about it and consider how it could be done and what's needed. Noone ever says do it right now (at least rarely anyway).

Electricstar · 27/10/2022 11:37

I agree with you mostly but also disagree in some cases

Sometimes when a OP writes that her partner cheats on her constantly, lies to her etc I think it’s really hard to think of anything other then “why are you still staying and being a doormat” of course it is so much easier said than done when love is involved or even kids, but in reality if they are with someone who just doesn’t respect them then I am not sure what else OP expects other than LTB or a hand hold.

It is not always easy to LTB in some cases and I think most replies know that. Especially in DV cases. The LTB are easy for some to throw out but it is not that simple at all.

I think that most MN users know that AIBU especially for relationship advice comes with all sarcastic, flippant or judgey answers.

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 27/10/2022 11:31

Putonyourshoes · 26/10/2022 19:32

Of course other people do it. When people say LTB, they’re not saying it’s going to be easy or it’s a simple as just packing a bag and leaving tonight. I’m exasperated by the posters who detail absolutely awful relationships and expect any advice other than to leave their partner.

I agree with this, and are in complete denial they are also enabling the abuse of their children but it’s fine cause they have a bedroom each.

I have to swerve the relationship board these days.