Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's not impossible that ds could become a barrister?

162 replies

coffeerevelsrule · 26/10/2022 15:41

I am shamelessly posting here for traffic to try and get some advice for ds1 as I don't know about this to advise him properly.

He is currently in Y11 and predicted all 8s and 9s. He is incredibly driven and focused and has done tons of research into degrees and careers. He has come to the conclusion that he'd like to be a barrister - he's certain at the moment he would not want to be a solicitor. However, his research has led him to believe that unless he does law at Oxbridge he stands next to no chance of securing a pupillage, and that even if he does this will still not guarantee a career as a barrister. He is quoting all sorts of scary stats and basically thinks that without connections and Oxbridge he'll have no chance. He's also concerned that it'll be a 'beggars can't be choosers' scenario and he'll end up helping some corporation pay less tax and/or screw over their employees, which he wouldn't want to do. He wants to go into human rights but has realised this doesn't pay well, which, despite his principles, puts him off.

My opinion is that he is extremely bright and also has other qualities that will make him desirable, such as the aforementioned drive and focus, and that he is likely to get an excellent degree from an excellent university (maybe Oxbridge, maybe not) and that that degree will lead him to some kind of excellent career that he may not even be aware exists at the moment. He's not happy with this response.

Does anyone have any advice and/or experience of people from 'ordinary' backgrounds making it as a barrister and/or people with law degrees having a worthwhile career in another sector? I'm all talked out about this at the moment!

OP posts:
Ilkleymoor · 26/10/2022 18:50

I know 8 barristers. 2 Oxbridge and years ago, rest late 30s early 40s, 2 Oxbridge and rest red brick unis. Only one went to public school. But it is very dog eat dog.

eurochick · 26/10/2022 18:50

Pupillary = pupillage. (Thanks, autocarrot)

eurochick · 26/10/2022 18:49

Lots of good advice on here.

As others have said Oxbridge still dominates the Bar, but diversity is slowly improving. I got pupillary at the second attempt as a state school non-Oxbridge candidate without connections 20 odd years ago. You need to be resilient though - I could have wallpapered my room with the rejection letters along the way.

Also as others have said, he should do everything he can to get work experience to see what solicitors and barristers actually do. He/you seem to have a pretty skewed idea at the moment. Giving tax advice to corporations is some of the best paid work available to either side of the profession.

Most court rooms are open to the public. He can go along to his local one and sit quietly at the back to see law in action. That is only a small part of the work though. Even barristers in most practice areas won't be in court every day.

At 16 the best thing he can do is to make sure his academics are outstanding.

trebarwith1 · 26/10/2022 18:48

Tell him to go for it. He doesn't need to go to Oxbridge to be in with a chance, but i would say connections are everything in law so if he can do any volunteering at the nearest chambers as he goes through his degree it will be invaluable. They are always happy to help proactive students who are willing to chain themselves to the photocopier for a few days, and the experience will help him know which area of law he wants to go into. Volunteering at a solicitor's firm in criminal or civil litigation departments is a good shout too! I got offered a pupillage whilst working as a PA to a divorce solicitor about 10 years ago. It wasn't the path i wanted to take but being keen, open, hard working, polite, personable and helpful will all help your son get to where he wants to be. Good luck to him!

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 26/10/2022 18:43

FAIRE is taking place at the moment and it would be worth hom signing up, it is mainly solicitors but they have at least one barrister speaking this year.

He doesn't need law or Oxbridge to be a respectable and successful barrister, a good degree from a good uni is important but it doesn't have to be law.

Don't let him be put off I was scared off by those stats and although I am a solicitor now and enjoy my job I so wonder what might have been.

The barriers to entry are breaking down and the profession is much more accessible than it was when I was applying

Reebokclassics · 26/10/2022 18:43

My brother has a law degree from oxford, middle class background. Hes a staff sergeant in Intelligence with an OBE at the age of 30.

Eccle80 · 26/10/2022 18:36

My DH is a barrister and part time judge. He is comprehensive school educated, went to a Russell group university, doesn’t have straight As or a first. He did a joint honours LLB degree. It isn’t easy, and I know a lot from his BVC course didn’t end up as barristers. He didn’t get a pupilage at his first attempt, but spent a year working gaining experience and was successful the next year. I would say you need to be flexible about location and type of law, we moved for his pupilage, and the area he practices in now is neither what he did during his pupilage nor what he might have envisaged when he was studying.

It’s a tough job, he works a huge number of hours, and at times deals with some upsetting things. You also need to be organised and good with money - as a self employed person you have to be careful to keep money aside for tax and VAT bills, and to deal with not having a regular income or know if and when the money will arrive for the work you do.

