Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's not impossible that ds could become a barrister?

162 replies

coffeerevelsrule · 26/10/2022 15:41

I am shamelessly posting here for traffic to try and get some advice for ds1 as I don't know about this to advise him properly.

He is currently in Y11 and predicted all 8s and 9s. He is incredibly driven and focused and has done tons of research into degrees and careers. He has come to the conclusion that he'd like to be a barrister - he's certain at the moment he would not want to be a solicitor. However, his research has led him to believe that unless he does law at Oxbridge he stands next to no chance of securing a pupillage, and that even if he does this will still not guarantee a career as a barrister. He is quoting all sorts of scary stats and basically thinks that without connections and Oxbridge he'll have no chance. He's also concerned that it'll be a 'beggars can't be choosers' scenario and he'll end up helping some corporation pay less tax and/or screw over their employees, which he wouldn't want to do. He wants to go into human rights but has realised this doesn't pay well, which, despite his principles, puts him off.

My opinion is that he is extremely bright and also has other qualities that will make him desirable, such as the aforementioned drive and focus, and that he is likely to get an excellent degree from an excellent university (maybe Oxbridge, maybe not) and that that degree will lead him to some kind of excellent career that he may not even be aware exists at the moment. He's not happy with this response.

Does anyone have any advice and/or experience of people from 'ordinary' backgrounds making it as a barrister and/or people with law degrees having a worthwhile career in another sector? I'm all talked out about this at the moment!

OP posts:
titchy · 26/10/2022 17:07

Just to correct your last post - he won't be applying to universities this time next year, it'll be the year after so he's still got a good bit of time to think about what he wants.

Cheeseandpineappleonastick · 26/10/2022 17:04

A family member of mine has recently got a pupillage after passing the bar. They went to a good university in a big city but nowhere like oxbridge. Pupillages are very competitive and my family member is working in a certain type of law which wasn't thier number one preference but the only pupillage they could get after applying for loads all over the country. Back up plan was to be a solicitor. It is very competitive but not impossible.

JustMarriedBecca · 26/10/2022 16:53

Solicitor here. Private commercial practice.

I think you can probably be a barrister in fields like criminal law from non-Oxbridge backgrounds. As someone said above, they've all been striking because they earn 17p a day or something awful. I work with Chambers in London (corporate and property law) mainly and all are, without exception, predominantly Oxbridge. It's all about who you know AND merit. You can't get there just on contacts alone.

Those regional chambers I work with on occasion have non Oxbridge barristers but they earn less than I do.

My advice would be that it's easier to be a solicitor coming from a middle or working class background than the bar.

Wiluli · 26/10/2022 16:52

There is no reason why he cannot be a barrister , this being said I think it’s good he realises it’s hard . Not easy to get a pupilage or funding to survive on one at present . And as you know barristers are self employed so at the start of the careers they often can go months even a full year without being paid . I know this as I’m one who choose to leave the profession and I’m now a practicing solicitor . But I graduated late 20s and I already had a child so it was the uncertainty of income that killed the dream for me , plus I had a few rough cases to start with and decided I needed my consciente clear for a good nights sleep , it’s not easy and it’s not as in the movies . I’m quite happy doing what I do now , ideas change as we mature and your son has plenty of opportunities within his legal degree if he changes his mind . Good luck for whatever he chooses

DelurkingLawyer · 26/10/2022 16:52

I am a barrister and went to Oxbridge from a sink comprehensive. Didn’t read law. There are plenty in my set who are non-Oxbridge though Oxbridge remains over represented at the Bar as a whole.

