Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's not impossible that ds could become a barrister?

162 replies

coffeerevelsrule · 26/10/2022 15:41

I am shamelessly posting here for traffic to try and get some advice for ds1 as I don't know about this to advise him properly.

He is currently in Y11 and predicted all 8s and 9s. He is incredibly driven and focused and has done tons of research into degrees and careers. He has come to the conclusion that he'd like to be a barrister - he's certain at the moment he would not want to be a solicitor. However, his research has led him to believe that unless he does law at Oxbridge he stands next to no chance of securing a pupillage, and that even if he does this will still not guarantee a career as a barrister. He is quoting all sorts of scary stats and basically thinks that without connections and Oxbridge he'll have no chance. He's also concerned that it'll be a 'beggars can't be choosers' scenario and he'll end up helping some corporation pay less tax and/or screw over their employees, which he wouldn't want to do. He wants to go into human rights but has realised this doesn't pay well, which, despite his principles, puts him off.

My opinion is that he is extremely bright and also has other qualities that will make him desirable, such as the aforementioned drive and focus, and that he is likely to get an excellent degree from an excellent university (maybe Oxbridge, maybe not) and that that degree will lead him to some kind of excellent career that he may not even be aware exists at the moment. He's not happy with this response.

Does anyone have any advice and/or experience of people from 'ordinary' backgrounds making it as a barrister and/or people with law degrees having a worthwhile career in another sector? I'm all talked out about this at the moment!

OP posts:
Oblomov22 · 26/10/2022 16:22

I know 3 barristers, all did other subjects eg English at good RG Unis, then law, then bar.

Northbynorthbreast · 26/10/2022 16:22

Not to piss on his parade but instead to expand his perspective…. I’m a career coach and work for many blue chips and law firms.

ask him- what experiences in life is he looking for that he he hopes being a barrister will give him?

what skills does he want to use?
what impact does he want to have?

he might find that there are a number of interesting jobs that give him those experiences and are better paid and more meritocratic.

just a thought.

Fink · 26/10/2022 16:20

All the barristers I know are Oxbridge educated but didn't do first degrees in law. This isn't supposed to be representative, it's just that I'm Oxbridge non-lawyer so that's the people I know.

flamingogold · 26/10/2022 16:19

I was a barrister in a public law set.

Oxbridge is useful but not vital, but a 1st from a good university is. Also a law degree isnt vital - a lot of people do history particularly or STEM.

Have a look at Blackstone and Landmark chambers websites - both will set out the application forms for mini pupillages.

It is a hard life - particularly the first few years when you have all the expenses and none of the money, but public law (which includes human rights) can earn £££. There is the cab rank rule which mean you won't always be on the 'right' side.

SweetSakura · 26/10/2022 16:18

I know plenty of barristers who didn't come from prestigious backgrounds and plenty who did.

You can't go in with a chip in your shoulder about the posh ones. Just get on with working hard and finding ways to get relevant experience.

There are so many different careers in law. Its finding the one that works for your skills and values. The people who manage that tend to really enjoy their jobs (I love mine)

EnEspana · 26/10/2022 16:17

My SIL is a respected barrister in her field. She started in family law and went on to do work with UNICEF. Her degree was from Liverpool - she didn’t want to go to Oxbridge.

catsandkid · 26/10/2022 16:15

I'm a law graduate, and a qualified solicitor. From a working class background - no one in my family went to uni before me. Went to a mediocre state school and sixth form, and a relatively good (but not Russel Group/Oxbridge) university and got a 2:1. Then went on to study the LPC at law school to be a solicitor. Whilst at law school several friends were studying BVC to become barristers - they were a real mixed bag in terms of background and social class, but from memory none were Oxbridge grads.

I went in-house as a solicitor in a global company and have a really exciting and progressive career without the stress of worrying about my billable hours! So... maybe suggest a law study route if he's particularly interested in that, but definitely don't discount the other legal professions at such an early stage! He genuinely won't know enough about the opportunities in either profession until he's in the thick of it all. Advise him to spend time obtaining internships, vacation scheme placements and work experience in all kinds of legal roles so he can really see what its like. I didn't even really understand that my area of law existed when I was in sixth form!

Swedishmeatball · 26/10/2022 16:15

I’d echo a previous poster - what is it that appeals about being a barrister rather than a solicitor? I’m dual qualified (as came from a jurisdiction where it is a fused bar. Only requalified as a solicitor in England).