Good luck to him, I hope it works out

Hayliebells · 26/10/2022 18:35

I'm going to add to the list of all the people who know barristers who didn't go to Oxbridge. A friend of mine from school did law at De Montfort uni in Leicester, and she's now a barrister. It absolutely can be done.

goldfinchonthelawn · 26/10/2022 18:35

He certainly doesn't need an Oxbridge law degree. Most barristers I know (some of whom did a first degree at Oxford or Cambridge but not in Law) did a conversion course at City. He can gain experience with internships or shadowing and then see about getting pupillage.

independentfriend · 26/10/2022 18:35

I was thinking the same thing at about 15.

I went from a bog standard comprehensive, to a sixth form college to Oxford.

I then wasn't sure whether I wanted to do law at all for a bit - what was most prominent in careers type stuff was commercial law which I didn't find interesting.

Having decided I wanted to do law, but not that sort of law I then took the Legal Practice Course (then the vocational course for solicitors) part time over two years. Shortly after that I fell into a niche area.

Between 15 and 22 ish, I'd decided I didn't want to be a barrister - I didn't want to be self employed (though I've changed my mind about that again as I now effectively work for myself), I didn't want to specialise in the restricted area of work that barristers specialise in - advocacy and advice (now there's so much direct access to barristers the distinctions are perhaps less important than they were 20 ish years ago) and the costs were prohibitive - the Bar Vocational Course (now renamed as something else) was more expensive than the LPC and I don't think anybody offered it part time. I don't remember if pupillages were funded then, but they were very competitive and I didn't think I stood a good chance of getting one. And there was then the prospect of doing work and not getting paid for it for ages, "aged debt".

Many people go to the Bar with masters degrees / doctorates / experience in other areas first. I think being a solicitor is a better 'all rounder' option - you can transfer to the Bar as a qualified solicitor and by that point you're likely to have your own client following that makes it less risky.

It's worth him reading #LegalTwitter - seeing people talk about "Sunday homework club" and the other pressures the job brings - self employed people don't like turning work away, even when they're busy - it can be difficult to take holidays/to switch off from work.

Mainly, my advice now is that he doesn't need to make a decision about any of this now - keeping your options open is something lawyers quite often advise their clients about. He can focus on doing well in his GCSEs. Part time employment/voluntary work isn't a bad idea [demonstrates time management skills and possibly more]. Going to some university open days next summer (post GCSEs) isn't a bad plan. Checking out suitable combinations of A levels to take is a good plan - he wants subjects he enjoys that fit what the Russell Group think of as good subjects. Look at the offers the unis are making for law. Trying to arrange work experience with solicitors / mini-pupillages with chambers is a plan for next summer and the one after. Some chambers restrict mini-pupillages to people over 18. [work experience with sols = he'll have a better answer to "why don't you want to be a solicitor?" which chambers might ask]

TalbotAMan · 26/10/2022 18:34

Oxbridge isn't essential but a good Oxbridge degree is always a help.

The Bar is surprisingly diverse (and becoming more Diverse). There is a huge difference between (for example) the work of someone doing high value commercial work in London and someone doing family work in a local court. I know of some barristers who make huge amounts doing 'below-the-radar' road accident claims (£250 x 10 15-minute hearings a day x 5 days a week) and others who are quite badly paid for criminal defending on legal aid. There are barristers who are in court all day every day and others who spend all their time advising and writing opinions and don't go to court from one year to the next.

Being a barrister is a very strange life, but can be addictive. It's not all defending murder suspects at the Old Bailey like oin the Telly - Defending The Guilty on iPlayer is the closest thing to real life that I have seen.

I used to be a law lecturer, and, following my students after they graduated, a lot who wanted to be barristers didn't get there in the end, but many did. As far as I know, none are (yet) KCs, but quite a few have become judges. Most didn't have Oxbridge degrees.

Mitski · 26/10/2022 18:33

His research needs to be more extensive- plenty of information out there about how applications by chambers are now blind and inclusivity and diversity are being slowly welcomed by the Bar. Very much not Oxbridge focused anymore. It seems from the post that doing work experience would be helpful- both in a solicitors’ firm and at chambers. How does he know he doesn’t want to be a solicitor unless it is rooted in evidence? Evidence is the most important part for any aspiring lawyers. It also seems confused about the areas of law- sampling a few different areas, visiting courts (which are open) and trying to get other connected experience would help here. Human Rights is not its own discrete area of law. He needs to research more on what barristers actually do- the example you have given in advising companies is much more likely advice given by a solicitor. Barristers have to take cases based on what comes along within their competence, so no declining cases on the basis that you don’t fancy helping a corporation. Ultimately, being a barrister is a service provision- so the implications of that and the reality of self employed need to be carefully thought about.