I’d say this:

  • my set never gave points at the paper assessment stage to the university, only to the class of degree, and for many years has redacted the university so assessors don’t even see what university it is.
  • I would expect most sets now to do the same as a matter of best recruitment practice.
  • Oxbridge, and Russell Group universities, and law degree courses, are all competitive. The knock-on effect is that applicants for pupillage from any of those backgrounds are likely to be well-qualified, competitive and driven people with excellent CVs. I am not saying there is no “Oxbridge bias” but you have to take that into account too.
  • Oxbridge also has the advantage that many of the CV points like mooting and debating are easy to pick up because every college has its own moot club, whereas I know from my outreach work that students from other universities may struggle because moot competitions and the like are less available and are oversubscribed.
  • The Inns of Court run open days for 6th formers, and their websites generally have a lot of information. Worth a look.
  • I agree with PP who is a barrister that the absolute best thing is to focus on getting the best academic qualifications possible, from school and from whatever university he goes to.
  • Also focus on CV points and it is worth looking at junior barristers’ CVs to see what sort of things they did as students.
  • The financial outlook for criminal barristers is dire. Civil practice much less so, though there are increasingly downward pressures on fees. I admire the criminal Bar hugely, their job is vital, but I would not (and most criminal practitioners would not) recommend going to the criminal Bar.
  • Good luck to him. I’ve hugely enjoyed it for most of my time.
coffeerevelsrule · 26/10/2022 16:52

Thank you very much for all these helpful responses - lots to read, consider and look into. I'll be showing him all the links.

He is well aware of the need to do work experience, mini-pupillages, mooting/debating etc and I have no doubt he would avail himself of these opportunities and would seek them out. I don't think it's impossible for him to get to Oxbridge, but I've known several people over the years to get fantastic grades and on paper look like perfect candidates and they weren't offered places, so it's nice to read that it's not necessarily essential.

As for being a barrister rather than a solicitor, he has always been something of a leader and the advocacy element is what really appeals to him about that. However, I completely agree that he needs to look into the difference between the roles more carefully and be more open-minded about it, and indeed look at other careers. He's dead against working for corporations though...I am trying to get him to be more open-minded about that too. I also thought myself that he probably has a somewhat simplistic view of corporate law (though he definitely knows it's very competitive - I shouldn't have used the 'beggars can't be choosers' phrase as that's not how he put it to me and it obviously isn't how people 'end up' in corporate law!)

The problem with not doing a law degree initially is one of cost if he then did decide to go into it. History is his passion, but the worry is the cost of adding an additional year of study if this could be avoided. This time next year he'll be applying for university, so that element at least has to be decided by them.

what I would say to any year 11 is get on with your studies, get into the best university you can , get involved in life, speak to peers and college tutors, apply for vacation schemes and most importantly keep an open mind about how your career will pan out.

Aside from the bit about vacation schemes, this is pretty much what I say to him every day but he won't stop going on about this, hence me seeking advice on here!

OP posts:
Bumpsadaisie · 26/10/2022 16:50

Barristers I know ...

One went to London state school, 2(1) in humanities subject at Cambridge, BVC, Bar school and pupillage after that. Not outstanding genius but always very good at connecting with people, getting work experience, being on every committee going and getting involved in all sorts. Now a KC and has continued that drive to connect and organise.

Other went to ordinary midlands comp, very clever, first in sciences at Cambridge, did PhD then swapped to law.

Another very similar, but very good independent day public school, very bright, top sciences degree, PhD, then barristering.

Two other - private day school, Cambridge (humanities) - BVC and pupillage - both now KCs

Another Eton, (scholarship) Cambridge, BVC, pupillage - now a KC

None of them studied law at Cambridge, interestingly. They all did history, music, or sciences.

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 26/10/2022 16:50

I know a few barristers, only one did a law degree. The others all did Classics, History, Philosophy... essay subjects Grin. One Oxford, the others went to Edinburgh, Durham or St Andrews.

I don't know any scientists who later became barristers, but I know a fair few who did PhDs and now do patent law.

FiddlefigOnTheRoof · 26/10/2022 16:50

He needs to look at the cvs of a range of barristers and do what they did. They are not all Oxbridge, but all have stellar academics. Usually masters, lots of mooting and debating. Get a first wherever you go, and study hard.

Onlyhereforchaletschool · 26/10/2022 16:49

I work in a sixth form college. I have taught a number of students who are now barristers. None went to Oxford, none have law connections. Sometimes being the big fish in the slightly smaller pond can give you the edge. E.g, I taught A level law to a student who had done his GCSEs at the worst school results wise in the borough. Lived in an area of extreme socio economic deprivation. He got A grades at A level, a first class degree from a Russell group uni (but one of the lesser ones) prize for best LLB student, scholarship for bar finals. Still took him a year or so to get pupillary but he’s done so well since then.