To put it extremely basically - does he absolutely love the idea of verbal jousting and being quick on his feet? Both professions require excellent research and writing skills, and both professions cover all areas of law.

Mummybud · 26/10/2022 16:14

Lawyer here. He’s still very young. He should do his best in his school exams and get into the best uni he can. If law is his chosen path, Oxbridge or a Russell group uni will serve him well. I meet a lot of students who want to do human rights or become barristers. When you learn about law and the different careers your views change. He may decide that land law is for him. City lawyers don’t just try to help big corporations avoid tax… that’s naive. The posters above who say you can transition from solicitor to barrister are quite correct - I know of at least 5-6 through my career, and they are excellent barristers.

Whichever route he chooses (barrister or city lawyer or something else) it’s fiercely competitive. Focusing on the statistics won’t help, encourage him to focus on his studies and any work experience he can get instead. There’s little space for defeatism before he’s even started(!) There are plenty of people in the legal profession who didn’t go to private school or Oxbridge, but everyone I work with is driven and very clever - those are the qualities he’ll need.

x2boys · 26/10/2022 16:13

My uncle is in his 70,s,he's a KC ,( seems strange writing that ) he s defence KC and worked on some really high profile murder cases ,he went to Newcastle I think .

bigfamilygrowingupfast · 26/10/2022 16:07

Not an area I know a lot about but it's worth getting in touch with a company called Tayberry for advice - my nephew used them (he's studying law at Oxford) and they gave him and his parents a lot of support with the application and also onward planning for work experience and internships etc. They're very well known so you should be able to Google them and they'll come up

DanniDryer · 26/10/2022 16:05

Agree with pp that the “beggars can’t be choosers” comment suggests he doesn’t know much about the Bar- this is obviously totally fair enough at 16 but a good reason not to rule anything out at this stage.

ADialgaAteMyDog · 26/10/2022 16:05

I work in public law/human rights and a lot of the barristers we instruct don't have LLBs let alone went to Oxbridge.
Might be worth looking at the barristers list of local chambers so see where they all went. have a look at this chambers

ttcchapter1 · 26/10/2022 16:05

Studied not stymied 😂😂

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 26/10/2022 16:05

YANBU and it's really good that he's going into this with his eyes open (if slightly pessimistic) so he doesn't finish uni and get a shock. I know a girl who was on my undergrad course (a BA similar to philosophy) at York who did the conversion course to become a barrister and one of my relatives did a law degree at an ex-poly and never got a pupillage so used it in the public sector instead. I don't know anyone who has actually "made it" in any area of law who didn't have a lot of money/connections behind them because of the amount they don't pay when you're starting out means you need a lot of parental support both emotionally and financially. Are there any other careers he would enjoy that might pay better/offer more stability?

ttcchapter1 · 26/10/2022 16:05

His research is wrong I'm afraid, I know plenty barristers who have stymied at various university's up and down the country and completed their BPTC at various providers. The main setback with succeeding to become a barrister is gaining as much experience as you can within chambers completed mini pupillage's, shadowing judges etc.

Welshwabbit · 26/10/2022 16:04

I'm a barrister. I went to a comprehensive and had no legal connections. I applied to Oxford (and was lucky enough to get in) because like your son, I thought I had no chance of succeeding as a barrister if I didn't go to Oxbridge. I had 10 A*s at GCSE, 4 As at A level and, 25 years ago, I think I was right. It is much better now, but although many chambers (including mine) recruit university blind, there are still an awful lot of Oxbridge graduates (and private school alumni) in the profession. However, you absolutely can make it from an "ordinary" background and from a non Oxbridge university.

On your son's other questions, there are loads of different areas of law and you absolutely don't have to do corporate stuff. Different chambers have different focuses and different political positions so although the cab rank rule exists many places will have barristers who in practice only act for one "side". It is worth noting what's going on in criminal law at the moment though- it's chronically underfunded and people are working extremely hard for what can work out as less than the minimum wage.

If he's really set on it, I'd say go for it. It is very hard work, but in my areas, also very well paid and when it's going well, it's the best job in the world for me. And I can honestly count on the fingers of one hand the number of times I've felt that I'm being put down for my background or lack of connections - in over 20 years of practice.

Minkyscamp · 26/10/2022 16:03

I was a barrister in London for 15 years before giving it up a few years back. Normal state secondary school, and definitely no family connections. It was hard, and the competition was ruthless (which will still be the case now no doubt), but, as with anything, if you want it enough you should go for it.