Piglet89 · 26/10/2022 18:32

In-house solicitor here, with a Cambridge law degree. I was completely put off the bar because practically everyone I know, certainly in decent commercial sets, has first class Oxbridge degrees, normally with prizes for coming top of the university or their College in at least one subject in their degree, plus postgrad degrees plus mooting champion etc etc. I thought I just wasn’t intellectually up to it - although I’m a really excellent communicator and presenter and probably would have made a good advocate.

The formality and stress of getting told off my stern judges sometimes (maybe often!) also didn’t appeal.

It is considered that the very brightest legal minds end up at the bar; it’s partly why my organisation seeks counsel’s opinion on the more complex points of law.

Applesonthelawn · 26/10/2022 18:29

Surely our recent experience with Kwasi Kwarteng has caused people to rethink how exclusively valuable it is to have all the right qualifications from all the best places?

Badnewsoracle · 26/10/2022 18:26

I know 1 barrister who went to Manchester uni, 1 Liverpool and 1 Bristol. The one who went Liverpool came from a very working class background, state school etc.

AloysiusBear · 26/10/2022 18:22

The Bar is a terribly cliquey, closed profession.

Its got a huge contingent of privileged, white privately educated types. There are then niche pockets of extremely bright ethnic minority barristers, often practising out of majority minority chambers - see 12 old sq. Many of these will also be from rather wealthy backgrounds and/or be very well connected. Then there are criminal etc barristers on the fringes/in regions, much more normal (albeit bright) and earning a pittance.

I know one individual from a less privileged background who broke in. They are oxbridge educated and were extremely bright (we are talking best in year) and spent years after university earning little while getting going.

Malfi · 26/10/2022 18:18

I know a couple of barristers -both female. Neither went to Oxbridge, but they did go to other very highly regarded universities. Neither did law at university. They had degrees in English and in History. Neither were privately educated or had any family connections. I know a lot more solicitors from similar backgrounds.

bluefrog11 · 26/10/2022 18:17

The barrister I know went to Newcastle university and is also part of a female same sex couple (not saying that’s a problem - I’m just pointing out that being different from the perceived notion of the typical barrister isn’t always a barrier!). She’s driven and certainly clever but I wouldn’t say is a particularly “alpha” sort of person.

Do note though that barristers don’t always earn a fortune - they are self employed and the pay isn’t always as good as you would expect for such a highly trained professional!

OldWivesTale · 26/10/2022 18:16

..and if he does criminal law he'll be broke for years 😒

JaffavsCookie · 26/10/2022 18:15

I have 2 very good mates who are barristers. Both were state educated ( one at a grammar, one at a comp) and neither went to Oxbridge, so it can definitely be done. Its a competitive career, but so are many others.

ElspethTascioni · 26/10/2022 18:15

Sorry, showing my excellent attention to detail there and misreading your question! YANBU! For the reasons given in my previous post 😂

Anonymouslyposting · 26/10/2022 18:13

Oysterbabe · 26/10/2022 17:50

But he might end up as a lawyer. Being a lawyer is hell on earth. Tell him to choose anything else, literally anything.
It's too late for me he can save himself.

I genuinely play that song at trainees sometimes…

onemomentintime · 26/10/2022 18:13

Also meant to say he definitely doesn't need to do a law degree. DH really wishes he'd done something else and most of the barristers he knows didn't do law at Uni.

ElspethTascioni · 26/10/2022 18:13

YAB completely unreasonable. It’s definitely worth a try. I am a barrister, ordinary family, no legal connections, got decent GCSEs and A levels, 2:1 from a red brick and VC (very competent - the top grade being outstanding) on the bar course. I also did a load of mooting at uni, did a handful of mini-pupillage and marshalled some judges. Having sat on the pupillage committee many times, it is still possible for a similar candidate to get pupillage today. I did get a scholarship from my inn of court, which will have helped my application- but your son could equally apply for one of those. I’m confused by the previous poster saying they didn’t get an inn - there isn’t a selection process for simply getting in! Only for scholarships.

My husband is also a barrister with a very similar academic background- the only difference is he comes from a working class background whereas mine was more middle class.

It is completely achievable for a bright, hardworking kid, who can think on their feet. Hard, but achievable. Why not go for it? What’s the worst that can happen?

OldWivesTale · 26/10/2022 18:11

Well at my d dad's former chambers, their criteria for picking pupils was based on whether they would stick around once they'd qualified- or whether they'd bugger off to a more glamorous city. So on that basis, they'd often choose people who had already lived in the area for a while or who had family/ connections in the area. So it really depends on what type of law/ chambers your son is interested in. None of the barristers (about 20 altogether) there were Oxbridge.

Swipe left for the next trending thread