KatieBell12 · 26/10/2022 16:48

I have a few barrister friends and none of them went to Oxbridge. Manchester, Sheffield, Durham and Birmingham off the top of my head.

RosesAndHellebores · 26/10/2022 16:47

As a wife and mother, what @reluctantlogin said.

Aim high and make compromises along the way whilst keeping all the doors open.

My DH did it from a comp. 40 years ago. It's more diverse than it was. There were years when the DC didn't see him from Monday to Friday. As your ds matures he will think about the life he wants and how to get it.

He needs the courage of his convictions.

bewarethetides · 26/10/2022 16:44

DazedandConcerned · 26/10/2022 15:47

I was top of my class at a red brick law school.

Year before me. National mooting champion. First class degree. Did the BPTC and graduated near top. Didn’t get an inn at court.

I was told not to bother trying to be a barrister because not only is it dog eat dog, it’s about who you know and where you went to school.

Do you - or any of his family - know anyone who could give him a mini pupillage leg up?

Imagine it isn’t what you wanted to read - but it’s the truth from my experience (graduated 2017).

I'd listen to accounts like this, OP.

My son is like yours, OP, but now in Year 13. Seriously considered pursuing being a barrister, loves the idea, matches to that a career in many ways ... but ultimately decided against it for reasons like this. We know no one. He went to a state school, so no connections to share at Oxbridge if he went. And it's so competitive, with many barristers struggling to make ends meet. He's now applying to engineering programmes.

Croque · 26/10/2022 16:43

RincewindsHat · 26/10/2022 15:52

Someone I know is now a millionaire barrister and did not go to Oxbridge - got a First at uni (not law), did an internship & then got a training contract to qualify as a solicitor in a Magic Circle law firm then transitioned to the Bar. Throughout the whole thing, he excelled at both study and his work, has networked furiously and as a result of those two things has done extremely well in his career. Very possible, as with most things in life who you know can certainly help and the rest is down to being extremely good at what you do.

I think internships and connections will be very valuable, so if you know anyone who's a barrister, ask them for advice and possibly work experience. Otherwise, get networking :)

That sounds just like my OH. He did not do a law degree but did get a first (following public school). He has brilliant social skills and is funny and a brilliant networker so perhaps tell your DS to focus on building those skills.

He spent many years living off his side hustles (property investment) before he became a superstar performer so it helped that he was never poor. He now chooses to work for about a quarter of the week to hit his six figure annual target.

Eek3under3 · 26/10/2022 16:40

My friend (mid 30s) retrained. She studied law at the local uni (not RG and definitely not oxbridge) at 30 and has just secured a pupillage. So it’s definitely possible.

reluctantlogin · 26/10/2022 16:34

My post above should have been directed at dazedandconcerned whose comments about ‘ not getting an Inn of Court’ were unduly negative and incorrect - especially coming from a law graduate. Apologies.
I am a barrister - what I would say to any year 11 is get on with your studies, get into the best university you can , get involved in life, speak to peers and college tutors, apply for vacation schemes and most importantly keep an open mind about how your career will pan out.

Dotcheck · 26/10/2022 16:32

longwayoff · 26/10/2022 15:51

30 years ago I was working in a centre for stressed young single mums having a bit of a hard time. One of them was 17 years old with a one year old and a couple of GCSEs. She wanted to be a lawyer and, frankly, I thought it unlikely that would happen but kept that to myself, of course. Remembered her a few weeks ago and googled her to see if she had an online presence. She's a QC. How impressive! I was thrilled to see that. All best wishes to your son.

Aw, I love those kinds of life stories ☺️

Pedallleur · 26/10/2022 16:31

Worth reading Nothing but the Truth by The Secret Barrister. Talks about how he/She got into the job. No connections or public school.

CarefreeMe · 26/10/2022 16:29

To be honest it makes me laugh when people say how bright and driven their DC are and then ask for information on their behalf that a bright, driven person would be able to find in about 5 minutes by googling chambers websites and LinkedIn.

This is very unfair.

A lot of info you get off the internet is very biased or complete BS.