I do think it's important to have very realistic expectations though, and prepare to be flexible if it doesn't work out.

Good luck to him.

ButterflyAi · 26/10/2022 16:02

I come from a background of law and lawyers and know lots of barristers - only one of them is Oxbridge.

They're a mixed bag - one I know retrained in his 40's, and most are pretty unexceptional backgrounds. They all seem to do pretty well and attract the work they need to.

The old boys network is alive and kicking, but I honestly think the bar is accessible these days for most people if they want a crack at it.

DanniDryer · 26/10/2022 16:02

Of course it’s possible, although not easy.

www.barcouncil.org.uk/becoming-a-barrister/school-students/bar-placement-scheme.html

There are lots of schemes aimed at making the Bar more accessible and diverse. He should apply for the Bar Placement Scheme in sixth form (see the link) and maybe look at this as well smartlaw.org.uk/mock-trials/bar-mock-trials-teachers-2/

He doesn’t need to decide on whether to become a barrister or a solicitor until he’s finished his degree. I’d encourage him to keep an open mind and try to get work experience for both. At 16 he’s unlikely to have a realistic view of the differences between the professions.

illiterato · 26/10/2022 16:01

Firstly, I know plenty of barristers who didn’t go to Oxbridge. Secondly I know quite a few barristers who don’t have a law degree- did a post grad law conversion course, then bar school.

I’m not sure what he means about “beggars can’t be choosers” as corporate litigation/ tax is probably one of the more competitive areas to get a pupillage in. It’s not an area you end up in if you don’t get human rights, although he’s right, that and criminal law don’t pay v well. I have a friend who does family law- mainly med neg ( not an ambulance chaser)- and enjoys it but it’s steady and rewarding vs. exciting.

He’s right that to get a tenancy is quite a wide funnel- not all those who pass bar exams get a pupillage and not all those that get a pupillage get a tenancy.

What exactly is it that attracts him about the bar vs being a solicitor?

glassfully · 26/10/2022 15:58

This isn't what you want to hear. I left my job as a solicitor a few years ago but I still remember a conversation I had with a barrister during a day of mediation not long before I left. She was on the interview panel for her chambers and had a day of interviews later that week. She said that the candidates they had lined up were almost intimidating and she wouldn't get an interview let alone a pupilage if she was applying these days. It's not just that most were from Oxbridge, it's the experience they all managed to get to bolster their CV. Every single interviewee had done work experience somewhere prestigious overseas. It's a few years ago now but two examples I remember were the European Court of Human Rights and with Congress in Washington. It was a good set of chambers in London but not one of the top chambers. I've just looked her up and she's a KC now. She was very very talented when I worked with her so it's depressing to think she's only there because it wasn't quite so competitive when she started.

Georgeskitchen · 26/10/2022 15:58

Hollyhead · 26/10/2022 15:46

I think you generally need a good uni but not oxbridge. To be honest it makes me laugh when people say how bright and driven their DC are and then ask for information on their behalf that a bright, driven person would be able to find in about 5 minutes by googling chambers websites and LinkedIn.

Sure the DC could have googled but OP was asking if anyone had any PERSONAL experience in this field, which is not the same as googling information

Swivellingbrat · 26/10/2022 15:57

I know 2 barristers neither went to Oxbridge. One (a relative) is extremely well connected and I think got her pupillage through that, though she is undoubtedly able.

The other one I met through my Saturday job years ago. She was absolutely ruthless and determined to get there despite coming from an immigrant background. She is very extravert and a real ‘character’.

Its not impossible but you need to make the right connections and have the personality to charm and impress people.

VatofTea · 26/10/2022 15:55

Barristers in both England & Ireland have protested over recent years due to poor pay.

Your sons expectations are pretty close to reality. It is difficult to get consistent work as a self employed BL without good connections, not impossible. BLs are at the mercy of law firms, and he will need to play a very political game to ensure he creates lucrative contacts.

If he goes in-house, he will be paid a salary and payrises will be linked to longevity and experience etc. He could go into Funds, M&A, Software/IP law. I personally think without a network of boys club contacts, he would be better off considering what industry he might enjoy working in. For example chip design and everything connected to Software design is lucrative.

Law is not the highest paid department in any company, lawyers tend to work very hard to justify their expense, they are a drain on each company and are not revenue generating. Other departments can pay more. Sometimes the less lofty aspirations actually pay more.

Swipe left for the next trending thread