Most year 11s do not come on to mumsnet.

OP is asking for opinions for herself, based on people’s experience in RL.

Anonymouslyposting · 26/10/2022 16:28

I’m a litigation solicitor so work with barristers every day. Far from all barristers went to oxbridge but it depends on what type of barrister he wants to be - regional criminal barrister non-oxbridge is totally normal, top London commercial set many (but definitely not all) of his colleagues would be oxbridge. Is there a reason your son can’t or doesn’t want to go to oxbridge (or other top tier universities)? From what you’ve said there doesn’t seem to be any reason why he couldn’t.

He also doesn’t need to study law as I know plenty of barristers who studied something else and then converted - but again, a good law degree is an advantage if he wants a top commercial set.

I don’t think it’s about who you know or connections, top chambers know that their clients want the best rather than someone’s son or friend so if you’re not good enough you won’t get in on connections. I’m sure it happens and the profession still has a legacy of nepotism in the older generations, but you don’t see it as much in the new intakes.

In terms of the ethical concerns, it’s always a risk if you act for others you won’t always be on the side of the angels. This is especially true when you’re a junior and the work you do is largely dictated by your seniors. However, on the flip sides barristers have strict ethical codes, while they can pursue aims that your son may not like, they must do it in an open and honest way so the court knows the facts and can make a fair decision within the law. As he gets more senior he’ll be able to make more decisions about what cases he takes on and throughout a barristers career there are opportunities to do pro bono in areas that he cares about.

I would also advise him not to rule out being a solicitor too early. It may be that being a barrister is 100% the right choice for him but there’s a lot of variation in what solicitors can do - for example, there’s more opportunity to do pro bono if he wants to follow his conscience. I work for a US law firm and get paid a high salary but was still able to devote 20% of my hours to charities that I care about in the last year. I would suggest looking at arbitration where solicitors can do a lot of the advocacy.

Overall, nothing you’ve said suggests it is impossible for your son to be a barrister.

givemushypeasachance · 26/10/2022 16:28

I did law at uni 20 years ago. We were told then that about 2/3 of people studying law don't go into the legal profession. It's still a respected and useful subject to have a degree in though! Either side, solicitor or barrister, training positions are competitive.

But tbh both professions want to diversify - male oxbridge graduates are already ten a penny. I know there aren't quotas, but both professions want more state school kids, not oxbridge, women/minorities/disabled candidates to apply. So actively seeking out the most boring old school route in may not be the best.

To put a different spin on it: if you did something like a degree in chemistry or engineering, got a first with time in industrial placements, then did a conversion course and aced that, and come with a bit of experience and insight in a different field - that brings something new and different to the table. If you've got 40 candidates who all went to the same unis, did law, work experience at the same firms, and then one candidate who can talk about the skills their different studying and industry experience have taught them - who will you remember that stands out?

Lopilo · 26/10/2022 16:28

If he gets put off by those statistics or because he fails to get into oxbridge, then it is unlikely he will have the resilience or enough confidence to be a barrister. He is already finding excuses for not succeeding!

MichaelFabricantWig · 26/10/2022 16:26

I know plenty of barristers without an Oxbridge education. If he wants to aim for Oxbridge all well and good but if he doesn’t get in and finds going to A N Other Uni holds him back in his career he’ll just need to find something else to do. He’s still very young to be so fixated on a very narrow pathway IMO.

reluctantlogin · 26/10/2022 16:25

I think you are mistaken here. You can ‘ get ‘ an Inn of Court by paying a tiny joining fee . If you mean pupillage- yes there are more people holding Bar Qualifications than there are pupillages but I don’t think people should be unduly put off. The Bar is tough - always was- but there are many different sorts of practice areas and some are more competitive than others as in any profession.
in my experience barristers chambers and indeed the Inns try quite hard to support young meritorious candidates. The cronyism is much less a factor than it was 40 years ago.
To the OP - it’s a long road from year 11.

HappyHedgehog247 · 26/10/2022 16:24

My family includes a state educated, non-prestigious university educated barrister. Intellect, drive, single minded competitive focus and superior interpersonal skills ie building relationships rather than just networking is what clinched the pupillage I think.